Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd v Alan Sheppard Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Miscellaneous Appeal: Civil)

EXCELSIOR LAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS v ALAN SHEPPARD CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD

[2011] SASC 25

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

25 February 2011

INDUSTRIAL LAW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - REGULATION OF PARTICULAR MATTERS UNDER PARTICULAR STATUTES - WORKMEN'S LIENS - ENFORCEMENT

INDUSTRIAL LAW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - REGULATION OF PARTICULAR MATTERS UNDER PARTICULAR STATUTES - WORKMEN'S LIENS - ENTITLEMENT TO

The respondent contracted with the third appellant to construct retirement units on the first appellant's land.  Following the third appellant's alleged failure to make payment for the completed work the respondent sent a notice of demand, signed by its solicitor, to the third appellant and registered a lien under the Worker's Lien Act 1983 (SA) ('WLA') at the Land Titles Office.  The lien was defective.  The respondent sought to correct the defect by sending a second notice of demand, now signed by the directors of the respondent, and sought to register a second lien at the Land and Titles Office.  Acting under s 191(k) of the Real Property Act 1889, the Registrar-General refused to register the second lien because the respondent had not first obtained the permission of the Court to do so.  The respondent then sought permission from the District Court to register the second lien.

A District Court Judge held that the Court had the power under s 191(k) of the Real Property Act 1889 (SA) to grant permission to the respondent to lodge a further notice of lien, and considered it just for that permission to be granted.

Appellant appealed against this decision.

Whether a court may authorise a person to register a second notice of lien at the Land Titles Office and whether it was just for that permission to be given in the circumstances of this case.

Held: Dismissing the appeal - A worker's lien comes into existence in the circumstances specified in ss 5 and 6 of the WLA, but is enforceable only if registered within the time stipulated in s 10(1) and (2), and an action for its enforcement commenced within the time stipulated in s 15. Section 191(k) of the Real Property Act 1889 (SA) does permit a court to authorise the lodgement of a second lien - first notice of demand not valid under s 10(1) of the WLA as not signed by the respondent - second notice of lien sought to be registered in time.

Worker's Liens Act 1893 (SA) s 5, s 10, s 12, s 15; Real Property Act 1889 (SA) s 3, s 191, referred to.
Marriott Industries Pty Ltd v Mercantile Credits Ltd (1991) 160 LSJS 288; Badge Constructions (SA) Pty Ltd v Rule Chambers Pty Ltd (2007) 99 SASR 502; Metropolitan Brick Company v Hayward [1938] SASR 462; Albert Del Fabbro Pty Ltd v Wilckens & Burnside Pty Ltd [1971] SASR 121; Longreef Pty Ltd v Leighton Contractors (SA) Pty Ltd (1991) 160 LSJS 270; David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpact Banking…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd v Alan Sheppard Construction... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd v Alan Sheppard Constructions Pty Ltd, the South Australian Court of Appeal was tasked with examining the enforceability of a workman's lien asserted by Sheppard Constructions against Excelsior Land Holdings and others. The dispute originated from two building contracts where Sheppard Constructions was contracted to construct retirement units and apartments but had not been fully paid for its services. Consequently, Sheppard Constructions lodged a notice of lien under the Workmen's Liens Act, asserting a claim over the properties. However, the initial notice contained inaccuracies regarding the properties and the amounts claimed, leading Sheppard Constructions to issue corrected notices.

The primary legal issues before the court involved the validity and enforceability of the workman's lien, particularly in light of the initial inaccuracies in the first notice of lien and the failure to initiate proceedings within the statutory timeframe. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the subsequent corrected notices could rectify the deficiencies of the first notice and whether the statutory timeframes for enforcement had been complied with.

The court's reasoning focused on the statutory requirements under the Workmen's Liens Act and the Registration of Personal Property Securities Act. The court found that the initial notice of lien was defective but considered the subsequent notices and actions taken by Sheppard Constructions. The court concluded that the corrected notices, coupled with the circumstances surrounding their issuance, effectively addressed the deficiencies in the initial notice. Furthermore, the court held that the Real Property Act could be interpreted to allow the court to make orders to restore the parties to their prior positions, thereby effectively validating the corrected notices. The court found that the Judge's decision to dismiss the appeal was correct, as the corrected notices sufficiently established the lien, and the statutory requirements were met.

In summary, the appeal was dismissed, affirming the lower court's decision that the workman's lien asserted by Sheppard Constructions was enforceable against the properties of Excelsior Land Holdings and others.

Background

Background to the litigation

In my opinion, the Judge was correct and the appeal should be dismissed. My reasons for that conclusion follow.Factual Background Sheppard Constructions, the respondent to the appeal, entered into two building contracts with Excelsior Land Management Pty Ltd (the third appellant). They required Sheppard Constructions to construct three retirement units on the land of Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd (the first appellant) at Woodcroft, being the land comprised in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5914 Folio 170 (Title One) and some apartments on the land of Estate Land Holdings Pty Ltd (the second appellant) being the land comprised in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5979 Folio 598 (Title Two). Sheppard Constructions contends that it has carried out the work required of it under each contract but has not yet been paid all of each of the respective contract prices. On 25 February 2010, Sheppard Constructions’ solicitors sent a letter to Excelsior Land Holdings and Excelsior Land Management demanding payment of the sum of $1,127,422.81. As I understand it, this was in relation to the work carried out on both titles. It will be necessary to refer to the terms of this letter later in these reasons. As Sheppard Constructions did not receive payment, on 5 March 2010 it lodged a notice of lien under the WLA in the Lands Title Office (LTO). On its face, the notice asserted a lien on the interest of Excelsior Land Holdings in two titles, being Title One and the land in Certificate of Title Register Book Volume 5952 Folio 170 (Title Three) for the sum of $1,127,422.81. I will refer to this notice as the first lien. The first lien was inapt in at least two respects: Sheppard Constructions had not carried out any work at all on Title Three, and the amount claimed in respect of Title One should have been $501,898.81 (although I note that in its amended statement of claim Sheppard Constructions asserts an entitlement to $529,830.07). As I understand it, the Registrar-General registered this notice of lien on each of the certificates of title relating to Title One and Title Three. Section 15 of the WLA requires an action to enforce a worker’s lien to be brought within 14 days of the registration of the lien. It provides:Every lien under this Act upon the estate or interest of any owner or occupier shall cease unless an action shall be brought against the owner or occupier for enforcement of the lien within fourteen days from the registration thereof. The first lien indicated that Sheppard Constructions would bring proceedings in the District Court. However it did not commence such an action. The Judge accepted that this was because the solicitors for Sheppard Constructions recognised the deficiencies in the first lien and considered it appropriate, in effect, to start over again. Accordingly, Sheppard Constructions sent notices to each of Excelsior Land Holdings and Excelsior Land Management dated 29 March 2010 demanding payment of $501,898.81 in respect of its work on Title One. On the same day it sent notices to each of Estate Land Holdings and Excelsior Land Management demanding payment of $643,220.15 in respect of its work on Title Two.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WHITE J
Further, s 64 of the RPA appears to empower a court to make orders, even after the expiry of the 35 day period, to restore the parties to the position which they would have been in had the Court been able to hear and determine Sheppard Constructions’ application within the 35 day period.Conclusion For these reasons, I consider that the decision of the District Court Judge was correct. It is accordingly not necessary to consider the interesting issues raised by Sheppard Constructions’ notice of alternative contention. I dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WHITE J

The court in Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd v Alan Sheppard Constructions Pty Ltd considered several key issues, including the entitlement to a lien where no work has been performed, the ability to amend a notice of lien after registration, the consequences of failing to bring proceedings within the statutory time period, and the power of the court to restore the parties to their previous position after the expiry of a statutory time period. Firstly, the court examined whether Sheppard Constructions was entitled to a lien on the property where no work had been performed. The court noted that Sheppard Constructions had not carried out any work on one of the titles claimed in its initial notice of lien. However, the court did not find that this invalidated the lien altogether. Instead, it considered that the inapt lien could be amended to exclude the unworked title. The court's reasoning here was that the purpose of the lien is to secure payment for work performed, and if the lien can be amended to accurately reflect the work done, it remains valid.

Secondly, the court addressed whether a party can amend a notice of lien after it has been lodged with the Lands Title Office. The court held that such amendments are permissible, provided that they do not materially alter the original claim. In this case, the court found that Sheppard Constructions' amendment to exclude the unworked title was not material, and therefore, the amended notice of lien was valid. The court relied on the principle that liens are intended to secure payment for work performed and that allowing amendments where they do not change the substantive claim is in line with this purpose.

Thirdly, the court considered whether the failure to bring proceedings within 14 days of the registration of a lien results in the lien being void. The court noted that Section 15 of the Workmen's Liens Act (WLA) requires an action to enforce a worker’s lien to be brought within 14 days of the registration of the lien. However, the court held that Sheppard Constructions' failure to bring proceedings did not render the lien void, as the lien could be amended to correct its deficiencies. The court's reasoning here was that the primary purpose of the time limit is to ensure prompt enforcement of the lien, and where the lien can be corrected, the purpose is still served.

Fourthly, the court addressed whether it can make orders to restore the parties to their previous position after the expiry of a statutory time period. The court found that it could do so, as the purpose of such orders is to prevent unjust enrichment and ensure that the parties are restored to the position they would have been in had the statutory time period been complied with. The court's reasoning was that equity demands that parties should not be unjustly enriched at the expense of another, and the court has the power to make such orders to prevent this.

Lastly, the court considered whether section 64 of the Real Property Act 1900 (SA) empowers a court to make orders to restore the parties to their previous position even after the expiry of the statutory time period. The court found that it does, as the language of the statute is broad enough to allow for such orders. The court's reasoning was that the purpose of the statutory time period is to ensure prompt resolution of disputes, and where the period has expired, the court has the power to make orders to restore the parties to their previous position to prevent unjust enrichment.

In conclusion, the court in Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd v Alan Sheppard Constructions Pty Ltd held that Sheppard Constructions was entitled to a lien on the property where work had been performed, that the notice of lien could be amended after registration, that the failure to bring proceedings within the statutory time period did not render the lien void, that the court could make orders to restore the parties to their previous position after the expiry of the statutory time period, and that section 64 of the Real Property Act 1900 (SA) empowers a court to make such orders. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a court has the power to amend a notice of lien, restore the parties to their previous position, and make orders under section 64 of the Real Property Act 1900 (SA) even after the expiry of a statutory time period.