ElecNet (Aust) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL, GAGELER, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ

ELECNET (AUST) PTY LTD (AS TRUSTEE FOR
THE ELECTRICAL INDUSTRY SEVERANCE
SCHEME)   APPELLANT

AND

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION  RESPONDENT

ElecNet (Aust) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation

[2016] HCA 51

21 December 2016

M104/2016

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

A H Slater QC with B L Jones for the appellant (instructed by Mills Oakley)

G J Davies QC with S J Sharpley QC and A T Broadfoot for the respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Taxation – Unit trusts – Public trading trust – Where trust settled by deed – Where employers become members of industry severance scheme created by trust – Where members of scheme obliged to make payments to trustee – Where trustee credits payments to accounts in name of individual employees – Where trustee makes payment to employee upon termination of employment – Whether unit trust within meaning of Div 6C of Pt III of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth).

Words and phrases – "beneficial interest", "ordinary acceptation", "prescribed trust estate", "public trading trust", "unit", "unit trust". 

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth), ss 102M, 102P, 102R, 102S, 102T.

  1. KIEFEL, GAGELER, KEANE AND GORDON JJ.   The appellant ("ElecNet") is the trustee of a trust known as the Electrical Industry Severance Scheme ("the EISS").  The trust was settled by deed in 1997 ("the Deed").  The parties to the Deed are the National Electrical Contractors Association and the Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia ("the Sponsors"), and ElecNet.

  2. Under the EISS, employers within the electrical contracting industry may become members of the scheme and, upon doing so, become obliged to make payments to ElecNet.  These payments are credited by ElecNet to accounts in the name of each of the employees in respect of whom a payment is made.  The Deed contemplates that, at such time as an employee's employment is terminated, ElecNet is to make a severance or redundancy payment to that employee.  In this way, the EISS serves to protect, and allow the portability of, benefits payable to employees upon termination of employment.

  3. On 10 December 2012, ElecNet requested a private ruling from the respondent ("the Commissioner") as to whether the EISS is a public trading trust for the purposes of Div 6C of Pt III of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ("the ITAA"). A ruling that ElecNet is a public trading trust within Div 6C would afford ElecNet a fiscal advantage, in that, where Div 6C applies, s 102S provides that ElecNet is to pay tax on its net income, not at the rate otherwise applicable under the general provisions in Div 6 of Pt III of the ITAA relating to trusts (and in particular s 99A)[1], but at a lower rate declared by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ElecNet (Aust) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] HCA 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia concerning whether a trust established by ElecNet (Aust) Pty Ltd was a unit trust for the purposes of Division 6C of Part III of the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1936* (Cth). The dispute arose because ElecNet argued that the trust, known as the Electrical Industry Severance Scheme (EISS), qualified as a unit trust, which would have implications for how payments made to employees upon termination were taxed. The Commissioner of Taxation contended that the EISS did not meet the criteria for a unit trust under Division 6C.

The central legal issue before the High Court was to determine whether the beneficial interests of the employees (referred to as "Workers") in the EISS were divided into "units" in a manner that satisfied the requirements of Division 6C. This involved interpreting the meaning of "unit trust" and "unit" within the context of the Act, particularly in relation to the structure of the EISS where payments were credited to individual employee accounts and paid out upon termination. The court also considered the purpose and legislative history of Division 6C, which was designed to tax certain public trading trusts.

The High Court reasoned that the definition of a "unit" in section 102M of the Act, which is inclusive, relates to beneficial interests in a "prescribed trust estate." A prescribed trust estate, by definition, must be a public trading trust whose interests are held by unitholders. The court found that the trust deed for the EISS did not create discrete parcels of rights that could be dealt with as items of commerce, analogous to shares in a company. While individual workers had beneficial interests measured by the dollar amounts credited to their accounts, these interests were not described as "units" in the deed itself. The court concluded that the inclusive definition of "unit" did not expand the meaning of "unit trust" to encompass interests that would not otherwise be identifiable as units. The common understanding of a unit trust, supported by case law, requires the beneficial interest in the trust fund to be divided into units that are capable of being traded.

The High Court dismissed the appeal with costs, upholding the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court. Consequently, the EISS was not considered a unit trust for the purposes of Division 6C of Part III of the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1936* (Cth). This meant that payments made to employees upon termination would be taxed under other provisions, such as Division 82 or 83 of the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1997* (Cth), which are generally more favourable to recipients than taxation as unit trust dividends.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL, GAGELER, KEANE AND GORDON JJ NETTLE J
In addition, payments to Active Workers under cl 8 are, if Div 6C does not apply, taxable as employment termination payments under Div 82 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) or redundancy payments or similar under Div 83 of that Act, which are apt to be less burdensome to the recipients. It would be of grave concern to Workers if, by reason of the application of Div 6C, payments to them were treated as unit trust dividends rather than being subject to tax under the specific provisions of Div 82 or Div 83. Conclusion and orders The rights conferred on Workers by the Deed were not such as to support the conclusion that the EISS is a unit trust for the purposes of Div 6C of Pt III of the ITAA. The appeal should be dismissed. ElecNet should pay the costs of the appeal. This is an appeal from orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (Jessup, Pagone and Edelman JJ)[39] which, in effect, upheld a ruling by the respondent ("the Commissioner") that the trust of which the appellant ("ElecNet") is trustee is not a unit trust for the purposes of Div 6C of Pt III of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ("the 1936 Act"). The relevant facts and the parties' contentions are set out in the plurality's reasons. For the reasons which follow, the Electrical Industry Severance Scheme ("the EISS") is not a unit trust in the sense required by Div 6C and the appeal to this Court should be dismissed. [39]Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Elecnet (Aust) Pty Ltd (2015) 239 FCR 359.Relevant statutory provisions Division 6C was modelled on provisions of Div 6B of Pt III of the 1936 Act[40], which, in turn, needs to be understood in light of Div 6 in the same Part. Thus, to place Div 6C in context, it is first necessary to refer briefly to Divs 6 and 6B. [40]Australia, House of Representatives, Taxation Laws Amendment Bill (No 4) 1985 and Income Tax (Companies, Corporate Unit Trusts and Superannuation Funds) Amendment Bill 1985, Explanatory Memorandum at 10. Division 6 Division 6 provides generally for the taxation of trust income. The basic principle of the Division, which emerges from ss 96 and 97, is that a trustee is not liable to pay income tax on the income of the trust estate, but a beneficiary who is presently entitled to a share of the income of the trust estate will have that share included in his or her assessable income. That is the position unless one of the other provisions applies. For example, s 98 makes a trustee liable to pay tax in respect of the share of the income of the trust estate to which a beneficiary who is under a legal disability is presently entitled. Special provision is made for discretionary trusts in s 101 and for revocable trusts in s 102.Division 6B Division 6B was introduced in 1981[41] to provide for the taxation of "corporate unit trusts". "Unit trust" was not specifically defined[42]. Its meaning was apparent, however, from the operative provisions of the Division and, in particular, from the concern to tax corporate unit trusts as close substitutes for public companies. Section 102K provided in substance that a trustee of a "corporate unit trust" was to be assessed and was liable to pay tax on the net income of the trust at the rate declared by Parliament. Section 102J(1)(b) provided that a unit trust was a "corporate unit trust" in relation to a year of income commencing on or after 1 July 1983 if:[41]Income Tax Laws Amendment Act (No 3) 1981 (Cth), s 10. Division 6B has since been repealed by the Tax Laws Amendment (New Tax System for Managed Investment Trusts) Act 2016 (Cth), Sched 5, Pt 2.[42]Section 102D provided definitions of "unit", "unitholder" and "unit trust dividend"."(i)the unit trust is an eligible unit trust in relation to the relevant year of income; (ii)the unit trust is a public unit trust in relation to the relevant year of income; and(iii) either of the following conditions is satisfied:(A) the unit trust is a resident unit trust in relation to the relevant year of income;(B) the unit trust was a corporate unit trust in relation to a year of income preceding the relevant year of income." (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL, GAGELER, KEANE AND GORDON JJ, NETTLE J

On behalf of ElecNet, it was argued that the beneficial interest of each Worker, while not divided into equal units, was measurable by reference to the number of dollars credited to each Worker's Account so that the units are the number of dollars so credited. On this view, the units were said to be $1 units, so that each unit entitles the holder to receive a return of $1 and no present income but a future contingent and defeasible right to share in any surplus under cl 23. But one can say that the units are $1 units only because of the absence from the Deed of any provision on the topic. One might as well speak of one cent units because the Worker is entitled to be paid every cent that is due. The problem for ElecNet's argument is not that the beneficial interest of each Worker is not described as a "unit" but that it is not "described" by the Deed at all. That is simply a reflection of the circumstance that the Deed does not concern itself with the creation of discrete parcels of rights which might be dealt with as items of commerce analogously with shares in a company.Division 6C: textual considerations The inclusive definition of "unit" in s 102M is expressed to relate only to beneficial interests in income or property of a prescribed trust estate. By definition, a prescribed trust estate must be (or have been) a trust estate that is a public trading trust the interests in which are held by unitholders. Jessup J was right to hold that the inclusive definition of "unit" does not expand the meaning of "unit trust" for the purposes of Div 6C. The term "unit" is defined specifically "in relation to a prescribed trust estate", which, as has been seen, is linked with the defined term "unitholder". As has been noted above, Div 6C, and s 102P in particular, is cast in terms that are apposite to a species of trust in which the beneficial interest in the trust fund is divided into units as discrete parcels of rights themselves capable of being dealt with, like shares in a company, as items of commerce. The inclusive definition of "unit" does not encompass an interest that would not otherwise be identifiable as a unit in relation to a prescribed trust estate merely because it is a beneficial interest in any of the income or property of the trust estate. Rather, the inclusive definition of "unit" ensures that a beneficial interest is a "unit" for the purposes of Div 6C, however it might be so described, and even if it is limited to only part of the property or income of the trust estate. There is no reason in the text or context of Div 6C to attribute to the undefined expression "unit trust" any meaning other than the meaning evident from the language of Div 6C. That meaning accords with the common usage of the expression "unit trust". As the Commissioner rightly observed, there is no reported case, in Australia or elsewhere, in which the expression "unit trust" has been applied other than in circumstances where, under the applicable trust deed, the beneficial interest in the trust fund is divided into units, which when created or issued are to be held by the persons for whom the trustee maintains and administers the trust estate.