EUB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

EUB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 124

File number(s): ADG 496 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 7 February 2025 
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review application – citizen of Pakistan – decision of the Immigration Assessment authority – refusal of Safe Haven Enterprise visa – where admitted breach by Secretary of the Minister’s department of requirement to provide to the Immigration Assessment Authority material provided to the Delegate of the Minister prior to the Delegate making a decision – whether material not provided to the Immigration Assessment Authority was new information – whether failure to exercise discretion to rectify breach by considering material not provided was unreasonable – whether material jurisdictional error
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) Pt 7AA, ss 5, 5H, 36, 473CB, 473DB, 473DC, 473DD, 474, 476

Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Bill 2014 (Cth)

Cases cited:

ApplicantWAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630

AUS17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] HCA 37; (2020) 269 CLR 494; (2020) 94 ALJR 1007; (2020) 384 ALR 196

BVT20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 222; (2020) 283 FCR 97; (2020) 385 ALR 286

CPJ17v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (No 2) [2018] FCA 1664

DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2; (2018) 258 FCR 175; (2018) 74 AAR 121; (2018) 353 ALR 641

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088; (2003) 197 ALR 389; (2003) 73 ALD 321

DVO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 12; (2021) 273 CLR 177; (2021) 95 ALJR 375; (2021) 388 ALR 389; (2021) 178 ALD 1

EVS17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 20; (2019) 268 FCR 299; (2019) 163 ALD 422

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12; (2024) 98 ALJR 610; (2024) 418 ALR 152

Ludgero v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCCA 1060; (2021) 358 FLR 215

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CED16 [2020] HCA 24; (2020) 94 ALJR 706; (2020) 380 ALR 216

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CPA16 [2019] FCAFC 40; (2019) 268 FCR 379; (2019) 163 ALD 469

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Pandey [2014] FCA 640; (2014) 143 ALD 640

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Singh [2014] FCAFC 1; (2014) 231 FCR 437; (2014) 308 ALR 280; (2014) 139 ALD 50

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW [2018] HCA 30; (2018) 264 CLR 541; (2018) 92…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EUB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 124
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of EUB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involves a judicial review application by a citizen of Pakistan, EUB19, against the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) not to grant him a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa. EUB19, who arrived in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival, argued that the IAA had unreasonably failed to exercise its discretion to rectify the Secretary’s breach of the Migration Act by not providing a medical certificate to the IAA. The key issue before the court was whether the failure to consider the medical certificate constituted a material jurisdictional error that affected the decision to deny EUB19 a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa.

The court examined the statutory framework and relevant authorities to determine the threshold for material jurisdictional error. It noted that a decision could be set aside if it was affected by such an error, and the court must be careful not to assume the function of the decision-maker, maintaining the line between judicial review and merits review. The court found that EUB19 had established an error and demonstrated a realistic possibility that the outcome could have been different had the error not occurred, thus meeting the threshold of materiality.

In conclusion, the court found that the failure to consider the medical certificate was indeed a material jurisdictional error. Consequently, the court quashed the decision of the IAA and remitted the matter back to the IAA for reconsideration, taking into account the medical certificate and its implications for EUB19’s application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

All references to the Migration Act in these Reasons for Judgment are to the provisions therein as they were at the time of the Authority Decision. BACKGROUND AND CLAIMS EUB19’s background and claims advanced in support of the SHE Visa application were as follows:(a)EUB19, a citizen of Pakistan, arrived on Christmas Island as an unauthorised maritime arrival on 8 July 2013: CB 52;(b)on 22 November 2016 EUB19 lodged an application for the SHE Visa: CB 31-68, and advanced the following claims:(i)he was a Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity from Pakistan;(ii)in his home area of Parachinar, he witnessed bomb blasts arising from the violence between the Taliban and the Pakistani Army;(iii)in March 2013, whilst driving a taxi, he was injured and nearly killed in a bomb blast, and he had lost many of his cousins to similar bomb blasts; and(iv)he feared harm from the Taliban, the Sunni community and other insurgent groups due to his status as a Shia Muslim and as a person who had lived in the West.AUTHORITY DECISION In relation to the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)had regard to the review material given by the Secretary under s 473CB of the Migration Act: CB 118 at [3];(b)recorded that at the interview by the Delegate (“Delegate Interview”) the Delegate had said that he would photocopy a medical certificate (“Medical Certificate”) that EUB19 provided and had assured EUB19 that the Medical Certificate would be taken into account in the Delegate’s review: CB 118 at [4];(c)said that no Medical Certificate was included in the review material provided by the Secretary under s 473CB of the Migration Act: CB 118 at [4];(d)said that it sought clarification from the Delegate as to whether the Medical Certificate was before it for consideration, and that the Delegate had confirmed that the Medical Certificate was neither photocopied nor taken into consideration by the Delegate, and the Medical Certificate could not be located: CB 118 at [4];(e)decided that because EUB19 did not provide any submissions on the Medical Certificate and his claims did not relate to his health or that Medical Certificate, it would not invite him to provide the Medical Certificate: CB 118 at [4];(f)recorded that no new information had been obtained or received: CB 118 at [4];(g)accepted, at CB 119 at [8]-[9] that:(i)Pakistan was EUB19’s receiving country;(ii)he was a practising Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity;(iii)he worked as a driver;(iv)his family continued to reside in Parachinar; and(v)Kurram was the area to which he would return: CB 119 at [9];(h)found that EUB19 would be identifiable as a Bangash Pashtun Shia from Parachinar based on his identity documents, religious practices, accent and physical features: CB 119-120 at [10];(i)based on country information: (i)accepted that there previously was a high level of sectarian violence in Kurram which impacted EUB19 and his family, and that EUB19 witnessed or was aware of bombing in his area and that he had lost relatives to the bombing: CB 120-121 at [12];(ii)accepted that at times EUB19 would have been unable to leave his home and that he was encouraged by his family to depart Pakistan so that he would provide for his family from overseas: CB 120-121 at [12]; and(iii)found that his community was viewed as anti-Taliban: CB 120-121 at [12];(j)whilst accepting that EUB19’s car was hit by a bomb blast found that that was not because he was on the Taliban’s “hit list” as claimed but was due to general sectarian violence: CB 121 at [13];(k)was not satisfied on the evidence that EUB19 was of adverse attention to the Taliban or anyone else: CB 121 at [13];(l)based on country information, and contrary to the Delegate’s Decision, was not satisfied that EUB19 faced a real chance of serious or significant harm in Kurram District: CB 121-122 at [14]-[19];(m)found, contrary to EUB19’s submission, that the issues of corruption and resource constraints did not impede the Pakistani authorities’ ability to take action to improve the safety of Shias and Shia Bangash: CB 122-123 at [20]-[21];(n)did not accept that EUB19 would be unable to seek help because the Sunni Muslim community in his area had links to the Taliban, and found that the Pakistani authorities had security measures in place to tackle extremist groups: CB 123 at [22];(o)found that the country information did not support EUB19’s claim that driving in Pakistan was dangerous due to the targeting of Shias: CB 123 at [23];(p)recorded that it was not apparent that EUB19 had claimed to fear harm on the basis of his Pashtun ethnicity, but in any event it reviewed the country information and found that there was not a real chance of EUB19 facing discrimination, violence or other issues due to his status as a Pashtun or Shia Pashtun: CB 124 at [24];(q)with respect to EUB19’s status as a person returning from the West, found that Western influence was pervasive in many parts of Pakistan and was not satisfied that EUB19 would be discriminated against or subjected to violence for his time spent in a Western country, and that he would be able to reintegrate into Pakistani society: CB 124 at [25];(r)found that EUB19 did not face a real chance of any harm for any of the reasons claimed and concluded that EUB19 did not meet the definition of refugee in s 5H of the Migration Act and did not meet s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act: CB 124-125 at [26]-[27];(s)relying on its anterior findings, concluded that EUB19 did not face a real risk of significant harm and did not meet s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act: CB 125 at [28]-[31]; and(t)affirmed the Delegate’s Decision to not grant EUB19 a SHE Visa: CB 117-129.AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION – SINGLE GROUND OF REVIEW

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

EUB19’s background and claims advanced in support of the SHE Visa application were as follows:(a)EUB19, a citizen of Pakistan, arrived on Christmas Island as an unauthorised maritime arrival on 8 July 2013: CB 52;(b)on 22 November 2016 EUB19 lodged an application for the SHE Visa: CB 31-68, and advanced the following claims:(i)he was a Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity from Pakistan;(ii)in his home area of Parachinar, he witnessed bomb blasts arising from the violence between the Taliban and the Pakistani Army;(iii)in March 2013, whilst driving a taxi, he was injured and nearly killed in a bomb blast, and he had lost many of his cousins to similar bomb blasts; and(iv)he feared harm from the Taliban, the Sunni community and other insurgent groups due to his status as a Shia Muslim and as a person who had lived in the West.AUTHORITY DECISION In relation to the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)had regard to the review material given by the Secretary under s 473CB of the Migration Act: CB 118 at [3];(b)recorded that at the interview by the Delegate (“Delegate Interview”) the Delegate had said that he would photocopy a medical certificate (“Medical Certificate”) that EUB19 provided and had assured EUB19 that the Medical Certificate would be taken into account in the Delegate’s review: CB 118 at [4];(c)said that no Medical Certificate was included in the review material provided by the Secretary under s 473CB of the Migration Act: CB 118 at [4];(d)said that it sought clarification from the Delegate as to whether the Medical Certificate was before it for consideration, and that the Delegate had confirmed that the Medical Certificate was neither photocopied nor taken into consideration by the Delegate, and the Medical Certificate could not be located: CB 118 at [4];(e)decided that because EUB19 did not provide any submissions on the Medical Certificate and his claims did not relate to his health or that Medical Certificate, it would not invite him to provide the Medical Certificate: CB 118 at [4];(f)recorded that no new information had been obtained or received: CB 118 at [4];(g)accepted, at CB 119 at [8]-[9] that:(i)Pakistan was EUB19’s receiving country;(ii)he was a practising Shia Muslim of Pashtun ethnicity;(iii)he worked as a driver;(iv)his family continued to reside in Parachinar; and(v)Kurram was the area to which he would return: CB 119 at [9];(h)found that EUB19 would be identifiable as a Bangash Pashtun Shia from Parachinar based on his identity documents, religious practices, accent and physical features: CB 119-120 at [10];(i)based on country information: (i)accepted that there previously was a high level of sectarian violence in Kurram which impacted EUB19 and his family, and that EUB19 witnessed or was aware of bombing in his area and that he had lost relatives to the bombing: CB 120-121 at [12];(ii)accepted that at times EUB19 would have been unable to leave his home and that he was encouraged by his family to depart Pakistan so that he would provide for his family from overseas: CB 120-121 at [12]; and(iii)found that his community was viewed as anti-Taliban: CB 120-121 at [12];(j)whilst accepting that EUB19’s car was hit by a bomb blast found that that was not because he was on the Taliban’s “hit list” as claimed but was due to general sectarian violence: CB 121 at [13];(k)was not satisfied on the evidence that EUB19 was of adverse attention to the Taliban or anyone else: CB 121 at [13];(l)based on country information, and contrary to the Delegate’s Decision, was not satisfied that EUB19 faced a real chance of serious or significant harm in Kurram District: CB 121-122 at [14]-[19];(m)found, contrary to EUB19’s submission, that the issues of corruption and resource constraints did not impede the Pakistani authorities’ ability to take action to improve the safety of Shias and Shia Bangash: CB 122-123 at [20]-[21];(n)did not accept that EUB19 would be unable to seek help because the Sunni Muslim community in his area had links to the Taliban, and found that the Pakistani authorities had security measures in place to tackle extremist groups: CB 123 at [22];(o)found that the country information did not support EUB19’s claim that driving in Pakistan was dangerous due to the targeting of Shias: CB 123 at [23];(p)recorded that it was not apparent that EUB19 had claimed to fear harm on the basis of his Pashtun ethnicity, but in any event it reviewed the country information and found that there was not a real chance of EUB19 facing discrimination, violence or other issues due to his status as a Pashtun or Shia Pashtun: CB 124 at [24];(q)with respect to EUB19’s status as a person returning from the West, found that Western influence was pervasive in many parts of Pakistan and was not satisfied that EUB19 would be discriminated against or subjected to violence for his time spent in a Western country, and that he would be able to reintegrate into Pakistani society: CB 124 at [25];(r)found that EUB19 did not face a real chance of any harm for any of the reasons claimed and concluded that EUB19 did not meet the definition of refugee in s 5H of the Migration Act and did not meet s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act: CB 124-125 at [26]-[27];(s)relying on its anterior findings, concluded that EUB19 did not face a real risk of significant harm and did not meet s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act: CB 125 at [28]-[31]; and(t)affirmed the Delegate’s Decision to not grant EUB19 a SHE Visa: CB 117-129.AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION – SINGLE GROUND OF REVIEW

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

EUB19 filed an amended application on 8 September 2023 with a single ground of review as follows:The IAA unreasonably failed to exercise s.473DC(3) of the Act to rectify the Secretary’s breach of s 473CB(1)(b) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)Particulars(a) At my protection visa interview, I did not have a lawyer and I gave the delegate a medical certificate about my depression and mental health issues.(b) The delegate told me he would take the issue into consideration when assessing my case but did not do so and instead found I was resilient and could relocate to another part of Pakistan.(c) The IAA did not let me know the document had been lost and did not consider my mental health at all.(d) It was unreasonable for the IAA to not give me the opportunity to provide this document when I had been told it would be taken into account and to not have regard to this issue.(e) A claim for complementary protection clearly emerged from this evidence and the failure to refer or obtain this document was jurisdictional error: CPJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (No 2) [2018] FCA 1664.CONSIDERATIONMaterial jurisdictional error For present purposes it suffices to observe that the Court may set aside a decision of the Authority upon judicial review if it is affected by material jurisdictional error: Migration Act, ss 474 and 476; MZAPC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2021] HCA 17; (2021) 273 CLR 506; (2021) 95 ALJR 441; (2021) 390 ALR 590; (2021) 177 ALD 464 (“MZAPC”) at [2] per Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane and Gleeson JJ. In LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12; (2024) 98 ALJR 610; (2024) 418 ALR 152 (“LPDT”) at [15]-[16] per Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson and Jagot JJ the plurality in the High Court said that:15.What must be shown to demonstrate that an established error meets the threshold of materiality will depend upon the error. In some cases, it will be sufficient to show that there has been an error and that the outcome is consistent with the error having affected the decision. Where the error is a denial of procedural fairness arising from a failure to put the applicant on notice of a fact or issue, the court may readily be able to infer that, if fairly put on notice of that fact or issue, the applicant might have addressed it by way of further evidence or submissions, and that the decision-maker would have approached the applicant's further evidence or submissions with an open mind. In those cases, it is “no easy task” for the court to be satisfied that the loss of such an opportunity did not deprive the person of the possibility of a successful outcome. Importantly, a court called upon to determine whether the threshold has been met must be careful not to assume the function of the decision-maker: the point at which the line between judicial review and merits review is crossed may not always be clear, but the line must be maintained. This case affords an example.16.In sum, unless there is identified a basis on which it can be affirmatively concluded that the outcome would inevitably have been the same had the error not been made, once an applicant establishes that there has been an error and demonstrates that there exists a realistic possibility that the outcome of the decision could have been different had that error not been made, the threshold of materiality will have been met (and curial relief will be justified subject to any issue of utility or discretion).Not merits review