EWR18 v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

EWR18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1460

File number: NSD 1756 of 2018
Judge: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 21 September 2018
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for interlocutory injunction to remove applicants from Nauru in order to receive appropriate medical and mental health treatment – where applicants are living on Nauru – where medical evidence indicated significant and deteriorating physical and mental health issues – whether serious question to be tried that respondents owe applicants a duty of care to provide them with a level of medical care appropriate to meet their needs – whether balance of convenience favours granting injunction
Legislation:

Constitution s 61

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 55ZF

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 198AHA

Legal Services Directions 2017 (Cth) Sch 1, Appendix B

Cases cited:

ABAR15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 363

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57

Beecham Group Limited v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618

Bullock v The Federated Furnishing Trades Society of Australasia (No 1) (1985) 5 FCR 464

DCQ18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 918

FRX17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 63

MZYYR v Secretary, Department of Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 694; 292 ALR 659

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Fejzullahu [2000] HCA 23; 171 ALR 341

S v Secretary, Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 143 FCR 217

SZTZM v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 534

Date of hearing: 21 September 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 58
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr D F Villa & Ms D Tang
Solicitor for the Applicants: The National Justice Project
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr A Markus of Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD 1756 of 2018
BETWEEN:

EWR18

First Applicant

EXI18 BY HIS LITIGATION REPRESENTATIVE EXJ18

Second Applicant

EXJ18

Third Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

THAWLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 SEPTEMBER 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to r 9.05(1)(b)(iii) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), EXJ18 be joined as the third applicant.

2.Pursuant to r 9.62 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the third applicant be appointed as the litigation representative for the second applicant.

3.On the grounds set out at s 37AG(1)(a) and (c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), publication of the following information be prohibited under s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order or six months from today, whichever first occurs:

(a)the name of the applicants or any member of the applicants’ family;

(b)the identification number of the boat on which any applicant first arrived in Australia; and

(c)the age of the first or third applicants;

(d)the age of the second applicant, other than…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EWR18 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1460
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants in this case, nationals of Country X, sought an interlocutory injunction to be removed from Nauru to Australia in order to receive urgent medical and mental health treatment. The first applicant is the mother of the second applicant, who is a minor, and the third applicant is the deceased son's widow. They were transferred to Nauru in 2014 and have been living in various accommodation areas since then. The medical condition of each applicant has deteriorated significantly since the suicide of the second applicant's older brother in June 2018. The applicants' solicitors wrote to the Minister for Home Affairs requesting their immediate removal from Nauru so that they could receive appropriate and urgent medical care. The Minister did not respond to this request, and the applicants commenced proceedings seeking the relief they did.

The legal issues before the court were whether there was a serious question to be tried that the respondents owed the applicants a duty of care to provide them with a level of medical care appropriate to meet their needs, and whether the balance of convenience favoured granting the interlocutory injunction. The court found that the applicants could not get the urgent treatment that they required in Nauru and that their respective situations could only deteriorate further in the circumstances in which they found themselves. The court granted the interlocutory relief sought and ordered the Minister to transfer the applicants to a location where they could receive the specified treatment. The court also ordered that the Minister not return the applicants to Nauru without giving five clear business days’ notice in writing to the applicants’ solicitor or, in the event there is no solicitor on the record, the applicants. The court ordered that the Minister pay the applicants' costs of the interlocutory application unless leave was exercised within seven days to approach the court for a different order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 9.05(1)(b)(iii) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), EXJ18 be joined as the third applicant.

2. Pursuant to r 9.62 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the third applicant be appointed as the litigation representative for the second applicant.

3. On the grounds set out at s 37AG(1)(a) and (c) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), publication of the following information be prohibited under s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), until further order or six months from today, whichever first occurs:

(a) the name of the applicants or any member of the applicants’ family;

(b) the identification number of the boat on which any applicant first arrived in Australia; and

(c) the age of the first or third applicants;

(d) the age of the second applicant, other than the fact that he is a minor;

(e) the country of origin of applicants;

(f) the name of any current employee of International Health and Medical Services.

4. The first applicant hereafter be identified as EWR18.

5. The second applicant hereafter be identified as EXI18 by his litigation representative EXJ18.

6. The third applicant hereafter be identified as EXJ18.

7. An order that the Minister by himself or by his Department, officers, agents or delegates shall, on an urgent basis, transfer the applicants to a location where the applicants can receive the ‘Specified Treatment’.

For the purpose of these orders, ‘Specified Treatment’ means:

(a) as soon as is reasonably practicable, assessment in a tertiary hospital and such treatment as may be identified as necessary or appropriate as a result of the foregoing assessment; and

(b) treatment provided by specialists not contracted by International Health and Medical Services or Australian Border Force.

8. The respondents shall not return the applicants to Nauru without giving five clear business days’ notice in writing to the applicants’ solicitor or, in the event there is no solicitor on the record, the applicants.

9. Subject to the first respondent exercising leave to approach the Court for a different order, such leave to be exercised within 7 days, the first respondent is to pay the applicants’ costs of the interlocutory application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The first applicant is the mother of the second applicant, who is a minor. The third applicant is the daughter-in-law of the first applicant. She married the first applicant’s eldest son who committed suicide on Nauru on 15 June 2018. At the commencement of the hearing, I appointed the third applicant (who was then not a party to the proceedings) as the litigation representative for the second applicant. She was later joined to the proceedings. The orders which had been sought by the first and second applicants were to the effect that the third applicant also be removed from Nauru and brought to Australia for medical treatment. BACKGROUND The applicants are nationals of Country X who fled that country in 2013. The first and second applicants travelled to Australia by boat, which was intercepted by the Australian Border Force and escorted to Christmas Island in July 2013. The third applicant fled Country X by a different boat, which was intercepted by an Australian Customs vessel and taken to Christmas Island, also in July 2013. Following understandings reached between the Commonwealth of Australia and Nauru, all three applicants were transferred to Nauru in January 2014. They were housed in a regional processing centre for four years until the first applicant’s eldest son committed suicide earlier this year. After that event, the first and second applicants were admitted to the Supported Accommodation Area of Nauru Regional Processing Centre 1 (RPC1). The applicants were subsequently moved to the Managed Accommodation Area (MAA) and later to the Restricted Accommodation Area (RAA), where they have remained since around 22 July 2018 under the watch of the International Health and Medical Services (IHMS). IHMS are contracted by the Australian Government to provide health services on Nauru. The Minister has access to the health records maintained by the IHMS. The applicants have never been provided a placement in a community settlement on Nauru. The medical evidence will be set out in further detail below, however in summary form, the condition of each of the applicants has steadily deteriorated to a point where it is indicated that their removal is both appropriate and urgent. The respective medical conditions of each of the applicants deteriorated substantially following the suicide of the first applicant’s eldest son (being the second applicant’s older brother and the third applicant’s late-husband). On 26 July 2018, the solicitor for the applicants wrote to the Minister requesting the immediate removal of the applicants from Nauru. The request was made so that the applicants could be provided with appropriate and urgent medical care. The letter was provided by email, sent also to the Australian Government Solicitor (AGS), and included the following:I am writing to request the immediate removal from Nauru of [the first applicant], her [minor son] and her daughter-in-law … (our “Clients”) in order that they be provided with appropriate and urgent medical care. …On 17 July 2018, [the first applicant] attempted suicide by cutting her wrist and attempted to strangulate herself which left a ligature mark around her neck. On 19 July 2018 she further self-harmed by repeatedly hitting herself with rocks until she started to bleed. …Since his brother’s suicide in June 2018 [the second applicant] has been exposed to his mother’s highly distressed state of crying and shouting, appeared distressed himself, very teary with a flat mood.On 3 July 2018 [the second applicant] was assessed by a psychologist to be at high risk of self-harm and suicidal ideations. His suicidal ideation fluctuated according to his contact with his mother …On or about 20 July 2018 [the second applicant] attempted to cut himself with a knife, however was stopped by security with the result being a small scratch on his wrist. He was placed on high watch, however attempted again with similar results on 23 July 2018. There are reports of his increasing depressive state and suicidal ideations to ‘be with his brother’. …Since her husband’s passing on 15 June 2018 [the third applicant] has been observed to be in obvious signs of distress, crying, hitting her chest and head, and depressed. She spent a significant period continuously outside on a mattress in the heat, next to the fence of the MAA, on the other side of which her husband’s body was in a container. She decreased her food and fluid intake over a number of days and on 20 June 2018 began food and fluid refusal, in the context of the unknown and unresolved circumstances surrounding the death of her husband. At times she took small amounts of oral fluid; and continually declined to engage with IHMS.The only plan noted was for her to remain in MAA for respite until planned discharge date (22.6.18).REQUEST FOR URGENT ATTENTIONThe Commonwealth and the Department of Home Affairs are now on notice that the long-term health and possibly the lives of our Clients are at risk due to:1. The living conditions on Nauru;2.The mental health care that has been provided to our Clients to date has been ineffective; and3.That the mental health care they now urgently require, is not and cannot be delivered in Nauru.The Commonwealth and the Department have a duty to act by facilitating the urgent removal of our Clients from the environment that is causing harm to a place where they can obtain the necessary medical care. …We have instructions to commence legal action without further notice but given the urgency of this matter we would prefer to work quickly and efficiently with your client [the Minister].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Although asked directly, no explanation was provided as to why no substantive response had ever been provided to the requests which had been made for the urgent removal of the applicants from Nauru. ADDITIONAL MEDICAL EVIDENCE There was a significant amount of medical material before the Court in relation to the applicants in addition to that referred to above. In relation to the first applicant, that material reveals the following. The IHMS made requests on 27 February 2017, 29 June 2017, 12 October 2017 and 3 April 2018 that the first applicant be removed from Nauru in order to access specialist assessment, treatment and/or surgery for chronic urinary incontinence and symptoms suggestive of vaginal prolapse. The history of her physical problems can be summarised as follows. On 14 June 2016, she was taken to Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea to undergo a hysterectomy, endometrial ablation and dilation and curettage at the Pacific International Hospital. The doctor who carried out the procedure noted other serious gynaecological problems, including a moderately large cystocoele or prolapse and obvious pelvic floor laxity. The first applicant also presented with chronic back pain two weeks post-surgery and stress incontinence but “[t]hese symptoms were not further evaluated because these were not approved”. During her time in Port Moresby she presented with significant mental health concerns and stated she wanted to end her life. She was placed on “High Whiskey Watch – Within Arm’s Length” and given medication. The phrase “High Whiskey Watch” is used to refer to a patient who requires constant monitoring to protect against self-harm. The IHMS referral request of 27 February 2017 included:Currently, [the first applicant] is suffering from worsening urinary incontinence causing significant personal distress and having an adverse effect on her quality of life. The condition is potentially treatable but without specialist evaluation and management, she will have ongoing symptoms with adverse consequences on her quality of life and the potential for local soft tissue complications such as skin excoriation and infection. IHMS Assistance recommends that [the first applicant] be transferred to Australia or equivalent third country option for further urogynaecology review and management. The IHMS referral request of 29 June 2017 included:[The first applicant] requires transfer for urogynaecological assessment (including urodynamic studies) and definitive urogynaecological management of stress and urge incontinence associated with vaginal prolapse.IHMS has received a further opinion from Dr Maneesh Singh (Docto) who recommends that a urodynamic assessment be undertaken prior to any surgery being performed. Neither the RON [Republic of Nauru] hospital nor PIH [Pacific International Hospital] have the capacity to undertake this assessment nor do they have the capacity to undertake any required surgery. Based on the report from DOCTO, IHMS recommends the client to be transferred to Australia to have a urologynaecological assessment which will involve urodynamic studies and based on these results, to receive definitive management.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is clear that the applicants cannot get the urgent treatment that they require in Nauru. It appears that their respective situations can only deteriorate further in the circumstances in which they find themselves.CONCLUSION For these reasons, it is appropriate to grant the interlocutory relief sought. The applicants applied for costs. I made an order for costs in their favour but in terms which permitted the Minister to apply for a different order if such application were made within seven days. No application was made. One matter I took into account in making the order for costs was the fact that the applicants had no choice but to commence proceedings seeking the relief they did in light of the fact that the Minister did not respond to a single letter that had been written requesting the urgent transfer of the applicants from Nauru and indicating that proceedings would be commenced. As has been noted earlier, those letters included detailed accounts of the conditions of the applicants and was supported by substantial medical evidence from treating doctors. The Minister also had access to the medical records kept by IHMS which contained extensive records in respect of the medical conditions of the applicants, some of which have been set out above. As noted above, the failure by the Minister to respond to the letters written on behalf of the applicants over an extended period was left unexplained. The failure to communicate any substantive response to these letters fell short of what is expected of a model litigant – cf: Appendix B of Schedule 1 to the Legal Services Directions 2017 (Cth) made under s 55ZF of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.