Director of Public Prosecutions v Sheehy

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

DPP v SHEEHY & ORS

[2012] SASC 152

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kelly

4 September 2012

MAGISTRATES - APPEALS AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - APPEALS BY CROWN - POWER TO BRING APPEAL

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE  - SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AGAINST PEACE AND PUBLIC ORDER - AFFRAY, RIOT, UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY AND LIKE OFFENCES - AFFRAY

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - RELEVANT FACTORS  - NATURE AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF OFFENCE - GRAVITY OF OFFENCE

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING ORDERS - NON-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - SUSPENDED SENTENCE OF IMPRISONMENT - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

Crown appeal against sentence imposed by Magistrate - respondents pleaded guilty to one count of aggravated affray, contrary to s 83C(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) - Magistrate sentenced all respondents to a head sentence of imprisonment for four months, reduced from six months on account of the respondents’ pleas - two of the respondents received an immediate custodial penalty, one respondent received a partially suspended sentence upon entering into a bond for three months, and the balance of the respondents received a wholly suspended sentence upon entering into a bond for 12 months - where circumstances of offending serious, and in context of revenge attack - whether sentence manifestly inadequate - discussion regarding prosecution appeals against sentence - discussion regarding the courts' approach to revenge taking - discussion of principles regarding suspended sentences of imprisonment.

Held: appeal allowed - offence was a serious one of its type - sentence was so low as to shock the public conscience - sentences imposed by Magistrate set aside and respondents resentenced.

Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) s 42; Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 83C, s 340, referred to.
R v Osenkowski (1982) 30 SASR 212; Everett v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 295; R v Nemer (2003) 87 SASR 168; R v Harkin (2011) 109 SASR 334; R v Menzies [2012] NSWSC 158; Dinsdale v The Queen (2000) 202 CLR 321, applied.
R v MacGowan (1986) 42 SASR 580; Elliott v Harris (No 2) (1976) 13 SASR 516; WorkCover Corporation of South Australia v Musolino (2008) 100 SASR 147, discussed.
Wood v Samuels (1974) 8 SASR 465; Darby v Police [2009] SASC 394; R v Kitchener [2003] NSWCCA 134; R v KR & PR [2008] NSWSC 970; R v Lewis [1999] NSWSC 131; R v Eken [2012] NSWSC 2; R v Hawi [2012] NSWSC 332; Knight v The Queen [2010] NTCCA 15; Smith v Tasmania [2012] TASCCA 3; R v O'Keefe [1969] 2 QB 29; R v Weaver (1973) 6 SASR 265, considered.

DPP v SHEEHY & ORS
[2012] SASC 152

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Sheehy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 152
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Court was brought by the Crown against the sentences imposed on nine respondents who had pleaded guilty to one count of aggravated affray under section 83C(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). The case arose from a violent confrontation between members of the Finks and Hells Angels motorcycle gangs, which occurred in a nightclub in Adelaide. The respondents were part of a group of Finks members who went to the nightclub with the intention of confronting and fighting the Hells Angels members who were already present. The altercation resulted in serious injuries to several individuals, including one person who required 16 staples to close a wound on his head.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the sentences imposed by the Magistrate were manifestly inadequate or excessive and whether there were grounds for the Crown to appeal against the sentences. The Crown argued that the sentences were too lenient given the seriousness of the offence and the need to deter such conduct. The respondents, on the other hand, contended that the sentences were within the appropriate range and that the Magistrate had considered all relevant factors in determining the penalty.

The Court, after reviewing the circumstances of the offence and the sentences imposed, concluded that the sentences were manifestly inadequate. The offence was characterised by premeditated and violent behaviour, with the respondents acting as a group with a clear intent to confront and fight the Hells Angels members. The use of bar stools as weapons and the serious injuries sustained by the victims underscored the gravity of the offence. The Court held that the sentences imposed by the Magistrate did not adequately reflect the seriousness of the offending, and as such, the appeal was allowed. The sentences were set aside, and the respondents were resentenced.

In re-sentencing, the Court emphasised the need for sentences that would appropriately reflect the seriousness of the offence and serve as a deterrent to others who might engage in similar conduct. The Court noted the importance of sending a clear message that such violent and premeditated group behaviour would not be tolerated.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents argue that it has not been shown that the Magistrate made any error, let alone one which would justify any intervention by this Court properly applying the principle laid down in Everett and other authorities. The respondents submit this Court should reject the prosecution invitation to interfere with the discretionary decision of the Magistrate, who addressed every relevant consideration, made no error and arrived at an appropriate sentence within the range available to him. Background At about 3.30am on Sunday 29 May 2011 members of the Hells Angels attended The Firm nightclub on North Terrace. Security officers recognised them, requested them to leave and telephoned the police. As they exited the premises they became involved in a physical altercation with three Finks motorcycle club members. As a result of that altercation one Hells Angels member and one Finks member were arrested for fighting and conveyed to the City Watch House. That incident served as a catalyst for subsequent event which gave rise to the charge of aggravated affray. Following the incident at The Firm nightclub, 10 Hells Angels members moved to the City Nightclub on Hindley Street. At about 4.32am Finks member Peter Pantic was observed to enter the City Nightclub with two other people. At about 4.54am the nine respondents attended the City Nightclub. They forced their way past security at the front door, stormed across the dance floor and confronted the Hells Angels who were standing about inside. A violent brawl ensued, involving punching, kicking, stomping and the use of bar stools as weapons. As a consequence of the affray a member of the Hells Angels required 16 staples to his head. A number of other participants in the affray sustained injuries, including a broken arm. In total the affray lasted about three minutes. The respondents were initially charged on an Information containing two offences; one, the major indictable offence of aggravated riot contrary to s 83B of the Act, and the alternative, minor indictable offence of aggravated affray contrary to s 83C of the Act. The Information was laid against eight of the respondents on 28 June 2011, and the Information in respect of Mr Brouwer was laid on 13 October 2011. On 30 May 2012 each of the nine respondents entered a plea of guilty to the offence of aggravated affray. The prosecution accepted that plea in full satisfaction of the Information. The Magistrate’s decision The Magistrate commenced his sentencing remarks by setting out the factual basis on which he intended to sentence the respondents. It had earlier been accepted on behalf of the respondents that each of the nine respondents were members of the Finks Motorcycle Club. After dealing with the personal circumstances of each of the respondents the Magistrate commented on the seriousness of the offence. He then said:What is clear from the material before me is that following the incident outside The Firm nightclub, all of you went to the City Nightclub knowing members of the Hells Angels were there and you went there for the purpose of confronting and fighting them. You entered the nightclub and immediately confronted and fought with members of the Hells Angels. You did this in a public place where it could be expected members of the public would be present and indeed members of the public were present. You did this without any regard for the fear this aggressive and uncontrolled behaviour would place and did place members of the public and staff of the nightclub in. The fact that each of you went to the nightclub for this purpose distinguishes your offending from the spur-of-the-moment incident occurring in and around a nightclub or other licensed premises in the early hours of the morning that unfortunately the court regularly deals with. Because of this there is no doubt in my mind that each of you went to the nightclub for the purpose of getting involved for the type of incident that actually occurred.In my view it is incumbent on courts to send a clear message that this sort of conduct is unacceptable.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KELLY J (dissent)
The respondents were initially charged on an Information containing two offences; one, the major indictable offence of aggravated riot contrary to s 83B of the Act, and the alternative, minor indictable offence of aggravated affray contrary to s 83C of the Act. The Information was laid against eight of the respondents on 28 June 2011, and the Information in respect of Mr Brouwer was laid on 13 October 2011. On 30 May 2012 each of the nine respondents entered a plea of guilty to the offence of aggravated affray. The prosecution accepted that plea in full satisfaction of the Information. The Magistrate’s decision The Magistrate commenced his sentencing remarks by setting out the factual basis on which he intended to sentence the respondents. It had earlier been accepted on behalf of the respondents that each of the nine respondents were members of the Finks Motorcycle Club. After dealing with the personal circumstances of each of the respondents the Magistrate commented on the seriousness of the offence. He then said:What is clear from the material before me is that following the incident outside The Firm nightclub, all of you went to the City Nightclub knowing members of the Hells Angels were there and you went there for the purpose of confronting and fighting them. You entered the nightclub and immediately confronted and fought with members of the Hells Angels. You did this in a public place where it could be expected members of the public would be present and indeed members of the public were present. You did this without any regard for the fear this aggressive and uncontrolled behaviour would place and did place members of the public and staff of the nightclub in. The fact that each of you went to the nightclub for this purpose distinguishes your offending from the spur-of-the-moment incident occurring in and around a nightclub or other licensed premises in the early hours of the morning that unfortunately the court regularly deals with. Because of this there is no doubt in my mind that each of you went to the nightclub for the purpose of getting involved for the type of incident that actually occurred.In my view it is incumbent on courts to send a clear message that this sort of conduct is unacceptable. He then determined that a sentence of imprisonment was necessary and imposed a head sentence of four months in each case after applying a discount for the pleas of guilty of two months. His Honour then proceeded to sentence each of the respondents according to their respective antecedents. In the result, three of the respondents received immediate custodial sentences and the remaining six received suspended sentences. Discussion The facts accepted by the learned Magistrate highlight the seriousness of this offending. The nine respondents acted as a group. Their actions were premeditated and motivated by a desire for retaliation or revenge arising from the earlier incident outside The Firm nightclub. They pushed past the security officers at the entrance to the nightclub and walked directly to the area in the nightclub where the Hells Angels members were standing. The sole purpose of their attendance at that nightclub was to have a violent confrontation with the Hells Angels members who were present there. They used bar stools as weapons to strike each other. Some were seriously injured, including one man who sustained injuries necessitating 16 staples to the head. These circumstances place the respondents’ conduct at the upper level of seriousness for an offence of aggravated affray.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

The Court examined the Crown's power to bring an appeal against the sentences imposed by the Magistrate, determining that such appeals are permissible in cases where the sentence is manifestly inadequate. In this case, the Court found the sentences to be manifestly inadequate and allowed the appeal. The Court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that the Crown has the authority to appeal when the sentence imposed by the Magistrate is deemed inappropriate. This principle is supported by relevant statutes and authorities that allow for appeals by the Crown in cases where the sentence is excessive or inadequate.

The Court found the sentences imposed by the Magistrate to be manifestly inadequate, considering the serious nature of the offence and the premeditated nature of the attack. The Court applied the principle that a manifestly inadequate sentence is one that shocks the conscience of the community. The Court held that the sentences were insufficient to reflect the gravity of the offence, which involved a violent confrontation in a public place, resulting in serious injuries to several participants. This principle was derived from authorities such as R v Everett, which establish the criteria for determining when a sentence is manifestly inadequate.

In reviewing the sentences imposed by the Magistrate, the Court outlined the principles that should guide such reviews. The Court emphasised that the primary consideration is the seriousness of the offence, taking into account the nature and circumstances of the crime. The Court noted that the Magistrate had addressed the seriousness of the offence but found the imposed sentences to be inadequate in light of the premeditated and violent nature of the attack. The Court also considered the necessity of sending a clear message to deter similar conduct in the future, reinforcing the principle that sentences should reflect the gravity of the offence and serve as a deterrent.

The Court considered whether the approach to revenge taking should influence the sentencing of the respondents. The Court recognised that the offence was motivated by revenge, which is a significant aggravating factor. The Court held that while revenge is a relevant factor, it does not absolve the need for a sentence that adequately addresses the seriousness of the offence. The Court applied the principle that the primary objective of sentencing is to ensure justice is served, which includes deterrence and denunciation. The Court found that the imposed sentences did not adequately reflect the premeditated and violent nature of the attack, which was driven by revenge.

In determining the appropriateness of suspended sentences of imprisonment in cases of aggravated affray, the Court applied principles that consider the nature and circumstances of the offence, the culpability of the offender, and the need for deterrence. The Court found that the serious nature of the offence, which involved a premeditated violent confrontation resulting in significant injuries, warranted immediate custodial sentences. The Court held that suspended sentences were inappropriate in this case because they did not adequately address the gravity of the offence or serve as an effective deterrent. The Court's decision was influenced by authorities that establish the importance of imposing sentences that reflect the seriousness of the offence and the need to protect public safety.