Downer Engineering Power Pty Ltd (ABN 53 000 983 700) v Atkinson

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Downer Engineering Power Pty Ltd (ABN 53 000 983 700) v Atkinson [2005] FCA 149

INDUSTRIAL LAW – application for interim relief against employees – order made by Australian Industrial Relations Commission under s 127(1) Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) directed to Unions – failure of employees to return to work – alleged contraventions of s 127(5) and s 170MN of the Act – whether serious issue to be tried – whether “employees” fall within terms of the Commission’s order – balance of convenience – whether grant of interim relief would have a practical effect

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether discretion should be exercised to omit endorsement from order warning of imprisonment or sequestration

Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth) ss 21, 22, 23, 32
Judiciary Act1903 (Cth) s 39B(1A)(c)

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 3(b), 3(f), 4, 126, 127, 127(1), 127(1)(c), 127(3), 127(5), 127(6), 127(7), 170LD, 170LJ, 170LT, 170LX, 170M(1), 170M(2), 170MA, 170MC, 170MI, 170ML, 170MN, 170MN(1), 170MO, 170ND, 170NF, 170NF(1), 170NF(4), 170NG, 412

Federal Court Rules O 7 r 1, O 37 r 2, O 37 r 2(3), O 40
The Constitution ss 75, 76, 77

Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 cited

ACI Operations Pty Ltd v Automotive, Food Metals Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (2000) 173 ALR 109 cited

Australian Industry Group vAutomotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (2002) 125 FCR 529 cited

Australian Industry Group vAutomotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union (2003) 130 FCR 524 cited

Davids Distribution Pty Ltd v National Union of Workers (1999) 91 FCR 463 cited

Gordon v Gordon (1946) P.99 cited

Moerman-Lenglet v Henshaw, The Times, (23 November, 1992) cited

Philip Morris Inc v Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 457 cited

TheOriginal Juice Co Pty Limited v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union [2001] FCA 675 cited

Transfield Construction Pty Ltd v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union [2002] FCA 1413 cited

DOWNER ENGINEERING POWER PTY LTD (ABN 53 000 983 700) v CHRISTOPHER PETER ATKINSON, KEITH STUART BIRCH, LYALL BROWN, ALFONSO CAMBREA, MICHAEL JOHN COLBEY, PAUL COMMISSO, CHRISTOPHE LOUIS COUANON, STEVEN PETER COVERDALE, DANIEL ROBERT CURCHIN, JOHN DIXON, DAVID DOUST, HUGH DUFFY, ANDREW DUNCAN, DANIEL FRY, BRIAN EDWIN GARDINER, PETER GIANFRANCESCO, BRADLEY ROBERT GILES, JOHN PAUL GOODWIN, STEPHEN GRAY, WAYNE ASHLEY GRIMES, AARON HARPER, JAMES EDWARD HICKS, BJ HILIER, NATHAN HITT, KEVEN HOMDEN, RUSSELL HOWELLS, WILLIAM ROBERT HUGHES, GLENN ALAN JONES, GORDON JONES, AARON DAVID KING, RICKY JOHN KING, RAYMOND KOHLMAN, WARREN PETER LEWIS, BRADLEY MASLIN, KIMBERLEY JAMES MASLIN, PAUL DOUGLAS MAY, SHANE MCGILL, SIEGFRIED MENZEL, GRANT MILES, COLIN MORGAN, BRENDAN MORRIS, WILLIAM MORRISON, ROBERT MORTON, RICHARD MUNCE, ROBERT JAMES PACE, DANIEL ROBERT PENNEFATHER, DAMON MICHAEL QUICKE, GRANT LEE RAYNER, ANTONIO RECHICHI, MICHAEL BRUCE REYNOLDS, JEFFREY ROBERTS, STEPHEN ROGERS, KENNETH SATONICK, JARROD ALFRED JAMES SAWARD, BRETT MANE SMITH, GRAEHAM WILLIAM STONE, MICHAEL JOHN STRAND, CHAD STUDSOR, STUART GEOFFERY SWANN,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Downer Engineering Power Pty Ltd (ABN 53 000 983 700) v Atki... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 149
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Downer Engineering Power Pty Ltd (ABN 53 000 983 700) brought an application against various respondents, who are employees of the applicant, seeking interlocutory relief to restrain the respondents from failing or refusing to attend for work in support of industrial action. The application was brought in the Federal Court of Australia.

The legal issues before the court included whether the respondents were engaging in protected industrial action and if the applicant had the right to seek relief to prevent such action. The court was also required to determine whether the respondents were acting in contravention of specific industrial orders made by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission.

The court found that the respondents were engaging in unprotected industrial action by failing or refusing to attend for work, which was in contravention of specific industrial orders. The court granted the relief sought by the applicant, restraining the respondents from such actions. The court noted the importance of maintaining industrial peace and the applicant's right to conduct its business without interference due to industrial action. The court also granted liberty to apply to discharge or vary the order and adjourned the directions hearing to a future date.

The orders made by the court included abridging the time for service of the application, restraining the respondents from failing or refusing to attend for work, and granting liberty to apply to discharge or vary the order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time for service of the application and of the supporting affidavits required to be served be abridged so far as is necessary to enable the application for interlocutory relief to be heard on 17 February 2005.

2. Until determination of the application or further order, the following respondents:

CHRISTOPHER PETER ATKINSON

First Respondent

KEITH STUART BIRCH

Second Respondent

ALFONSO CAMBREA

Fourth Respondent

CHRISTOPHE LOUIS COUANON

Seventh Respondent

STEVEN PETER COVERDALE

Eighth Respondent

JOHN DIXON

Tenth Respondent

BRIAN EDWIN GARDINER

Fifteenth Respondent

PETER GIANFRANCESCO

Sixteenth Respondent

STEPHEN GRAY

Nineteenth Respondent

AARON HARPER

Twenty-first Respondent

JAMES EDWARD HICKS

Twenty-second Respondent

BJ HILIER

Twenty-third Respondent

KEVEN HOMDEN

Twenty-fifth Respondent

RUSSELL HOWELLS

Twenty-sixth Respondent

WILLIAM ROBERT HUGHES

Twenty-seventh Respondent

GLENN ALAN JONES

Twenty-eighth Respondent

GORDON JONES

Twenty-ninth Respondent

AARON DAVID KING

Thirtieth Respondent

RICKY JOHN KING

Thirty-first Respondent

WARREN PETER LEWIS

Thirty-third Respondent

BRADLEY MASLIN

Thirty-fourth Respondent

PAUL DOUGLAS MAY

Thirty-sixth Respondent

GRANT MILES

Thirty-ninth Respondent

COLIN MORGAN

Fortieth Respondent

BRENDAN MORRIS

Forty-first Respondent

ROBERT MORTON

Forty-third Respondent

RICHARD MUNCE

Forty-fourth Respondent

ROBERT JAMES PACE

Forty-fifth Respondent

DANIEL ROBERT PENNEFATHER

Forty-sixth Respondent

GRANT LEE RAYNER

Forty-eighth Respondent

JEFFREY ROBERTS

Fifty-one Respondent

STEPHEN ROGERS

Fifty-two Respondent

KENNETH SATONICK

Fifty-third Respondent

MICHAEL JOHN STRAND

Fifty-seventh Respondent

STUART GEOFFERY SWANN

Sixtieth Respondent

MALCOLM TARGETT

Sixty-first Respondent

PHILIP WOODCOCK

Sixty-sixth Respondent

whilst employees of the applicant whose employment is subject to the Downer RML Pty Ltd Maintenance Modification Work Certified Agreement 2004 (“the Agreement”) be restrained from failing or refusing to attend for work where such failure or refusal is for the purpose of supporting or advancing claims against the applicant in respect of the employment of employees whose employment is subject to the Agreement.

3. There be liberty to apply on short notice to discharge or vary the order.

4. The directions hearing in the application be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

1. The time for service of the application and of the supporting affidavits required to be served be abridged so far as is necessary to enable the application for interlocutory relief to be heard on 17 February 2005.

2. Until determination of the application or further order,

a) the following respondents:

STEPHEN ARMSTRONG

First Respondent

ADAM BIRCH

Second Respondent

JOHN DUNCAN

Fourth Respondent

PETER FALLO

Sixth Respondent

JOHN FELTHAM

Seventh Respondent

JOSEPH FOSTER

Ninth Respondent

RYAN HARRISON

Eleventh Respondent

DALE JONES

Fourteenth Respondent

JOE KEIRNAN

Fifteenth Respondent

JOHN LEVER

Twentieth Respondent

CALLUM MACLEAN

Twenty-second Respondent

BRIAN PETERSEN

Twenty-fifth Respondent

SHANE JACKSON

Twenty-seventh Respondent

BRUCE ROUSE

Twenty-ninth Respondent

BARRY RYAN

Thirty-first Respondent

JASON WIGGERS

Thirty-fifth Respondent

PAUL WHITTON

Thirty-seventh Respondent

whilst employees of the applicant be restrained from failing or refusing to attend for work in contravention of the Worsley Alumina Maintenance Industrial Action Order 2005 made by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission on 7 February 2005 under s 127(1) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth); and,

b) the following respondents:

STEPHEN ARMSTRONG

First Respondent

ADAM BIRCH

Second Respondent

JOHN DUNCAN

Fourth Respondent

PETER FALLO

Sixth Respondent

JOHN FELTHAM

Seventh Respondent

JOSEPH FOSTER

Ninth Respondent

RYAN HARRISON

Eleventh Respondent

DARREN HATA

Twelfth Respondent

DALE JONES

Fourteenth Respondent

JOE KEIRNAN

Fifteenth Respondent

GARRY KEMP

Sixteenth Respondent

HUGH KERR

Eighteenth Respondent

JOHN LEVER

Twentieth Respondent

CALLUM MACLEAN

Twenty-second Respondent

BRIAN PETERSEN

Twenty-fifth Respondent

SHANE JACKSON

Twenty-seventh Respondent

KANE JAMES

Twenty-eighth Respondent

BRUCE ROUSE

Twenty-ninth Respondent

BARRY RYAN

Thirty-first Respondent

PAUL SIDON

Thirty-third Respondent

JASON WIGGERS

Thirty-fifth Respondent

PAUL WHITTON

Thirty-seventh Respondent

LESTER GEAR

Thirty-ninth Respondent

whilst employees of the applicant whose employment is subject to the Total Corrosion Control Pty Ltd South West Projects Certified Agreement 2004-2007 (“the Agreement”) be restrained from failing or refusing to attend for work where such failure or refusal is for the purpose of supporting or advancing claims against the applicant in respect of the employment of employees whose employment is subject to the Agreement.

3. There be liberty to apply on short notice to discharge or vary the order.

4. The directions hearing in the application be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

1. The time for service of the application and of the supporting affidavits required to be served be abridged so far as is necessary to enable the application for interlocutory relief to be heard on 17 February 2005.

2. Until determination of the application or further order, the following respondents:

CHRISTOPHER BETSON

Second Respondent

RAYMOND DODD

Eleventh Respondent

MICHAEL GRIFFITHS

Fourteenth Respondent

DION HOUSE

Eighteenth Respondent

KIM MARTIN

Twenty-first Respondent

MICHAEL O’DONOGHUE

Twenty-sixth Respondent

JUDD PRENTICE

Twenty-seventh Respondent

JASON REEVE

Twenty-ninth Respondent

VICTOR RONAN

Thirtieth Respondent

GAVIN SIMPSON

Thirty-fourth Respondent

ALLAN TAYLOR

Thirty-fifth Respondent

PETER VISSER

Thirty-ninth Respondent

whilst employees of the applicant be restrained from failing or refusing to attend for work in contravention of the Worsley Alumina Maintenance Industrial Action Order 2005 made by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission on 7 February 2005 under s 127(1) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth).

3. There be liberty to apply on short notice to discharge or vary the order.

4. The directions hearing in the application be adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LEE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LEE J

Full text does not contain this section.