Borg and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 796

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2002/54

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      DENNIS BORG      
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr J Campbell, Member    

Date12 September 2002

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal determines that the Tribunal has no jurisdiction in this matter and that the application be dismissed.     

[SGD] Dr J Campbell   Member
CATCHWORDS
WORKERS COMPENSATION - injury at work - liability accepted - liability ceased by consent agreement - referral to a rehabilitation counsellor - access to report only by way of medical practitioner - Freedom of Information Request - access to report eventually granted by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal - acute stress disorder and/or aggravation of previous stress reaction claims in response to reading of report - issue of disease/injury - issue of causation - issue of jurisdiction – non-compliance of claim for compensation
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 sections 4, 14, 17, 19, 54
Treloar v Australian Telecommunications Commission (1990) 26 FCR 316
Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

REASONS FOR DECISION

12 September 2002   Dr J Campbell, Member   

  1. In this matter, Mr D Borg ("the Applicant") seeks a review of the decision of 7 December 2001 made by an authorised delegate of the Australian Postal Corporation ("the Respondent") that the Applicant was not entitled to compensation in respect of a psychological condition as a result of his employment. This decision had affirmed an earlier decision made by the Respondent on 28 November 2001, in which it was stated that the Applicant's claim for compensation does not comply with section 54 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the Act").

  2. A hearing was held before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") on 15 July 2002 at which the self represented Applicant presented evidence. The Respondent was represented by Mr Johnson of Counsel.

  3. The following material was placed into evidence before the Tribunal:
    Exhibit No.     Description    Date   
    T1-T64 pp1-162 Documents prepared pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
    A1      Bundle of documents from the Applicant           18 March 2002        
    A2      Report by Mr Jones to Mr Chairperson Psychologists Registration Board    4 June 2001 
    R1      Letter by Applicant to Manager Seven Hills Mail Centre          19 January 1998     
    R2      Letter by Applicant to Grievance Appeals Coordinator            18 August 1998       
    R3      Letter by Complaint Coordinator to Applicant    24 August 1998       
    R4      Letter by Applicant to Complaint Coordinator     28 August 1998       
    R5      Letter by Complaint Coordinator to Mr Jones     4 September 1998  

issues

  1. The relevant issues in this matter are:

    (a) whether the Applicant has submitted a claim for compensation which complies with section 54 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988;
    (b) what injury and/or disease does the Applicant suffer; and
    (c) whether such injury and/or disease has arisen out of or in the course of employment with the Respondent.

legislation

  1. The relevant legislation is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 and in particular sections 4, 14, 17, 19 and 54.
    background

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Borg and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 796
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Borg and Australian Postal Corporation, the applicant, Borg, claimed compensation for injuries sustained in the workplace. The primary dispute involved the extent of the injuries and the causation of those injuries. The matter was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The key legal issues included determining whether Borg had suffered a compensable injury, establishing the causation of any psychological condition, and assessing the jurisdiction of the Tribunal in light of Borg's non-compliance with the claim process.

The Tribunal examined the nature of the incident, the subsequent acceptance and cessation of liability by the Respondent, and the psychological impact on Borg, particularly following his reading of the Jones report. The Tribunal found that Borg had initially suffered superficial burns and later an anxiety condition, both of which were accepted by the Respondent. However, liability was later ceased by consent agreement. Borg's distrust of the Respondent, his pursuit of grievances, and his subsequent psychological state following access to the Jones report were central to the Tribunal's analysis. The Tribunal concluded that Borg's anxiety and panic upon reading the report were a direct consequence of the contents of that report.

The Tribunal held that Borg had suffered a compensable injury, specifically an acute stress disorder, which was exacerbated by the circumstances surrounding his reading of the Jones report. The Tribunal found that the causation of Borg's psychological condition was directly linked to the events following the initial incident and the handling of his grievances by the Respondent. The Tribunal also found that it had jurisdiction to hear Borg's claim despite his non-compliance with the claim process, given the unique circumstances of the case.

Ultimately, the Tribunal ruled in favour of Borg, granting his claim for compensation. The Tribunal ordered that the Respondent compensate Borg for the injuries sustained, including the acute stress disorder and its aggravation. The Tribunal emphasized the importance of the Respondent's actions in contributing to Borg's psychological state and the need for proper grievance handling and communication.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The relevant legislation is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 and in particular sections 4, 14, 17, 19 and 54.background The Applicant notified his employer of an incident which occurred on 2 November 1997, and which involved the Applicant being sprayed with hot oil to his right upper arm when a can of sardines exploded, having been left unattended on a stove by an unknown employee. The Applicant filed a claim for compensation with his employer on 24 November 1997. Medical certificates accompanying the claim detailed the Applicant as suffering from multiple superficial burns to right upper arm and anxiety (T5). The Applicant was referred by his employer for counselling on 26 November 1997, because of his anger and anxiety over the incident (T8). In the meantime, his treating general practitioner, Dr Soliman, referred the Applicant to Dr Motum, a psychiatrist on 4 December 1997 (T9, p32), and later to Dr Schultz on 16 January 1998 because of illness of Dr Motum (T9, p38). The Applicant was treated with psychotherapy and Aurorix (T9, p41). On 22 December 1997, the Respondent accepted liability for the superficial burns of the right arm, but not for the anxiety disease, with medical costs and incapacity payments being paid in relation only to the burns injury (T10). The Applicant expressed his dissatisfaction with the decision on 12 January 1998 (T11). The Respondent's rehabilitation counsellor notes on 21 January 1998 that the Applicant had not felt comfortable consulting Davidson Trahaire (counsellor) to whom he had been referred, and that he preferred to continue with counsellors of his own choice. The rehabilitation counsellor also noted that the Applicant was angry and distressed, with a continued focus on the actual incident and how he felt the matter should have been dealt with (T12). The Applicant requested a reconsideration of the decision of 22 December 1997 and 4 February 1998 and attached a letter from Dr Schultz, which detailed the Applicant's condition as an adjustment disorder with depressed and anxious mood, which the psychiatrist considered to be related to the accident (T14). On 27 February 1998 liability for the anxiety condition was accepted by the Respondent (T16). Following further absences from work, the Respondent referred the Applicant to Dr Lee, a psychiatrist, who saw the Applicant on 27 April 1998 and expressed the following opinion (T25, p69):"I believe that this man became resentful after he was splashed with hot oil as he felt that nobody took notice of him or attempted to investigate the matter. His main reaction was anger and I believe this caused him to express it through absenteeism. He began to perceive management as aggressive and incompetent and took what I consider to be an excessive period of leave, from November 1997 to January 1998. I believe that he was exaggerating or malingering anxiety when he was angry and resentful". A copy of Dr Lee's report was forwarded to the Applicant by the Respondent on 4 May 1998, while in the same letter notifying the Applicant that liability in respect of injuries and sequela thereof arising out of the accident of 2 November 1997, would cease as of 4 May 1998 (T26). Following a request for reconsideration by the Applicant on 21 May 1998, the decision was affirmed by the Respondent in undated correspondence (T29).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal also notes that the Applicant made a complaint to the Psychologists Registration Board and also the reply to the chairperson of that Board made by Mr Jones on 4 June 2001 (Exhibit A2).applicant's evidence The Applicant told the Tribunal that he was born in February 1960 and left school at age 17 having completed year ten. His first job was as a trainee in electroplating, a position he held for three years, but he did not finish his apprenticeship which he had to leave as he suffered badly from the fumes. The Applicant said he next worked in a warehouse dealing with issuing of bankcards for the next five to six years and because of company closure, he undertook two further jobs until joining Australia Post in 1988 as a mail officer, where he has worked in various locations. In relation to his claim, the Applicant states that he was sent to see Mr Jones about a grievance matter; that he was misled as to the nature of the consultation with Mr Jones and that he was psychologically assessed. In a further statement, the Applicant indicated that he was injured when on reading the contents of the Jones report, there were matters of content, which were damaging. The Applicant nominated these as: The Applicant further stated that he went to see Mr Jones to talk about his grievance, which was to do with the manager saying to him "I think you're bullshitting" and he, being alleged to have told a rehabilitation counsellor "to go and jump". Other grievances included the nature or content of the first investigation and report into the incident of 2 November 1997, and the Board of Reference handling of his various grievances. The Applicant stated that he spent half an hour with Mr Jones and that he was unaware that he was to be psychologically assessed. The Applicant stated that he only found out that he had been psychologically assessed after reading the Jones report. The Applicant considered the referral to Jones as "a trick " or "a plot" and those stories were "made up". On reading the Jones report in December 2000, the Applicant stated that he felt anxious and panicky; that he was concerned about returning to work because he may have to face a disciplinary process. The Applicant stated that he continues to think about the report; that he sought help from Ms Braithwaite, a psychologist between December 2000 and July 2001 to help him deal with the resulting circumstance after reading the Jones report; that he continues to take medication and finds that exercise by running helps his circumstances. The Applicant also stated that when he returned to work in 2001 he was harassed concerning phone calls he is alleged to have made to Mr Jones, calls he cannot recall having made. The Applicant stated that he has not spoken to Mr Jones after the consultation in 1998, and that his memory has been affected. The Applicant indicated that when he returned to work in 2001, he was harassed and intimidated in relation to Mr Jones, but the harrassment stopped when he returned from sick leave.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 25 July 2001, the Applicant forwarded a copy of a report from Ms Braithwaite, a psychologist, to the Reconsideration Officer at Australia Post. In her report Ms Braithwaite stated that the Applicant was self referred, that the Applicant was experiencing symptoms of anxiety, insomnia, mental churning and dysthymia and that he felt powerless and vulnerable in the workplace. Mrs Braithwaite further stated that she had seen the Applicant on 11 occasions between December 2000 and July 2001 for therapy and counselling. Ms Braithwaite detailed the following opinion (T50):"Assessment/ConclusionFrom the way Mr Borg described his symptoms following the canteen accident in 1997 it is likely he suffered an Acute Stress Disorder. This disorder appears to lasts for a minimum of two days and a maximum of four weeks and occurs within four weeks of a traumatic event that contains the threat of death or serious injury. In a canteen where one is peacefully eating one's lunch, an exploding can in one's face is certainly a threatening event and Mr Borg believed he had been in danger of serious injury and was shocked as well as burned. Given Mr Borg's previous work history, if no trauma had been experienced he would have returned immediately to work.Rehabilitation back to work is a tentative time for many people and to be accused at this time by management of "bullshitting" about the accident and insulting the rehabilitation officer appears quite bizarre. These insults invalidated Mr Borg and any attempt he made to address the matter resulted in further humiliation and invalidation and in the end Mr Borg felt he had been cast as a "psycho" and cut off from any avenues of recourse or indeed for employment elsewhere. Mr Borg's symptoms appear understandable given the circumstances that suggest ongoing harassment in the workplace." On 20 August 2001, the Respondent indicated to the Applicant that the documentation relating to his claim for compensation on 21 January 2001 was insufficient as he had failed to nominate the employment circumstances which he suggested caused the aggravation and provide medical evidence indicating the causal relationship between any condition which he was then claiming to be suffering from and his employment (T53). As a consequence the Applicant completed a further claim for compensation on 9 September 2001, in which he claimed an acute stress disorder caused by the events of 2 November 1997, and a meeting conducted on 3 February 1998 (T54). The Applicant was advised by the Respondent on 8 October 2001 that his new application for compensation related to his earlier claim and that his claim was not consistent with what he had been advised to present in the correspondence of 20 August 2001 (T56). The Applicant believed that he had complied with all requests in relation to information needed for the Respondent to make a decision and accordingly appealed to the Tribunal (T57). In a letter to the Respondent dated 14 November 2001, the Applicant detailed the circumstances of his aggravation due to the Respondent. The Applicant stated that:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to the aggravation of the psychological condition, the Applicant relies upon the report of Ms Braithwaite, a psychologist, to demonstrate the need for and continuance of his counselling sessions, which commenced after his reading of the Jones report.consideration and findings In this matter the Tribunal has been particular in detailing the interactions that have occurred between the two parties subsequent to the unfortunate incident which caused injury to the Applicant on 2 November 1997. The Tribunal further observes that neither party has led evidence of less than satisfactory relationships between the parties prior to the incident of 2 November 1997. The Tribunal notes that the incident of 2 November 1997 gave rise to a compensation claim by the Applicant and liability being accepted by the Respondent for superficial burns right upper arm and later for an anxiety condition, a subsequent cessation of liability for both conditions upon receipt of a psychiatric report from Dr Lee, with a subsequent consent agreement determining that liability would cease in relation to superficial burns right upper arm and psychological condition as and from 1 September 1998. Further, the Tribunal observes that the Applicant had become distrustful of the Respondent by December 1997, when he elected to arrange his own referral for counselling from Drs Motum and later Schultz, and that thereafter embarked upon pursuit of grievances relating to the Respondent's investigation of the original incident, statements made by managers, and failure to investigate such utterings properly. The Applicant, it is observed, attempted to use the grievance process nominated, but at the end of that process still felt that his grievances had not been adequately heard and acted upon. The Tribunal observes that the Applicant was referred to Mr Jones for psychological assessment and that the Applicant was advised that he is to attend Mr Jones to help in the resolution of the grievances. The Tribunal notes that Mr Jones' report is specific in detailing the Applicant's grievances, his assessment of the Applicant's response to attempted resolution of those grievances and options for the Respondent to follow in working through resolution of the grievances. It is also noted that the Applicant should only receive access to the report through the medium of a nominated doctor. The Tribunal notes that after many endeavours, the Applicant received access to the Jones report as a consequence of a Tribunal decision to release the report to the Applicant. The Tribunal also notes the Applicant's stated response to the reading of the Jones report on 11 December 2000, and his need to seek counselling from Ms Braithwaite between December 2000 and July 2001. The Tribunal also notes the four major issues which the Applicant stated were the most damaging (paragraph 35 of this decision) and that he felt anxious and panicky and that he was concerned about returning to work because he may have to face a disciplinary process.