Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Turner

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Turner & Anor [2016] QSC 107

PARTIES:

COMMONWEALTH DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

(applicant)

v
ELIZABETH ANNE TURNER

(first respondent)
BETTY DUNMALL
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Brisbane No 409 of 2014

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

18 May 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

21 April 2016

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDERS:

1.   I declare that the defendant’s undertaking as to bail, executed by the defendant on 30 April 2013, be forfeited;

2.   I order that the cash deposit of $70,000 be forfeited and paid to Her Majesty;

3.   I order that the amount of the surety be reduced from $450,000 to $315,000;

4.   I order that the surety in the amount of $315,000 be forfeited and paid to Her Majesty;

5.   I order that the first respondent pay the amount of $315,000 to the proper officer of the Court within six months of the date of these orders;

6.   I order that the first respondent be imprisoned for the term of 12 months if she defaults in paying the amount of $315,000 within six months of the date of these orders to the proper officer of the Court.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – BAIL – BEFORE TRIAL – where defendant released on undertaking as to bail – where first respondent and second respondent provided surety for defendant’s undertaking – where defendant failed to report in accordance with bail conditions – where first respondent alleges that defendant is dead – where defendant is unable to be located – whether defendant failed to appear in accordance with undertaking

CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – BAIL – SURETIES – where defendant released on own undertaking before trial – where first respondent and second respondent provided surety for defendant’s undertaking – where defendant failed to appear in accordance with undertaking – where applicant seeks forfeiture of surety for defendant’s failure to appear

CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – BAIL  - RECOGNISANCES – FORFEITURE AND ESTREATMENT – RELIEF FROM ESTREATMENT AND REDUCTION OF LIABILITY – where first respondent granted leave to file application for relief and reduction of liability to forfeit surety – where first respondent alleges financial hardship – where first respondent alleges that defendant is dead – whether first respondent took all reasonable steps – whether first respondent will suffer financial hardship if surety is forfeited

Bail Act 1980 (Qld), s 20, s 27, s 31, s 32, s32A, s32B, s 36A

R v Mokbel & Mokbel (2006) 199 FLR 176; [2006] VSC 158, applied

Baytieh v State of Queensland [2001] 1 Qd R 1; [1999] QCA 466, considered

Thomakakis v Sheriff of New South Wales (1993) 33 NSWLR 36; 71 A Crim R 265, considered

Re Condon [1973] VR 427, considered

The Director of Public Prosecutions v Lipp & Anor [2008] VSC 203, considered

COUNSEL:

G P Lynham with A J Guilfoyle for the applicant

P J…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Turner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Turner, the dispute involved the forfeiture of a bail bond due to the defendant's failure to appear in court. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The defendant had been released on bail, with two respondents providing surety for the bail undertaking. The defendant failed to comply with the bail conditions and could not be located, leading to the application for the forfeiture of the bail bond.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the defendant had indeed failed to appear in accordance with the bail undertaking and whether the first respondent was entitled to relief from the forfeiture of the surety due to financial hardship and the defendant's alleged death. The court needed to determine if the evidence supported the claim that the defendant was deceased before a specific date and whether the first respondent had taken all reasonable steps to ensure the defendant's attendance in court. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the first respondent would suffer financial hardship if the surety was forfeited.

The court found that the evidence supporting the defendant's death was circumstantial and did not meet the required standard of proof on the balance of probabilities. Consequently, the court declared the defendant's bail undertaking forfeited, ordered the cash deposit forfeited, and reduced the surety amount from $450,000 to $315,000. The first respondent was ordered to pay the reduced surety amount within six months or face imprisonment for 12 months if payment was not made.

The court's decision underscores the importance of the surety system and the limited circumstances under which relief from forfeiture may be granted. The evidence provided by the first respondent, although demonstrating efforts to supervise the defendant and financial hardship, did not sufficiently establish that the defendant was deceased prior to the specified date, nor did it justify relief from the forfeiture of the surety.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. I declare that the defendant’s undertaking as to bail, executed by the defendant on 30 April 2013, be forfeited;

2. I order that the cash deposit of $70,000 be forfeited and paid to Her Majesty;

3. I order that the amount of the surety be reduced from $450,000 to $315,000;

4. I order that the surety in the amount of $315,000 be forfeited and paid to Her Majesty;

5. I order that the first respondent pay the amount of $315,000 to the proper officer of the Court within six months of the date of these orders;

6. I order that the first respondent be imprisoned for the term of 12 months if she defaults in paying the amount of $315,000 within six months of the date of these orders to the proper officer of the Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 32B(2)(c) of the Act requires the application to briefly state the circumstances relied on by the first respondent. The application identifies the following circumstances:(i)the defendant is deceased and was deceased before 9 November 2015 so securing his attendance at Court was impossible;(ii)the surety’s financial position has deteriorated so hardship will be suffered if relief is not given;(iii)during the time the defendant was on bail the surety did her best to supervise him and ensure his adherence to the bail conditions;(iv)the departure of the defendant was sudden and not foreseen by the surety;(v)through the actions of the Director of Public Prosecutions the application for forfeiture of the bail undertaking and the surety has been adjourned on occasions incurring unnecessary costs to the surety. Circumstance (i): Does the evidence support a finding that the defendant was deceased prior to 9 November 2015? The first respondent carries the onus of establishing that the interests of justice require an order for relief under s 32B.[29] As observed by McMurdo P and Davies JA in Baytieh v State of Queensland:“It may be accepted that the circumstances will be rare in which it would be against the interests of justice to require the person indebted to pay any part of the amount ordered to be paid, given the importance of ensuring the integrity of the surety system.”[30][29] Applicant’s Outline of Submissions, 21 April 2016, [7] citing CUCU v The District Court (NSW) (1994) 73 A Crim R 240 at 242. [30] [2001] 1 Qd R 1 at [12]; [1999] QCA 499 at [12]. If the court were to be satisfied that the defendant was deceased then it would have been impossible for the first respondent to secure the defendant’s attendance at Court. What is necessary however, is evidence to satisfy the court on the balance of probabilities, of the fact of death. The evidence must be enough to enable the court to feel an actual persuasion that a particular fact is so.[31] [31] Brown v New South Wales Trustee and Guardian (2012) 10 ASTLR 164 at 176 per Campbell JA [2012] NSWCA 431 at [51] per Campbell JA; Austin v Parmalat Australia Limited [2013] QSC 227 at [33] per Dalton J. The evidence that the defendant is deceased is entirely circumstantial. The first respondent has not seen the defendant since 13 August 2015.[32] She held significant concerns about the state of the defendant’s mental health as the trial approached.[33] On the last occasion that she spoke to her son, she believed that his mental condition had deteriorated significantly. The defendant had made comments about committing suicide and had obtained a shot fire licence.[34] Two weeks prior to 13 August 2015 the defendant had placed a life insurance form on the first respondent’s desk and asked her to deal with it. [32] Affidavit of Elizabeth Anne Turner sworn 14 October 2015, para. 22. [33] Affidavit of Elizabeth Anne Turner sworn 14 October 2015, para. 17.[34] Affidavit of Elizabeth Anne Turner sworn 14 October 2015, para. 22.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established