Dahdah v Platinum Distributors Australia Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Dahdah v Platinum Distributors Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] FCA 416

File number: NSD 61 of 2019
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 22 April 2022
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – claim for unpaid wages and entitlements under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and relevant industrial award – where respondent sponsored applicant’s visa to work in Australia – whether applicant terminated his employment in June 2015 – application dismissed

CONSUMER LAW – alleged misleading representations regarding respondent’s willingness to apply for permanent residency for the applicant after two years of employment – where representation conditional on applicant continuing his employment for two years – where that condition not met – case not established

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) sch 2 ss 4, 18, 31, 236

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 13, 14, 19, 87, 139, 323, 535, 542, 543, 545, 550

Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Cth)

Superannuation Guarantee Charge Act 1992 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Association of Professional Engineers, Scientists and Managers, Australia v Wollongong Coal Ltd [2014] FCA 878

Automatic Fire Sprinklers Pty Ltd v Watson [1946] HCA 25; 72 CLR 435

Bluescope Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd v Australian Workers Union [2019] FCAFC 84; 270 FCR 359

Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; 60 CLR 336

Kelly v Fitzpatrick [2007] FCA 1080

Koutalis v Pollett [2015] FCA 1165; 235 FCR 370

Murrihy v Betezy.com.au Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 908; 238 IR 307

Qantas Airways Ltd v Flight Attendants’ Association of Australia [2020] FCAFC 227; 282 FCR 243

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 258
Date of last submission/s: 19 July 2021
Date of hearing: 28-30 September 2020
20, 23-25 November 2020
18 December 2020
14 May 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms U Okereke-Fisher
Solicitor for the Applicant: Abu Legal Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First Respondent: The First Respondent did not appear
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr M Seck
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Solve Legal Pty ltd
Table of Corrections
12 May 2022 In paragraph 177 line seven, the word “respondent” has been replaced with “applicant”

ORDERS

NSD 61 of 2019
BETWEEN:

JEAN DAHDAH

Applicant

AND:

PLATINUM DISTRIBUTORS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

First Respondent

JAMES DAHDAH

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BURLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 APRIL 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

1       INTRODUCTION

[1]

1.1      The proceedings

[1]

1.2      The pleaded case

[3]

1.3      Introduction to the factual dispute

[8]

1.4      Summary of conclusions

[15]

2       THE WITNESSES

[16]

2.1      The applicant’s witnesses

[16]

2.2      The respondent’s witnesses

[20]

3       THE SUBMISSIONS

[31]

3.1      The applicant

[31]

3.2      The respondent

[39]

4       CHRONOLOGY OF BACKGROUND FACTS

[41]

5       THE CREDIT OF THE APPLICANT AND THE RESPONDENT

[86]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dahdah v Platinum Distributors Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Dahdah v Platinum Distributors Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a claim by the applicant for unpaid wages and entitlements under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and relevant industrial award. The applicant alleged that the respondent, who sponsored his visa to work in Australia, terminated his employment in June 2015. The court had to determine whether the applicant was entitled to the unpaid wages and whether the respondent breached the relevant industrial award by terminating the applicant's employment without just cause or reason.

The court found that the applicant did not establish the breaches alleged. The court examined the evidence and found that the applicant's claim for unpaid wages and entitlements was not substantiated. The court also found that the applicant did not establish that the respondent breached the relevant industrial award by terminating his employment without just cause or reason. The court found that the applicant's evidence was not reliable, and the respondent's evidence was more credible.

The court dismissed the application and made no orders for costs. The court found that the applicant's evidence was not reliable, and the respondent's evidence was more credible. The court found that the applicant did not establish the breaches alleged, and therefore, the application was dismissed. The court also found that the applicant did not establish that the respondent breached the relevant industrial award by terminating his employment without just cause or reason. The court made no orders for costs as the applicant's claim was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent contends that a key issue in the case is the credit of the main protagonists. He submits that the applicant was not a witness of truth for a number of reasons. The respondent accepts that certain employee and financial records have not been retained by his accountant and as a consequence of Platinum’s deregistration and that this is unsatisfactory. However, he submits that there is no evidence or even suggestion that the respondent deliberately engineered this situation to avoid legal scrutiny, and the absence of records can be explained by the fact that Platinum was a small business which relied on its accountant to assist in the keeping of records. He also admits that he made a number of regrettable errors of judgment in failing to report the cessation of the applicant’s employment to the Department of Home Affairs and in creating false 2016 and 2017 group certificates. In his evidence he contends that he asked his accountant to create those summaries as a result of a threat made to him by the applicant to kill him and to “get him off his back”. He submits that he has disclosed these mistakes to the authorities and exhibits copies of letters to the Department of Home Affairs, the ATO and the Legal Services Commissioner, none of whom have taken any action. The respondent submits that whilst these lapses of judgment are regrettable, the context reveals that he acted in accordance with his values and that they do not demonstrate that his evidence is not to be accepted. 4. CHRONOLOGY OF BACKGROUND FACTS Much of the factual basis for the case is in dispute. In this section I set out my findings of fact in relation to background matters that are established by the evidence. In 2011 Platinum was incorporated, with the respondent as its sole director and shareholder. In 2012 Platinum reported in its Financial Statements a loss of $236,000. In 2013 it reported a gross profit of $122,544 and the payment of “salaries and wages” of $12,000. On or about 14 November 2013 the Department recorded receipt of a Business Sponsorship Application made by the respondent on behalf of Platinum for the sponsorship of the applicant. The application required information including a “detailed explanation which outlines your reasons” for proposing that the applicant receive a sponsorship and invited the applicant to lodge further documents in support of the application. The application records a statement made by the respondent to the effect that Platinum had two professional employees, that the gross payroll expenditure of the business was $12,000. It included a statement that the sponsor (Platinum) agreed that it was willing to meet its obligations as a Business Sponsor and a declaration that the details on the form were correct. On 3 December 2013 a representative of the Department sought further information from Platinum about the business sponsorship application. The respondent replied on 7 January 2014 providing documents including; (a)a Business Plan dated December 2013;(b)a letter of reference from Australian Tax Services, signed by Mark-Anthony Basha, a Tax agent acting on behalf of Platinum; and(c)a letter from Rhyder Industries Pty Ltd dated 19 December 2013 (Rhyder letter) stating: “This letter is to verify that invoices [numbered] were in relation to training provided to [Platinum] for the employee Mrs Vivienne Dahdah”. Rhyder Industries is a company of which the respondent is the sole director and shareholder.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent acknowledges that Platinum did not have certain employee financial records relevant to the case as a result of Mr Basha no longer retaining them and because Platinum has been deregistered. He accepts that this state of affairs is unsatisfactory, but submits that no suggestion was made that he deliberately engineered this situation to avoid legal scrutiny. He submits that Platinum was a small business which relied on its accountants to keep its records. He also acknowledges that he has made a number of errors of judgment in not reporting the applicant’s cessation of employment with the Department of Home Affairs and by creating false 2016 and 2017 group certificates. He submits that he candidly acknowledged those mistakes and has disclosed them to the relevant authorities. He submits that he made those mistakes consistently with the values instilled in Lebanese culture which emphasises family ties and helping out family members. He submits that once the applicant got angry and aggressive he felt intimidated and so under duress he gave the applicant what he wanted in order to avoid further trouble.7. REVIEW OF THE EVIDENCE In the sections below I review the evidence presented in relation to the primary areas of disputed fact and then set out my conclusions in relation to those facts in issue.7.1 The conversation of 26 June 2015 There is a dispute on the evidence as to whether on 26 June 2015 the applicant informed the respondent that he intended to buy a truck so that he could start his own business. The respondent gives evidence that during the week of 22 June 2015 the applicant approached him and said that he had a friend who had a truck that he wanted to sell and that the friend had work for him to do. The respondent deposes to having a conversation in Arabic to the following effect:Jean:James, a friend of mine has a truck he wants to sell, and I want to buy it.James: What do you mean?Jean: I have a friend who is selling his truck and he has work for me.James: Jean you can’t buy a truck. You are working for me. Jean: OK, we will talk. The respondent gives evidence of a further conversation on 26 June 2015 to similar effect in which Mr Boustany participated. He gives evidence that during the conversation, Mr Boustany and the respondent informed the applicant that he could not buy a truck. The respondent gives evidence that the conversation included the following:James: What is this? What’s going on?Habib: Did you hear Jean wants to buy a truck?James: What do you mean Jean?Jean: Yes the truck I want to buy from my friend. James: Jean, I told you that you can’t buy the truck. You are not allowed.Habib:Yes, Jean you are not allowed to buy a truck. You are bound by that condition on your visa. James:Jean, you are not allowed to start a business. How are you going to do that?Jean: I will put the truck in your name. James:No, I won’t allow that. I don’t want that liability and can’t afford to hold that liability. Mr Boustany left the conversation but the respondent and the applicant continued their conversation, the respondent giving evidence that it traversed the type of truck for sale, its cost, the earning rate per load and its potential. The respondent gives evidence that he pointed out to the applicant the weekly costs and earnings and said that he would be better off continuing to work at Platinum.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider the conflicting evidence in relation to these disputes in section 7 below before turning to consideration of the ultimate issues between the parties. 1.4 Summary of conclusions For the reasons set out in more detail below I find that the applicant has not established the breaches alleged. The application must be dismissed. 2. THE WITNESSES2.1 The applicant’s witnesses Jean Dahdah is the applicant. He was born in 1970 and grew up and lived in Lebanon until 2015. Prior to his departure from Lebanon his primary occupation was as a bus driver for a school. Before the applicant came to Australia he had a limited ability to speak English and little ability to read or write in English. He gave four affidavits, each of which were translated into Arabic before they were affirmed. He gave oral evidence and was cross examined with the assistance of an interpreter. In his affidavit in chief dated 30 June 2019, the applicant describes how he came to Australia and provides his version of events concerning the duration of his employment with Platinum and the instructions that he received from the respondent. The affidavit is relatively brief and exhibits a limited number of documents. In his second affidavit, dated 24 April 2020, the applicant provides a very detailed response to the affidavit in answer supplied by the respondent. In his third affidavit, dated 3 June 2020, the applicant provides details of payments that he received from Platinum. In his fourth affidavit, dated 7 August 2020, he responds by paragraph to an affidavit made by the respondent in answer to the applicant’s reply affidavit. Jousephine Dahdah is the sister of the applicant and the cousin of the respondent. She gave one affidavit about two meetings that she recalled attending, one in about July 2017 and another in September 2017. She speaks fluent English and Arabic and was cross examined. Jouliana Dahdah is the daughter of Jousephine, niece of the applicant and a cousin of the respondent. She lives with her parents. She gives evidence of her recollection of a meeting that she attended in mid-September 2017. She is fluent in English and Arabic and was cross examined.2.2 The respondent’s witnesses James Dahdah is the respondent. He was admitted to practice as a solicitor in August 2017 and studied law part time from 2011. Prior to commencing his work as a solicitor he was the sole director and shareholder of Platinum, which traded in the import and export of goods to and from Australia. He is of Lebanese heritage and speaks English and Arabic. The respondent provided a first affidavit on 19 September 2019, in which he sets out his version of events concerning his recruitment of the applicant to work for Platinum and the work that the applicant performed. The respondent affirmed a second affidavit on 19 July 2020. In it he provides a paragraph by paragraph response to the applicant’s second affidavit. On 17 September 2020 the respondent provided a third affidavit in which he gives evidence about the loss of relevant records from Platinum, the payment of salary to the applicant and exhibits letters to the ATO, the Department of Home Affairs and also the Legal Services Commissioner about his fabrication of certain group certificates.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I find that the respondent was prepared to satisfy that expediency by instructing his accountant to prepare false group certificates.8. CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICANT’S CLAIMS8.1 Claim under s 323 of the FW Act The applicant’s pleaded case is that he performed work for Platinum for a period of 32 months for which he was paid only $19,711. The pleaded basis for that claim is that the applicant was an employee of Platinum from 17 February 2015 until October 2017. I have summarised the disputed factual issues in some detail above. The first relevant legal issue is whether on or about 26 June 2015 the applicant resigned from or abandoned his employment. This does not depend on the parties’ subjective intentions or understanding, but is determined by what a reasonable person in the parties’ position would have understood was the objective position immediately after the conversation ended on 26 June 2015, based on what each party said and did and in light of the surrounding circumstances: Koutalis v Pollett [2015] FCA 1165; 235 FCR 370 at [43] (Rares J). In Koutalis the Court made the following observation of present relevance (emphasis added by Rares J):43.…In Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165 at 179 [40], Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Callinan and Heydon JJ said:This Court, in Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas [(2004) 218 CLR 451], has recently reaffirmed the principle of objectivity by which the rights and liabilities of the parties to a contract are determined. It is not the subjective beliefs or understandings of the parties about their rights and liabilities that govern their contractual relations. What matters is what each party by words and conduct would have led a reasonable person in the position of the other party to believe. References to the common intention of the parties to a contract are to be understood as referring to what a reasonable person would understand by the language in which the parties have expressed their agreement. The meaning of the terms of a contractual document is to be determined by what a reasonable person would have understood them to mean. That, normally, requires consideration not only of the text, but also of the surrounding circumstances known to the parties, and the purpose and object of the transaction [Pacific Carriers Ltd v BNP Paribas (2004) 218 CLR 451 at 461-462 [22]]. (emphasis added)44. In my opinion, the same considerations apply to the evaluation of the circumstances where parties engage in conversations and conduct that affects their legal rights under a contract, including the assessment of whether or not words and or conduct can be seen to amount to a resignation. Nonetheless, in employment contexts, a court must be conscious that situations can arise in which one or other of the parties acts in the heat of the moment in such a way that a reasonable person in the position of the parties in all the circumstances would not understand the employee to be resigning or the employer to be terminating the employee’s employment, as the case may be. So much is reflected in what May LJ, with whom Croom-Johnson and Woolf LJJ agreed, said in Sovereign House Security Services Limited v Savage [1989] IRLR 115 at 116, namely:In my opinion, generally speaking, where unambiguous words of resignation are used by an employee to the employer direct or by an intermediary, and are so understood by the employer, the proper conclusion of fact is that the employee has in truth resigned. In my view tribunals should not be astute to find otherwise. However, in some cases there may be something in the context of the exchange between the employer and the employee or, in the circumstances of the employee him or herself, to entitle the Tribunal of fact to conclude that notwithstanding the appearances there was no real resignation despite what it might appear to be at first sight. (emphasis added)