Donnelly v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

DONNELLY v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (SA)

[2024] SASCA 45

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, the Honourable Justice Doyle and the Honourable Justice Blue)

10 April 2024

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - CONFISCATION OF PROCEEDS OF CRIME AND RELATED MATTERS - FORFEITURE OR CONFISCATION - OTHER MATTERS

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - CONFISCATION OF PROCEEDS OF CRIME AND RELATED MATTERS - FORFEITURE OR CONFISCATION - APPEAL OR REVIEW

This was an appeal against a declaration made pursuant to s 56B of the Criminal Assets Confiscation Act 2005 (SA) (the “Act”) that all of the appellant’s property held as at 8 November 2022 had been forfeited to the Crown.

On 8 November 2022, the appellant entered pleas of guilty in the Magistrates Court to ten counts of trafficking in a controlled drug contrary to s 32(3) of the Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA). A single allocutus was administered after the entry of those pleas, following which the appellant was committed to the District Court for sentence.

At all relevant times, s 56A(1)-(2) of the Act provided that, upon a person becoming a ‘prescribed drug offender’, the convicting court was deemed to have made a forfeiture order in respect of all property owned by, or subject to the effective control of, the offender on the conviction day for the conviction offence. Section 6A(1) of the Act provided, relevantly, that a prescribed drug offender included a person who has at least 2 other convictions for prescribed drug offences committed on separate occasions to the conviction offence within a general period of ten years. It was not in dispute at first-instance that the offences to which the appellant had pleaded guilty answered the description of prescribed drug offences for the purposes of the Act.

On an application brought by the respondent for the forfeiture of certain property consequent upon the appellant’s convictions, and over the appellant’s objection, the Magistrate at first-instance declared that the property in question had been forfeited by force of ss 56A and 56B of the Act. In so determining the matter, the Magistrate rejected the construction of s 6A advanced by the appellant: namely, that the two other convictions for prescribed drug offences must have preceded, rather than have been entered simultaneously with, conviction for the conviction offence. On appeal, the appellant reagitated that contention.

Held (per Kourakis CJ, Doyle JA agreeing), varying the declaration in part but otherwise dismissing the appeal:

1.Section 6A(1)(b) of the Act requires no more than that the offender has at least two other convictions of the prescribed kind at the date of conviction for the conviction offence. The relevant point in time at which those conditions to the effectuation of a deemed forfeiture order must contemporaneously exist is the making of the order of conviction of a prescribed drug offence committed after the commencement date specified by the Act. Accordingly, when the allocutus was administered to the appellant, he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Donnelly v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASCA 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by Mr Donnelly against a decision of the Director of Public Prosecutions (SA) regarding the forfeiture of his property. The dispute arose from Mr Donnelly's conviction for 10 trafficking charges on 8 November 2022, which triggered provisions of the Criminal Assets Confiscation Act 2005 (SA) concerning forfeiture of property. The appeal was heard by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia, comprising Kourakis CJ, Doyle JA, and Blue AJA.

The central legal issue before the Court was the interpretation of sections 6A and 56A of the Criminal Assets Confiscation Act 2005 (SA). Specifically, the Court had to determine whether Mr Donnelly was a "prescribed drug offender" at the time of his conviction, which would render all his property forfeit. This involved considering whether the phrase "has ... convictions" in the legislation included convictions that occurred simultaneously with the conviction offence, or if it required prior existing convictions. The Court also considered whether the Attorney-General's interpretation of the provisions, by reference to Western Australian legislation, was relevant to the task.

The Court reasoned that the provisions of the Act must be interpreted according to their own formulation, context, and purpose, rather than by analogy to other jurisdictions, particularly where the wording differed. The Court noted that the South Australian legislation used the expression "has ... convictions" rather than "has been convicted," suggesting a different legislative intent. The Court concluded that the proper interpretation of sections 6A and 56A meant that Mr Donnelly was a prescribed drug offender on the day of his conviction.

Consequently, the Court ordered that all of Mr Donnelly's property on the conviction day was forfeited, save for the interest held by the National Australia Bank Ltd in the Port Broughton property by reason of a registered mortgage. The appeal was otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his reasons, which I have had the advantage of reading in draft, Blue AJA refers to the Western Australian scheme ­– under s 32A(1)(a) of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1981 (WA) and s 5(1) of the Criminal Property Confiscation Act 2000 (WA) – said to be reflected in ss 6A and 56A by the Attorney-General. I agree with Blue AJA that the views expressed by the Attorney-General as to the interpretation and operation of ss 6A and 56A, as distinct from the mischief which those provisions were inserted into the Act to address, are irrelevant to the task presently before this Court.[1] It is, however, telling, in my view, that the reference made by the Attorney-General to the Western Australian scheme was by way of illustration only of statutory forfeiture regimes. It is more telling that the amendments inserted into the Act did not replicate the formulation of their analogues in the Western Australian Acts identified above. In particular, the expression in the Western Australia legislation ‘has … been convicted’ was eschewed and the expression ‘has … convictions’ used instead. The provisions of the Act must, therefore, be interpreted according to their own formulation, the context within which they appear, and the purpose they exist to serve.[2] For the reasons I have given above, the proper interpretation of ss 6A and 56A leads to the conclusion that the appeal must be almost entirely dismissed. [1] See, eg, Harrison v Melhem (2008) 72 NSWLR 380, 399 [162] (Mason P); Amaca Pty Ltd v Novek (2009) 9 DDCR 199, 215 [74]-[78] (Campbell JA, Giles and Tobias JJA agreeing); Saeed v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) 241 CLR 252, 264-5 [31]-[33] (French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Crennan and Kiefel JJ).[2] See, eg, SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 262 CLR 362, 368 [14] (Kiefel CJ, Nettle and Gordon JJ). Cf Robert Bosch (Australia) Pty Ltd v Secretary, Department of Industry, Innovation, Science, Research and Tertiary Education (2012) 206 FCR 92, 111 [71] (Kenny, Edmonds and Robertson JJ). Conclusion For the reasons given in [15]-[16], Mr Donnelly was a prescribed drug offender when he was convicted of 10 trafficking charges on 8 November 2022. All of his property on that day, the conviction day, was forfeited. I would amend the declaration by adding the words ‘save for the interest held in the Port Broughton property by the National Australia Bank Ltd by reason of registered mortgage of [date]’. I would otherwise dismiss the appeal. DOYLE JA: I agree with the reasons of the Chief Justice, and the orders he has proposed. I have had the benefit of reading the draft reasons of both the Chief Justice and Blue AJA. Both accept that the relevant time for determining whether a person “has” at least two other convictions for the purposes of s 6A(1)(b) of the Criminal Assets Confiscation Act 2005 (SA) (the Act) is the moment he or she is convicted of “the conviction offence”. The point of difference is whether, in circumstances where the person’s conviction for the conviction offence occurs simultaneously with the other convictions, it can be said that the person “has” those other convictions at the moment he or she is convicted of the conviction offence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established