FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v KENSINGTON MANAGEMENT SERVICES PTY LTD | [2012] FMCA 225 |
| INDUSTRIAL LAW – Employer’s failure to pay employee entitlements - Basic minimum hourly rate of pay and casual loading for resident caretaker – legality of weekly deduction for ‘rent’ - identification of hours of ‘work’ – effects of preserved APCS and employer’s greenfields collective agreement – contraventions established – rights of compensation – further hearing ordered. |
| Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW), ss.118,119 Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), ss.16(3), 171, 172, 173, 178, 179, 181, 182, 183, 185, 186, 208(1), 330, 333, 344, 346M(1)(b), 346R, 346T(2), 346X, 346ZD, 347(4), 349, 350, 351, 719, 722 Workplace Relations Regulations 2006 (Cth), sub-reg.7.1(5A), 7.1(18) |
| Automatic Fire Sprinklers Pty Ltd v Watson (1946) 72 CLR 435 Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410 Fair Work Ombudsman v Essendene Security Pty Ltd & Anor [2010] FMCA 384 Mark Dickinson and Jenny Bates v The Proprietors of Body Corporate Strata Plan No.125 [2002] NSWCIMC 10 (25 January 2002) Mark Dickinson and Jenny Bates v The Proprietors of Body Corporate Strata Plan No.125 [2002] NSWCIMC 116 (23 July 2002) Mark Dickinson and Jenny Bates v The Proprietors of Body Corporate Strata Plan No.125 [2002] NSWCIMC 157 (21 October 2002) United Firefighters’ Union of Australia v Metropolitan Fire & Emergency Services Board (2006) 152 FCR 18 Warramunda Village Inc v Pryde (2002) 116 FCR 58 |
| Applicant: | Fair Work Ombudsman |
| Respondent: | Kensington Management Services Pty Ltd ACN 064 931 415 |
| File Number: | SYG 844 of 2011 |
| Judgment of: | Smith FM |
| Hearing dates: | 14, 15 & 16 February 2012 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 27 April 2012 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Ms F Hancock |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Fair Work Ombudsman |
| Counsel for the Respondent: | Mr S Meehan |
| Solicitors for the Respondent: | Macpherson + Kelley Pty Ltd |
ORDERS
The matter is adjourned for further hearing.
| FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT Sydney |
SYG 844 of 2011
| Fair Work Ombudsman |
Applicant
And
| Kensington management services Pty Ltd ACN 064 931 415 |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Mr Walder and his partner Ms Kilbourne were chosen by Kensington Management Services Pty Ltd (“Kensington”) to fill a position as caretaker at one of its retirement villages which was under development near Albury in NSW. Kensington appointed them both to the one position, and required at least one of them to be in attendance and to undertake the responsibilities of the position at all times during specified ‘attendance hours’ when the day-time village manager was not present. It was also a condition of their employment that they should live together in designated caretaker’s accommodation in the village. They were given, and accepted, a letter of appointment which told them that they would, in effect, receive a single wage consisting of a weekly net ‘on call allowance’ of $115.13 as well as the benefit of the accommodation.
The couple moved into the village, and Mr Walder undertook all the duties of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Kensington Management Services Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] FMCA 225
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The key legal issues before the court were the interpretation and application of the Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard, particularly sections 172 and 173, which address the operation and non-excludability of the AFPCS from workplace agreements. Specifically, the court needed to ascertain whether the employer's deductions for rent from the employees' pay were lawful under the regulations made under section 172(4). Additionally, the court had to decide whether the employees received the full remuneration they were entitled to under the AFPCS, irrespective of the deductions made.
The Fair Work Commission examined the statutory provisions and the relevant regulations to conclude that the deductions for rent from the employees' pay were not unlawful. However, it found that even accounting for these deductions, Mr Walder and Ms Kilbourne did not receive the full remuneration to which they were entitled under the AFPCS. The court emphasized that the AFPCS, as outlined in sections 172 and 173, sets out minimum entitlements that must be provided to employees and that these entitlements prevail over any contrary terms in workplace agreements. The court's interpretation underscored that the AFPCS, including provisions for basic rates of pay and casual loadings, must be strictly adhered to by employers.
The matter was adjourned for further hearing to allow the parties to present additional evidence and arguments on the specific details of the underpayments and compliance with the AFPCS.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
The matter is adjourned for further hearing.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Part 7 of the Act contained provisions for ‘The Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard’, which was to govern ‘key minimum entitlements of employment’, including “basic rates of pay and casual loadings” (see s.171(2)(a)). They were to be found in new instruments to be made by a new agency, the Australian Fair Pay Commission, or in parts of previous industrial instruments given continuing transitional effect as ‘preserved APCSs’. The minimum entitlements of a relevant AFPCS or preserved APCS, prevailed over the terms of workplace agreements, notwithstanding that the agreement otherwise excluded entitlements otherwise arising. This was clear from s.172, and s.173:172 Operation of the Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard (1) The Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard provides key minimum entitlements of employment for the employees to whom it applies.(2) The Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard prevails over a workplace agreement or a contract of employment that operates in relation to an employee to the extent to which, in a particular respect, the Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard provides a more favourable outcome for the employee.…(4) The regulations may prescribe: (a) what a particular respect is or is not for the purposes of subsection (2) or (3); or (b) the circumstances in which the Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard provides or does not provide a more favourable outcome in a particular respect.173 Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard cannot be excluded A term of a workplace agreement or a contract has no effect to the extent to which it purports to exclude the Australian Fair Pay and Conditions Standard or any part of it. In the present case, I was taken to the regulations made under s.172(4) only in so far as they have a bearing on whether or not deductions for rent shown in Mr Walder’s pay slips were lawful or unlawful. I shall set out these regulations and address that debate below, since it forms a secondary element in the case. As I shall explain, I have concluded that these deductions were not unlawful, but that even if account is made for them, Mr Walder and Ms Kilbourne still did not receive the full amount of remuneration to which they were entitled under law at any time during their employment. In relation to guaranteed basic rates of pay and casual loadings under the APCS, Division 2 of Part 7 contained the following relevant definitional provisions:178 Definitions In this Division:APCS means a preserved APCS or a new APCS....basic periodic rate of pay means a rate of pay for a period worked (however the rate is described) that does not include incentive‑based payments and bonuses, loadings, monetary allowances, penalty rates or any other similar separately identifiable entitlements. The meaning of basic periodic rate of pay is also affected by section 210.…casual loading provisions has the meaning given by section 179.classification has the meaning given by section 180.coverage provisions means: (a) for a pre‑reform wage instrument—all provisions (whether of that instrument or of another instrument or law), as in force on the reform comparison day, that would have affected the determination of whether the employment of any particular employee was covered by the instrument on that day; or (b) for an APCS—provisions of the APCS that determine whether the employment of a particular employee is covered by the APCS.Note: For a preserved APCS, the coverage provisions will (at least initially) be the coverage provisions for the pre‑reform wage instrument from which the APCS is derived (see paragraph 208(1)(g)).covered: for when the employment of a particular employee is covered by a particular APCS, see sections 204 and 205.current circumstances of employment, in relation to an employee, includes any current circumstance of or relating to the employee’s employment.default casual loading percentage has the meaning given by subsection 186(1).derived from: for when a preserved APCS is derived from a particular pre‑reform wage instrument, see subsection 208(2).…frequency of payment provisions means: (a) for a pre‑reform wage instrument—provisions (whether of that instrument or of another instrument or law), as in force on the reform comparison day, that would have determined the frequency with which an employee covered by the instrument had to be paid; or (b) for an APCS, a workplace agreement or a contract of employment—provisions of the APCS, workplace agreement or contract that determine the frequency with which an employee covered by the APCS, workplace agreement or contract must be paid.Note: For a preserved APCS, the frequency of payment provisions will (at least initially) be the frequency of payment provisions (if any) for the pre‑reform wage instrument from which the APCS is derived (see paragraph 208(1)(f)).…pre‑reform non‑federal wage instrument means a pre‑reform State wage instrument or a pre‑reform Territory wage instrument.pre‑reform State wage instrument means: (a) a State award (as defined in subsection 4(1) of this Act as in force immediately before the reform commencement) as in force immediately before the reform commencement; or…pre‑reform wage instrument means a pre‑reform federal wage instrument or a pre‑reform non‑federal wage instrument.preserved APCS has the meaning given by subsection 208(1).…rate provisions has the meaning given by section 181.…179 Meaning of casual loading provisions(1) For the purposes of this Division, casual loading provisions, of a pre‑reform wage instrument or an APCS, are provisions of the instrument or APCS that determine a casual loading payable to an employee, or an employee of a particular classification, in addition to a basic periodic rate of pay.…180 Meaning of classification (1) For the purposes of this Division, a classification of employees is a classification or category of employees, however described in the pre‑reform wage instrument or APCS concerned. (2) A classification or category of employees may be described by reference to matters including (but not limited to) any of the following, or any combination of any of the following: (a) the nature of work performed by employees;…181 Meaning of rate provisions (1) For the purposes of this Division, rate provisions, of a pre‑reform wage instrument or an APCS, are provisions of the instrument or APCS that determine a basic periodic rate of pay, or basic piece rates of pay, payable to an employee, or an employee of a particular classification. (2) The means by which such provisions may determine a basic periodic rate of pay, or a basic piece rate of pay, include the following, or any combination of any of the following: (a) direct specification of a rate; (b) identification of a rate by reference to other provisions (whether or not of the same instrument or APCS); (c) direct specification, or identification by reference to other provisions (whether or not of the same…208 Deriving preserved APCSs from pre‑reform wage instruments (1) If a pre‑reform wage instrument contains rate provisions determining one or more basic periodic rates of pay, or basic piece rates of pay, payable to employees, then, from the reform commencement, there is taken to be a preserved APCS that includes (subject to this Subdivision): (a) those rate provisions; and (b) if those rate provisions determine different basic periodic rates of pay, or different basic piece rates of pay, for employees of different classifications—the provisions of the instrument that describe those classifications; and (c) any casual loading provisions of the instrument that determine casual loadings payable to employees, other than employees for whom the instrument provides basic piece rates of pay; and (d) if the casual loading provisions determine different casual loadings for employees of different classifications—the provisions of the instrument that describe those classifications; and (e) any provisions of the instrument that determine, in relation to employees to whom training arrangements apply, whether hours attending off‑the‑job training (including hours attending an educational institution) count as hours for which a basic periodic rate of pay is payable; and (f) any frequency of payment provisions for the instrument; and (g) the coverage provisions for the instrument. (2) The preserved APCS is derived from the pre‑reform wage instrument.…