Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: D151, D152, D154 v New South Wales Crime Commission [2017] NSWCA 143 Hearing dates: 24 February 2017 Decision date: 21 June 2017 Before: Beazley ACJ at [1];
Basten JA at [2];
Simpson JA at [43]Decision: Q1. Upon its proper construction, does s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) (“Act”) confer a power upon the Supreme Court to grant leave to the New South Wales Crime Commission to take evidence from a person who is the subject of a current charge against the laws of the Commonwealth?
Answer: Yes.
Q2. If yes, is s 35A of the Act invalid to that extent, on the ground that to permit such leave to be granted in those circumstances:
(a) would contravene Ch III of the Constitution by reason that it would purport to authorize a contempt of a State court exercising federal criminal jurisdiction thereby impairing the institutional integrity of that court as a repository of judicial power of the Commonwealth; or
(b) would contravene Ch III of the Constitution by reason that it would be an impermissible interference with:
(i) essential features of the judicial power of the Commonwealth, namely the accusatorial nature of a criminal trial (as considered in X7 v Australian Crime Commission (2013) 248 CLR 92); or
(c) would contravene s 80 of the Constitution by reason that it would be an impermissible alteration of fundamental features of ‘trial … by jury’ on an indictment for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth?
Answer: No.
Q3. If yes, should s 35A of the Act be read down to avoid any operation that would be constitutionally invalid?
Answer: Does not arise.
Q4. If yes, how should s 35A of the Act be read down?”
Answer: Does not arise.Catchwords: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – respondents charged with federal criminal offences – power of court to grant leave to State body to examine person about the subject matter of pending federal criminal charges – power conferred by Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) s 35A – whether provision invalid because it (a) contravenes Constitution Ch III (b) interferes with essential features of judicial power to control abuse of process and the adversarial nature of a criminal trial or (c) alters fundamental features of a trial by jury under Constitution, s 80
CRIME – Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) s 35A – whether provision confers power on court to grant leave to authority to examine a person subject to pending federal criminal charges
STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – whether reference to an “offence” in a State statute covers an offence under federal law – application of Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW), s 12(1) – whether contrary intention appears in substantive Act – Interpretation Act, s 5(2)
WORDS AND PHRASES – “offence” – Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) –whether “offence” in s 35A includes federal offencesLegislation Cited: Constitution, ss 80, 109; Ch III
Australian Crime Commission Act 2002…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read D151 v New South Wales Crime Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NSWCA 143
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court was required to determine three primary legal issues. First, whether, on its proper construction, section 35A of the Act empowered the Supreme Court to grant leave for the Commission to take evidence from a person subject to current federal criminal charges. Second, if such power existed, whether section 35A was invalid to that extent on the grounds that it contravened Chapter III of the Commonwealth Constitution by authorising a contempt of a State court exercising federal criminal jurisdiction, thereby impairing the institutional integrity of that court, or by impermissibly interfering with the accusatorial nature of a criminal trial. Third, the Court considered whether section 35A contravened section 80 of the Constitution by impermissibly altering fundamental features of a trial by jury for a federal offence.
The Court reasoned that, by virtue of section 12(1) of the *Interpretation Act 1987* (NSW), the reference to an "offence" in section 35A of the *Crime Commission Act 2012* (NSW) included offences against the laws of the Commonwealth, as no contrary intention appeared in the substantive Act. Accordingly, the Court held that section 35A did confer the power to grant leave to examine a person subject to pending federal criminal charges. The Court then unanimously dismissed the constitutional challenges, finding that the provision did not contravene Chapter III of the Constitution, nor did it impermissibly interfere with the accusatorial nature of a criminal trial or the fundamental features of a trial by jury under section 80. Consequently, the Court answered "Yes" to the first question and "No" to the second question, rendering the third and fourth questions moot.
Orders
Orders of the court
Q1. Upon its proper construction, does s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) (“Act”) confer a power upon the Supreme Court to grant leave to the New South Wales Crime Commission to take evidence from a person who is the subject of a current charge against the laws of the Commonwealth?
Answer: Yes.
Q2. If yes, is s 35A of the Act invalid to that extent, on the ground that to permit such leave to be granted in those circumstances:
(a) would contravene Ch III of the Constitution by reason that it would purport to authorize a contempt of a State court exercising federal criminal jurisdiction thereby impairing the institutional integrity of that court as a repository of judicial power of the Commonwealth; or
(b) would contravene Ch III of the Constitution by reason that it would be an impermissible interference with:
(i) essential features of the judicial power of the Commonwealth, namely the accusatorial nature of a criminal trial (as considered in X7 v Australian Crime Commission (2013) 248 CLR 92); or
(c) would contravene s 80 of the Constitution by reason that it would be an impermissible alteration of fundamental features of ‘trial … by jury’ on an indictment for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth?
Answer: No.
Q3. If yes, should s 35A of the Act be read down to avoid any operation that would be constitutionally invalid?
Answer: Does not arise.
Q4. If yes, how should s 35A of the Act be read down?”
Answer: Does not arise.
Background
Background to the litigation
The legal dispute escalated when the Supreme Court granted the Commission's application, prompting D151 to challenge the constitutionality of section 35A in the High Court of Australia. D151 argued that allowing the Commission to examine him about federal offences would contravene the separation of powers under Chapter III of the Constitution and interfere with the essential features of federal judicial power and the adversarial nature of a criminal trial. He also contended that it would alter fundamental features of a trial by jury as guaranteed by section 80 of the Constitution. The High Court was asked to determine whether section 35A of the Crime Commission Act, when interpreted to apply to federal offences, is valid and does not infringe upon the constitutionally protected features of federal criminal proceedings. The case thus hinges on the interpretation of the term "offence" in section 35A and whether it encompasses federal offences, as well as the constitutional implications of such an interpretation.
The matter of D151 v New South Wales Crime Commission was brought before the court as an appeal against a decision made by the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The original proceedings commenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the appellant, D151, sought a declaration that section 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) was invalid. The Supreme Court referred the matter to the Land and Environment Court for a determination on specific questions of law, which was subsequently appealed to the higher court. The appeal was allowed, and the case now rests before the court to address the validity of section 35A of the Act and its constitutionality under the Australian Constitution. Throughout these proceedings, the court has considered the interpretation of the term "offence" within the context of the Act, and whether it includes federal offences, as well as the implications of permitting a State body to examine a person subject to pending federal criminal charges.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) confer a power upon the Supreme Court to grant leave to the New South Wales Crime Commission to examine a person subject to a pending federal criminal charge?
2. If s 35A does confer such a power, is the provision invalid because it contravenes Chapter III of the Constitution by impairing the institutional integrity of federal courts or interfering with the essential features of judicial power?
3. If s 35A does confer such a power, is the provision invalid because it interferes with the accusatorial nature of a criminal trial or the adversarial process under federal law?
4. If s 35A does confer such a power, is the provision invalid because it alters fundamental features of a trial by jury under s 80 of the Constitution?
5. Does the term "offence" in s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) include federal offences?
6. Does s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) need to be read down to avoid any operation that would be constitutionally invalid, and if so, how should it be read down?
Held
1. The court concluded that s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) does confer a power upon the Supreme Court to grant leave to the New South Wales Crime Commission to examine a person subject to a pending federal criminal charge. Result: Yes.
2. The court concluded that s 35A of the Act is not invalid on the grounds that it contravenes Chapter III of the Constitution by impairing the institutional integrity of federal courts, interfering with the essential features of judicial power, or altering fundamental features of a trial by jury under s 80 of the Constitution. Result: No.
3. The court concluded that s 35A of the Act does not need to be read down to avoid any operation that would be constitutionally invalid. Result: Does not arise.
4. The court concluded that there is no need to read down s 35A of the Act to avoid any operation that would be constitutionally invalid. Result: Does not arise.
5. The court concluded that the term "offence" in s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) includes federal offences. Result: Yes.
6. The court concluded that s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) does not need to be read down to avoid any operation that would be constitutionally invalid. Result: Does not arise.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In D151 v New South Wales Crime Commission, the Court addressed whether s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) permits the Supreme Court to grant leave to the New South Wales Crime Commission to examine a person who is subject to a pending federal criminal charge. The Court found that s 35A does confer such a power, establishing the first issue in the case. In reaching this conclusion, the Court considered the express language of s 35A, which does not explicitly limit the scope of the Commission's power to cases under State law alone. Therefore, the Court held that the provision does not confine the Commission's powers to State offences only.
The second issue considered whether this conferred power contravenes Chapter III of the Constitution. Specifically, the Court examined whether granting leave would impair the institutional integrity of federal courts or interfere with essential features of judicial power. The Court held that s 35A does not contravene Chapter III. It reasoned that the provision does not authorize contempt of a federal court nor does it undermine the essential characteristics of judicial power, such as the control of abuse of process and the adversarial nature of a criminal trial. The Court distinguished this case from X7 v Australian Crime Commission, where the Court found that a similar power infringed upon the accusatorial nature of a criminal trial.
The third issue addressed whether s 35A interferes with the adversarial process under federal law. Again, the Court found that it does not. It reasoned that the power to examine a person does not alter the adversarial nature of a criminal trial, as the power is not exercised during the trial itself but rather before the trial commences. Therefore, the power does not interfere with the essential adversarial process.
The fourth issue considered whether s 35A alters fundamental features of a trial by jury under s 80 of the Constitution. The Court held that it does not, as the power does not affect the right to a trial by jury once a trial has commenced. The power to examine a person before the trial does not alter the trial's fundamental features.
The fifth issue addressed the meaning of the term "offence" in s 35A. The Court held that the term includes federal offences. It reasoned that the plain language of s 35A does not confine the Commission's powers to State offences only, and the Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW) does not suggest a contrary intention.
Finally, the Court did not need to address the sixth issue, as it had already found that s 35A does not contravene Chapter III or interfere with the essential features of judicial power, the adversarial process, or a trial by jury. Therefore, no reading down of the provision was necessary.
In summary, the Court held that s 35A of the Crime Commission Act 2012 (NSW) confers a power upon the Supreme Court to grant leave to the New South Wales Crime Commission to examine a person subject to a pending federal criminal charge. The Court also held that the provision does not contravene Chapter III of the Constitution, interfere with the essential features of judicial power, the adversarial process, or a trial by jury. The Court further held that the term "offence" in s 35A includes federal offences.