Deckers Outdoor Corporation v B&B McDougal

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposed application by Bruce E McDougall and Bronwyn McDougall under section 92 to remove 245662(25) UGH-BOOTS registered in the name of Deckers Outdoor Corporation.

Delegate:

Ian Thompson

Representation:

Applicants: David Stewart instructed by Dr Michael Brewis of Wray & Associates via video conference from Perth

Opponent:  Chris Dimitriadis instructed by Melinda Upton of Blake Dawson Waldron

Decision:

s92 proceedings – onus on owner of trade mark to show use within relevant period – use of generics by owner – trade mark to be removed from register.

Costs ordered against the opponent.

Background

  1. Deckers Outdoor Corporation (‘the owner’ or ‘the opponent’) of California, United States of America, owns a registered trade mark, current details of which are:

    App No:  245662

    Registered from:  25 January 1971

    Goods:Class: 25 Boots, shoes and slippers

    Trade Mark:  UGH-BOOTS

    (‘the registered trade mark’)

  2. On 30 December 2003, Bruce McDougall and Bronwyn McDougall (‘the applicants’) filed application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) claiming that during the period 30 November 2000 until 30 November 2003 the registered trade mark was not used or used in good faith by either the owner or an authorised user. 

  3. On 7 May 2004 Ugg Holdings Inc, a predecessor in business of Deckers Outdoor Corporation, filed notice of opposition to the removal of the registered trade mark alleging as the sole ground of opposition that the registered trade mark had been used within the relevant period.

  4. The parties have both served and filed evidence as allowed by the Act and regulations thereto.

  5. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the matter at a hearing in Canberra on 24 November 2005.  David Stewart instructed by Dr Michael Brewis of Wray & Associates of Perth appeared for the applicants by a video conference link.  Chris Dimitriadis instructed by Melinda Upton of Blake Dawson Waldron appeared in person for the opponent.

    Evidence and discussion

  6. Detailed discussion of all of the evidence served and filed in this matter would, in my opinion, distract from the question which is at the core of this matter and it is most convenient for me to here discuss the evidence which relates to that question.  This question forms the keystone of the submissions of both parties and is also central to my decision.

  7. I will discuss the other evidence as it becomes necessary in my reasons.

  8. There is one critical piece of supporting documentation in evidence in the material filed by the opponent which might show the trade mark in use within the relevant period of 30 November 2000 until 30 November 2003.  This is a newspaper advertisement which appears in The Sydney Morning Herald dated 3 November 2003 and which is exhibited to the first declaration of Mr John Kalinich.  The copies before me are not of reproducible quality but the advertisement appears to be identical to that below (of a later…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deckers Outdoor Corporation v B&B McDougal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] ATMO 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Deckers Outdoor Corporation (the applicant) sought the removal of trade mark registration number 245662, for the mark "UGH BOOTS", from the Register of Trade Marks on the grounds of non-use. B&B McDougal (the opponent) opposed this removal. The matter was heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether the opponent had demonstrated genuine and commercial use of the trade mark "UGH BOOTS" in Australia during the relevant period of 30 November 2000 to 30 November 2003. Specifically, the delegate had to consider whether a newspaper advertisement and potential sales via the opponent's website constituted sufficient use to prevent the removal of the registration.

The delegate found that a newspaper advertisement placed by the opponent in *The Sydney Morning Herald* did not demonstrate use of the trade mark in good faith. While the advertisement might have been intended to gauge interest or test the Australian market, the delegate noted significant doubts regarding the actual receipt of goods by Australian customers who ordered via the website. Evidence suggested that the website only permitted orders from the USA, Canada, and the United Kingdom, and the opponent's leading declarant attested to difficulties processing Australian credit card orders. Consequently, the delegate concluded that the use, if any, was not a genuine and commercial use of the trade mark.

Accordingly, the delegate ordered that trade mark registration number 245662 be removed from the Register of Trade Marks and ordered costs against the opponent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the matter at a hearing in Canberra on 24 November 2005. David Stewart instructed by Dr Michael Brewis of Wray & Associates of Perth appeared for the applicants by a video conference link. Chris Dimitriadis instructed by Melinda Upton of Blake Dawson Waldron appeared in person for the opponent.Evidence and discussion Detailed discussion of all of the evidence served and filed in this matter would, in my opinion, distract from the question which is at the core of this matter and it is most convenient for me to here discuss the evidence which relates to that question. This question forms the keystone of the submissions of both parties and is also central to my decision. I will discuss the other evidence as it becomes necessary in my reasons. There is one critical piece of supporting documentation in evidence in the material filed by the opponent which might show the trade mark in use within the relevant period of 30 November 2000 until 30 November 2003. This is a newspaper advertisement which appears in The Sydney Morning Herald dated 3 November 2003 and which is exhibited to the first declaration of Mr John Kalinich. The copies before me are not of reproducible quality but the advertisement appears to be identical to that below (of a later date) which appears elsewhere in the opponent’s evidence: It is Mr Stewart’s contention that the above advertisement does not show the registered trade mark in use and, additionally, or in the alternative, that the above advertisement was a ‘water tester’ in that although the opponent has shown that it might have resulted in a license agreement with an Australian company, Pacific Sheepskins Pty Ltd whereby the Australian company is licensed to use, inter alia, this registration 245662 “for the mark UGH BOOTS”, the opponent has not shown that there were any sales as a direct result of the advertisement under the registered trade mark. There is also evidence which might suggest sales to Australia from the website within the relevant period. However, the declarations of Michelle Jansen and Colleen Treloar aver that they are people referred to in the opponent’s evidence as having ordered goods on the website from Australia. Both of these declarants aver to not receiving the goods they are purported to have ordered. Moreover, a printout, in evidence, of the Internet website shows that it only permits orders from USA, Canada and the United Kingdom. The owner’s leading declarant, Mr Kalinich, attests to ‘difficulties’ processing credit card orders from Australia. There are thus strong doubts as to whether the other customers listed in fact received goods in the relevant period and the opponent has not shown that the other customers referred to on the list actually received the goods.[1] It should be relatively simple to provide evidence of postal or courier delivery of such goods within Australia, or declarations from the recipients of the goods to refute the inference that such deliveries did not take place. The fact that such evidence has not been led by the owner may be telling.[1] In terms of Nodoz Trade Mark (1962) RPC 1, if a party is to rely on slight use of a trade mark, the evidence of that usage should be of high provenance and reliability.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There are possible explanations for the apparent placement by the owner of an advertisement which could not result in the immediate sale of goods. One is that the advertisement was placed so that the number of ‘hits’ on the website from Australians responding to the advertisement could be gauged; this would both test the efficacy of the advertising medium and whether it was to be worthwhile entering the Australian market. Another explanation could be that the opponent was aware that the trade mark was vulnerable to removal for non use and sought to make some public exposure of it. However, in view of the seeming problems of customers in Australia actually receiving goods, (although it would appear that some ordered them) this does not constitute a use in good faith of the trade mark, not being a ‘genuine and commercial’ use of the trade mark.[5] [5] See Concord Trade Mark [1987] FSR 209.Decision The opponent has not, accordingly, established its opposition to the removal of 245662 (UGH-BOOTS) from the Register of Trade Marks. Subject to any appeal from this decision, filed within the allowed time, I direct that registration 245662 be removed from the register of trade marks.Costs As the applicant has been successful in these proceedings, I order costs against the opponent at the official scale.Ian ThompsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings16 January 2006

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.