Dick Smith Electronics Pty Limited v Westpac Banking Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dick Smith Electronics Pty Limited v Westpac Banking Corporation
[2002] FCA 1040

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery – legal professional privilege – whether legal professional privilege existed in relation to internal memorandum prepared for mixed purposes of human resources activities and potential litigation.

Esso Australia Resources Limited v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 applied
Grant v Downs (1976) 135 CLR 674 cited
Hartogen Energy Ltd v The Australian Gas Light Company (1992) 36 FCR 557 cited
Trade Practices Commission v Sterling (1979) 36 FLR 244 applied
Waugh v British Railways Board [1980] AC 521 cited
Wheeler v Le Marchant (1881) 17 Ch D 675 cited

DICK SMITH ELECTRONICS PTY LIMITED V WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION

N 0026 OF 2002

BEAUMONT J
23 AUGUST 2002
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 0026 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

DICK SMITH ELECTRONICS PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 AUGUST 2002

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The claim of privilege in respect of Portion 1 is disallowed.

2.        The claim of privilege in respect of Portion 2 is allowed.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 0026 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

DICK SMITH ELECTRONICS PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BEAUMONT J

DATE:

23 AUGUST 2002

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR RULING
(ON PRIVILEGE CLAIM)

BEAUMONT J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. By its list of documents filed on 8 July 2002, pursuant to an order for discovery, Westpac Banking Corporation (“Westpac”), the respondent in the principal proceedings, made a claim of legal professional privilege in respect of certain portions only of a confidential internal memorandum, dated 2 March 2001 (“the Memorandum”).

  2. By its notice of motion filed on 17 July 2002, Dick Smith Electronics Pty Limited (“Dick Smith”), the applicant in the principal proceedings, now seeks an order, pursuant to O 15 r 11, for the production of the whole of the Memorandum, contending that the claim for privilege cannot be maintained in the present context.

  3. For its part, Westpac accepts, in accordance with the settled course of authority, that it bears the onus of showing that the claim for privilege ought to be allowed.

    THE MEMORANDUM

  4. Privilege is claimed in respect of two distinct portions of the Memorandum, now described as “Portion 1” and “Portion 2” respectively.  In order to understand their context, it will be necessary to explain the Memorandum’s form, structure and contents other than these Portions.

  5. The Memorandum, dated 2 March 2002, is headed:  “Westpac Confidential”; and is entitled: “Internal Memo [from] Group Investigations …”.  It is from Raff Del Vecchio, Manager Investigations, Group Fraud Control, and is addressed to Stephen Hull, an Area Network Manager, and Ross Miller, NSW Head of Human Resources.  The subject of the Memorandum is stated as:  “Investigation into Macquarie Centre CSR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dick Smith Electronics Pty Limited v Westpac Banking Corpora... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1040
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dick Smith Electronics Pty Limited v Westpac Banking Corporation involved a dispute between Dick Smith Electronics, the applicant, and Westpac Banking Corporation, the respondent. The applicant sought to compel the respondent to disclose certain documents, while the respondent claimed legal professional privilege over those documents. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central issue before the court was whether certain parts of an internal memorandum prepared by the respondent were protected by legal professional privilege. Specifically, the court had to determine if the privileged parts were created for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice or for litigation purposes.

The court examined the affidavit of Julia Elizabeth Bracun, a solicitor for the respondent, who provided evidence about the preparation and purpose of the internal memorandum. The memorandum, dated 2 March 2001, was prepared by Raff del Vecchio, the Manager Investigations, Group Fraud at the respondent, and was copied to several individuals including Alastair Mackay, the Head of Dispute Resolution Group. The affidavit detailed that the memorandum was created in response to a potential claim by the applicant and was intended to brief the in-house counsel on the matter. Portion 1 of the memorandum was argued to have been created for the purpose of briefing legal counsel on potential liability and anticipated legal proceedings. Portion 2, on the other hand, was noted as referring to legal advice received from Alastair Mackay.

The court concluded that Portion 1 of the memorandum was not protected by privilege as it was created for the purpose of briefing legal counsel on potential liability and anticipated legal proceedings, rather than solely for obtaining legal advice. However, Portion 2, which contained the legal advice received from Alastair Mackay, was protected by privilege as it was created for the purpose of obtaining legal advice.

The court's final orders were that the claim of privilege in respect of Portion 1 was disallowed, whereas the claim of privilege in respect of Portion 2 was allowed. This decision highlights the importance of the dominant purpose test in determining the extent of legal professional privilege over documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The claim of privilege in respect of Portion 1 is disallowed.

2. The claim of privilege in respect of Portion 2 is allowed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Memorandum was copied to Alistair Mackay, as Head of Dispute Resolution Group (Mr Mackay is a practising solicitor). It was also copied to another Area Network Manager.THE CIRCUMSTANCES SURROUNDING THE PREPARATION OF THE MEMORANDUM - WESTPAC’S SOLICITOR’S EVIDENCE In support of its privilege claim, Westpac relies upon the evidence in the affidavit of Julia Elizabeth Bracun, sworn on 31 July 2002, relevantly as follows:“1.I am a solicitor in the employ of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, the solicitors for the Respondent (“the Bank”) and I have the carriage of this matter under the supervision of Stuart Westgarth.2.The matters I have deposed to in this affidavit are based on information and belief, such information received from Raff del Vecchio, Manager Investigations, Group Fraud at the Bank (“Mr Del Vecchio”).3.Annexed hereto and marked with the letter “A” is a copy of a Westpac Confidential Internal Memorandum dated 2 March 2001 from Raff Del Vecchio to Stephen Hull, Area Network Manager, Homebush Bay Region and Ross Miller, Head of Human Resources and copied to Alastair Mackay, Legal Counsel and Head Of Dispute Resolution Group at the Bank and Chris Pappas, Area Network Manager.4.On pages 2 and 3 of annexure “A” is a blanked out portion which I have marked portion 1 (“Portion 1”). On Page 3 of annexure “A” is a blanked out portion, which I have marked portion 2 (“Portion 2”).5.I am informed by Mr Del Vecchio and verily believe that:(a)Shortly prior to 1 March 2001, he received a telephone call from the Finance & Administration Manager of the Applicant (“Dick Smith”) who informed him that Dick Smith would likely make a claim on the Bank as a consequence of a police inquiry into the activities of an employee of the Bank [the Employee - then named] and a facsimile dated 23 February 2001 sent by [the Employee] to Dick Smith.(b)Following notification of the possible claim, a decision was made by him in his capacity as Manager Investigations, Group Fraud to investigate the circumstances of the claim and an investigation and interview was carried out by him with [the Employee] on 1 March 2001.(c)Annexure “A”, excluding Portion 1 and Portion 2, was created by him for the purposes of consideration of any disciplinary proceedings against [the Employee].(d)Annexure “A”, excluding Portion 1 and Portion 2, was also created by him for the purpose of providing a briefing to Alastair Mackay, Legal Counsel and Head of the Bank’s Dispute Resolution Group in anticipation of defending the possible claim. This is why the memorandum has been copied to Alastair Mackay. If the memorandum had been created solely for disciplinary proceedings, Group Fraud would not copy in the Bank’s in-house counsel.(e)Portion 1 was created by him and recorded in the memorandum for the dominant purpose of briefing Alastair Mackay for advice in relation to any liability the Bank may have and for use in any anticipated legal proceedings involving [the Employee] and Dick Smith, or either of them. Portion 1 is accurate in its recording of its content.(f)Portion 2 refers to legal advice he received from Alastair Mackay in relation to the possible claim by Dick Smith, consequent upon him informing Mr Mackay of the outcome of the interview and after his discussions with Mr Mackay concerning the possible claim and the contents of Portion 1.CONCLUSIONS ON THE CLAIM OF PRIVILEGE

Decision

Reasons for decision

BEAUMONT J
In support of its privilege claim, Westpac relies upon the evidence in the affidavit of Julia Elizabeth Bracun, sworn on 31 July 2002, relevantly as follows:“1.I am a solicitor in the employ of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, the solicitors for the Respondent (“the Bank”) and I have the carriage of this matter under the supervision of Stuart Westgarth.2.The matters I have deposed to in this affidavit are based on information and belief, such information received from Raff del Vecchio, Manager Investigations, Group Fraud at the Bank (“Mr Del Vecchio”).3.Annexed hereto and marked with the letter “A” is a copy of a Westpac Confidential Internal Memorandum dated 2 March 2001 from Raff Del Vecchio to Stephen Hull, Area Network Manager, Homebush Bay Region and Ross Miller, Head of Human Resources and copied to Alastair Mackay, Legal Counsel and Head Of Dispute Resolution Group at the Bank and Chris Pappas, Area Network Manager.4.On pages 2 and 3 of annexure “A” is a blanked out portion which I have marked portion 1 (“Portion 1”). On Page 3 of annexure “A” is a blanked out portion, which I have marked portion 2 (“Portion 2”).5.I am informed by Mr Del Vecchio and verily believe that:(a)Shortly prior to 1 March 2001, he received a telephone call from the Finance & Administration Manager of the Applicant (“Dick Smith”) who informed him that Dick Smith would likely make a claim on the Bank as a consequence of a police inquiry into the activities of an employee of the Bank [the Employee - then named] and a facsimile dated 23 February 2001 sent by [the Employee] to Dick Smith.(b)Following notification of the possible claim, a decision was made by him in his capacity as Manager Investigations, Group Fraud to investigate the circumstances of the claim and an investigation and interview was carried out by him with [the Employee] on 1 March 2001.(c)Annexure “A”, excluding Portion 1 and Portion 2, was created by him for the purposes of consideration of any disciplinary proceedings against [the Employee].(d)Annexure “A”, excluding Portion 1 and Portion 2, was also created by him for the purpose of providing a briefing to Alastair Mackay, Legal Counsel and Head of the Bank’s Dispute Resolution Group in anticipation of defending the possible claim. This is why the memorandum has been copied to Alastair Mackay. If the memorandum had been created solely for disciplinary proceedings, Group Fraud would not copy in the Bank’s in-house counsel.(e)Portion 1 was created by him and recorded in the memorandum for the dominant purpose of briefing Alastair Mackay for advice in relation to any liability the Bank may have and for use in any anticipated legal proceedings involving [the Employee] and Dick Smith, or either of them. Portion 1 is accurate in its recording of its content.(f)Portion 2 refers to legal advice he received from Alastair Mackay in relation to the possible claim by Dick Smith, consequent upon him informing Mr Mackay of the outcome of the interview and after his discussions with Mr Mackay concerning the possible claim and the contents of Portion 1.CONCLUSIONS ON THE CLAIM OF PRIVILEGE

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BEAUMONT J

Full text does not contain this section.