DFD Rhodes Pty Ltd v Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   DFD RHODES PTY LTD -v- HANCOCK PROSPECTING PTY LTD [No 3] [2023] WASC 392

CORAM:   WHITBY J

HEARD:   14 SEPTEMBER 2023

DELIVERED          :   11 OCTOBER 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2737 of 2013

BETWEEN:   DFD RHODES PTY LTD

First Plaintiff

MATTHEW JOHN KEADY AND DOROTHEA MARGARET CAMPBELL as executors of the estate of DONOVAN FRANCES DUNCAN RHODES

Second Plaintiffs

AND

HANCOCK PROSPECTING PTY LTD

First Defendant

WRIGHT PROSPECTING PTY LTD

Second Defendant

HOPE DOWNS IRON ORE PTY LTD

Third Defendant

BIANCA HOPE RINEHART

Fourth Defendant

JOHN LANGLEY HANCOCK

Fifth Defendant

HOPE RINEHART WELKER

Sixth Defendant

GINIA HOPE FRANCIS RINEHART

Seventh Defendant

HAMERSLEY WA PTY LTD

Third Party

(BY ORIGINAL ACTION)

BIANCA HOPE RINEHART

First Plaintiff by Counterclaim

JOHN LANGLEY HANCOCK

Second Plaintiff by Counterclaim

AND

GEORGINA HOPE RINEHART

First Defendant by Counterclaim

HANCOCK PROSPECTING PTY LTD

Second Defendant by Counterclaim

HANCOCK MINERALS PTY LTD

Third Defendant by Counterclaim

THE HANCOCK FAMILY MEMORIAL FOUNDATION LTD

Fourth Defendant by Counterclaim

TADEUSZ JOZEF WATROBA

Fifth Defendant by Counterclaim

WESTRAINT RESOURCES PTY LTD

Sixth Defendant by Counterclaim

HMHT INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Seventh Defendant by Counterclaim

150 INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Eighth Defendant by Counterclaim

HOPE RINEHART WELKER

Ninth Defendant by Counterclaim

GINIA HOPE FRANCIS RINEHART

Tenth Defendant by Counterclaim

MAX CHRISTOPHER DONNELLY as trustee in bankruptcy of LANGLEY GEORGE HANCOCK

Eleventh Defendant by Counterclaim

HOPE DOWNS IRON ORE PTY LTD

Twelfth Defendant by Counterclaim

ROY HILL IRON ORE PTY LTD

Thirteenth Defendant by Counterclaim

MULGA DOWNS INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Fourteenth Defendant by Counterclaim

MULGA DOWNS IRON ORE PTY LTD

Fifteenth Defendant by Counterclaim

WRIGHT PROSPECTING PTY LTD

Sixteenth Defendant by Counterclaim

DFD RHODES PTY LTD

Seventeenth Defendant by Counterclaim

MATTHEW JOHN KEADY AND DOROTHEA MARGARET CAMPBELL as executors of the estate of DONOVAN FRANCES DUNCAN RHODES

Eighteenth Defendants by Counterclaim

(BY COUNTERCLAIM)


Catchwords:

Practice and Procedure - Discovery - Legal professional privilege claimed over discovered documents - Documents ordered to be produced to adversary in private arbitration - Whether privilege lost

Practice and Procedure - Discovery - Documents - Legal professional privilege - Waiver - Whether documents lost quality of confidence by virtue of being produced in private arbitration - Whether documents lost quality of confidence by virtue of orders compelling production of documents - Whether parties claiming privilege demonstrated inconsistency of conduct in maintaining a claim for privilege

Practice and Procedure - Discovery - Documents - Legal professional privilege - Waiver - Whether party claiming privilege put their knowledge in issue in assertions made in submissions in answer to claim of laches - Whether submissions amounted to party claiming privilege putting forward a positive case as to knowledge - Whether an assertion that a party is put to proof on a matter constitutes conduct inconsistent with the maintenance of privilege

Practice and Procedure - Discovery - Documents - Legal professional privilege - Waiver - Whether legal professional privilege applies to copies of original documents copied for the purpose of storage on an electronic management system

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DFD Rhodes Pty Ltd v Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 392
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of DFD Rhodes Pty Ltd v Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd [No 3] involves a complex dispute concerning title to the Hope Downs Tenements, involving multiple parties including HPPL, Gina, her children, and WPPL. The primary legal issues revolve around the application of legal professional privilege to documents that were disclosed during private arbitration proceedings and the potential waiver of this privilege through various actions and orders. Additionally, the case examines whether the court is bound by the arbitral tribunal's ruling regarding privilege.

The court considered whether the privilege over certain documents was lost due to their disclosure in private arbitration, and whether the orders compelling their production constituted a waiver of privilege. The court also scrutinised whether the parties claiming privilege demonstrated inconsistent conduct in maintaining their claim for privilege, particularly in light of assertions made in response to claims of laches. Furthermore, the court addressed whether the privilege applied to copies of original documents made for storage purposes and whether the court was bound by the arbitral tribunal's ruling regarding privilege.

The court found that the documents in question were not privileged because they were disclosed in private arbitration and through orders compelling their production. It was held that the actions and submissions of the parties claiming privilege were inconsistent with maintaining the privilege, effectively waiving it. The court also determined that the privilege did not apply to copies of the original documents made for storage purposes. Lastly, the court held that it was not bound by the arbitral tribunal's ruling regarding privilege.

As a result, the court ordered the production of the disputed documents to the opposing party in the Rhodes Proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This precipitated negotiations between Gina and her children which, in August 2006, culminated in a number of parties entering into a deed, referred to in the curial proceedings as the Hope Downs Deed, by which they agreed to settle disputes about the title to the Hope Downs Tenements. The parties to the Hope Downs Deed include HPPL, Gina, HFMF, Bianca, Ginia and Hope. John adopted the Hope Downs Deed in April 2007 by executing the 2007 HD Deed as described in the curial proceedings.[3][3] 2018 Stay Decision [35]. The purported effect of the Hope Downs Deed was that, in consideration for the acknowledgments, releases and undertakings given by the parties to the deed, HPPL and Gina agreed to distributions to Bianca and John provided for in the deed (cl 5). The Hope Downs Deed contains an arbitration clause (cl 20) that provides that any disputes under the Hope Downs Deed shall be resolved by confidential mediation and, if unsuccessful, confidential arbitration. In 2014, prior to the commencement of the Rhodes Proceedings, Bianca and John commenced proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia against, inter alia, the HPPL parties and Gina (Federal Court Proceedings). As part of the Federal Court Proceedings, Bianca and John claimed that the Hope Downs Tenements were held on trust for Gina's children and challenged the validity of the Hope Downs Deed. In the Federal Court Proceedings, Bianca and John were seeking relief from a number of parties, all of whom (except one) was a party to the Hope Downs Deed (in the sense that they were actual parties to the deed or, within the meaning of the Commercial Arbitration Act 2010 (NSW) (the NSW Act), were parties that claimed 'through or under' a party to the deed).[4] [4] The Act, s 2(1). The Full Court of the Federal Court ordered that the Federal Court Proceedings be stayed under s 8(1) of the NSW Act pending referral to arbitration or until further order.[5] The decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in the Federal Court Proceedings was upheld by the High Court.[6][5] Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd v Rinehart [2017] 257 FCR 442 [327] (Full Federal Court Decision).[6] Rinehart v Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 13(HC Decision). Bianca and John's claims in the Federal Court Proceedings were referred to arbitral proceedings constituted before the Honourable Wayne Martin AC KC, Dr Michael Hwang SC and the Honourable Dr Kevin Lindgren AM KC (Martin Arbitration). The Martin Arbitration occurred in three blocks of time between August 2022 and March 2023. The decision in the Martin Arbitration is reserved. In 2016, Le Miere J made an order in each of the curial proceedings that Gina's children be joined as defendants on the basis that their asserted proprietary interest in the Hope Downs Tenements was inconsistent with the interests claimed in the Hope Downs Tenements by not only Gina and the HPPL parties, but also those claimed by WPPL and the Rhodes Parties. Le Miere J held that the joinder of Gina's children to the curial proceedings was necessary to ensure all matters in dispute could be completely determined.[7] The result is that the HPPL Parties, Gina's children and WPPL are defendants in the Rhodes Proceedings. [7] Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd v Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd [No 7] [2016] WASC 305.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.