Elton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

Elton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) [2016] AATA 479 (6 July 2016)

Division

VETERAN'S APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

2015/2851

Re

Peter Elton

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 6 July 2016
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

..................................[sgd]......................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – disability pension – claim for post-traumatic stress disorder, major depressive disorder, lumbar spondylosis and spondylolisthesis as being war-caused – operational service of 35 days in Vietnamese waters over two periods in 1969 and 1970 – in receipt of disability pension for various physical conditions – alcohol dependency and cannabis dependency both in remission – absence of any corroborating evidence regarding stressors – credit of the applicant – unreliability of evidence and conflict of evidence – satisfied beyond reasonable doubt – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986

Cases

Re Elton and Australian Trade Commission [2013] AATA 133
Re Elton and Repatriation Commission [2014] AATA 475
Repatriation Commission v Deledio (1998) 83 FCR 82
Border v Repatriation Commission (No 2) (2010) 191 FCR 163
Meehan v Repatriation Commission [2003] FCA 1371
Forrester v Repatriation Commission [2013] FCA 898
Re Cooke and Repatriation Commission (1998) 50 ALD 907
McKenna v Repatriation Commission (1999) 86 FCR 144
Repatriation Commission v Gosewinkel (1999) 59 ALD 690
Repatriation Commission v Bawden (2012) 206 FCR 296
Repatriation Commission v Codd (2007) 95 ALD 619
Repatriation Commission v Bey (1997) 79 FCR 364
Repatriation Commission v Hill (2002) 69 ALD 581
East v Repatriation Commission (1987) 16 FCR 517

Secondary Materials

Statement of Principles Instrument No 82 of 2014 Posttraumatic stress disorder

Statement of Principles Instrument No 5 of 2008 Posttraumatic stress disorder as amended by Instrument No 19 of 2014 Posttraumatic stress disorder

Statement of Principles Instrument No 102 of 2014 Anxiety disorder

Statement of Principles Instrument No 101 of 2007 Anxiety disorder

Statement of Principles Instrument 83 of 2015 Depressive disorder

Statement of Principles Instrument No 27 of 2008 Depressive disorder as amended by Instrument No 40 of 2010 Depressive disorder

Statement of Principles Instrument No 62 of 2014 Lumbar spondylosis

Statement of Principles Instrument No 37 of 2005 Lumbar spondylosis as amended by Instrument No 69 of 2013 Lumbar spondylosis

Statement of Principles Instrument No 59 of 2015 Spondylolisthesis and spondylolysis

Statement of Principles Instrument No 5 of 2006 Spondylolisthesis and spondylolysis as amended by Instrument No 44 of 2010 Spondylolisthesis and spondylolysis

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

6 July 2016

  1. Mr Elton lodged an application for an increase in pension and claim for acceptance of conditions in accordance with s 9 of the Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (the Act) with the Repatriation Commission (the Commission) on 14 August 2012. This claim related to his diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), a major depressive disorder (MDD) and lumbar spondylosis. The initial claim also made reference to a number of other conditions, which are not relevant for the purpose of this decision.

  2. On 10 October 2013,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elton and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 479
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Elton against a decision of the Repatriation Commission regarding his claim for an increased disability pension. Mr Elton sought this increase based on several claimed war-caused medical conditions, including Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), and lumbar spinal conditions. The dispute centred on whether these conditions were causally linked to his naval service, particularly during his deployments to Vietnam.

The Tribunal was required to determine the diagnosis and date of clinical onset of Mr Elton's claimed medical conditions to a reasonable satisfaction. Subsequently, it needed to assess whether these conditions were war-caused in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth). Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the claimed psychiatric conditions met the criteria for Category 1A Stressors and whether the lumbar spinal conditions were linked to a discrete injury sustained during service.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including Mr Elton's own testimony, medical reports, and previous decisions. It noted inconsistencies and a lack of corroboration in Mr Elton's account of events, particularly concerning the incidents he claimed constituted Category 1A Stressors. The Tribunal found that the weight of psychiatric evidence did not support a diagnosis of PTSD, and while a depressive disorder might be present, its onset did not meet the required timeframe for a war-caused condition. Regarding his lumbar back pain, the Tribunal found no record of a discrete injury to his spine that met the definition of trauma under the relevant Statements of Principles.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that, due to conflicting evidence, credibility issues, and a lack of corroboration, it was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Mr Elton's claimed psychiatric and lumbar spinal conditions were war-caused. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that the claim failed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Elton receives the disability pension at 100 per cent of the general rate and has a lifestyle rating of 4. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mr Elton enlisted as a recruit in the Royal Australian Navy (the Navy) on 7 July 1968. He was then 15 years and 9 months old. At that time, he was repeating Form 4 (Year 10) at Blackburn South High School, having failed Year 10 in six of eight subjects the previous year. On his three entry tests for the Navy, Mr Elton scored one ‘A’ grade and two ‘C’ grades. Both Mr Elton and his father were anxious for him to attend officer training school, but he was assessed by the naval psychologist as not meeting the required standard. Despite this, he finished his general 11 month training course on HMAS Leeuwin first in a class of 32 and was then assigned to training as an electrical mechanic. In the final examination for that specialty he was placed third in a class of seven. Mr Elton was discharged from the Navy for the given reason of services no longer required on 13 January 1972, having on 8 December 1971 pleaded guilty to possessing cannabis on board HMAS Sydney. The naval psychologist had on 27 September 1971 reported that Mr Elton had an exaggerated idea of his own capabilities and noted that they could not help feeling that we may someday see [Mr Elton] as a discharge case. Mr Elton’s service, most of which was in training, was from 7 July 1968 to 21 January 1972. During this period he served on the Sydney from 27 October 1969 to 15 July 1970. For 35 days in this period he was involved in the Sydney’s troop carrying services between Australia and Vung Tau Harbour in Vietnam. There were two such trips, the first between 17 November and 5 December 1969 and the second from 16 February to 5 March 1970. He therefore had operational service for the period 17 November 1969 and 5 March 1970. Mr Elton has described several incidents resulting in stressful experiences. The first of these was encountered during his training period on Leeuwin where he says bastardisation and physical and verbal attacks on junior recruits was the order of the day. He does not however, claim he suffered in any way during his period on Leeuwin. Mr Elton has described three incidents during his trips to Vietnam, which he claims meet the definition of a Category 1A Stressor in the relevant psychiatric Statements of Principles (SoPs) and resulted in his claimed psychological injuries. In the first of these incidents Mr Elton claims that in his haste to escape from below deck, having perceived that a catastrophic event had occurred on the Sydney, he fell and injured his back. This it was claimed had led to 45 years of chronic back pain. The three incidents are described as follows:Incident One: While sailing through a typhoon in the approach to Vung Tau Harbour during his first trip, Mr Elton was positioned below the waterline in the bow of the vessel when the Sydney shuddered and lurched. There followed an uncanny silence, which led Mr Elton to believe that the bow of the Sydney had broken off from the hull and that he was in the sinking part of the ship. He states he climbed the stairs from below deck to the flight deck as quickly as he could and was reassured to find the ship was perfectly intact.Incident Two: The second incident is said to have occurred on the same trip and in the same storm or, as described by Mr Elton, typhoon. He and another naval rating were on the flight deck for reasons he cannot recall and the Sydney was said to be lurching from side to side as well as pitching up and down in rough seas. Mr Elton says that he and his colleague were clinging to the rails around the forward lift and, in a lull in the storm, decided to run to the tower which was in a direct diagonal line across the flight deck. However, the pitching of the Sydney was such that their straight line between the forward lift and the tower became a wide arc. According to Mr Elton, they were in danger of going overboard, despite there being a fence around the perimeter of the deck. Mr Elton expressed surprise that no one came to help them given they were in full view of the tower at all times. He could not recall the name of the colleague with whom he experienced the incident. Incident Three: The third incident was described as occurring on both tours to Vietnam and concerned predominately the detonation of grenades or scare charges around the ship when in port, bombing runs, gunboats in the harbour, helicopters in the air and being surrounded by people carrying guns. While Mr Elton had told several medical practitioners he had stayed in Vung Tau Harbour for approximately two days on each occasion, the records reveal that the first visit was for just over six hours and the second was for four hours and forty-two minutes.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the decision dated 5 May 2015, the VRB determined that the weight of the psychiatric evidence was that Mr Elton does not suffer from PTSD. The VRB further determined that while Mr Elton may have a depressive disorder, its onset was not until 2012 or 2013 and therefore did not meet the requirement of the relevant SoPs that the clinical onset of the disorder be within five years of experiencing a Category 1A Stressor. In relation to the lumbar back pain diagnosed as lumbar spondylosis with spondylolisthesis, Mr Elton did not meet any of the SoP factors causally linking the condition to service. In particular, there was no record whatsoever of a discrete injury to Mr Elton’s spine meeting the definition of trauma to the lumbar spine provided in factor 6(h) of the relevant SoP. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMr Peter Elton Mr Elton’s evidence has been summarised under background to the application. It is also referred to in the Interlocutory Decision regarding apprehension of bias. It must be noted that Mr Elton’s replies to questions, particularly those from Mr Purcell, were frequently nonresponsive and often he answered a question by posing another question himself. He had to be cautioned by his counsel Ms Ryan for interjecting during submissions and evidence of other individuals. Where, as was quite frequent, his evidence before this Tribunal was contrary to that given to various medical practitioners who have provided opinions, Mr Elton attributed this to a typographical error on the part of the doctor or a failure of the doctor to note accurately the history that he had given. He insisted that he had told every medical practitioner exactly the same history of his experiences in the Navy, his visits to Vietnam and his health thereafter. The Tribunal noted that similar reactions to questioning occurred at the VRB hearing and in the hearing of previous proceedings before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Re Elton and Australian Trade Commission [2013] AATA 133), where Mr Elton had accepted that some data in his claim for an export market development grant was incorrect but maintained this was not his doing, but that of his agent who had assisted in completing the claim form. Mr Elton was somewhat derisive of Dr Velakoulis’ report and in particular Dr Velakoulis’ reference to him grieving over his brother’s death. Mr Elton said that although his brother had been seriously ill, he had survived his life threatening illness. Similarly, Mr Elton was also extremely critical of Dr Strauss’s opinion and the events of the actual consultation, wherein he said Dr Strauss was extremely rude to him, did not listen to the history he gave and was in general extremely aggressive. No complaints were aired regarding Doctors Collier and Kaplan, both of whom supported Mr Elton’s diagnosis of PTSD as being war-caused. Associate Professor Bruce Love, orthopaedic surgeon On 29 September 2015, Associate Professor Love examined Mr Elton in person. Associate Professor Love obtained the history of Mr Elton falling from a ladder during Incident One and experiencing back pain for two days after the fall. Mr Elton did not report it or attend sick bay. Mr Elton told Associate Professor Love that the acute pain had settled quickly but that he has had back pain of variable intensity ever since that episode and as time has gone by and he aged his symptoms have worsened.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The conflicting evidence, credibility issues and almost total lack of corroboration of Mr Elton’s evidence in support of his claim result in the Tribunal, in accordance with the decision in Meehan v Repatriation Commission [2003] FCA 1371, concluding that it is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the Applicant’s psychiatric conditions as claimed and his lumbar spinal conditions as delineated are not war-caused. Conclusions For these reasons outlined above, the Tribunal is satisfied to the requisite standard that, in each case, the claim fails. The Tribunal therefore affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response, Mr Ryan distinguished the decision in Forrester, as this had been a widow’s claim and no evidence was available from the Veteran. TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS Mr Elton has based his claim for an increase in his disability pension on the medical conditions of PTSD, MDD, spondylosis and spondylolisthesis with spondylolysis as being war-caused and disabling. Ms Ryan highlighted the previous decision of Senior Member Friedman dated 15 July 2014 and requested this Tribunal give consideration to that decision and the evidence then given. The Tribunal has done so, particularly as there existed a direction that all summons material provided for the 2014 hearing be made available for the current hearing. In accessing the documentation provided for Mr Elton’s earlier DVA claim lodged on 28 February 2011, another closed file in which Mr Elton had been the applicant was found. This related to the decision in Re Elton and Australian Trade Commission [2013] AATA 133. Mr Elton had lodged a claim relating to his business activities in Vietnam between 2006 and 2012, and concerned his application to the Australian Trade Commission under the Export Market Development Grant for compensation for various costs he had encountered in exporting wine to Vietnam. In this application, the Tribunal determined that Mr Elton was a resident of Vietnam working as a consultant to Kangaroo Indochine Trading Services Company Limited, rather than providing approved promotional activity on behalf of his company Corp di Oro Pty Ltd. This decision is relevant only as a cross-reference to evidence in the current matter. Diagnosis of Claimed Conditions The Tribunal is required, before proceeding to a consideration of whether the claimed conditions are war-caused in accordance with s 120(1) and s 120(3) of the Act, to establish the diagnosis and date of clinical onset of the claimed medical conditions (Re Cooke and Repatriation Commission (1998) 50 ALD 907; McKenna v Repatriation Commission (1999) 86 FCR 144; Repatriation Commission v Gosewinkel (1999) 59 ALD 690, Repatriation Commission v Bawden (2012) 206 FCR 296) to its reasonable satisfaction, pursuant to s 120(4) of the Act. On both the oral and documentary evidence provided, the Tribunal determines that Mr Elton’s claimed medical conditions and their dates of clinical onset, where such information is provided, are:·Post- Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) - first diagnosed in July 2012 with, according to Dr Collier, a clinical onset date in the early 1970s;·Major Depressive Disorder (MDD)- first diagnosed in July 2012 by Dr Collier with a clinical onset attributed to the early 1970s;·Spondylosis with spondylolisthesis and spondylolysis, with the first provided record of the complaint of back pain with right sciatica being made on 4 July 2012 to Mr Elton’s general practitioner Dr Moffitt. Although a CT scan, said to have been performed in 2004/2005, had shown spondylolisthesis at L5/S1 with nerve root compression and a plain x-ray conducted on 14 April 2004 had shown L5/S1 spondylolisthesis, it was not until an MRI in September 2015 that this diagnosis was confirmed. Mr Elton had told Dr Horsley in 2013 that he had an x-ray of his spine some years before which showed a congenital defect. This, to the Tribunal’s knowledge, would refer to what is called a pars defect, that being a failure of the maturation process wherein the epiphyses of the lamina of the vertebral arch do not ossify and the arch therefore does not become complete, resulting in a gap in both laminae. This defect allows a greater range of forward displacement of one vertebra upon another.