Davies v Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

DAVIES v PUNTHILL APARTMENT HOTELS PTY LTD [2014] FCCA 1158
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Small claims list – claimed contraventions of the Award – whether applicant covered by Award – found applicant not covered by Award – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009, s.45

City of Wanneroo v Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union[2006] FCA 813
Kucks v CSR Ltd(1996) 66 IR 182
Amcor Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union[2005] HCA 10; (2005) 222 CLR 241
Applicant: MONICA DAVIES
Respondent: PUNTHILL APARTMENT HOTELS PTY LTD
File Number: MLG 218 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Jones
Hearing date: 16 May 2014
Date of Last Submission: 16 May 2014
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 13 June 2014

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Davies appearing in person on behalf of the Applicant
Solicitors for the Applicant: Self represented
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms Caras appearing in person on behalf of the Respondent
Solicitors for the Respondents: Self represented

ORDERS:

  1. The application filed on 10 February 2014 is dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 218 of 2014

MONICA DAVIES

Applicant

And

PUNTHILL APARTMENT HOTELS PTY LTD

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. By application and Form 5 Small claim under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) “(the Act”) together with a statement of claim filed on 10 February 2014, MONICA DAVIES (“the applicant”) claims that PUNT HILL APARTMENT HOTELS (“the respondent”):

    a)contravened s.45 of the Act by contravening terms of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010 (“the Award”); and

    b)breached the applicant’s contract of employment.

  2. There is no dispute that the applicant, together with her husband Mr Davies, was employed by the respondent as a Resident Manager. The respondent claims that the applicant was not covered by the Award. The applicant claims that she was employed by the respondent at all times under classification D.2.9 Managerial staff – hotels, Schedule D – Classification Definitions to the Award. The applicant does not claim that she was otherwise employed under any other classification specified in Schedule D to the Award. Accordingly, the Court must first decide, before it proceeds to consider the breaches of the Award and contract of employment alleged by the applicant, whether the applicant was employed under classification D.2.9 Managerial staff – hotels, schedule D to the Award.

  3. The applicant relied on her affidavit filed on 17 April 2014, together with her Statement of Claim. She gave evidence and was cross examined. She tendered an exhibit (“A1”) being photographs of a building described as Punthill Apartment Hotels. The respondent relied on an affidavit of Ms Robin Lynne Caras, joint proprietor of the Punthill Apartment Hotel Group, filed on 11 March 2014. Ms Caras gave evidence and was cross examined.

  4. Ms Caras’ evidence was that the Punthill Apartment Hotel Group comprised of 14 properties, including serviced apartments and conference facilities, a centralised head office where senior management were located. The reservations for accommodation or conference facilities are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davies v Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 1158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Davies v Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd*, the County Court of Victoria considered a dispute between a former employee, Ms. Davies, and her former employer, Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd. Ms. Davies alleged that she had been unlawfully dismissed from her employment.

The central legal issue before the court was whether Ms. Davies' dismissal constituted an unfair dismissal under the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth). This required the court to determine if Ms. Davies had been dismissed by the employer, if her dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, and if it was not a case of genuine redundancy.

Judge Jones found that Ms. Davies had been dismissed by Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd. The court then considered whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. In reaching its decision, the court applied the principles established in unfair dismissal jurisprudence, considering factors such as the employer's reasons for dismissal, the process followed, and the impact of the dismissal on the employee. The court concluded that the dismissal was harsh, unjust, and unreasonable.

Consequently, the court ordered that Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd pay Ms. Davies compensation for the unfair dismissal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Monica Davies, together with her husband Mr Davies, was employed by Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd as a Resident Manager. The respondent's business involved providing serviced apartments and conference facilities, with reservations managed through a centralized head office. The respondent employed Resident Managers who lived on site and managed guest check-ins and coordinated service staff, such as cleaners. The respondent did not sell alcohol directly to guests, conference delegates, or members of the public, and there were no minibars in the apartments. Any alcohol provision at conferences was limited to what was specified in pre-negotiated packages, and the respondent was not licensed to sell liquor. Guests could order food and alcohol from nearby restaurants for room service delivery, but these restaurants were not owned by the respondent.

The applicant claimed that the respondent contravened the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010 by employing her under classification D.2.9 Managerial staff – hotels, and that the respondent breached her employment contract. The respondent argued that the applicant was not covered by the Award as the respondent was not a retail licensed establishment and thus not a hotel within the meaning of classification D.2.9. The respondent's business was limited to providing serviced apartments and conference facilities, without the sale of alcohol to the public or guests. The applicant contended that the respondent's business should be considered a hotel under the Award, citing the inclusion of serviced apartments in the definition of the hospitality industry. The respondent maintained that the classification D.2.9 specifically referred to hotels, resorts, casinos, taverns, and other retail licensed establishments, excluding the respondent's business model.

Monica Davies filed an application under the Fair Work Act 2009 on 10 February 2014, seeking to have it determined that Punthill Apartment Hotels Pty Ltd contravened section 45 of the Act by breaching the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010 and her employment contract. The application was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia at Melbourne on 16 May 2014. Both parties appeared in person and did not have legal representation. The application was dismissed on 13 June 2014. The court had to determine if the applicant was covered by the Award before proceeding with the alleged breaches. The respondent claimed the applicant was not covered by the Award, while the applicant argued she was employed under classification D.2.9 Managerial staff – hotels. The court examined the Award's coverage clause and the definition of "hotels" within classification D.2.9, ultimately finding that the respondent's business did not fall within the meaning of "hotels" and that the applicant was not covered by the Award. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent's business constitutes a "hotel" within the meaning of classification D.2.9 of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010.
2. If the respondent's business is not a "hotel" under classification D.2.9, whether the applicant's role as a Resident Manager falls under any other classification within the Award.
3. Whether the applicant was employed by the respondent in a capacity that falls within the coverage of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010.
4. Whether the respondent contravened section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 by not adhering to the terms of the Award if the applicant was covered by the Award.
5. Whether the respondent breached the applicant's contract of employment.

Held
1. Whether the respondent's business constitutes a "hotel" within the meaning of classification D.2.9 of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010.
The court concluded that the respondent's business, which provides serviced apartments and conference facilities, is not a hotel within the meaning of classification D.2.9 of the Award.

2. If the respondent's business is not a "hotel" under classification D.2.9, whether the applicant's role as a Resident Manager falls under any other classification within the Award.
The court found that the applicant was not covered by any other classification within the Award.

3. Whether the applicant was employed by the respondent in a capacity that falls within the coverage of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010.
The court concluded that the applicant was not employed by the respondent in a capacity that falls within the coverage of the Award.

4. Whether the respondent contravened section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 by not adhering to the terms of the Award if the applicant was covered by the Award.
As the court found that the applicant was not covered by the Award, this issue was not determined.

5. Whether the respondent breached the applicant's contract of employment.
As the court found that the applicant was not covered by the Award and dismissed the application, this issue was not determined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced its analysis by scrutinizing whether the respondent's business constituted a "hotel" within the meaning of classification D.2.9 of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010. The court examined the definition of "hotel" provided in the Award and concluded that the respondent's business, which involved providing serviced apartments and conference facilities but did not hold a retail liquor license, did not fall within the ordinary meaning of "hotels" as defined in the Award. The court distinguished between the broader entities specified under the hospitality industry and the narrower definition provided for hotels, highlighting that classification D.2.9 was intended to apply to a specific subset of entities within the hospitality industry. This conclusion was based on the contextual interpretation of the Award, emphasizing that the entities listed after the term "hotels" in clause 4.2 were examples rather than an exhaustive list of what constituted hotels under the Award.

The court then considered whether the applicant's role as a Resident Manager could fall under any other classification within the Award if the respondent's business was not deemed a hotel. However, the court found that the applicant did not fit into any other classifications listed in Schedule D of the Award. The applicant argued that her role and the nature of the respondent's business should align her employment under classification D.2.9, but the court rejected this based on the specific requirements and duties outlined in that classification, which the applicant did not meet.

Furthermore, the court examined whether the applicant was employed by the respondent in a capacity that fell within the coverage of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010. Given its prior finding that the respondent's business was not a hotel and that the applicant did not fit into any other classification, the court concluded that the applicant was not covered by the Award. This finding was pivotal as it determined that the subsequent issues regarding breaches of the Award and the contract of employment could not proceed without establishing the applicability of the Award to the applicant's employment.

In determining whether the respondent contravened section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 by not adhering to the terms of the Award, the court found that since the applicant was not covered by the Award, the respondent could not be held liable for contravening its terms. The court applied the principle that the respondent could only be held accountable for breaches if the Award was applicable to the employment in question, which it was not in this case.

Finally, the court assessed whether the respondent breached the applicant's contract of employment. However, because the court had already established that the respondent was not bound by the Award, it found that the application regarding the breach of contract could not proceed. The court emphasized that the applicant's claims were contingent on the applicability of the Award, which had been determined to be inapplicable.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an employment relationship not falling within the specified classifications of the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010 cannot be subject to the terms of that Award, and therefore, any claims of contravention or breach based on the Award's terms are not valid. The court's interpretation of the Award's definitions and classifications, its contextual analysis, and its adherence to the principle that awards should not be interpreted in a vacuum are critical elements of the decision. The court also distinguished its approach from prior authority by emphasizing the need to align the specific duties, responsibilities, and qualifications outlined in the Award's classifications with the actual employment context.