Dura (Australia) Constructions Pty Ltd v Victorian Managed Insurance Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE
COMMON LAW DIVISION
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

No 671 of 2011

IN THE MATTER OF s 148 of the Victorian and Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998
BETWEEN
DURA (AUSTRALIA) CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD Plaintiff
v
VICTORIAN MANAGED INSURANCE AUTHORITY Defendant

---

JUDGE:

ROBSON J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

28, 29 November 2011 and 13 March 2012

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

30 March 2012

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Dura (Australia) Constructions Pty Ltd v VMIA

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2012] VSC 114

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Appeal from Associate Justice – Associate Justice heard application for leave to appeal by a builder from VCAT for determination of preliminary questions in proceeding in the Domestic Building List between Victorian Managed Insurance Authority and the builder – Leave to appeal only available on questions of law - Associate Justice granted leave to appeal on some questions and refused leave to appeal on other questions – Hearing de novo – Builders indemnity insurance under House Contracts Guarantee Act 1987  - Policy issued by FAI to builder - Whether insurance of builder under policy complied with the 1998 or 1996 Ministerial Order – Under 1996 Ministerial Order the Builder was the insured – Under 1998 Ministerial Order the building owner was insured - Held VCAT had not erred in law in deciding issued policy complied with 1998 Ministerial Order and the building owner was insured – Appeal dismissed – Application for leave to appeal dismissed.  

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal on question of law from decision of VCAT – whether conclusion of the Tribunal was reasonably open to it on the facts and the evidence – no error of law.

INSURANCE - Whether on proper construction of insurance policy issued by FAI under 1998 Ministerial Order, FAI, and thus, the Victorian Managed Insurance Authority, had power to direct builder to rectify building defects – Held VCAT had erred in law in construing policy finding that FAI and thus Victorian Managed Insurance Authority had such power - Appeal allowed in part – Proceeding referred back to VCAT.

INSURANCE – Subrogation – Construction of policy – Whether policy gave power to insurer to direct builder to rectify defects in building.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the plaintiff R Andrew Noble Lawyers
For the defendant P B Murdoch QC with
S W Stuckey
LMS Lawyers

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction................................................................................................................................... 2
History of the home owners’ warranty...................................................................................... 3
VMIA’s claim in VCAT................................................................................................................ 8
VCAT orders determination of preliminary questions......................................................... 10
Requirements for leave to appeal............................................................................................ 12
Question 1.................................................................................................................................... 12

The evidence before the Tribunal.............................................................................................. 13
The Tribunal’s findings............................................................................................................ 17
Dura’s contentions on question 1............................................................................................. 18
Was there an error of law?........................................................................................................ 18

Question 1A................................................................................................................................. 20
Question 1B.................................................................................................................................. 22
Question 2.................................................................................................................................... 23
Question 3.................................................................................................................................... 27
Question 4.................................................................................................................................... 28

Was there an error of law?........................................................................................................ 29

Question 5.................................................................................................................................... 31
Question 6.................................................................................................................................... 33
Question 7.................................................................................................................................... 35

Reasons why special condition  2(c) does not justify direction of VMIA................................. 35
The Tribunal’s construction.....................................................................................................…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dura (Australia) Constructions Pty Ltd v Victorian Managed I... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] VSC 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dura (Australia) Constructions Pty Ltd v Victorian Managed Insurance Authority involved a builder, Dura, who was in dispute with the Victorian Managed Insurance Authority. The dispute arose from a decision made by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) regarding an application for leave to appeal, specifically focusing on issues related to builders' indemnity insurance under the House Contracts Guarantee Act 1987. The builder sought to challenge VCAT's determination of preliminary questions in a proceeding against the Victorian Managed Insurance Authority, arguing that the insurance policy issued by FAI did not comply with the 1998 Ministerial Order. The central legal issues revolved around whether VCAT had correctly interpreted the insurance policy and the implications of the 1998 Ministerial Order on the insured party.

The court had to decide whether VCAT erred in law when it concluded that the policy issued by FAI complied with the 1998 Ministerial Order, which insured the building owner instead of the builder. The court also had to determine if VCAT made an error in law when it interpreted the policy to allow FAI and the Victorian Managed Insurance Authority to direct the builder to rectify building defects. The court found that VCAT had not erred in its interpretation of the 1998 Ministerial Order, affirming that the building owner was indeed insured. However, it found that VCAT had erred in law when it construed the insurance policy to grant FAI the power to direct the builder to rectify defects, as this was not supported by the proper construction of the policy.

In summary, the court dismissed the appeal on the question of whether VCAT had erred in law in deciding that the insurance policy complied with the 1998 Ministerial Order. However, the court allowed the appeal in part regarding the construction of the insurance policy and found that VCAT had indeed erred in law in concluding that FAI had the power to direct the builder to rectify building defects. The court referred the matter back to VCAT for further proceedings.