FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v ITAL ONE HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR [2019] FCCA 187
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Declarations as to various contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010 – penalties – objections to evidence – impact of a media release issued by the applicant prior to the determination of liability – whether ancillary orders should be made for an audit of the respondents’ payment system – whether injunctions should be granted restraining the respondents from further breaches of the Act or Award.
Legislation:
Evidence Act 1995, s.69
Fair Work Act 2009, ss.45, 539, 545(1), 546(1), 546(2), 546(3)(a), 550, 557
Restaurant Industry Award 2010, cls.12.3, 13.1, 20.1, 34.1, 34.2(a)(i), 34.2(a)(ii), 33.2(a), 33.2(b), 33.2(c)
Crimes Act1914, s.4AA
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Ital One Holdings Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] FCCA 187
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether Ital One Holdings had contravened section 50 of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth) by failing to pay the employee the minimum rate of pay stipulated in the applicable enterprise agreement and by failing to provide other entitlements. This required the Court to determine the proper construction of the enterprise agreement and whether the employer's actions were consistent with its terms.
Riley J reasoned that the employer's obligation to pay the minimum rate of pay was clear and unambiguous under the enterprise agreement. The Court found that the employer had failed to demonstrate that the payments made to the employee met the minimum rate prescribed by the agreement, taking into account all relevant allowances and loadings. The Court applied the principles of contractual interpretation to the enterprise agreement, emphasizing that the plain meaning of the words used should be given effect. The Court also considered the employer's failure to provide other entitlements, such as leave, as further contraventions of the agreement.
The Court ordered that Ital One Holdings Pty Ltd pay pecuniary penalties for the contraventions of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth). The Court also ordered Ital One Holdings to pay the Fair Work Ombudsman's costs of the proceeding.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia concerns an application for declarations and penalties for contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010. The applicant, Fair Work Ombudsman, brought this proceeding against the first respondent, Ital One Holdings Pty Ltd trading as Baci Café, and the second respondent, Len Di Pietro. The proceeding was initiated on 29 May 2017. The parties filed a statement of agreed facts on 15 May 2018. At the hearing on 26 September 2018, the parties reached agreement on certain declarations and orders, but disputed the appropriate penalties and some ancillary orders. The court delivered its reasons for judgment on 1 February 2019. The court made declarations as to the contraventions on the basis of the admissions in the statement of agreed facts. The court also made orders for pecuniary penalties, workplace relations compliance training, and an audit of the first respondent's payment system. The court struck out certain paragraphs of an affidavit and annexures on the basis that they were either irrelevant or inadmissible hearsay. The court considered the appropriate penalties by reference to the nature and extent of the contraventions, the need for deterrence, and the principles established in relevant case law.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the disputed evidence contained in paragraphs 66, 67, 70, and 78 of the affidavit sworn by Sasha Renee Srkulj on 3 August 2018 and the annexures marked SRS-19, 21, and 25 thereto should be admitted into evidence.
2. Whether the court should make the declarations sought by the parties on the basis of the admissions made by the respondents.
3. What is the appropriate amount of pecuniary penalties to be imposed on the first and second respondents for the contraventions set out in declaration 1.
4. Whether the court should order workplace relations compliance training for the first respondent.
5. Whether the court should order an audit of the first respondent’s compliance with the Fair Work Act 2009 and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010.
6. Whether the court should make ancillary orders for an audit of the respondents’ payment system.
7. Whether the court should make ancillary orders for injunctions restraining the respondents from further breaches of the Fair Work Act 2009 and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010.
Held
1. The court held that paragraphs 68, 69, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, and 77 of the affidavit sworn by Sasha Renee Srkulj on 3 August 2018 and the annexures marked SRS-22, SRS-23, and SRS-24 thereto should be struck out by consent.
2. The court held that it was appropriate to make the declarations sought by the parties on the basis of the admissions made by the respondents.
3. The court held that the first respondent should pay pecuniary penalties of $217,000 and the second respondent should pay pecuniary penalties of $40,000 for the contraventions set out in declaration 1.
4. The court held that the first respondent should provide workplace relations compliance training to its employees and the second respondent.
5. The court held that the first respondent should order an audit of its compliance with the Fair Work Act 2009 and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010.
6. The court held that it was appropriate to make ancillary orders for an audit of the respondents’ payment system.
7. The court held that it was not necessary to make ancillary orders for injunctions restraining the respondents from further breaches of the Fair Work Act 2009 and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia in Fair Work Ombudsman v Ital One Holdings Pty Ltd addressed several key issues, establishing binding legal principles in the context of workplace relations law and the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). The court considered whether certain evidence should be admitted, the appropriateness of declarations based on admissions, the quantum of pecuniary penalties, and various ancillary orders.
The first issue addressed was whether disputed evidence contained in specific paragraphs of an affidavit and its annexures should be admitted. The court found that the evidence was largely inadmissible. Paragraphs 66 and 67, which referred to communications with alleged former employees, were excluded because there was no evidence to substantiate that these individuals were actual employees or had been underpaid. Paragraph 70, concerning a telephone conversation with another alleged former employee, was deemed inadmissible because the representation was prepared in connection with an Australian proceeding, triggering an exception under the Evidence Act 1995. Paragraph 78, which involved an email to the second respondent, was also excluded as irrelevant and unfairly prejudicial.
The court proceeded to make declarations sought by the parties based on the admissions made by the respondents. It was appropriate to do so, following recent authority that permits such declarations in public interest cases. The court then turned to determining the appropriate penalties for the contraventions. In line with High Court decisions, the court accepted the parties' agreed range of penalties if sufficiently persuaded of the accuracy of the parties' agreement on facts and consequences. After considering various factors, including the nature and extent of the conduct, the circumstances of the contraventions, and the need for deterrence, the court imposed pecuniary penalties of $217,000 on the first respondent and $40,000 on the second respondent.
The next issue was whether workplace relations compliance training should be ordered for the first respondent. The court found it appropriate to order such training, stipulating its terms and conditions. Regarding the audit of the first respondent’s compliance, the court ordered an audit by qualified third parties to ensure compliance with the FW Act and the Restaurant Industry Award 2010.
The court also considered whether ancillary orders for an audit of the respondents’ payment system and injunctions should be made. It concluded that an audit of the payment system was unnecessary but granted injunctions to restrain the respondents from further breaches of the FW Act and the Award.
The ratio decidendi of this case is the court's approach to admitting evidence, making declarations based on admissions, determining appropriate penalties, and issuing ancillary orders such as training and injunctions in workplace relations cases under the FW Act. The court distinguished its approach from prior cases by focusing on the relevance and probative value of evidence and the specific deterrence needs in imposing penalties. It followed recent authority in making declarations based on admissions and emphasized the importance of specific deterrence and compliance training.