Peter Cracknell v Revlon Consumer Products Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Peter Cracknell to application under section 92 of the Act by Revlon Consumer Products Corporation to remove trade mark number 1041514(3) - Customeyes & Lips – registered in the name of The WOW Factor-e Pty Ltd

Delegate: Iain Thompson
Representation: Opponent: Did not appear – written submissions
Applicant: Margaret Ryan of Philips Ormonde Fitzpatrick
Decision: 2012 ATMO 70
s92 opposition – opponent’s evidence establishes use during the relevant period – application for removal unsuccessful.

Background

  1. On 9 December 2010, Revlon Consumer Products Corporation (‘the applicant’) made application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) for the removal from the register of trade marks of the trade mark subject of the registration detailed hereunder:

    Registration No:         1041514
    Owner:  The WOW Factor-e Pty Ltd
    Registration Date:      13 February 2005
    Goods:  Class 3: Cosmetics, colour cosmetics, bath and body related   products
    Trade Mark:               Customeyes & Lips

    (‘the trade mark’)

  2. The application for removal was made under subsection 92(4)(b) of the Act in respect of all of the goods the subject of the registration. The non-use period is 9 November 2007 to 9 November 2010 (‘the relevant period’).

  3. On 21 February 2011, Peter Cracknell, (‘the opponent’) filed notice of opposition to the removal of the trade mark.

  4. Both the opponent and applicant have served and filed evidence as allowed by the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.

  5. The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, at a hearing in Melbourne on 18 July 2012.  Margaret Ryan, solicitor, of Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick, Patent and Trade Marks Attorneys, represented the applicant.  The opponent did not appear but relied on written submissions.

  6. In this matter the onus is, in terms of section 100 of the Act, on the opponent to establish to my satisfaction there was at least a single use of the impugned trade mark within the relevant period. In Woolly Bull Enterprises Pty Ltd v Reynolds [2001] FCA 261; (2001) 107 FCR 166; [2001] AIPC 91-713; (2001) 51 IPR 149 Drummond J said at [14]:

    An application for removal cannot be made on an allegation of almost continuous non-use throughout the whole of the three year period: only an allegation of unbroken non-use throughout a continuous period of three years will suffice. If a single user of the mark during that period is sufficient to disentitle a person from making an application for removal based on s 92(4)(b), the opponent must be entitled by s 100(3)(a) to rebut the allegation on which such a removal application is based by proving a use (in good faith) on just one occasion during the three year period.

    The Evidence

  7. It is convenient to observe at the outset that the opponent’s evidence which is claimed to demonstrate use of the trade mark during the relevant period was criticised by Ms Ryan at the hearing as:

    ·not demonstrating the use…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peter Cracknell v Revlon Consumer Products Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ATMO 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Peter Cracknell (the applicant) to remove the trade mark "Customeyes & Lips" from the Register of Trade Marks, based on allegations of non-use. Revlon Consumer Products Corporation (the opponent) sought to defend the registration by demonstrating use of the trade mark within the relevant three-year period. The hearing was conducted by Iain Thompson, a Hearing Officer for Trade Marks.

The central legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether the opponent had established, to his satisfaction, that there had been at least a single use of the impugned trade mark "Customeyes & Lips" in good faith within the three years preceding the application for removal. This required the opponent to rebut the applicant's claim of non-use, as per section 100 of the relevant Act. The applicant had also argued that the evidence of use was insufficient, either because it did not demonstrate use of the trade mark in its precise registered form or because it was of low probative value regarding the dates of use.

The Hearing Officer considered the evidence presented by the opponent, which included statements about the vision for the "Customeyes & Lips" trade mark, the nature of the product (customisable cosmetic palettes), and documentary evidence such as sales receipts and in-store posters. The opponent asserted that the product was trialled in early 2010, with sales occurring in January and March of that year, and that promotional posters were displayed from April to May 2010, followed by a product launch in May 2010. Further sales receipts from June to November 2010 were also exhibited. The Hearing Officer found that the opponent's evidence, including the sales receipts and posters, was sufficient to establish use of the trade mark during the relevant period. He also determined that the goods in question, "bath and body related products," were sufficiently similar to "cosmetics" such that use of the trade mark in relation to them would not be deceptive or confusing, and therefore, no limitation of the registration scope was warranted.

Ultimately, the Hearing Officer was not satisfied that the grounds on which the application for removal was made had been established by the applicant. Accordingly, the application for removal was dismissed. The opponent, having been successful, was awarded costs against the applicant on the official scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In this matter the onus is, in terms of section 100 of the Act, on the opponent to establish to my satisfaction there was at least a single use of the impugned trade mark within the relevant period. In Woolly Bull Enterprises Pty Ltd v Reynolds [2001] FCA 261; (2001) 107 FCR 166; [2001] AIPC 91-713; (2001) 51 IPR 149 Drummond J said at [14]:An application for removal cannot be made on an allegation of almost continuous non-use throughout the whole of the three year period: only an allegation of unbroken non-use throughout a continuous period of three years will suffice. If a single user of the mark during that period is sufficient to disentitle a person from making an application for removal based on s 92(4)(b), the opponent must be entitled by s 100(3)(a) to rebut the allegation on which such a removal application is based by proving a use (in good faith) on just one occasion during the three year period.The Evidence It is convenient to observe at the outset that the opponent’s evidence which is claimed to demonstrate use of the trade mark during the relevant period was criticised by Ms Ryan at the hearing as:·not demonstrating the use of the trade mark in the precise form it was registered; and,·being of low probative value in establishing the dates of use of the trade mark. The opponent is a part owner of the opponent. He states that ‘the vision’ for the ‘Customeyes & Lips’ trade mark has been to develop a high quality, yet affordable range of cosmetics that allows the end-consumer to make unique selections reflecting their preferences and needs. Products sold under the ‘Customeyes & Lips’ trade mark thereby allow consumers to customise the make up palettes they purchase, rather than accepting a manufacturer's colour combinations. The customer purchases an empty cosmetic compact with magnetic insert. Customers then select specific colours as they require and the individual metal product pans holding their chosen colours, drop into the compact. The opponent further states:The WOW Factor-e Pty Ltd finetuned design, development and product sourcing activity and launched the product under the "Customeyes & Lips" trade mark at The WOW Factor-e [shop] in Frankston, Victoria. The trade marked product was initially trialled in early 2010, with a small quantity of product in the same style as was subsequently launched, offered for sale. See copy sales receipts dated 24/1/2010 and 6/3/2010 as examples of sales made of the trade mark product under "Customeyes & Lips" during this trial marketing phase. A copy of one of these sales receipts appears below: The opponent states that an A3 sized in-store poster announcing the up-coming arrival of the new product and showing the trade mark was displayed in-store from late April 2010 until the launch of the product in May 2010. Exhibit 5A of the opponent’s declaration shows this poster: A similar poster was, states the opponent, displayed in-store when the product was launched in May 2010: The opponent exhibits to his declaration several sales receipts, dated from June 2010 through to November 2010, which are in similar form and content to that shown above at paragraph 10 of this decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The goods ‘bath and body related products’ are, in my consideration, sufficiently similar to ‘cosmetics’ that use by a person other than the registrant of the trade mark Customeyes & Lips in relation to those goods would be deceptive and confusing. Accordingly, no good purpose would be served by directing that the scope of the registration be limited in relation to those goods.Decision Section 101 of the Act relevantly provides:101Determination of opposed application—general(1)Subject to subsection (3) and to section 102, if:(a)the proceedings relating to an opposed application have not been discontinued or dismissed; and(b)the Registrar is satisfied that the grounds on which the application was made have been established;the Registrar may decide to remove the trade mark from the Register in respect of any or all of the goods and/or services to which the application relates. I am not satisfied that the grounds on which the application was made have been established.Costs Having been successful in this matter the opponent is entitled to his costs which I order against the applicant at the official scale.Iain ThompsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings17 August 2012

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.