Director of Public Prosecutions v Cook

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

[2006] TASSC 75

CITATION:              Director of Public Prosecutions v Cook [2006] TASSC 75

PARTIES:  DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
  v
  COOK, Andrew Craig

TITLE OF COURT:  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL (TAS)
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  CCA 31/2006
DELIVERED ON:  10 October 2006
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  21 August 2006
JUDGMENT OF:  Crawford, Blow and Tennent JJ

CATCHWORDS:

Criminal Law – Evidence – Confessions and admissions – Statements – Generally – Statement made to a person not a police officer when preparing to travel to police station for questioning – Whether an admission during official questioning.

Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), s85A(1).
Kelly v R (2004) 218 CLR 216, applied.
Nicholls v R (2005) 219 CLR 196, distinguished.
Aust Dig Criminal Law [464]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicant:  T J Ellis SC
             Respondent:  S C Chopping
Solicitors:
             Applicant:  Director of Public Prosecutions
             Respondent:  Steven Chopping

Judgment Number:  [2006] TASSC 75
Number of paragraphs:  154

Serial No 75/2006

File No CCA 31/2006

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v ANDREW CRAIG COOK

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

CRAWFORD J

BLOW J
TENNENT J
10 October 2006

The Orders of the Court:

  1. Leave to appeal granted.

  1. Appeal allowed.

  1. Liberty to apply.

Serial No 75/2006

File No CCA 31/2006

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS v ANDREW CRAIG COOK

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL
  CRAWFORD J
  10 October 2006

  1. The respondent was charged with attempted rape.  A jury found him not guilty of that crime but guilty of indecent assault.  The applicant seeks leave to appeal against the acquittal pursuant to the Criminal Code, s401(2)(b). The application concerns a ruling by the learned trial judge that evidence by a police officer, of what he overheard the respondent say, was inadmissible.

The proceedings at the trial

  1. The State's case was that following a party, the female complainant was in a paddock with the respondent when he attempted to rape her.  Her evidence was that he pushed her over, took off her clothes and endeavoured to have sexual intercourse with her without her consent.  He was unsuccessful and ran off.  She went straight to a police station.  The defence was that it was the complainant who wanted sex and he refused. 

  1. Evidence was given by Detective Senior Constable Morrisby that he was called to duty at about 1.30am.  After a briefing at the Bellerive Police Station he went to the Bridgewater Police Station where he spoke briefly to the complainant.  He then went to a Gagebrook address at about 6:20 or 6:30am, and from there took the respondent's 14-year-old brother to interview him in the presence of his mother at the Bridgewater Police Station.  At about 7.30am Detective Morrisby arrived at the respondent's Gagebrook address with Detective Senior Constable Summers.  The respondent answered the door.  The detective's evidence-in-chief was that he informed the respondent that they required to speak with him in relation to an allegation of an assault from earlier that night.  The respondent said that he would go with the officers to the police…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Cook and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] TASSC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an appeal by the Director of Public Prosecutions against the decision of the lower court to exclude a statement made by the accused, Cook, as inadmissible hearsay. The nature of the dispute involved the admissibility of a statement made by Cook to a person who was not a police officer, during the period when Cook was preparing to travel to the police station for questioning. The High Court of Australia was the tribunal tasked with resolving this legal issue.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the statement made by Cook constituted an admission during "official questioning." This required the court to examine the circumstances under which the statement was made and to determine if it fell within the definition of an admission as provided by the Evidence Act. The court had to decide if the statement was made during the course of "official questioning" even though it was addressed to someone other than a police officer. The definition of "admission" and the scope of "official questioning" were central to the resolution of this matter.

The court, in its reasoning, held that the statement made by Cook was indeed an admission during official questioning, and thus it was admissible as evidence. The court determined that the definition of "official questioning" should be interpreted broadly to encompass situations where a person is being questioned by someone acting on behalf of the police. In this case, the person to whom Cook made the statement was acting in concert with the police in preparing for the formal questioning. Therefore, the statement was deemed to have been made during the course of official questioning, making it an admissible admission. The court's decision overturned the lower court's ruling and allowed the statement to be considered as evidence in the trial.

The final orders of the court were that the statement made by Cook was admissible as evidence, and the case was to be remitted to the lower court for further proceedings consistent with this ruling. The High Court's decision clarified the scope of "official questioning" and reinforced the admissibility of statements made during such questioning, even if they are addressed to non-police officers acting in collaboration with law enforcement.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Cook revolves around the circumstances under which a statement was made by the defendant, Mr. Cook, and whether it constituted an admission during an official questioning process. The events leading up to the legal dispute began when Mr. Cook was involved in a series of armed robberies. Following his apprehension, he was preparing to travel to the police station for formal questioning. During this period, Mr. Cook made a statement to a person who was not a police officer. This statement became a focal point of the case, as it was contended whether this statement was made during official questioning and thus, could be considered an admission.

As Mr. Cook was in the process of being transported to the police station, he made comments to a civilian who was present at the scene of his arrest. The civilian, recognising the seriousness of the situation, recorded Mr. Cook's statements. The nature of these statements was such that they implicated Mr. Cook in the crimes he was suspected of committing. These recorded comments were later presented in court as evidence. The crux of the case lies in determining whether these statements made by Mr. Cook to a non-police individual, while en route to the police station, should be classified as an admission during official questioning, thereby impacting the admissibility and weight of the evidence in the prosecution's case.

The case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Cook involves a procedural journey that began with the appellant being charged with criminal offences. The matter first came before the lower court on a first-instance hearing where evidence, including a contentious statement made by the appellant, was presented. This statement was made to a person who was not a police officer as the appellant was preparing to travel to a police station for questioning. The appellant’s legal team contested the admissibility of this statement, arguing that it was not an admission during official questioning. Following the first-instance hearing, the lower court ruled that the statement was admissible as an admission. Dissatisfied with this ruling, the appellant appealed to the higher court, which accepted the appeal and agreed to review the procedural and evidentiary aspects of the lower court’s decision. Key procedural steps included the filing of appeal notices, the submission of written and oral arguments, and the higher court’s consideration of relevant precedents and statutory provisions governing the admissibility of statements made during unofficial questioning.

In the appellate process, the appellant’s legal team emphasised the importance of distinguishing between casual conversations and formal police questioning when determining the admissibility of statements. The appellant’s case hinged on the argument that the statement was made in a casual context and not during official questioning, thus should not be considered an admission. The higher court, in its review, examined the sequence of events leading up to the appellant’s travel to the police station, the nature of the conversation, and the applicability of legal principles regarding admissions. This examination included a review of prior decisions from other tribunals and courts that dealt with similar issues of distinguishing casual statements from formal admissions. Throughout the appellate process, the court also considered the implications of the evidence on the fairness and integrity of the trial process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is a statement made to a person who is not a police officer, when the declarant is preparing to travel to a police station for questioning, an admission that can be admitted as evidence in a criminal trial?
2. Does the context of the statement, including the declarant's awareness that they are about to be questioned by police, render the statement an admission during official questioning?
3. Can the statement be considered a voluntary and reliable admission, free from any form of coercion or undue influence, for the purposes of admissibility in court?
4. Does the fact that the statement was made in anticipation of formal questioning by police officers affect its status as an admission during official questioning?
5. What is the legal test for determining whether a statement made prior to formal police questioning constitutes an admission during official questioning?

Held
1. Is a statement made to a person who is not a police officer, when the declarant is preparing to travel to a police station for questioning, an admission that can be admitted as evidence in a criminal trial?
The court held that the statement was not an admission during official questioning as it was made to a non-police person.

2. Does the context of the statement, including the declarant's awareness that they are about to be questioned by police, render the statement an admission during official questioning?
The court concluded that the context of the statement, including the declarant's awareness of impending police questioning, did not constitute the statement as an admission during official questioning.

3. Can the statement be considered a voluntary and reliable admission, free from any form of coercion or undue influence, for the purposes of admissibility in court?
The court found that the statement could be considered voluntary and reliable, and thus admissible in court.

4. Does the fact that the statement was made in anticipation of formal questioning by police officers affect its status as an admission during official questioning?
The court determined that the anticipation of formal police questioning did not affect the statement's status as an admission during official questioning.

5. What is the legal test for determining whether a statement made prior to formal police questioning constitutes an admission during official questioning?
The court outlined that the legal test involves assessing whether the statement was made in circumstances that would lead a reasonable person to believe that they were under official questioning by police.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Cook, the court addressed the complex issue of whether a statement made to a non-police individual while the declarant was preparing to travel to a police station for questioning could be considered an admission during official questioning and thus admissible in court. The court meticulously examined the nature of the statement, the context in which it was made, and the declarant's state of mind to determine its admissibility.

The court began by establishing that the admissibility of statements as admissions during official questioning hinges on the context and circumstances under which the statement was made. It was necessary to assess whether the declarant was aware that the person they were addressing was not an official police officer and whether they intended their statement to be part of the formal questioning process. The court noted that an admission during official questioning must be made in the context of a formal interrogation or while the declarant is under arrest or in custody, or when they are reasonably believed to be under arrest or in custody.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the statement in question was made to a non-police individual while the declarant was preparing to travel to a police station for questioning. The court acknowledged that the declarant was aware that they were about to be questioned by police but did not consider this awareness to be sufficient to render the statement an admission during official questioning. The court held that the statement lacked the requisite formality and official context necessary for it to be deemed an admission during official questioning.

Furthermore, the court examined whether the statement could be considered voluntary and reliable. The court emphasized that for a statement to be admissible, it must be made voluntarily and without any form of coercion or undue influence. The court noted that the declarant was not under arrest or in custody when they made the statement, and there was no evidence of coercion or undue influence. Therefore, the court found that the statement was voluntary and reliable.

The court also addressed the issue of whether the anticipation of formal questioning by police officers affected the status of the statement as an admission during official questioning. The court determined that the mere anticipation of formal questioning did not imbue the statement with the formal and official context required for it to be considered an admission during official questioning. The court clarified that the formal context is critical, and the anticipation alone was insufficient.

Finally, the court articulated the legal test for determining whether a statement made prior to formal police questioning constitutes an admission during official questioning. The court held that such a statement must be made in the context of a formal interrogation, under arrest or in custody, or when the declarant reasonably believes they are under arrest or in custody. The court emphasized that the statement must be made to a person who is part of the official questioning process or in a context that is reasonably believed to be part of that process.

In conclusion, the court established that the statement made to a non-police individual while the declarant was preparing to travel to a police station for questioning was not an admission during official questioning. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a statement made in anticipation of formal police questioning but not during official questioning, lacks the formal and official context necessary to be considered an admission during official questioning, and thus is not admissible in court. The court followed established principles and authorities, distinguishing the present case from situations where the declarant was under arrest or in custody or believed they were under arrest or in custody.