Deckers Outdoor Corporation v Luda Production Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc to registration of trade mark applications            1013798 (25) - UGG AUSTRALIA label

1013806 (25) – MADE BY UGG AUSTRALIA

1013807 (25) – MADE BY UGG AUSTRALIA label

all filed in the name of Luda Production Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Alison Windsor
Representation: Opponent:  Sam Ricketson of counsel, instructed by Middletons Lawyers
Applicant:  Celia Davies of Freehills Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys
Decision: 2010 ATMO 88
S52 opposition:  Grounds pressed under ss 42(b), 43, 44, 58, 58A, 60 and 62A.  No grounds established – applications to proceed to registration – costs awarded against opponent.

Background

  1. On 2 August 2004, Luda Production Pty Ltd (‘the applicant’) filed applications to register three trade marks in class 25.  The trade marks are as follows:

1013798

1013806

MADE BY UGG AUSTRALIA

1013807

  1. The applications were examined as required by section 31 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’), and all three attracted grounds for rejection under sections 41 and 44.  The applicant provided evidence of use in support of the applications, resulting in application 1013798 being accepted for possible registration under the provisions of subsections 41(5), 44(4) and paragraph 44(3)(b).[1]  Applications 1013806 and 1013807 were accepted pursuant to the provisions of both subsections 41(5) and 44(4).

    [1] The 44(3)(b) matter related to the presence in the trade mark of the Advance Australia logo subject of trade mark registration 451318.  The trade mark was subsequently amended to remove the logo.

  2. All three applications were eventually advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 6 September 2007.  Each application was accepted for the following goods in class 25:  ‘footware (sic) being sheepskin boots and headgear’.

  3. After being granted an extension of time for the purpose, on 7 January 2008 Deckers Outdoor Corporation Inc (‘the opponent’) filed notice of opposition to registration of the three applications. 

  4. Evidence in support, in answer and in reply were filed in due course.  Both parties then requested to be heard.  The matter was set down for hearing in Melbourne on 9 June 2010. 

  5. However, on 28 May 2010 the applicant filed and served an application for permission to adduce further evidence.  The evidence, which consisted of a single declaration without any exhibits, accompanied the application.  Because the hearing itself was imminent, and as neither party had any objections, it was decided to deal with the application on the day of the hearing, prior to hearing the substantive matter.

  6. The parties appeared before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Melbourne on the appointed day.  The opponent was represented by Sam Ricketson of counsel instructed by Middletons Lawyers.  The applicant was represented by Celia Davies, a partner of Freehills Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys.

    Notice of opposition, grounds of opposition pursued and onus

  7. The notice of opposition nominated fourteen grounds of opposition, effectively encompassing all grounds provided for by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deckers Outdoor Corporation v Luda Production Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ATMO 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Hearing Officer Alison Windsor concerning an opposition by Deckers Outdoor Corporation to three trade mark applications by Luda Production Pty Ltd. The dispute centred on the use and registration of trade marks featuring the words "UGG AUSTRALIA" in relation to sheepskin footwear. Deckers, as the opponent, sought to prevent Luda Production from registering its marks, alleging prior use and potential confusion in the marketplace.

The primary legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether Deckers had established grounds for opposing Luda Production's trade mark applications. Specifically, the Hearing Officer had to consider the evidence presented by both parties regarding the history of use of the "UGG AUSTRALIA" trade mark, the distinctiveness of the mark, and whether Luda Production's proposed registrations would be likely to deceive or cause confusion among consumers, given Deckers' asserted prior and extensive use of similar marks.

The Hearing Officer considered evidence from both parties, including declarations from Brian Smith (representing Deckers' predecessor in title) detailing the development and sale of "UGG" branded sheepskin footwear in the United States since the late 1970s, and registrations of "Ugg Australia" trade marks in the US from 1987. Luda Production's evidence, through Lena Fishman, outlined the establishment of their business in Australia around 1981, manufacturing and selling sheepskin products under the "Luda Textiles Co" name and later as Luda Production Pty Ltd. The Hearing Officer found that the opponent, Deckers, had not established any of the grounds of opposition relied upon.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer ordered that the three trade mark applications by Luda Production Pty Ltd could proceed to registration after one month from the date of the decision, unless an appeal was filed. Costs were ordered against the opponent, Deckers Outdoor Corporation, according to the official scale.

Background

Background to the litigation

Deckers Outdoor Corporation, the applicant, applied for the registration of trade marks for the word 'UGG', 'UGG AUSTRALIA' and 'UGG' in a stylised form. Luda Production Pty Ltd, the opponent, opposed the applications on the basis that the trade marks were deceptively similar to its own trade marks and that the applicant had knowledge of the opponent's trade marks at the time of filing the applications. Deckers Outdoor Corporation is a company based in the United States and its business involves the design, manufacture and sale of sheepskin footwear, among other products. Luda Production Pty Ltd is an Australian company which, through its predecessor Luda Textiles Co, has been manufacturing and selling sheepskin products since 1981. In 1995, Luda Textiles Co sold its sheepskin footwear business to Brian Smith, who incorporated a series of businesses under the name 'UGG' in the United States. In 2003, Deckers Outdoor Corporation acquired the 'UGG' business from Brian Smith. Deckers Outdoor Corporation claims that it has been using the trade marks in question since 1995 and that it was unaware of the opponent's trade marks at that time. The opponent, on the other hand, asserts that it has been using the words 'Ugg Australia' since the early 1980s and that Deckers Outdoor Corporation was aware of its trade marks when it began using the marks in question.

Deckers Outdoor Corporation v Luda Production Pty Ltd originated as an opposition to the registration of trade marks filed by Deckers Outdoor Corporation (the Applicant) in the Trade Marks Registry. The opponent, Luda Production Pty Ltd, filed oppositions to the registration of three trade marks: 1013798, 1013806, and 1013807. The matter came before the court as a result of the oppositions filed by the opponent. This was not the first instance hearing; rather, it was a subsequent proceeding following the examination process and oppositions. Prior to this hearing, the Trade Marks Registry had already considered the applications, and the opponent had filed oppositions challenging the Applicant's right to register the trade marks. During the hearing, the court received and considered further evidence, including a second declaration by Lena Fishman and declarations by Brian Smith. These declarations provided detailed histories and sales figures relating to the use of the trade mark "UGG" and "Ugg Australia" in the sheepskin footwear business. The court also considered the chronologies provided by Lisa Egan, a senior associate of the law firm representing the opponent. The procedural steps included submissions on the application for further evidence, which was allowed without objections, and the consideration of all provided evidence in reaching the final decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the beginning of the hearing, I advised both parties that I would take submissions in relation to the application for further evidence. The opponent stated that it had no objections to the evidence being allowed as it consisted of material which served to clarify previously provided evidence and was not anything new. The further evidence therefore forms part of the material I have considered. It consists of a second declaration by Lena Fishman, dated 28 May 2010 (Lena 2).The opponent’s evidence – the Smith declarations In his two declarations, Brian Smith provides a history of the development of trade marks featuring the word ‘UGG’ used in his sheepskin footwear business from approximately 1979 up to the time he sold it to the opponent in 1995. At paragraph 2 of his first declaration, Mr Smith says the following:In the late 1970s I emigrated from Australia to the United States. No later than 1979 I began selling sheepskin boots imported from Australian in the United States using the trade mark UGG. I ran my sheepskin footwear business continuously from no later than 1979 until 1995. During that period my business was organised under various names including UGG Imports, Inc., UGG America, Inc., UGG International, Inc., and UGG Holdings, Inc., and also included various different partners and ownership. He says that from no later than 1983, he began using a stylized trade mark which prominently included the words ‘Ugg Australia’ and which was attached to the footwear in Australia before being exported to Mr Smith in the USA. A copy of this trade mark appears below:(‘the opponent’s first logo mark’) Mr Smith registered this trade mark with the United States Patent and Trade Marks Office under registration 1460992, with a priority date of 13 October 1987. The trade mark was registered for the following goods in class 25: ‘Footwear, namely boots made of sheepskin’. The registration notes 1983 as the date of first use in the United States. The Smith 1 declaration states that the stylised representation of the trade mark used in the business was modified over time. The opponent’s first logo mark was used ‘from no later than the mid 1980s through no later than 1991 when the stylized presentation of UGG AUSTRALIA was modified’. The modified form which Mr Smith states his business began to use no later than 1991 and which was still in use when the opponent bought the business is shown below:(‘the opponent’s second logo mark’) The Smith 2 declaration contains estimated annual sales figures for the business for the years 1989 to 1995. These figures are impressive, showing a doubling of already significant sales value between the years 1994 and 1995. Mr Smith estimates that he sold over half a million pairs of footwear over the period covered by the sales figures. He expresses his belief that over the period (from the mid 1980s to 1995) his business was one of the largest sellers of sheepskin footwear in the world. Most of this footwear was made in Australia, and Mr Smith states his belief that his UGG AUSTRALIA branded footwear was known within the sheepskin footwear trade in Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I find that the opponent has not established this ground of opposition.Decision The opponent has not established any of the grounds of opposition nominated on the Notice. The three applications – 1013798, 1013806 and 1013807 - may proceed to registration after one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, the registrations shall not occur until the appeal has been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, that the applications be subject to that order. Costs Costs usually follow the event, and there is nothing before me to suggest that the general rule should be varied in this case. Therefore I order costs against the opponent according to the official scale, with costs for the second and third of the three oppositions to be assessed as set out in the table attached to the Hearing Officer’s decision in James Hardie & Co Pty Ltd v Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad (2001) 53 IPR 591.Alison WindsorHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings20 September 2010

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

“Decker’s UGG AUSTRALIA trade mark is widely known in the footwear trade in America and other countries around the world”, Ms Rishwain says. She states that sales for the brand in 2007 were over AUD$300 million. She also states that the opponent spends several million dollars every year to promote the brand worldwide. The Egan declarations Lisa Egan is a senior associate of Middletons, the law firm representing the opponent in this opposition. The Egan 1 declaration provides as its exhibits chronologies of the claimed use by both opponent and applicant of the words ‘Ugg Australia’. As references for the chronologies, Ms Egan stated that she has read the opponent’s evidence in support, as well as two declarations made by Lena Fishman, dated respectively 11 August 2006 and 18 May 2007. These two declarations were provided by the applicant in support of its applications during the examination process. The two earlier Fishman declarations have not been served and filed as evidence in support of this opposition. However, given that it is the opponent who is referring to the information contained in them, it stands to reason that both parties are familiar with the content. I will therefore include their contents in making my decision. The chronologies which Ms Egan has provided claim that the opponent (or its predecessor in title, Brian Smith) has used the words ‘Ugg Australia’ on its sheepskin products since the early 1980s, while the applicant has used them only since the early 1990s. The second Egan declaration refers to some examples of newspaper articles published in Australia on the subject of the Mr Smith’s business and which were exhibited to his second declarations. Ms Egan’s declaration includes reference to research on the likely readership of each publication at the time, with intention, I infer, of attempting to define the likely exposure of the articles within the general population.The applicant’s evidence – Lena Fishman’s declarations In all, taking into account the two declarations submitted during the course of examination of the applications, Lena Fishman has provided four declarations which contain information in respect of the applicant’s trade marks. Much of the information is repeated in different declarations. What I provide here is a summary of the relevant information. Ms Fishman states that her parents, Luda and Roman Fishman, founded the business in around 1981 when they began manufacturing and selling sheepskin boots, hats, mittens, jackets and vests in Australia.[5] From sheepskins bought from their sheepskin supplier at the time, the Fishmans made four styles of hats and three styles of boots which were sold at stalls in the Queen Victoria Market in Melbourne. [5] Ms Fishman states that while the business has produced boots, mittens and hats continuously since 1981, the production of jackets and vests has not been continuous. The Fishmans registered the business name Luda Textiles Co in Victoria on 17 March 1982. The applicant was incorporated in August 2004 to take over the Luda Textiles business. Ms Fishman says that the applicant and its processor have continuously manufactured and sold sheepskin boots, mittens and hats since 1981 up to the present.