Dennis Borg and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

[2013] AATA 363 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2009/4702

2011/5281
2012/0278

2012/1209

Re

Dennis Borg

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

J L Redfern, Senior Member
Dr W Isles, Member

Date 31 May 2013
Place Sydney

The decisions under review are affirmed.

....................................[sgd]....................................

J L Redfern, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION - claims for compensation for physiological and psychiatric injury as a result of work duties- whether causal connection between the applicant’s conditions and his employment - consideration of the nature of applicant's physical and mental conditions and when they arose - not satisfied that the applicant sustained a compensable injury under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in respect of the physiological and psychological injuries alleged. Decisions under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 - ss 4, 5B, 7(4), 14, 53

CASES

Von Stieglitz and Comcare [2010] AATA 263

Tsiamis and Comcare [2013] AATA 319
Borg and Australian Postal Corporation [2002] AATA 796
Borg and Australian Postal Corporation [2003] AATA 221
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705

REASONS FOR DECISION

J L Redfern, Senior Member
Dr W Isles, Member

31 May 2013

  1. Mr Dennis Borg joined Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) as a mail officer in 1988, and worked there for over 20 years. He was terminated on 21 May 2009 after extended absences from work. Mr Borg has made a number of applications to this Tribunal for review of decisions made by Australia Post to reject various claims for compensation, four of which are the subject of these proceedings. 

  2. On 21 October 2009, Mr Borg made an application for review in respect of the rejection of his claim for compensation for thoracolumbar back strain and left and right epicondylitis. He made two further applications for review in December 2011 and January 2012; the first in respect of an injury alleged to affect his right shoulder and right elbow as a result of a work-related incident on 18 February 2002 and the second in respect of the claim that the ‘nature and conditions’ of Mr Borg's employment contributed to pain and injuries to his neck, shoulder, elbow and wrists. Mr Borg made a further application for review on 28 March 2012 in respect of the denial of compensation for his claim for paranoid schizophrenia, stress, anxiety and depression.

  3. Australia Post denied liability for Mr Borg's physical conditions on the basis that liability for any injury on 18 February 2002 had ceased on 24 February 2002, as confirmed by a decision of this Tribunal on 7 March 2003, and there was no evidence that other injuries alleged were work-related. Australia Post also denied liability for Mr Borg's psychiatric condition on the grounds the condition was not caused by his employment with Australia Post. At the hearing, Counsel for Australia Post contended that, if Mr Borg’s psychiatric condition was so caused or aggravated, liability was nonetheless excluded on the basis that any injury arose as a result of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dennis Borg and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 363
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Borg and Australian Postal Corporation, Dennis Borg, a former mail officer for Australia Post, brought a claim for compensation for physical and psychiatric injuries sustained during his employment. The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with determining the nature and timing of Mr Borg's conditions, establishing a causal link between these conditions and his employment, and assessing whether any liability was excluded under the applicable legislation. Mr Borg argued that his employment contributed significantly to his physical and mental conditions, which arose from incidents at work, including a burn injury and subsequent anxiety.

The court examined the evidence regarding the timing and nature of Mr Borg's injuries, including his initial burn injury in 1997 and subsequent claims for psychiatric and physical conditions. The court assessed whether these conditions were causally linked to his employment and if such a link existed, whether any statutory exclusions applied. The court found that Mr Borg had not provided sufficient evidence to establish a causal connection between his employment and his alleged conditions. Specifically, the court noted the absence of timely medical reports and the lack of clear evidence linking the claimed conditions to his work activities.

As a result, the court concluded that Mr Borg's claims were not substantiated by sufficient evidence of a causal connection to his employment. Consequently, the court upheld the decisions of Australia Post denying liability for the claimed injuries. The court did not find it necessary to address the issue of potential exclusions under the legislation, as the primary issue of causation was unresolved.

The final orders of the court affirmed the decisions of Australia Post, dismissing Mr Borg's claims for compensation for both physical and psychiatric injuries.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

As such, the issues for determination were:(a)What is the nature of Mr Borg’s physical and mental conditions and when did they arise?(b)Is there a sufficient causal connection between those conditions and Mr Borg's employment with Australia Post within the meaning of the Act?(c)If so, is liability nonetheless excluded?BACKGROUND FACTS Mr Borg is a 53-year-old man who commenced work at Australia Post in 1988 after previously working in factory and warehouse jobs. He worked as a mail officer at various locations within Australia Post. His job was to process the mail and included the task of indexing, which involved observing large letters on a conveyor belt and keying data about the post code into a numeric key pad. On 2 November 1997, Mr Borg was in the kitchen at work preparing his lunch when a can of sardines on the stove nearby exploded, spraying hot oil onto his arm. Mr Borg made a claim for compensation for burns to his arm and for anxiety. Australia Post accepted liability for the burns but initially did not accept the claim for anxiety. Liability was subsequently accepted until 4 May 1998, after which time it was declined following a report from Dr Leonard Lee, psychiatrist. Mr Borg sought reconsideration of this decision but was unsuccessful. He complained about what he considered to be an unsatisfactory response by Australia Post in investigating the circumstances of the exploding can. His complaint was rejected by the Australia Post Board of Reference but Mr Borg continued with his complaints regarding the accident and in September 1998 Mr Borg was referred to psychologist, Mr Peter Jones, for assessment. Mr Borg made a claim for compensation on 21 January 2001 arising out of the incident in November 1997. This claim was denied by Australia Post. One of the issues raised by Mr Borg was the failure of Australia Post to disclose the report of Mr Jones to him. Mr Borg applied to this Tribunal for a review of the decision to deny liability for his claim. The report of Mr Jones was disclosed to Mr Borg as a consequence of the Tribunal ordering access. The Tribunal considered the matter but ultimately dismissed the application for want of jurisdiction on the basis that Mr Borg's claim had not properly been made in accordance with section 54 of the Act as there was no accompanying certificate from a qualified medical practitioner (Borg and Australian Postal Corporation [2002] AATA 796 (the 2002 Borg proceedings)). However, it is relevant to note that the Tribunal nonetheless concluded that even if it had jurisdiction to determine the merits of the case, it would have concluded that Mr Borg’s case would have failed as there was insufficient evidence of a psychiatric condition. Mr Borg made another claim for compensation in respect of an injury suffered on 18 February 2002, which was accepted until 24 February 2002, after which time Mr Borg returned to work on normal duties. Mr Borg made a claim for compensation for pain in his right shoulder, upper arm and elbow for incapacity beyond 24 February 2002. This issue was considered by this Tribunal, which accepted the injury was work-related but found that Mr Borg's musculoligamentous pain in his right elbow, arm and shoulder ceased as an injury on 24 February 2002. The Tribunal affirmed the decision of Australia Post on 7 March 2003 (Borg and Australian Postal Corporation [2003] AATA 221 (the 2003 Borg proceedings)).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

We are therefore not satisfied that there is sufficient probative evidence that the psychiatric conditions of in respect of which Mr Borg has been diagnosed, or indeed any aggravation of these conditions, were contributed to in a significant degree by his employment with Australia Post As such, we are not satisfied that Mr Borg has sustained a compensable injury under s 14 of the Act in respect of injuries alleged. This being the case, it is not necessary for us to consider whether liability for these conditions was excluded on the basis that they resulted from reasonable disciplinary action or reasonable administrative action. CONCLUSION Having regard to our findings that Mr Borg did not sustain a compensable injury under the Act, the decisions of Australia Post are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Borg provided the certificates in February and March 2008 from Dr Paleologos that led to Mr Borg's extended leave until November 2008. From 3 March until 20 May 2009, Mr Borg’s extended absences from work are described as “unauthorised”. He worked approximately two and a half weeks during this period.Consideration and Findings As previously noted, to assess whether Mr Borg’s physical conditions are casually connected to his employment we must identify which test applies. This requires us to consider when Mr Borg’s conditions arose. The earliest injuries alleged by Mr Borg are, in effect, ‘nature and conditions’ claims from 2002 for pain to his back, neck, shoulders and joints. These claims were lodged on 4 August and 18 October 2011. There is evidence that Mr Borg sought treatment for these conditions from 2002 until about mid-2005 and that he took time off work from time to time, citing these ailments as the cause for his absence. Mr Borg did not make any claim at this time for these absences. Section 53 of the Act provides that an employee must give notice in writing of an injury as soon as practicable after the employee becomes aware of the injury. Mr Borg contended that he kept lodging incident reports with Australia Post and that this was sufficient. Australia Post does not press any argument about this, however, we note that this delay makes Mr Borg’s claims difficult to assess given the time that has passed. It is relevant to note there is no evidence that Mr Borg took time off work in respect of these alleged conditions from about mid 2005 until his claim in early 2008. Mr Borg was self-represented and did not clearly articulate the basis for his second and third claims. Nonetheless we infer that Mr Borg’s claim is for an aggravation of the injury he allegedly sustained in February 2002 or, in the alternative, an aggravation of the pre-existing degenerative changes in his lower back and cervical spine. Given the date of the injury alleged, we must be satisfied that Mr Borg’s condition in respect of these claims was contributed to in a material degree by his employment. Mr Borg’s further claim in November 2008 was for strain to his lower back and epicondylitis. The certificates from Dr Paleologos diagnose a lumbar strain and refer to pre-existing injuries said to have been sustained two years previously. Notwithstanding this reference to “two years”, there is no evidence that Mr Borg took time off work in relation to these conditions in 2006 and 2007. We therefore find that the date of any injury or aggravation for this claim was after 13 April 2007. Given the later date of the injury alleged, we must be satisfied that Mr Borg’s condition in respect of this claim was contributed to in a significant degree by his employment. Having regard to all of the evidence, we are not satisfied that the physical conditions alleged by Mr Borg to his joints, shoulder, back and neck are causally connected to Mr Borg’s employment to a material, degree in respect of the earlier claims, or to a significant degree, in respect of the later claim.