Background
Background to the litigation
For the reasons set out below, I make the declarations as sought by the Director and have determined that the respondents pay pecuniary penalties in the amount of $37,000 for Mr Chi, and $17,000 for Ms Chau. I have made consequential orders relating to the time for payment of the pecuniary penalties.BACKGROUND On 29 December 2019, Mr Chi, travelling with Ms Chau, arrived at Melbourne International Airport having flown from Hong Kong. Mr Chi’s suitcase was scanned and, following an inspection, found to contain live freshwater fish in untreated fresh water. Mr Chi was then asked to present his IPC which did not declare the importation of fish or animals. The fish were seized and euthanised and Mr Chi was issued an infringement notice. On 29 January 2020, Mr Chi and Ms Chau again arrived at Melbourne International Airport from Hong Kong. Each carried a suitcase that was inspected and found to contain live freshwater fish in untreated fresh water. Each of Mr Chi and Ms Chau were asked to present their IPC, which did not declare the importation of fish or animals. The fish were seized and euthanised. I refer to these incidents on 29 December 2019 and 29 January 2020 as the first importation and second importation, respectively, and collectively as the importations. On 23 December 2022, the Director commenced proceedings in this Court. The respondents have cooperated with all stages of the investigation and the proceedings, including making significant admissions as to their conduct and contraventions of the Biosecurity Act. They even pleaded “guilty” on their first appearance before me. On 2 February 2024, a statement of agreed facts (SAF) was filed in accordance with s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). I received it into evidence at the hearing and I find in accordance with it (with minor edits) as follows:Mr Chi’s first importation – 29 December 20194.On Sunday, 29 December 2019, Mr Chi arrived at Terminal 2 of Melbourne International Airport on Cathay Pacific Flight CX163 from Hong Kong. Mr Chi was travelling with Ms Chau. 5.Mr Chi was travelling with one medium sized suitcase. 6.Mr Chi’s suitcase was passed through an x-ray machine and the image indicated that goods of biosecurity concern might be present. 7.Mr Petar Makalovski (a Biosecurity Officer of the then Department of Agriculture (Department)) requested that Mr Chi provide Mr Makalovski his incoming passenger card (IPC) and Mr Chi provided the document to Mr Makalovski. 8.The IPC, which Mr Chi had completed and signed, recorded the answer “No” to Questions 6 and 8 on the IPC. Those questions were as follows: Are you bringing into Australia: …(6) Meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?…(8)Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biologicals, specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?9.Mr Makalovski then inspected Mr Chi’s suitcase. The suitcase contained four insulated bags, each of which contained a separate plastic bag that was tied at the top, was filled with water and contained approximately 30 live freshwater fish.10.The plastic bags and fish were inspected and photographed by Ms Leanne Keenan (a Biosecurity Officer of the Department).11.The fish were then euthanised and stored by the Department.12.The fish in the plastic bags found in Mr Chi’s suitcase included plecos, arowana and snakeheads. The water in each of the four bags was fresh water, which had not been treated using a method that the Director was satisfied was appropriate to manage biosecurity risks associated with the water to an acceptable level.13.Mr Chi admits that:(a) he had packed his baggage and was aware of its contents;(b)he was aware that the importation of the fish and water was prohibited without a permit; and(c) he did not hold a permit for the importation.14Mr Makalovski issued Mr Chi an Infringement Notice in connection with the provision of a false or misleading IPC pursuant to s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act. Mr Chi paid the amount stated in the Infringement Notice.Mr Chi’s second importation – 29 January 202015.On the evening of Wednesday, 29 January 2020, 31 days after receiving the Infringement Notice, Mr Chi arrived at Terminal 2 of Melbourne International Airport on Cathay Pacific Flight CX163 from Hong Kong. Mr Chi was travelling with Ms Chau.16.Mr Chi was travelling with one large suitcase and one backpack.17.Mr Matthew Lombardi (an Australian Border Force (ABF) officer) asked for Mr Chi’s IPC and Mr Chi provided the document to him. Mr Lombardi returned the IPC to Mr Chi.18.Mr Lombardi escorted Mr Chi to a baggage inspection area.19.Mr Daniel Sanders (an ABF officer) and Mr Ryan McNeill (a Biosecurity Officer of the Department) attended the baggage inspection area.20.Mr McNeill asked for Mr Chi’s IPC and Mr Chi provided the document to him.21.The IPC, which Mr Chi had completed and signed, recorded the answer “No” to Questions 6 and 8 on the IPC. Those questions were as follows:Are you bringing into Australia: …(6) Meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?…(8)Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biologicals, specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?”.22.Mr Sanders asked Mr Chi: “What is inside the bag?”. Mr Chi replied: “Fish”.23.Mr Chi’s suitcase was inspected and was found to contain an insulated bag, which contained a separate plastic bag that was tied at the top, was filled with water and contained live freshwater fish.24.The plastic bag and fish were then inspected and photographed by Mr Glenn Johnston, a Senior Investigator at the Department.25.The fish were then euthanised and stored by the Department.26.The fish in the plastic bags found in Mr Chi’s suitcase included plecos and other catfish. The water in each of the four bags was fresh water, which had not been treated using a method that the Director was satisfied was appropriate to manage biosecurity risks associated with the water to an acceptable level. Mr Chi's suitcase contained 19 fish.27.Mr Chi admits that:(a)he had packed his baggage and was aware of its contents.(b)he had read, understood and signed the IPC prior to providing it to Mr Lombardi and Mr McNeill;(c)he knew that the IPC was false or misleading because he had recorded “no” to questions 6 and 8 in circumstances where he knew that his bag contained live fish;(d)he was aware that the importation of the fish and water was prohibited without a permit; and(e)he did not hold a permit for the importation.Ms Chau’s Importation - 29 January 202028.On the evening of Wednesday, 29 January 2020, Ms Chau arrived at Terminal 2 of Melbourne International Airport on Cathay Pacific Flight CX163 from Hong Kong. Ms Chau was travelling with Mr Chi.29.Ms Chau was travelling with one large suitcase and one backpack.30.Ms Janelle De Goede (an ABF officer) asked for Ms Chau’s IPC and Ms Chau provided the document to her. Ms De Goede returned the IPC to Ms Chau.31.Ms De Goede escorted Ms Chau to a baggage inspection area.32.Mr Joel Scantlebury (an ABF officer), Mr Jarrod Smith (an ABF officer) and Mr Makalovski attended the baggage inspection area.33.Mr Makalovski asked for Ms Chau’s IPC and Ms Chau provided the document to him.34.The IPC, which Ms Chau had completed and signed, recorded the answer “No” to Questions 6 and 8 on the IPC. Those questions were as follows:Are you bringing into Australia: …(6) Meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?(8)Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biologicals, specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?35.Mr Smith asked Ms Chau whether there were any fish in her bag and Ms Chau replied: “Yes, I have some fish”.36.Ms Chau’s suitcase was inspected. The suitcase was found to contain seven insulated bags, each of which contained a separate plastic bag that was tied at the top, was filled with water and contained live freshwater fish. Ms Chau's suitcase contained 103 fish.37.The plastic bags and fish were inspected and photographed by Mr Glenn Johnston, a Senior Investigator at the Department.38.The fish were then euthanised and stored by the Department.39.The fish in the plastic bags found in Ms Chau’s suitcase included catfish, plecos and snakeheads. The water in each of the four bags was fresh water, which had not been treated using a method that the Director was satisfied was appropriate to manage biosecurity risks associated with the water to an acceptable level.40.Ms Chau admits that:(a)she had packed her baggage and was aware of its contents.(b)she had read, understood and signed the IPC prior to providing it to Ms De Goede and Mr Makalovski;(c)she knew that the IPC was false or misleading because she had recorded “no” to questions 6 and 8 in circumstances where she knew that her suitcase contained live fish;(d)she was aware that the importation of the fish and water was prohibited without a permit; and(e)she did not hold a permit for the importation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
As above, the respondents cooperated, admitted their conduct, agreed to the SAF and have demonstrated remorse as mitigating factors.CONCLUSION Taking all of these matters into account, I determine as appropriate the following civil penalties:(1)Mr Chi:(a)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 December 2019, $12,000;(b)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $20,000; and(c)for contravening s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $5,000.(2)Ms Chau:(a)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $12,000; and(b)For contravening s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $5,000. At the hearing, parties agreed that I would publish my judgment and invite the parties to provide further short submissions about whether this might be an appropriate matter for the payment of the penalties by instalments. The respondents should have the opportunity of making submissions, that the Director may respond to. The Director seeks costs and there is no reason why they should not follow the event. For the reasons set out above, I make the following declarations and orders:Declarations against Mr Chun Lok ChiDeclaration of contravention – 29 December 2019 importations1.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (Federal Court Act) that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth) (Biosecurity Act) on 29 December 2019, by bringing and/or importing live fish into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the condition in relation to such goods specified in s 11(1)(a) of the Biosecurity (Prohibited and Conditionally Non-prohibited Goods) Determination 2016 (Cth) (Goods Determination) in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.2.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 December 2019, by bringing and/or importing water, or alternatively bags of water, into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the conditions in relation to such goods specified in s 39(3) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.Declaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 importations3.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing live fish into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the condition in relation to such goods specified in s 11(1)(a) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.4.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing water, or alternatively bags of water, into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the conditions in relation to such goods specified in s 39(3) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.Declaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 incoming passenger card5.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by producing an Incoming Passenger Card (IPC) to Mr Matthew Lombardi, an officer of the Australian Border Force and Mr Ryan McNeill, a Biosecurity Officer of the Department, in circumstances where;(a)Mr Chi knew that the document was false or misleading in that he had placed crosses in boxes marked “No” on the IPC next to the questions:(i)“Are you bringing into Australia … meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?”; and(ii)“Are you bringing into Australia … Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biological specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?”,and had signed a declaration attesting that the information he had given on the IPC was true, correct and complete, but was in fact knowingly bringing fish into Australia; and(b)the IPC was produced in purported compliance with the Biosecurity Act.Declarations against Ms Linh Thi My ChauDeclaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 importation6.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Ms Linh Thi My Chau contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing live fish into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the condition in relation to such goods specified in s 11(1)(a) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.7.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Ms Linh Thi My Chau contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing water, or alternatively bags of water, into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the conditions in relation to such goods specified in s 39(3) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.Declaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 incoming passenger card8.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Ms Linh Thi My Chau contravened s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by producing an IPC to Ms Janelle de Goede, an officer of the Australian Border Force and Mr Petar Makalovski, a Biosecurity Officer of the Department, in circumstances where;(a)Ms Chau knew that the document was false or misleading in that she had placed crosses in boxes marked “No” on the IPC next to the questions:(i)“Are you bringing into Australia … meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?”; and(ii)“Are you bringing into Australia … Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biological specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?”,and had signed a declaration attesting that the information she had given on the IPC was true, correct and complete, but was in fact knowingly bringing fish into Australia; and(b)the IPC was produced in purported compliance with the Biosecurity Act.9.Pursuant to s 82(3) of the Regulatory Powers (Standard Provisions) Act 2014 (Cth) I order that the following pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia:(a)by Mr Chun Lok Chi:(i)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth) (Biosecurity Act) on 29 December 2019, $12,000;(ii)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $20,000; and(iii)for contravening s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $5,000.(b)by Ms Linh Thi My Chau:(i)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $12,000; and(c)for contravening s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $5,000.10.Any application by the respondents for time to pay or for payment by instalments of the penalties imposed by order is to be made in writing with any supporting affidavits by 4 pm on the day that is 14 days from the making of these orders. If such application is made, the applicant may respond thereto in writing with any supporting affidavits by 4 pm on the day that is 14 days from being served with any application made by the Respondents. Subject to any further order, any supplication that is made will be determined on the papers.11.If no application is made pursuant to order 10, the amounts required to be paid in order 9 must be paid within 42 days of the publication of these reasons.12.The respondents are to pay the applicant’s costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
For the reasons set out above, I make the following declarations and orders:Declarations against Mr Chun Lok ChiDeclaration of contravention – 29 December 2019 importations1.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (Federal Court Act) that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth) (Biosecurity Act) on 29 December 2019, by bringing and/or importing live fish into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the condition in relation to such goods specified in s 11(1)(a) of the Biosecurity (Prohibited and Conditionally Non-prohibited Goods) Determination 2016 (Cth) (Goods Determination) in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.2.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 December 2019, by bringing and/or importing water, or alternatively bags of water, into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the conditions in relation to such goods specified in s 39(3) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.Declaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 importations3.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing live fish into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the condition in relation to such goods specified in s 11(1)(a) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.4.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing water, or alternatively bags of water, into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the conditions in relation to such goods specified in s 39(3) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.Declaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 incoming passenger card5.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Mr Chun Lok Chi contravened s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by producing an Incoming Passenger Card (IPC) to Mr Matthew Lombardi, an officer of the Australian Border Force and Mr Ryan McNeill, a Biosecurity Officer of the Department, in circumstances where;(a)Mr Chi knew that the document was false or misleading in that he had placed crosses in boxes marked “No” on the IPC next to the questions:(i)“Are you bringing into Australia … meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?”; and(ii)“Are you bringing into Australia … Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biological specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?”,and had signed a declaration attesting that the information he had given on the IPC was true, correct and complete, but was in fact knowingly bringing fish into Australia; and(b)the IPC was produced in purported compliance with the Biosecurity Act.Declarations against Ms Linh Thi My ChauDeclaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 importation6.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Ms Linh Thi My Chau contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing live fish into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the condition in relation to such goods specified in s 11(1)(a) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.7.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Ms Linh Thi My Chau contravened s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by bringing and/or importing water, or alternatively bags of water, into Australian territory in circumstances where:(a)such goods were conditionally non-prohibited goods; and(b)the conditions in relation to such goods specified in s 39(3) of the Goods Determination in force under sub-s 174(1) of the Biosecurity Act had not been satisfied.Declaration of contravention – 29 January 2020 incoming passenger card8.Pursuant to s 21 of the Federal Court Act that Ms Linh Thi My Chau contravened s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, by producing an IPC to Ms Janelle de Goede, an officer of the Australian Border Force and Mr Petar Makalovski, a Biosecurity Officer of the Department, in circumstances where;(a)Ms Chau knew that the document was false or misleading in that she had placed crosses in boxes marked “No” on the IPC next to the questions:(i)“Are you bringing into Australia … meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, fruit, vegetables?”; and(ii)“Are you bringing into Australia … Animals, parts of animals, animal products including equipment, pet food, eggs, biological specimens, birds, fish, insects, shells, bee products?”,and had signed a declaration attesting that the information she had given on the IPC was true, correct and complete, but was in fact knowingly bringing fish into Australia; and(b)the IPC was produced in purported compliance with the Biosecurity Act.9.Pursuant to s 82(3) of the Regulatory Powers (Standard Provisions) Act 2014 (Cth) I order that the following pecuniary penalties be paid to the Commonwealth of Australia:(a)by Mr Chun Lok Chi:(i)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act 2015 (Cth) (Biosecurity Act) on 29 December 2019, $12,000;(ii)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $20,000; and(iii)for contravening s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $5,000.(b)by Ms Linh Thi My Chau:(i)for contravening s 186(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $12,000; and(c)for contravening s 533(1) of the Biosecurity Act on 29 January 2020, $5,000.10.Any application by the respondents for time to pay or for payment by instalments of the penalties imposed by order is to be made in writing with any supporting affidavits by 4 pm on the day that is 14 days from the making of these orders. If such application is made, the applicant may respond thereto in writing with any supporting affidavits by 4 pm on the day that is 14 days from being served with any application made by the Respondents. Subject to any further order, any supplication that is made will be determined on the papers.11.If no application is made pursuant to order 10, the amounts required to be paid in order 9 must be paid within 42 days of the publication of these reasons.12.The respondents are to pay the applicant’s costs.