FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Buenaobra v Alesi [2021] FCCA 2041
File number(s): SYG 1973 of 2020 Judgment of: JUDGE BAIRD Date of judgment: 24 August 2021 Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for default judgment – application for summary judgment – default largely remedied – proceeding not without reasonable prospects – application dismissed Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)
Cases cited: Fair Work Ombudsman v IE Enterprises Proprietary Limited [2020] FCA 848
Fair Work Ombudsman v Mobile Food Vans and Trucks Pty Limited [2021] FCCA 882
Fair Work Ombudsman v Sober Kitchen Pty Ltd [2020] FCCA 2358
Open Eye Pty Ltd v Audio-Visual Copyright Society trading as Screenrights [2020] FCCA 7
Number of paragraphs: 34 Date of last submission/s: 24 August 2021 Date of hearing: 24 August 2021 Place: Sydney Applicant: Ms B Buenaobra for herself with the assistance of an interpreter Respondents: Mr A Salman, second respondent, with leave for the first respondent ORDERS
SYG 1973 of 2020 BETWEEN: JULIET BANO BUENAOBRA
Applicant
AND: ANWAR ALESI
First Respondent
ANWAR SALMAN
Second Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE BAIRD
DATE OF ORDER:
24 AUGUST 2021
THE COURT:
1.DISMISSES the respondents’ application in a case date 12 April 2021.
2.DIRECTS by 19 October 2021 each of the applicant and the respondents file and serve any further evidence on which they intend to rely.
3.DIRECTS by 23 November 2021each of the applicant and the respondents file and serve an outline of submissions on which they intend to rely at final hearing, each party’s outline being in Microsoft Word and limited to 15 pages.
4.LISTS the proceeding for directions hearing on 26 November 2021 at 3:00pm at the Court in Sydney or such other date/time as advised administratively by the Court, such directions hearing to be conducted via videoconference or such other means as advised by the Court.
5.STANDS OVER the proceeding for final hearing to a date to be advised, being not before 1 February 2022, that hearing to be a 1 day hearing and to be conducted by video or web conference or in person as the Court advises administratively.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Judge Baird
Background
In this matter, the second respondent, Mr Anwar Salman, has brought an application in a case dated 12 April 2021, seeking orders to strike out any evidence provided after 9 April 2021 due to the applicant failing to follow procedure and comply with the timetable ordered by the Court, and secondly, that the application be dismissed on the basis that the applicant is not an Australian resident and an order of this Court may not be enforced against her in the country of origin, being the Philippines.
The evidence before me on this application today shows that the applicant, Ms Buenaobra’s, previous solicitor from Legal Aid withdrew and ceased to act on 8 April 2021. Ms Buenaobra is now resident in the Philippines. Mr Salman has explained to the Court that when the matter was last before the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Buenaobra v Alesi and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] FCCA 2041
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether to grant default judgment or summary judgment in favour of Ms Buenaobra, or to dismiss the proceedings. Specifically, the court considered whether the respondents' conduct warranted default judgment, and whether Ms Buenaobra's case had sufficient prospects to proceed to summary judgment. The court also considered whether Ms Buenaobra's residency in the Philippines should lead to a dismissal of the case.
Justice Baird noted that while Ms Buenaobra had been in default of the evidence timetable, this had largely been remedied. The court found that there was a genuine dispute between the parties, with both Ms Buenaobra and Mr Salman demonstrating a desire to pursue their respective positions. Crucially, the court observed that the respondents had, on the face of admissions and available material, contravened the Act by failing to provide payslips and a Fair Work Information Statement. The court also highlighted difficulties in accepting Mr Salman's evidence due to the lack of comprehensive records of cash payments, creating a contest of credit between the parties. Given these complexities, the unrepresented status of both parties, and the use of video conferencing, the court deemed it inappropriate to make a definitive judgment on the merits at this interlocutory stage.
Consequently, the court dismissed the applications for default judgment and summary judgment. The court found that the circumstances did not warrant default judgment, as the respondents' participation did not indicate an inability or unwillingness to cooperate, nor was there continuing non-compliance occasioning unnecessary delay or prejudice. Furthermore, the court was not persuaded that Ms Buenaobra's case met the principles for summary judgment, nor that her residency abroad should lead to dismissal, as the Fair Work jurisdiction is generally a no-costs jurisdiction.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Default judgment may be entered where a party’s participation in the proceeding is such as to indicate an inability or unwillingness to cooperate with the Court and the other party in having the matter ready for trial in an acceptable period or where the non-compliance is continuing and occasioning unnecessary delay, expense or prejudice to the other party. Consideration In the present case, whilst the applicant was in default of the timetable to file all her evidence, that default has now, in large part, been remedied. Secondly, the evidence shows that there is a genuine dispute between the parties, and that Ms Buenaobra shows that she wishes to proceed with her claim and to seek the compensation that I have adverted to in the pleadings. Thirdly, Mr Salman’s evidence shows that there is a genuine dispute on his part and that of his wife, Ms Alesi, with the matters alleged by Ms Buenaobra. It is clear, however, that, in respect of some matters at least, the respondents have contravened the Act, respectively, at least, on the face of the admissions to the Court and on the material, in that no payslips were provided, and there is no evidence that a Fair Work information statement was provided by them to Ms Buenaobra. Whether a person is employed as a domestic worker at a person’s residence or whether a person is employed in a business, the employment circumstances are governed, in this kind of case, by the provisions of the Act. The matter is complicated further in the present case because it appears that some, at least, if not most of Ms Buenaobra’s wages were paid in cash and there is no record which the respondents are able to provide showing in full the payments that were made. Thus, even if I were to accept, on the face of it, Mr Salman’s claims in his evidence, there are difficulties in my acceptance of it at this stage. That is because there is a clear contest that will arise between the credit of Ms Buenaobra, and the credit of Mr Salman and/or his wife, Ms Alesi. The matter is complicated further in the present case because both parties before me today are unrepresented. The matter is further complicated because I am viewing both parties by video digital conferencing facilities. These circumstances make it more difficult for me in this case, and, given that this is an interlocutory application, it is inappropriate for me today to make a clear judgment about whether to believe Ms Buenaobra or Mr Salman. Thus, in the absence of legal assistance, and in the absence of the parties being able to present the case in person, at this stage, I am not persuaded that it is appropriate to order a default judgment. Further, for these same reasons, I am not persuaded that Ms Buenaobra’s case satisfies the principles for summary judgment, which I have already read to both parties, before giving my reasons. Given that I have stated them twice, I will incorporate by reference what has been said by Judge Driver in this Court in Open Eye Pty Ltd v Audio-Visual Copyright Society trading as Screenrights [2020] FCCA 7 at [12] – [13], and also in relation to strikeout at [15] – [16].