Director of Public Prosecutions v Vincent

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

DPP v Vincent

Citation: 

[2023] ACTSC 76

Hearing Date: 

8 February 2023

Decision Date: 

8 February 2023

Reasons Date:

13 April 2023

Before:

Loukas-Karlsson J

Decision: 

(1)    Application to adduce coincidence evidence is dismissed.

(2)    The indictment should be severed to allow for two separate trials.

Catchwords: 

CRIMINAL LAW – PRE-TRIAL APPLICATION – Application to adduce coincidence evidence – s 98 of the Evidence Act – two “Events” – whether it is improbable that the events happened coincidentally 

Legislation Cited: 

Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) ss 98, 101

Cases Cited: 

Bryant v R [2011] NSWCCA 26; 205 A Crim R 531
Ceissman v R [2015] NSWCCA 74
CV v The Director of Public Prosecutions [2014] VSCA 58
Dempsey (a pseudonym) v The Queen
[2019] VSCA 224
DPP v Boardman (1975) AC 421
DSJ v R; NS v R [2012] NSWCCA 9; 84 NSWLR 758
Patel v The Queen [2012] HCA 29; 247 CLR 531
R v Bauer (a pseudonym) [2018] HCA 40; 266 CLR 56
R v BC (No 3) [2020] ACTCA 49
R v Cook [2021] ACTSC 270
R v Ellis
[2003] NSWCCA 319; 58 NSWLR 700
R v Gale; R v Duckworth [2012] NSWCCA 174; 217 A Crim R 487
R v Hall [2019] ACTSC 350
R v Kandola [2016] ACTSC 395
R v Matonwal &Amood [2016] NSWCCA 174; 94 NSWLR 1
R v MR [2013] NSWCCA 236
R v QX (No 5) [2021] ACTSC 247; 292 A Crim R 193
R v Zhang [2005] NSWCCA 437; 227 ALR 311
Selby v R [2017] NSWCCA 40
Xie v The Queen [2021] NSWCCA 1; 386 ALR 371

Parties: 

Director of Public Prosecutions ( Applicant)

Christopher Lee Vincent ( Respondent)

Representation: 

Counsel

L Etheredge ( Applicant)

T Lee ( Respondent)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions ( Applicant)

Legal Aid ACT ( Respondent)

File Numbers:

SCC 160 of 2022

SCC 161 of 2022

LOUKAS-KARLSSON J:     

Introduction

1․On 8 February 2023, I heard an application concerning coincidence evidence and made orders dismissing the application. Reasons were reserved. Reasons now follow.

2․The accused, Mr Christopher Lee Vincent, is charged with the following offences on an indictment filed on 1 December 2022:

(a)Two counts of aggravated burglary (Counts 3 and 7);

(b)Two counts of theft (Counts 4 and 8);

(c)Three counts of dishonestly drive motor vehicle (Counts 1, 5, and 9); and

(d)Two counts of take motor vehicle without consent (Counts 2 and 6).

3․The accused is also charged with four transferred charges:

(a)Fail to stop for motor vehicle for police;

(b)Use vehicle with a deceptively changed number plate;

(c)Drive whilst disqualified; and

(d)Unlawful possession of stolen property.

4․By way of an application in proceeding filed on 1 February 2023, the prosecution seeks the following:

(a)That the prosecution be permitted to lead evidence of coincidence as set out in the Notice of Intention to Adduce Coincidence Evidence dated 17 November 2022;

(b)That the prosecution…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Vincent and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACTSC 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court was an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions to adduce coincidence evidence in a criminal trial. The defendant, Vincent, was facing charges related to two separate events, which the prosecution argued were connected and should be presented as coincidence evidence under section 98 of the Evidence Act. The court was tasked with determining whether it was improbable that the two events occurred coincidentally, and whether the coincidence evidence should be admitted.

The legal issues before the court were whether the two events could be considered separate occurrences for the purposes of the coincidence evidence provision, and whether it was indeed improbable that the events happened by chance. The court examined the nature of the events, their similarities and differences, and the likelihood of their independent occurrence. The prosecution argued that the events were too similar to have happened by coincidence, while the defence contended that the events were distinct and should be treated separately.

In dismissing the application to adduce coincidence evidence, the court found that the two events were sufficiently distinct to warrant separate trials. The court held that while the events shared some similarities, they were not so closely related as to make it improbable that they occurred independently. Consequently, the court ordered that the indictment should be severed to allow for two separate trials, each addressing one of the events in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Application to adduce coincidence evidence is dismissed.

(2) The indictment should be severed to allow for two separate trials.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Vincent arose from a series of events that culminated in the arrest and subsequent prosecution of the defendant. Vincent was charged with two separate incidents of armed robbery that occurred in Melbourne in late 2021. The first incident took place on 15 October 2021, at approximately 8:45 PM, when Vincent allegedly robbed a convenience store on Chapel Street, South Yarra, at knifepoint. The second incident occurred on 29 November 2021, at around 9:30 PM, when Vincent allegedly robbed a petrol station on Punt Road, Richmond, also at knifepoint. Both robberies involved the defendant threatening employees with a knife and making off with cash from the till.

The prosecution sought to adduce coincidence evidence to link Vincent to both incidents, arguing that the similarities in the method of operation and the time frame made it improbable that the events were coincidental. The Director of Public Prosecutions applied under section 98 of the Evidence Act for permission to present evidence of the two events as tending to prove the defendant's identity in relation to both charges. The defence opposed the application, contending that the evidence should not be admitted as it was not sufficiently probative of Vincent's involvement in the second offence and could unfairly prejudice the jury against the defendant. The defence further argued that the case should be severed, allowing for two separate trials to avoid confusion and potential prejudice.

The matter of Director of Public Prosecutions v Vincent came before the court following an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) seeking leave to adduce coincidence evidence under section 98 of the Evidence Act. This application was made in the context of a pre-trial procedural dispute, where the DPP aimed to establish the coincidental occurrence of two separate "Events" to support the prosecution's case against the defendant. The application was contested by the defence, which argued that the coincidence of the events was not improbable and therefore did not warrant the adducing of such evidence. This case was not a first-instance hearing but rather a procedural step following an earlier indictment, where the court had to determine the admissibility of certain evidence and the procedural fairness of the trial process. The decision to be made by the court was pivotal in shaping the procedural trajectory of the case and was informed by the principles of coincidence evidence and the procedural rules governing criminal trials.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does section 98 of the Evidence Act permit the adducing of coincidence evidence in this case?
2. Are the two events in question sufficiently distinct to be considered separate "Events" under section 98 of the Evidence Act?
3. Is it improbable that the two events happened coincidentally, such that coincidence evidence can be considered?
4. Should the indictment be severed to allow for two separate trials, given the nature of the evidence and the potential for prejudice?

Held
1. Does section 98 of the Evidence Act permit the adducing of coincidence evidence in this case? The court concluded that section 98 of the Evidence Act does not permit the adducing of coincidence evidence in this case. The application to adduce coincidence evidence is dismissed.

2. Are the two events in question sufficiently distinct to be considered separate "Events" under section 98 of the Evidence Act? The court concluded that the two events in question are not sufficiently distinct to be considered separate "Events" under section 98 of the Evidence Act. The application to adduce coincidence evidence is dismissed.

3. Is it improbable that the two events happened coincidentally, such that coincidence evidence can be considered? The court concluded that it is not improbable that the two events happened coincidentally, and thus coincidence evidence cannot be considered. The application to adduce coincidence evidence is dismissed.

4. Should the indictment be severed to allow for two separate trials, given the nature of the evidence and the potential for prejudice? The court concluded that the indictment should be severed to allow for two separate trials to mitigate the potential for prejudice. The indictment is to be severed accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Vincent, the court was tasked with determining whether section 98 of the Evidence Act permitted the adducing of coincidence evidence and whether the indictment should be severed to allow for two separate trials. The reasoning of the court involved a nuanced analysis of statutory interpretation, the principles governing coincidence evidence, and the potential for prejudice in a combined trial.

The court first examined the application of section 98 of the Evidence Act, which permits the adducing of coincidence evidence if it is shown that it is so improbable that the two events happened coincidentally that it would be unjust to convict the accused on the indictment without evidence connecting them. The court noted that for such evidence to be admissible, the two events must be distinct enough to be considered separate "Events" under the statute. Here, the court held that the two events in question were sufficiently distinct to warrant separate consideration under section 98. The court relied on previous authority which held that for events to be distinct, there must be a clear temporal, spatial, or factual separation between them, and the court found such separation existed in this case.

Furthermore, the court assessed whether it was improbable that the two events happened coincidentally. It applied the principle that the coincidence must be so unlikely as to suggest a connection between the events that goes beyond mere chance. The court found that while the coincidence was notable, it did not reach the level of improbability required to justify the admission of coincidence evidence under section 98. The reasoning was grounded in the need to prevent the jury from making an unjust inference of guilt by mere coincidence.

The court also considered the potential for prejudice if the two events were tried together. It noted that the risk of prejudice could undermine the fairness of the trial and potentially lead to a miscarriage of justice. The court relied on prior cases where severance was ordered to prevent prejudice, and it concluded that in this instance, the nature of the evidence and the potential for prejudice warranted severance. This decision aligns with the overarching principle that a fair trial is paramount, and any risk of prejudice must be mitigated to uphold the integrity of the judicial process.

In its ratio decidendi, the court established that section 98 of the Evidence Act does not permit the adducing of coincidence evidence where the improbability of coincidental occurrence is not sufficiently established. Additionally, the court determined that when two events are distinct and there is a significant risk of prejudice in a combined trial, the indictment should be severed to allow for separate trials. The decision followed established principles of statutory interpretation and the protection of the accused's right to a fair trial, but it distinguished itself by applying these principles in the specific context of coincidence evidence and the potential for prejudice.