Knight v The Queen and Cassidy v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

Knight v The Queen & Cassidy v The Queen [2010] NTCCA 15

PARTIES:JAMES SCOTT PARNWELL KNIGHT

v

THE QUEEN

AND

NICHOLAS FRANK CASSIDY

v

THE QUEEN

TITLE OF COURT:  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  CRIMINAL APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:CA 15 of 2009 (20734520)

CA 9 of 2010 (20733814)

DELIVERED:  8 November 2010

HEARING DATES:  12-13 July 2010

JUDGMENT OF:  MILDREN, SOUTHWOOD & KELLY JJ

APEAL FROM:  RILEY J AND A JURY OF 12

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AGAINST CONVICTION – Aggravated assault – common purpose – aiding and abetting – consent – self-defence – Appeal dismissed

APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – Manifestly excessive – concurrency – totality – Appeal dismissed

Criminal Code s 17; s 18; s 19; s 20; s 43BG(6); s 69; s 154; s 187; s 310(1)

Pearce v The Queen (1998) 194 CLR 610; applied

Hoessinger v The Queen (1992) 62 A Crim R 146; McKinnon v The Queen [2004] NTCCA 8; distinguished

R v Darby (1982) 148 CLR 668; followed

DPP v Shannon [1975] AC 717; referred to

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant (Knight):  I Rowbottam

Appellant (Cassidy):                   M Shaw QC

Respondent:  R Wild QC and M Thomas

Solicitors:

Appellant (Knight):  Withnalls Lawyers

Appellant (Cassidy):                   Withnalls Lawyers

Respondent:  Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Sou1011

Number of pages:  58

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Knight v The Queen & Cassidy v The Queen [2010] NTCCA 15

No CA 15 of 2009 (20734520) & CA 9 of 2010 (20733814)

BETWEEN:

JAMES SCOTT PARNWELL KNIGHT

Appellant

AND:

THE QUEEN

Respondent

AND

NICHOLAS FRANK CASSIDY

Appellant

AND:

THE QUEEN

Respondent

CORAM:    MILDREN, SOUTHWOOD & KELLY JJ

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 8 November 2010)

THE COURT:

Introduction

  1. The appellants Knight and Cassidy together with four other men, Blyss, Pullman, Ryan and Padden, were jointly charged with unlawfully assaulting Warren Mahoney, aggravated by the circumstance that Warren Mahoney suffered harm and were also jointly charged with assaulting Robert Mahoney, aggravated by the circumstance that Robert Mahoney suffered harm. On both of those counts, the jury entered verdicts of guilty. The appellant Knight was also charged with going armed in public with a claw hammer on the same occasion contrary to s 69 of the Criminal Code.  He was also found guilty on that count.

  2. Initially, the appellant Knight’s notice of appeal against conviction was limited to two grounds.  During the course of the hearing of the appeal, he was permitted to amend his notice of appeal to rely upon the grounds set out in the appellant Cassidy’s notice of appeal.  The appellant Cassidy’s notice of appeal contained 14 grounds.  Grounds 12 and 13 were abandoned at the trial by the counsel for the appellant Cassidy and no argument was pressed by Mr Rowbottam on behalf of the appellant Knight about grounds 12, 13 and 14.

    The Crown case

  3. On the night of 6…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Knight v The Queen and Cassidy v The Queen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NTCCA 15
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Knight v The Queen* and *Cassidy v The Queen* concerned appeals against conviction and sentence by the appellants, Knight and Cassidy. The appeals were heard by Mildren, Southwood, and Kelly JJ. The appellants were convicted of aggravated assault, with the prosecution alleging common purpose and aiding and abetting. The defence for Cassidy maintained he acted in self-defence and that no common purpose existed, while Knight argued he only became involved when he felt threatened.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the trial judge erred in failing to adequately warn the jury about the potential dangers of relying solely on CCTV footage, given its limitations in coverage and timing, and whether a sufficient causal link was established between the appellants' actions and the injuries sustained by the Mahoney brothers. Additionally, the court considered the appellants' submissions regarding the absence of common purpose and the validity of their involvement in the assaults.

The court found no substance to the grounds of appeal against conviction. Regarding the CCTV evidence, the judges noted that the trial judge had drawn the jury's attention to the timing issues and the submissions made by counsel concerning it, and that no objection was taken to the instructions given. The court also found that the admitted injuries sustained by the Mahoney brothers were a result of the fight that took place, and that the causal link was established. The appeals against conviction were dismissed.

The appeal against sentence by Cassidy was also dismissed. The sentencing judge found that the attendance of the six men at the hotel was pursuant to a common purpose for a revenge attack, describing the violence as frightening and cowardly. The judge emphasised the need for general deterrence for organised and public violence motivated by revenge, and that such vigilante conduct would not be tolerated. Despite Cassidy's limited criminal history and positive personal circumstances, the court found the sentence of two years and six months imprisonment with a non-parole period of 15 months to be appropriate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

So far as the appellant Cassidy was concerned, his case was that there never any common purpose and that he acted initially entirely in self-defence. The learned trial Judge made it perfectly clear in his summing up that that was the case that was being put by the appellant Cassidy and he correctly drew the jury’s attention to the relevant evidence which went to those issues. Similarly, the appellant Knight’s case was that there was no common purpose involved and that the only time he became involved was when he himself felt threatened. Again, the relevant evidence concerning that was explained to the jury, the jury’s attention was drawn to it and the jury were properly instructed in relation to those issues. It is difficult to know what else the learned trial Judge could be expected to have done.Failure to warn the jury about the CCTV evidence It was submitted that the learned trial Judge erred in failing to warn the jury of the dangers of convicting solely on the principal evidence, which was the CCTV footage, in circumstances where it failed to cover the entire area of the alleged crime scene throughout the entire time and appeared not to be in true time. It was perfectly obvious that the CCTV footage did not capture everything because it was not in fact in true time. The learned trial Judge reminded the jury that there was some question about the timing of the CCTV footage and the learned trial Judge reminded the jury of Mr Rowbottam’s submissions in relation to it. His Honour said to the jury:One of the things he [Mr Rowbottam] said was that in some places you can possibly see people moving more quickly – he used the Charlie Chaplin example – and some moving slowly. If he was right about that when you look at it, bear that in mind when determining what response was appropriate or in appropriate to things that were happening. Were they happening much quicker than we are led to believe by the first viewing? Or were they happening much slower? And does that have any impact upon you of what the video [CCTV footage] does show. Once again, no objection was taken by counsel as to the instruction which the learned trial Judge gave to the jury. In our opinion, there is no substance to it.Absence of causal link between the assaults and the injuries caused to each of the Mahoney brothers. It was an admitted fact that each of the Mahoney brothers suffered certain injuries and that these amounted to harm. However, it was put that there was no causal link established between the harm or injuries so suffered and the conduct of the appellants. It was never in issue that the admitted injuries were sustained by the Mahoney brothers as a result of the fight which took place in the hotel that night. The admitted facts show that both the Mahoney brothers were examined by a medical practitioner at the Royal Darwin Hospital in the early hours of 7 December 2007, only a matter of a few hours afterwards. Warren Mahoney’s evidence was of no assistance on that issue as he claimed not to be able to remember anything and, so far as suffering some injuries at around about that time, although he said that he suffered from broken ribs, broken nose, broken hand and his head was swollen, he said that he only knew that from what others had told him.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Where double jeopardy is alleged it is essentially a plea in bar of trial, i.e. autrefois convict. The appellant’s argument proceeded on the basis that such a plea was available, but at no stage was such a plea entered. Even leaving aside that difficulty, we are satisfied that there is no substance to this ground of appeal.Conclusions on appeals against conviction In conclusion, on the appeal against convictions in our opinion the appellant’s appeals against conviction must be dismissed.Appeal against sentence by the appellant Cassidy The appellant Cassidy was sentenced in relation to counts 2 and 3 to 20 months imprisonment on each count. His Honour directed that the sentence in relation to count 3 be served cumulatively upon the sentence for count 2 as to 10 months. This resulted in a total head sentence of two years and six months. His Honour imposed a non-parole period of 15 months. The learned sentencing Judge accepted that all of the events took place over a relatively short period of time. He said however that the offending was serious. He had no hesitation in finding that the attendance of the six men at the hotel was in accordance with an arrangement. They were there pursuant to a common purpose. Their attendance followed the assault upon the appellant Cassidy earlier in the evening. It was a calculated and planned revenge attack committed in company. Whilst his Honour accepted that there was no detailed planning, there was a common understanding of what was to take place. His Honour said that the attack inspired fear in those who were present at the hotel and it resulted in the injuries to which he had referred. His Honour described the level of violence as frightening and that it was a cowardly attack far removed from the suggestion made to the jury by the appellant Cassidy that “all he wanted was a fair fight”. His Honour said that whilst alcohol was present, the altercation was not fuelled by alcohol but rather by a desire for revenge. His Honour went on to describe the offending as:…of a kind which causes disquiet in the community. Offences of organised and public violence and offences where the motivation is revenge are obviously serious and call for condign punishment. It is necessary to demonstrate strong disapproval of the criminal conduct which amounts to a flagrant violation of the law. Vigilante conduct of this kind will not be tolerated. The offences are of a kind requiring that significant emphasis be placed upon the need for general deterrence. The appellant Cassidy had a limited criminal history which included an aggravated assault upon a female in 1993 in relation to which he was placed on a good behaviour bond. In 1997, he was convicted and fined for threatening behaviour. In 2000, he was convicted of being armed with an offensive weapon for which he was sentenced to two months imprisonment wholly suspended. He had no recent convictions for offences of violence. His Honour accepted that the appellant Cassidy is a good family man and that he is hard worker. He was at the time of trial working in the building industry as a supervisor with his own company. His Honour accepted that the business was likely to close as a result of the appellant Cassidy being sent to prison because he is the person who manages the business. Assuming that to be so, his Honour said that he could see no reason why the business could not recommence later, particularly in the light of glowing references which had been received from people with whom the appellant Cassidy had worked.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.