Elton and Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Elton and Repatriation Commission [2016] AATA 260 (22 April 2016)

Division

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

2015/2851

Re

Peter Elton

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 22 April 2016
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal refuses to disqualify itself from determining the matter as there is no reasonable apprehension of bias.

........[sgd]....................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

APPREHENSION OF BIAS – respondent’s request that expert medical witness be called to refute applicant’s dispersions on his professional conduct – impact on the tribunal member’s approach to the decision and the facts – comments relating only to credit – no substantive or factual basis – rules against bias – no actual bias alleged

Cases

Webb & Hay v R (1994) 181 CLR 41

Johnson v Johnson (2000) 201 CLR 488

Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337

LA15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 30

Re Walker and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2016] AATA 179

JRL, Re; Ex parte CJL; sub nom Renaud, Re; Ex parte CJL (ALJR) (1986) 161 CLR 342

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

22 April 2016

  1. At the completion of the evidence in this matter on 24 March 2016 the parties informed the Tribunal that the applicant’s instructing solicitors had found a copy of an email from the applicant, Mr Elton, to his solicitors’ dated 6 June 2013 (Exhibit A5). He had seen Dr Nigel Strauss for a medico-legal opinion on that day at the request of the respondent.

  2. Mr Elton impugned Dr Strauss’s professional conduct stating he had been rude, aggressive and antagonistic.  The transcript records at page 87, on 23 March 2016 the following:

    [Mr Purcell] ... - because you talked to Dr Strauss as well didn’t you? — [Mr Elton] ..... Not really.

    MEMBER:  What do you mean? — [Mr Elton]   I had a bit of a problem because – with him and he was very aggressive towards me and very antagonistic from the moment he brought me into his room and he was screaming and yelling at me and so      

    MEMBER: —Screaming and yelling.  Dr Strauss?  — [Mr Elton]    Nigel Strauss, yes.

    MR PURCELL:  It’s not the Dr Strauss we know?   [Mr Elton] — Yes, and I complained      

    MEMBER:  We’ve never heard him scream and yell? —  [Mr Elton] And I must say – I must say that I had friends who have seen him and said he was a fine fellow and I said I don’t understand it but that’s the case.  He was yelling and screaming about – he’d say to me, “So what you’re telling me is this?” and I’d say, “No, I’m telling you” – and he’d screamed at me and say, “So what are you telling me” – so I really didn’t want to talk to him very much at all and I complained to my wife straight away.  I left there in a complete mess.  I wrote to my lawyer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elton and Repatriation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 260
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal where the applicant, Mr Elton, alleged an apprehension of bias on the part of the Tribunal member. The dispute arose from the applicant's assertions regarding the professional conduct of a medical expert, Dr Strauss, who had previously provided evidence. The applicant's representative argued that the Tribunal's failure to call Dr Strauss to refute these assertions created an apprehension of bias, suggesting the Tribunal's approach to the decision might be influenced by these comments.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant's allegations concerning Dr Strauss's professional conduct, and the Tribunal's subsequent decision not to call Dr Strauss to address these allegations, gave rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. This required the Tribunal to consider the principles established in *Ebner* regarding the identification of factors that might lead a decision-maker to decide a case other than on its merits, and the logical connection between those factors and any feared deviation from impartial decision-making.

The Tribunal, applying the principles from *JRL, Re; Ex parte CJL* and *Ebner*, determined that the applicant's comments about Dr Strauss related solely to the expert's credit and did not provide a substantive or factual basis for an apprehension of bias. The Tribunal noted that Dr Strauss had a long-standing and sound reputation within his profession and had consistently provided evidence based on medical history and evidence, free from external influence. While acknowledging the importance of justice being seen to be done, the Tribunal also considered the caution against acceding too readily to suggestions of bias, which could encourage parties to seek disqualification to obtain a more favourable outcome. The Tribunal concluded that the lapse of time since the consultation, the demands on Dr Strauss's time, and his established reputation weighed against adjourning the hearing to call him, particularly as the comments did not affect the Tribunal's ability to decide the matter on its legal and factual merits.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In JRL, Re; Ex parte CJL; sub nom Renaud, Re; Ex parte CJL (ALJR) (1986) 161 CLR 342, Mason J (as he then was), cautioned as follows:... Although it is important that justice must be seen to be done, it is equally important that judicial officers discharge their duty to sit and do not, by acceding too readily to suggestions of appearance of bias, encourage parties to believe that by seeking the disqualification of a judge, they will have their case tried by someone thought to be more likely to decide the case in their favour.TRIBUNAL’S CONSIDERATIONS The first step identified by the High Court in Ebner is the: ... identification of what it is said might lead a judge (or juror) to decide a case other than on its legal and factual merits.And secondly, what is said to be:... the logical connection between the matter and the feared deviation from the course of deciding the case on its merits. Mr Purcell has submitted that Mr Elton’s evidence and comments with regard to his consultation with Dr Strauss on 6 June 2013 (as reported on 7 June 2013), and his assertion that Dr Strauss’s conduct was unprofessional, necessitated Dr Strauss being called to address these assertions and in failing to do so the Tribunal raises the apprehension of bias. The Tribunal does not consider Mr Purcell’s arguments in relation to disadvantage to the Commission or the Tribunal’s duty to protect witnesses go to the question raised by step one of Ebner, that is, to decide the matters on other than its legal and factual merits. It may relate to an argument regarding procedural fairness, but this argument was not raised except in passing. As the transcript shows, the Tribunal expressed its surprise concerning Mr Elton’s description of Dr Strauss screaming and yelling at him (Transcript page 87, lines 35 and 40). In the Tribunal’s experience Dr Strauss has never been accused of screaming and yelling. Dr Strauss has given psychiatric evidence in matters before this Tribunal for nearly 20 years, both as an independent medical expert and as a treating psychiatrist. His assessments of applicants has to this Tribunal’s knowledge always been based purely on the medical history and evidence, devoid of any influence arising from the source of his instruction be it the respondent or the applicant. Dr Strauss’s reputation within the psychiatric speciality is sound and he (in concert with Doctor Epstein and Associate Professor Mendelson) has authored several psychiatric impairment guides used in Victorian and South Australian Tribunals and Courts. The Tribunal had given serious consideration to adjourning the hearing and calling Dr Strauss to address the aspersions on his professional conduct raised by Mr Elton, but given the two and a half year lapse of time since Dr Strauss saw Mr Elton, the demand on Dr Strauss’s time and his reputation within the profession and with this Tribunal has led to my decision not to do so. Mr Elton had made negative comments about the content of the reports of Dr Velakoulis, Dr Horsley and that of his treating psychiatrist Dr Collier in relation to entries in their reports that were contrary to what he claimed to have told them (Transcript page 85). Mr Elton described these conflicting reports as being due to errors on the part of the various doctors.