Applications for interlocutory injunctions and referral of discrete issue for judicial determination - Plaintiff and first defendant entered into two contracts to construct grain silos and supporting structural work - Two performance guarantees were provided as security for the performance of the contracts - Second defendant was named beneficiary in the performance guarantees - First defendant alleged defects in the construction work - Dispute as between the parties as to construction requirements under the contract - First defendant gave Notices of Termination of the contracts - Plaintiff claimed repudiation which it accepted - Second defendant gave notice that first defendant would call on the performance guarantees under the contracts - Plaintiff seeks to prevent both defendants from calling on the performance guarantees - Whether there is a serious question to be tried as to interpretation of underlying contract and performance guarantees, whether the contracts were validly terminated and whether the Notice from second defendant met the criteria outlined in the contract - Whether the balance of convenience is in favour of the plaintiff - Performance guarantees due to expire on 29 February 2008 - Whether damages would be an adequate remedy.
Held: There are serious questions to be tried as to the interpretation of the underlying contract and performance guarantees as well as whether the contracts were validly terminated by the first defendant and whether the Notice met the contractual criteria - Upon the plaintiff extending the termination for the performance guarantees, the balance of convenience lies in favour of granting the injunction - Damages would not be an adequate remedy - Conditional injunctions granted – Application as to determination of discrete issue dismissed.
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ewing International LP v Ausbulk Limited ACN 007 556 256 and more:
The case of Ewing International LP v Ausbulk Limited ACN 007 556 256 involves the plaintiff, Ewing International LP, seeking interlocutory injunctions against the first and second defendants, Ausbulk Limited and ABB Grain Limited respectively, in relation to two performance guarantees provided for the construction of grain storage silos and structural work. The primary dispute centers around the interpretation of the contracts, the validity of termination notices, and whether the balance of convenience favours the plaintiff. The Federal Court of Australia presided over the case, hearing submissions over two days and extending time for supplementary submissions and potential orders.
The legal issues before the court encompassed whether there was a serious question to be tried regarding the interpretation of the underlying contracts and performance guarantees, the validity of the termination of the contracts by the first defendant, and whether the notice from the second defendant met the contractual criteria. Additionally, the court had to determine if the balance of convenience lay in favour of the plaintiff and whether damages would be an adequate remedy. The performance guarantees were set to expire on 29 February 2008, adding urgency to the proceedings.
The court found that there were serious questions to be tried concerning the interpretation of the contracts and performance guarantees, as well as the validity of the termination notices. Upon the plaintiff extending the termination for the performance guarantees, the balance of convenience shifted in favour of granting the injunctions. The court also concluded that damages would not be an adequate remedy. Consequently, conditional interlocutory injunctions were granted against both defendants. The application to refer a discrete issue for judicial determination was dismissed.
In summary, the court granted the injunctions based on the presence of a serious question to be tried, the balance of convenience in favour of the plaintiff, and the inadequacy of damages as a remedy. The specific orders were to be determined if the court was to grant the injunctions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
I heard oral submissions on 22 and 23 January 2008 and gave further liberty to Mr Jenner to provide supplementary reply submissions on the law. I also extended time to 29 January 2008 for the parties to indicate whether they could agree to certain orders if I was to grant the injunctions.Facts Ewing is a limited liability partnership registered under the Partnership Act 1958 (Vic) and was set up for the purpose of trading in Australia. Ewing Construction Ltd (“ECL”) is a corporation registered in New Zealand. There is commonality between the shareholders of ECL and the partners of Ewing such that they are significantly overlapping, but not entirely. The business of both Ewing and ECL relates to a niche market of steel tank fabrication works both in Australia and New Zealand. Without going into further detail at this point, the essential facts are that there were two contracts between Ewing and the first defendant, Ausbulk Limited (“Ausbulk”). Both contracts were entered into on 24 January 2006. The first contract concerned the construction of grain storage bins or silos for a contract sum of $18.4 million (“the silos contract”). This contract had a job number “OHB/02/011-003” and work number “EWO141184”. The date for Practical Completion was to be 11 January 2007. The second contract was in relation to the structural work concerning the silos contract for a sum of $4,961,480 (“Structural Shell Package 2”). This contract had a job number “OHB/02/011-007” and work number “EWO1419193”. The Practical Completion date was to be 20 February 2007. The contract for the works agreed to between the parties included significant documentation, discussed hereafter. Each contract required security for performance of the contract as discussed hereafter. Two Performance Guarantees were provided by the ASB Bank Ltd of Auckland, New Zealand (“ASB”), naming the second defendant ABB Grain Limited (“ABB Grain”) as the beneficiary of $400,000 and $496,100 respectively. These are the two bank guarantees which are the subject of the injunction. ABB Grain is the holding company of Ausbulk.The contracts and the Performance Guarantees The documents, which comprised the contracts, are referred to in letters dated 13 December 2005.[1] The prime documents relevant to these applications are contained in various exhibits to the Heard Affidavit and the Kearney Affidavits.[1] The Heard Affidavit, Exhibits MH1 and MH2. The silos contract was for construction of 10 silo tanks for grain storage. The contract was for their fabrication and construction without any design component.[2] The tanks were to have a capacity of 7,500 tonnes and were to be elevated so that vehicles could drive beneath and receive the grain. The silos included the erection of wall plates (“strake plates”) which are circular structures which support the walls of the silos. The construction of the strake plates and the silo walls later became a significant matter of dispute between Ausbulk and Ewing.[2] The Gentilcore Affidavit, [7.1].
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The plaintiff (“Ewing”), at the hearing before me, sought to maintain the application for the injunction as the primary relief sought and, secondly, if it was unsuccessful, to have the Court deal with a particular contractual issue to be heard and determined on limited evidence prior to the date when the guarantees expire, namely by 29 February 2008. The same argument sought to be finally determined by a court on the contractual issue, emerged as a fundamental plank proffered by Ewing in support of its submission that there was a serious issue to be tried in relation to the grant of an injunction.Evidence The documentary evidence tendered by the parties was considerable and was as follows:·Affidavit and 19 exhibits of Michael Heard sworn on 18 December 2007 (“the Heard Affidavit”) (Exhibit P1);·A document entitled Performance Guarantee (Exhibit P2);·Notice of proceeding for the appointment of a liquidator to Ewing Construction Limited in the High Court of New Zealand with respect to alleged indebtedness (Exhibit D1);·Correspondence between solicitors for the plaintiff and solicitors for the defendant, respectively dated 16 January 2008 and 21 January 2008 (Exhibit D2);·Affidavit and 36 exhibits of John Joseph Gentilcore sworn on 14 January 2008 (“the Gentilcore Affidavit”) (Exhibit D3);·Affidavit and 4 exhibits of James Brendon Kearney sworn on 11 January 2008 (“the First Kearney Affidavit”) (Exhibit D4);·Affidavit and 9 exhibits of James Brendon Kearney sworn on 21 January 2008 (“the Second Kearney Affidavit”) (Exhibit D5); and·Bundle of correspondence between solicitors for the parties (Exhibit D6). In addition, Michael Heard, a partner of Ewing, gave evidence and was cross-examined by Mr Blue QC counsel for the defendant. Mr Jenner of counsel represented Ewing. I heard oral submissions on 22 and 23 January 2008 and gave further liberty to Mr Jenner to provide supplementary reply submissions on the law. I also extended time to 29 January 2008 for the parties to indicate whether they could agree to certain orders if I was to grant the injunctions.Facts Ewing is a limited liability partnership registered under the Partnership Act 1958 (Vic) and was set up for the purpose of trading in Australia. Ewing Construction Ltd (“ECL”) is a corporation registered in New Zealand. There is commonality between the shareholders of ECL and the partners of Ewing such that they are significantly overlapping, but not entirely. The business of both Ewing and ECL relates to a niche market of steel tank fabrication works both in Australia and New Zealand. Without going into further detail at this point, the essential facts are that there were two contracts between Ewing and the first defendant, Ausbulk Limited (“Ausbulk”). Both contracts were entered into on 24 January 2006. The first contract concerned the construction of grain storage bins or silos for a contract sum of $18.4 million (“the silos contract”). This contract had a job number “OHB/02/011-003” and work number “EWO141184”. The date for Practical Completion was to be 11 January 2007.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The court decided, first, that there was a bona fide claim made which would become worthless, and second, it was not necessary to have a court determine that the right had been established. It decided that the refusal of the injunction was in all of the circumstances appropriate.Conclusion Having undertaken the above exercise with regard to the case law and applying it to the facts before me, I consider that Ewing arguably has a cause of action by way of injunction which, having regard to the clauses 5.5 in conjunction with the other matters previously referred to, casts sufficient doubt as to whether Ausbulk can in fact appropriately trigger a demand being made on ASB. On that basis I consider that I am satisfied that there is a sufficient basis upon which Ewing may have to seek to sustain the application for an injunction. With regard to ABB Grain, the situation is different. ABB Grain is a party to the Performance Agreements, Ewing is not. In my view, the Performance Guarantees appear to be unconditional and subject only to process requirements. In no way could it be said to require the bank to investigate the matters contained in the statement. Having said that, it is obvious on the face of the document that ABB Grain would have to state that Ewing had been in breach of its obligations to it and indicate the respect in which Ewing was in breach of its contract. ABB Grain is now aware of the error. If ABB Grain sought to assert a breach(es) of contract between Ewing and itself, this would be a false representation to the bank made knowingly. This would prima facie amount to fraud.[86] Therefore, absent some process such as rectification, Ewing, which is an interested person and a party to the underlying contract, may appropriately seek to contend that recourse by ABB Grain to the Performance Guarantees would be fraudulent and in my view this would also amount to a serious issue to be tried.[86] Derry v Peek (1889) 14 App.Cas 337, 334 (Lord Herschell). On this basis I am satisfied that there is an appropriate basis upon which Ewing may seek to sustain an application for injunction against ABB Grain. I now turn to the second part of the criteria for an interlocutory injunction.Balance of convenience This requires me to consider whether any inconvenience or injury to Ewing if the interlocutory injunction is not granted, outweighs the defendants’ injury or damage which would be sustained, if the interlocutory injunction is granted. The combination of the affidavit of Mr Heard and his evidence is that Ewing, and its related party ECL, are likely to suffer the following harm:·Ewing’s inability to tender for work in Australia;·Ewing’s and ECL’s reduced inability to negotiate for and/or accept large projects which require significant Performance Guarantees. At the present time its limit on all facilities is $1.1m, although it has at times crept to $1.2m.·The balance of available security has been utilised to hold off or “drip feed” creditors who have made claims against Ewing for monies owed in relation to the contracts. About $1.2m is owing. ECL is one of the creditors for about $400,000 and the other $800,000 is owed to arms length creditors.·Ewing has no other assets.·Injunctions will cause damage to the goodwill and reputation of Ewing and ECL. Sub-contractors and suppliers gossip and already ECL is having difficulties getting its usual commercial terms for supplies.·There is a perception by Ewing’s and ECL’s clients and suppliers that the companies are unable to properly perform their contractual obligations.[87]·ECL’s and Ewing’s ability to win tenders will be diminished if both companies are required, in the tendering process, to reveal to potential principals that performance guarantees have been called upon.[88] At the hearing, Mr Heard, in evidence acknowledged that “pre-qualification” is not the norm and generally occurs in one out of 20 tenders. Nevertheless, pre-qualification is usually a requirement when tendering for big infrastructure projects or government or navy projects. [87] The Heard Affidavit, [81].[88] Ibid, [82], T35.