D v Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

D v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (CTH)

[2018] SASCFC 33

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Doyle)

11 May 2018

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - MISCELLANEOUS POWERS OF COURTS AND JUDGES - SUPPRESSION ORDERS

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - OFFENCES AND OTHER MATTERS RELATING TO TERRORISM

Appeal against decision not to make suppression order.

The appellant is charged in the District Court with four counts of advocating terrorism.  At arraignment, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the appellant applied for orders suppressing publication of the four videos the subject of the charges, other videos allegedly made by the appellant and material tending to identify the appellant.  The appellant also sought an order suppressing publication of the names or material tending to identify his children.

The Judge suppressed publication of the names of or material tending to identify the appellant’s children but declined to make the other orders sought. 

The appellant appeals against the Judge’s refusal to make the other orders sought. 

Held by the Court:

1.  The Judge did not address the questions he was required to address and this vitiates his decision (at [64]).

2.  The open justice principle applies with less force in respect of evidence tendered at committal or intended to be tendered at trial compared to evidence that has been tendered and received into evidence at trial (at [70]).

3.  Publication of the four videos (other than the visual component in which the man in the video is not holding an alleged weapon or prop) would potentially prejudice the interests of justice due to the potential effect thereof on potential jurors (at [80]).

4.  Weighing the potential prejudice caused by publication against the very limited  prejudice to the public interest principle caused by suppression, publication of the four videos should be suppressed (at [83]).

5.  For similar reasons, publication of the other videos that may be relied on by the Director should be suppressed (at [93]).

6.  Given that the practical effect of the suppression order made by the Judge in respect of material tending to identify the appellant’s children extends to prevent publication of material tending to identify the appellant, publication of the appellant’s name or material tending to identify him should be suppressed (at [99]).

7.  The suppression orders should be reviewed at the time of trial (at [100]).

8.  Appeal allowed.  Orders to be made suppressing until further order publication of the four videos, the 20 videos or any material tending to identify the appellant; except that publication of the video component of the four videos in which the man in the video is not holding an alleged weapon or prop and in which his face and distinctive features tending to identify him are pixelated is not prevented (at [101-102]).

Evidence Act 1929 (SA) 69A and 69AB; Criminal Code (Cth) 80.2C(1); Summary Procedure Act 1929 104 and 105; District Court Act 1991 (SA)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read D v Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, D, appealed against a decision of a single Judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) took no position on the appeal, while Advertiser Newspapers Ltd (The Advertiser) acted as a contradictor. D was charged with four counts of advocating terrorism, allegedly by creating and uploading videos to social media. D denied the charges and had a history of mental health problems. A Magistrate had initially made a suppression order regarding D's name and image, which was later revoked following a committal hearing. D appealed this revocation to the Supreme Court.

The central legal issue before the Full Court was whether the suppression order made by the single Judge was appropriate. The Judge had allowed D's appeal against the Magistrate's revocation, reinstating and extending the suppression order until the conclusion of the first hearing in the District Court. This order suppressed publication of D's name, pseudonyms, and any identifying audio or visual material, including the four videos central to the charges and twenty other videos relied upon by the prosecution at the committal hearing. The Advertiser sought to have this suppression order set aside.

The Full Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the single Judge's decision except for the making of the suppression order itself. The Court reasoned that while the administration of justice might be prejudiced by the publication of certain material before trial, this prejudice would likely cease once a jury was empanelled and evidence admitted. The Court therefore made orders suppressing publication of the four charged videos, the twenty other videos, and D's identifying information until further order. However, the Court permitted the publication of visual material derived from the four videos, provided that any alleged weapon or prop was not depicted and that the man's face and any identifying features were pixilated. The Court indicated it would hear the parties on the precise form of these orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

D appeals against the Judge’s decision. The Director takes no position on the appeal. Advertiser Newspapers Ltd (The Advertiser) opposes the appeal and effectively acts as a contradictor.Background In December 2016 D was arrested by the Australian Federal Police and charged with the four counts of advocating terrorism by creating four videos each advocating the doing of a terrorist act. The prosecution case is that D created the videos between July and November 2015 and uploaded them onto social media platforms between October 2015 and January 2016. The prosecution case is that D is the man who appears in each video and that man advocates by words and actions the doing of terrorist acts. D denies the charges. In December 2016 D appeared in the Magistrates Court on the charges. It is common ground between the prosecution and defence that D had a history of mental health problems since 1997. The Magistrate made an order that a psychiatric report be prepared in relation to D’s fitness to plead and mental competence at the time of the alleged commission of the offences. The Magistrate made an order suppressing publication of D’s name or image in any form that would identify him (subsequently extended to encompass pseudonyms). The Magistrate remanded D in custody pending receipt of the report. Since then D has been remanded in custody and remains in custody awaiting his trial. In February and March 2017 applications by a representative of The Advertiser to revoke the suppression order were dismissed. In May 2017 there was a committal hearing before a Magistrate. The four videos the subject of the four counts (the four videos), together with 20 other videos allegedly created and uploaded by D (the 20 videos), had been provided to the Magistrate in a sealed envelope. They were not tendered in open court. The Director relied inter alia on the four videos and the 20 videos (collectively the videos) as tending to establish D’s guilt for the purpose of committal for trial under sections 104 and 105 of the Summary Procedure Act 1929 (SA). D conceded that the evidence was sufficient to justify committal for trial. The Magistrate committed him for trial in the District Court. At the conclusion of the committal hearing the Magistrate reviewed the suppression order as required by section 69AB(1)(a)(i) of the Act. The Magistrate revoked the suppression order. In May 2017 D appealed to a single Judge of this Court against the revocation (the May appeal). On the hearing of the appeal the Director applied for an extension of the suppression order to any video in which D allegedly appears holding a weapon. The Judge allowed the appeal, set aside the revocation order and made orders suppressing publication of D’s name or pseudonyms and of any aural or visual material insofar as it may identify him until the conclusion of the first hearing in the District Court. On 14 July 2017 there was an arraignment hearing in the District Court. It was largely devoted to the suppression order issue.The hearing before the Judge

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Again, there is a temporal aspect to this order. Once the jury has been empanelled and such videos as are admitted into evidence have been admitted at trial, the prejudice to the administration of justice identified above will cease to exist. It may be expected that at that point this suppression order will be discharged. That would not necessarily affect the children’s suppression order but that can be considered at the appropriate time.Conclusion The appeal will be allowed. The decision of the Judge will be set aside except the decision to make the suppression order made by the Judge. Orders will be made:1. suppressing until further order publication:(a)subject to order 2, of the four videos the subject of the charges including the audio and video components thereof and any transcript or translation of the audio component and any visual material derived therefrom;(b)of the 20 videos not the subject of the charges but relied upon by the Director at the committal hearing including the audio and video components thereof and any transcript or translation of the audio component and any visual material derived therefrom;(c)of D’s name or any names or pseudonyms by which he is or has been known or any oral or visual material tending to identify him.2.Order 1(a) does not prevent the publication of visual material derived from the four videos in which:(a)the man in the video is not holding an alleged weapon or prop; and(b)the face and any distinctive features tending to identify the man in the video are pixilated. We will hear the parties as to the precise form of the orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established