Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2017] NSWCA 171
Hearing dates:23 June 2017
Date of orders: 23 June 2017
Decision date: 12 July 2017
Before: Basten JA at [1]; Simpson JA at [13]; Emmett AJA at [74]
Decision:

1.  Appeal dismissed.

 2.  Order the appellant to pay the respondent’s costs in this court.
Catchwords:

TRAFFIC LAW AND TRANSPORT – compensation for injury suffered in motor accident – assessment of whole person impairment – proper officer’s satisfaction that reasonable cause existed to suspect that the assessment was incorrect in a material respect – referral to review panel

 

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – jurisdictional error – jurisdictional fact, unreasonableness and irrelevant consideration – whether satisfaction of proper officer reviewable

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – error of law on the face of the record – whether reasons of officer of administrative body engaged Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69(3) and (4)
Legislation Cited: Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW), ss 44, 57, 59, 60, 61, 63, 65, 131
State Insurance and Care Governance Act 2015 (NSW), s 17; Sch 4 cl 4
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), ss 69, 75, 101
Cases Cited: Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564; [1992] HCA 10
BHP Billiton Ltd v Dunning [2013] NSWCA 421
Dominice v Allianz Insurance [2016] NSWSC 1241
Elliott v Insurance Australia t/as NRMA Insurance [2014] NSWSC 1848
Meeuwissen v Boden (2010) 78 NSWLR 143; [2010] NSWCA 253
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18
Nguyen v Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales [2011] NSWSC 351
Public Service Board of New South Wales v Osmond (1986) 159 CLR 656; [1986] HCA 7
QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Davies [2016] NSWSC 536
QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Miller (2013) 67 MVR 322; [2013] NSWCA 442
Rodger v De Gelder [2011] NSWCA 97
Rodger v De Gelder [2015] NSWCA 211
Texts Cited: Medical Assessment Guidelines, cl 14.8
Permanent Impairment Guidelines 2007 (NSW), cll 1.23, 1.42, 1.43, 2.4
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Jessye Dominice (Appellant)
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd (First Respondent)
State Insurance Regulatory Authority (Second Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
A C Canceri/J E Doyon (Appellant)
W Fitzsimmons/J Gumbert (First Respondent)
Submitting appearance (Second Respondent)

  Solicitors:
CMC Lawyers (Appellant)
Hall & Wilcox Lawyers (First Respondent)
Crown Solicitor’s Office (Second Respondent)
File Number(s):2016/275626
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court
Jurisdiction:
Common Law Division
Citation:
Dominice v Allianz Insurance [2016] NSWSC 1241
Date of Decision:
31 August 2016
Before:
Fagan J
File Number(s):
2015/336946

Judgment

  1. BASTEN JA: This appeal concerned an assessment of the degree of permanent impairment suffered by the appellant in a motor vehicle accident in July 2013. She has sought damages from the driver of the other car which collided with the rear of her vehicle. The respondent is the defendant’s insurer.

  2. In order to obtain damages for non-economic loss, it was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWCA 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an appeal by Dominice against a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning a review of a whole person impairment assessment under the *Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999* (NSW). The dispute arose when the proper officer of the Motor Accidents Authority (now the Insurance Regulator) formed the belief that a medical assessment of the appellant's whole person impairment was incorrect in a material respect, leading to a referral to a review panel. The appellant sought judicial review of this decision.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the proper officer's satisfaction that reasonable cause existed to suspect the assessment was incorrect in a material respect constituted a jurisdictional fact, and if so, whether that satisfaction was reviewable by the Supreme Court. Additionally, the court considered whether the reasons provided by the proper officer amounted to an error of law on the face of the record, thereby engaging the Supreme Court's supervisory jurisdiction under section 69(3) and (4) of the *Supreme Court Act 1970* (NSW).

The Court of Appeal affirmed that the proper officer's satisfaction was not a jurisdictional fact but rather a prerequisite for the exercise of a statutory power. It held that the test for reviewability was whether the proper officer's conclusion was so unreasonable that no reasonable officer could have reached it, or if irrelevant considerations were taken into account. The court found no error of law on the face of the record, concluding that the proper officer's reasons did not demonstrate a failure to apply the correct test or a misinterpretation of the relevant statutory provisions. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. Order the appellant to pay the respondent’s costs in this court.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 March 2012, the appellant, Dominice, was involved in a motor vehicle accident. Dominice, who was the driver, collided with a stationary vehicle, resulting in injuries that required medical treatment. Following the accident, Dominice lodged a claim for compensation under the Transport Accident Insurance Scheme, managed by Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, the respondent. As part of the assessment of the claim, an independent medical assessment was conducted, and it was determined that Dominice suffered a whole person impairment of 20%. Dominice disagreed with the assessment and sought a review of the decision.

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd referred the matter to a review panel, as permitted under the Transport Accident (Compensation) Act 1998 (NSW). The review panel was required to consider whether the proper officer was satisfied that there was reasonable cause to suspect that the initial assessment was incorrect in a material respect. The review panel found that there was no reasonable cause to suspect the initial assessment was incorrect, and thus, Dominice's whole person impairment remained at 20%. Dominice then sought judicial review of the review panel's decision in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, claiming that the review panel made a jurisdictional error and considered irrelevant factors.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales was asked to consider whether the proper officer's satisfaction that there was reasonable cause to suspect that the initial assessment was incorrect was a jurisdictional fact, and whether this satisfaction was subject to judicial review. The court also needed to determine whether the reasons provided by the officer of the administrative body engaged the scope of review under the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), sections 69(3) and (69). The court examined these issues to determine if there was an error of law on the face of the record, which would justify the court's intervention in the matter.

The case of Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd commenced as a dispute concerning the compensation for injuries sustained by the appellant in a motor accident. The matter first came before the Local Court, where an initial assessment of whole person impairment was conducted. Following dissatisfaction with this assessment, Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd referred the matter to a proper officer for review under the relevant legislative provisions. The proper officer reviewed the assessment and concluded that there was reasonable cause to suspect the assessment was incorrect in a material respect, leading to a referral to a review panel. The appellant subsequently sought judicial review of the proper officer’s decision in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, arguing that the officer’s satisfaction was subject to review and constituted a jurisdictional error. The appellant further contended that the reasons provided by the officer engaged the error of law on the face of the record, invoking the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), sections 69(3) and (4). This appeal followed the dismissal of the judicial review application in the Supreme Court, prompting the appellant to seek further recourse in the higher court. Key procedural steps included the filing of applications for judicial review and interlocutory orders, with the Supreme Court ruling on the scope of reviewability of the proper officer’s satisfaction and the applicability of the Supreme Court Act provisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the proper officer have the jurisdiction to review the assessment of whole person impairment, and was the decision to refer the matter to a review panel a jurisdictional error?
2. Was the satisfaction of the proper officer that there was reasonable cause to suspect the assessment was incorrect in a material respect a jurisdictional fact or a matter subject to judicial review?
3. Was the decision of the proper officer to refer the matter to a review panel unreasonable or based on an irrelevant consideration?
4. Did the reasons provided by the officer of the administrative body engage the provisions of Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69(3) and (4) to constitute an error of law on the face of the record?
5. Was the satisfaction of the proper officer that there was reasonable cause to suspect the assessment was incorrect in a material respect subject to judicial review for unreasonableness or error of law?

Held
1. The court held that the proper officer did have the jurisdiction to review the assessment of whole person impairment and that the decision to refer the matter to a review panel was not a jurisdictional error.
2. The court determined that the satisfaction of the proper officer that there was reasonable cause to suspect the assessment was incorrect in a material respect was not a jurisdictional fact, but rather a matter subject to judicial review.
3. The court concluded that the decision of the proper officer to refer the matter to a review panel was not unreasonable or based on an irrelevant consideration.
4. The court found that the reasons provided by the officer of the administrative body did not engage the provisions of Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69(3) and (4) to constitute an error of law on the face of the record.
5. The court held that the satisfaction of the proper officer that there was reasonable cause to suspect the assessment was incorrect in a material respect was not subject to judicial review for unreasonableness or error of law.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd, the Court of Appeal comprehensively addressed several issues pertaining to the review of the assessment of whole person impairment (WPI) in the context of motor accident compensation. The court first considered whether the proper officer had the jurisdiction to review the WPI assessment and whether the decision to refer the matter to a review panel constituted a jurisdictional error. The court affirmed that the proper officer, under the provisions of the Motor Accident Authority Act 1994 (NSW), did indeed possess the jurisdiction to review the WPI assessment. It was established that the decision to refer the matter to a review panel was not a jurisdictional error, as it fell within the scope of the proper officer’s powers to reassess and ensure the correctness of WPI assessments.

Further, the court deliberated on whether the satisfaction of the proper officer that there was reasonable cause to suspect the WPI assessment was incorrect in a material respect constituted a jurisdictional fact or was subject to judicial review. The court found that this satisfaction was not a jurisdictional fact but rather a matter that could be subject to judicial review. This determination was crucial as it set the stage for the court to examine the reasonableness and legality of the officer’s decision.

The court then scrutinized whether the decision of the proper officer to refer the matter to a review panel was unreasonable or based on an irrelevant consideration. The court held that the proper officer's decision was not unreasonable and was not based on irrelevant considerations. The court underscored that the proper officer had acted within their jurisdiction and had provided adequate reasons for their decision, which were consistent with the legislative framework and relevant guidelines.

In addressing whether the reasons provided by the officer of the administrative body engaged the provisions of Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69(3) and (4), the court examined the sufficiency and legality of those reasons. It was concluded that the reasons did not constitute an error of law on the face of the record, as they were sufficient and did not contravene the statutory requirements. The court's reasoning was grounded in the understanding that the reasons needed to be adequate for the court to review the decision, but did not have to provide exhaustive detail.

Finally, the court considered whether the satisfaction of the proper officer that there was reasonable cause to suspect the WPI assessment was incorrect in a material respect was subject to judicial review for unreasonableness or error of law. The court held that this satisfaction was not subject to judicial review for unreasonableness or error of law, as the proper officer had exercised their discretion within the bounds of the statutory framework. The court emphasized the importance of deference to the administrative decision-maker's expertise in such specialized assessments.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the satisfaction of a proper officer, within their jurisdiction, that there is reasonable cause to suspect an assessment is incorrect in a material respect is not subject to judicial review for unreasonableness or error of law. The court upheld the proper officer's decision to refer the matter to a review panel as reasonable and within their jurisdiction, provided that the reasons given were adequate and did not contravene statutory requirements. The court also distinguished this case from prior authority by clarifying the scope of judicial review in relation to administrative decisions regarding WPI assessments.