English Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd v Phillips

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read
57 CLR 302

THE ENGLISH SCOTTISH AND AUSTRALIAN

BANK LIMITED PHILLIPS

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

SOUTH AUSTRALIA.

OF A. Torrens System--Mortgage of fee simple-Transfer of fee simple subject to mortgage

-Payment off of mortgage by original mortgagor-Transfer of mortgage to original mortgagor-Further transfers of mortgage-Personal covenant-Effect of ADELAIDE,

original mortgagor being registered as mortgagee-Merger-Whethe original 1936,

mortgagor liable to ultimate transferee of mortgage-Real Property Act 1886 Sept. 30;

(S.A.) (No. 380), secs. 57, 97, 143, 150, 151. Oct. 1, 2.

After giving a mortgage securing principal and interest, a registered pro- MELBOURNE,

prietor of land under the Real Property Act 1886 (S.A.) transferred the land 1937,

subject to the mortgage to a purchaser, and the land was thus transferred several times in succession. By reason of sec. 97 of the Act the person in whom the land was vested subject to the mortgage became in respect of the mortgage moneys liable directly to the mortgagee as well as to indemnify the mortgagor. The mortgagee having called up the mortgage moneys and the registered proprietor for the time being having failed to pay them, the mort- gagor took a transfer of the mortgage in consideration of a sum equivalent to the mortgage moneys and became registered proprietor of the mortgage. He afterwards transferred the mortgage to a stranger, who in turn transferred it to a bank. The bank brought an action against the original mortgagor to recover the mortgage moneys.

Held, by Dixon, Evatt and McTiernan JJ. (Latham C.J. and Starke J. dissent- ing), that the mortgagor was liable notwithstanding that for a time the mort gage had vested in him SO that the benefit of the personal covenant had resided

57 CLR 303

57 C.L.R.]

OF AUSTRALIA. in the covenantor, because under the Real Property Act system the mortgage was transferable to and by the mortgagor himself as a registered interest in land and it would be inconsistent with the statute to treat the vesting of the mortgage in the mortgagor as destroying the covenant as against subsequent transferees of the mortgage.

Per Latham C.J. and Starke J.: In such a case the mortgage is not merged in the fee simple, though the personal covenant is extinguished.

Decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia (Angas Parsons A.C.J.) English Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd. v. Phillips, (1935) S.A.S.R. 303,

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of South Australia.

George Phillips was the registered proprietor of an estate in fee simple in land subject to the provisions of the Real Property Act 1886 (S.A.). He executed a mortgage of this land to Robert Jones to secure payment of the sum of £782 10s. and interest thereon Subsequently he transferred the land, subject to this mortgage, to Charlotte Mary Harry. Charlotte Mary Harry executed a second mortgage over the land. The land was transferred, subject to these mortgages, several times until ultimately it was transferred to Edward William Brown. Edward William Brown executed a third mortgage over the land.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read English Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd v Phillips and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1937] HCA 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The English Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd. (the appellant) appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal concerned an action brought by the bank against George Phillips (the respondent) to recover mortgage moneys under a personal covenant contained in a mortgage. Phillips had originally mortgaged land under the Real Property Act 1886 (S.A.) to Robert Jones. Subsequently, Phillips transferred the land, subject to the mortgage, and the land passed through several subsequent transferees. The mortgagee, Robert Jones, called up the mortgage moneys, and when the registered proprietor of the land failed to pay, Phillips paid the mortgage moneys to Jones and took a transfer of the mortgage, becoming the registered proprietor of the mortgage. Phillips later transferred the mortgage to Randell Rowlands Jones, who then transferred it to the appellant bank.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether Phillips remained personally liable to the bank on his original mortgage covenant, despite having paid the mortgage moneys to the original mortgagee and subsequently becoming the registered proprietor of the mortgage himself. This involved determining the effect of a mortgagor taking a transfer of their own mortgage under the Torrens system, and whether this extinguished the personal covenant or merely suspended it, and if suspended, whether it could be revived upon subsequent transfer of the mortgage.

A majority of the High Court (Dixon, Evatt, and McTiernan JJ.) held that Phillips remained liable on his personal covenant. Their reasoning was that under the Real Property Act system, a mortgage is a transferable interest in land. While the vesting of the mortgage in the mortgagor might have temporarily suspended the personal covenant, it did not extinguish it. The Court found it inconsistent with the statutory framework to treat the vesting of the mortgage in the mortgagor as destroying the covenant, particularly against subsequent transferees of the mortgage. The majority distinguished this situation from a simple discharge of the mortgage, emphasizing that Phillips had taken a transfer, thereby preserving the security. The dissenting judges (Latham C.J. and Starke J.) held that while the mortgage itself did not merge with the fee simple, the personal covenant was extinguished when Phillips became the registered proprietor of the mortgage, and therefore the bank could not recover on that covenant.

The High Court, by a majority, allowed the appeal, overturning the decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Court ordered that Phillips was liable to the English Scottish and Australian Bank Ltd. on his personal covenant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established