Delisio v Santoro No. Scciv-00-790

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

DELISIO & ORS v SANTORO

[2002] SASC 65

Civil

  1. BESANKO J:  The plaintiffs and counterclaimant have each issued an application under Section 7 of the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act 1972 (“the Act”) for an order that provision be made out of the estate of the late Max Hess.

    Introduction

  2. Max Hess was born on 15 April 1915.  He married Martha Hildegart Frank who was born on 9 July 1917.  They had nine children, four girls and five boys.  The four girls are Monika born on 3 January 1950, Margaret born on 14 May 1955, Angelika born on 5 June 1956 and Beate born on 20 November 1957.  One of the sons, Wolfgang, was born on 11 February 1951.

  3. Martha Hess died in 1988.

  4. Max Hess died on 14 August 1999.  Max Hess made a will on 30 January 1997.  I will refer to Max Hess as the testator, and for convenience and without any disrespect, I will use the christian names of the other parties and members of their families.

  5. By his will the testator left all his property, after the payment of funeral and testamentary expenses and debts, to his daughter Beate.  Beate was also appointed the executor and trustee of the will.

  6. The estate of the testator consists of various items of real and personal property.  There is a dispute about whether a caravan paid for by the testator forms part of his estate.  For reasons I will give, I have concluded that before he died the testator gave the caravan to Beate’s daughter, Cynthia.

  7. A statement of assets and liabilities values the net estate excluding the caravan at $149,432.18.  An affidavit of Beate sworn in her capacity as executor of the estate on 5 November 2001 was received without objection at the commencement of the trial in November 2001.  It provides a valuation of the estate as at the date of the affidavit.  The net value of the estate excluding the caravan is said to be $206,730.65.  I was invited to proceed on the basis that Beate’s statements as to the value of the estate are correct.

  8. Probate of the will was granted to Beate on 25 February 2000.

  9. On 23 August 2000, Margaret, Monika and Angelika issued an application seeking provision out of the estate under s 7 of the Act. That section provides as follows:

    “7     (1)    Where –

    (a)     a person has died domiciled in the State or owning real or personal property in the State;

    and

    (b)    by reason of his testamentary dispositions or the operation of the laws of intestacy or both, a person entitled to claim the benefit of this Act is left without adequate provision for his proper maintenance, education or advancement in life,

    the Court may in its discretion, upon application by or on behalf of a person so entitled, order that such provision as the Court thinks fit be made out of the estate of the deceased person for the maintenance, education or advancement of the person so…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Delisio v Santoro No. Scciv-00-790 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Delisio v Santoro No. Scciv-00-790, the court was tasked with resolving disputes related to the estate of a deceased individual, who had lived in a shed on his property. The primary parties involved were the testator, who resided in the shed, and Beate, one of the testator's children. The nature of the dispute centred on the validity of the testator's will and the claims of the children under the Family Provision Act. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The legal issues before the court included whether the testator's will was valid and if the children had a legitimate claim against the estate under the Family Provision Act. The court had to consider the circumstances surrounding the testator's living arrangements, the contributions made by the children to the family business and the overall estate, and the testator's intentions as expressed in his will. The court also needed to assess if Beate or any other claimant had engaged in conduct that would disentitle them from making a claim under the Act.

In its reasoning, the court examined the evidence presented regarding the testator's living arrangements and the contributions made by the children. It was determined that the testator's decision to live in the shed was likely his own, and this did not impact the validity of his will. The court also found that the market garden business was a substantial commercial venture, and the children had indeed contributed to it. The court concluded that Beate's claim was not barred by any disentitling conduct, and she was entitled to a reasonable provision from the estate. The court awarded her a specific sum from the estate, reflecting her contributions and needs.

The final orders included a determination that the will was valid and that Beate was entitled to a specified amount from the estate, reflecting her contributions and needs. The court directed the parties to prepare minutes of order embodying the orders made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The other matter to note at this stage is that, as is common in cases of this nature, there was a great deal of evidence about various incidents and events involving the testator and his children. Evidence was given expressing views as to who was in the right and who was in the wrong. Beate did not suggest that any of the claimants were guilty of “disentitling” conduct within s 7(3) of the Act. In many cases, it is not possible for me to make findings as to the rights and wrongs of certain behaviour. Even if it was, I do not think such findings are critical to the determination of the applications. I take various pieces of conduct and behaviour to which I refer, into account in a general way but I do not think that any of the conduct is of sufficient import to affect the outcome of the applications.Background Facts There are certain facts which are not in dispute and which formed the background to the detailed evidence given by the various witnesses. As I have said, the testator was born on 15 April 1915, and his wife, Martha, was born on 9 July 1917. The testator and his family came to Australia from Germany in 1963 or 1964. There was some conflict in the evidence as to whether it was 1963 or 1964, but I do not think the precise year matters for present purposes. Shortly after arriving in Australia, the family settled on a property at 11 Tolley Road, Hope Valley in the State of South Australia (“the Tolley Road property”). At that time the Tolley Road property consisted of three blocks. Many years later, one of the blocks was sold to Beate’s husband, and when Beate and her husband divorced it was given to Beate as part of a property settlement. She later sold the block. In 1964 there was a house on the middle block, and a glass-house at the back of that block. The testator built a large shed on one of the other blocks. The third block was vacant. The testator obtained employment as a spray painter. He also established a market garden business on the Tolley Road property. He grew cucumbers, flowers, tomatoes and other plants and vegetables in the glass-house, and mushrooms in the large shed. He grew strawberries on the vacant third block. The testator’s children helped in the business. I am not able to make a finding as to the profitability or otherwise of the market garden business. I find that it was a commercial venture and a reasonably substantial operation, and to the extent that Beate’s evidence suggests otherwise, I reject such evidence. The testator worked as a spray painter and in the market garden business for many years. Precisely when he retired was not made clear by the evidence. Martha had employment outside the family home. The evidence is not clear as to what employment she had although it appears that for a time she worked in a restaurant. At some stage, the testator started living in the shed. He came inside for his meals. Martha cooked for him and washed his clothes. When this arrangement commenced was not made clear in the evidence, but it had been the arrangement for a considerable time before Martha became ill in about 1981. I find that the decision to live in the shed was probably made by the testator, or at least (and I believe this is less likely) it was a joint decision made by the testator and Martha. All the evidence suggested that the testator was not the type of man who would have readily succumbed to the wishes of others. I reject Beate’s evidence to the effect that the testator was required by his family to sleep in the shed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will hear the parties on costs and any other relevant orders or matters. I will direct the parties to prepare minutes of order embodying the orders to be made.JUDGMENT CITATIONSLISTED IN ORDER OF APPEARANCE IN JUDGMENT1.Corin v Patton (1990) 169 CLR 540 per Mason CJ and McHugh J at 5582.(1969) 120 CLR 3653.[1944] SASR 2574.Flinn v White [1950] SASR 195; Commercial and Personal Property Law S Fisher at para [11.23] et seq.5.Family Provision in Australia 2nd ed de Groot & Nickel para [5.11]6.In the Estate of Barry (1974) 9 SASR 4397.Jones v G D Searle & Co Ltd [1978] 3 All ER 6548.Attorney General (NT) v Maurice (1986) 161 CLR 475 per Gibbs CJ at 4819.Thomason v the Council of the Municipality of Campbelltown (1939) 39 SR (NSW) 347 per Street CJ at 35910.Cross on Evidence 6th Australian Edition J D Heydon para (25010)11.(1997) 70 SASR 16612.Singer v Berghouse (1994) 181 CLR 201 per Mason CJ, Deane and McHugh JJ at 20813.In re McCaffrey (1982) 29 SASR 582 per Cox J at 58514.White v Barron (1980) 144 CLR 431 per Mason J at 44115.Singer v Berghouse per Mason CJ, Deane and McHugh JJ at 209; Goodman v Windeyer (1980) 144 CLR 490 per Murphy J at 504 – 505; Burke v Public Trustee (1997) 69 SASR 557 per Debelle J at 56016.Singer v Berghouse per Mason CJ, Deane & McHugh JJ at 21017.Hughes v National Trustees, Executors and Agency Co of Australasia Limited (1979) 143 CLR 134 per Gibbs J at 14618.Pontifical Society for the Propagation of the Faith v Scales (1962) 107 CLR 9 per Dixon CJ at 2019.(1979) 143 CLR 134 per Gibbs CJ at 147. See Hunter v Hunter (1987) 8 NSWLR 573; Gorton v Parks (1989) 17 NSWLR 1; Hawkins v Prestage (1989) 1 WAR 3720.Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 395 at 40321.at 14722.Authority in this State suggests that it is no longer appropriate to refer to a special need or special claim see Eckert v Starick (unreported judgment of the Full Court 15 June 1984 S4584) Lambeff v Farmers Cooperative Executors and Trustees Limited & Ors (1991) 56 SASR 323 per Matheson J at 32823.Re Sinnot [1948] VLR 279. As to whether there should be any difference in approach between an adult daughter and an adult son see In Re Anderson (1975) 11 SASR 276 and In the Estate of Vitch (1988) 147 LSJS 14324.Blore v Lang (1960) 104 CLR 124 per Fullagar and Menzies JJ at 13525.Singer v Berghouse Mason ACJ Dean and McHugh JJ at 210

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.