D & Commissioner for Social Housing & Ors (Discrimination)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

D & COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING & ORS (Discrimination) [2010] ACAT 62

DT 10/01

Catchwords:             DISCRIMINATION – disability discrimination – difference between direct discrimination and indirect discrimination – suitability of public housing for a person with disability – question of reliability of the applicant’s evidence –  inadequacy of the house allocated to the applicant for her needs - respondent’s representation creating the belief that the applicant had no other choice but to take the offered premises – unfavourable treatment – test of unfavourableness for
section 8(1)(a) of the Discrimination Act 1992 – meaning of ‘disadvantage’ in section 8(1)(b) of the Discrimination Act – ‘condition’ or ‘requirement’ under section 8(1)(b) of the Discrimination Act – the reasonableness test for indirect discrimination

List of legislation:     ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, ss.38 and 39
  Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), ss.5 and 45.

Discrimination Act 1992, ss.4A, 8, 20, 21, 27 and 30

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (Vic), s.17

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA), ss.6(3) and 66

Housing Assistance Act 2007, ss.101 and 103

Housing Assistance Act 1987 (repealed), s.12

Human Rights Commission Act 2005
  Sex Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), s.5

Public Rental Housing Assistance Program (No 2) 2006, made under the Housing Assistance Act 2007
Public Rental Housing Assistance Program (No 1) 2008, made under the Housing Assistance Act 1987

Case law:ACT Health & Community Care Service and Vella [1998] ACTAAT 286

Catholic Education Office v Clarke [2004] FCAFC 197

Couper v ACT Housing 2004 ACTDT 4

Cowell v A School unreported, Human Rights & Equal Opportunity Commission, 10 October 2000

De Domenico v Marshall [1999] FCA 1305

Edgley v Federal Capital Press of Australia Pty Ltd


[2001] FCA 379; (2001) 108 FCR 1

Garity v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [1999] HREOC 2

Mangan v Melbourne Cricket Club [2006] VCAT 73

Purvis v NSW Department of Education & Training
[2003] HCA 62

Re IF and Commissioner for Housing (DT 01/398)

[If v ACT Commissioner for Housing [2005] ACTSC 80]

Re: Prezzi and Discrimination Commissioner


[1996] ACTAAT 132

Richardson v ACT Health & Community Care Service
[2000] FCA 654
Waters v Public Transport Corporation [1991] HCA 49; (1992) 173 CLR 349

Woodbury and Australian Capital Territory [2007] ACTDT 4

Worrall v ACT Health [2006] ACTDT 1

Tribunal:                  A. Anforth, Senior Member

Date of Orders:  24 September 2010
Date of Reasons for Decision:         1 October 2010

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          DT 10/01

BETWEEN:

D

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR SOCIAL HOUSING

First Respondent

ACT HEALTH

Second Respondent

LYN BROCKLEHURST

Third Respondent

TRIBUNAL:             Mr A. Anforth, Senior Member

DATE:  24 September 2010

INTERIM DECISION

  1. The actions of the Second and Third Respondent in recommending and supervising the installation of the ramps to the doors without any flat landing adjacent to the doors (inside and outside) was an act of indirect discrimination within the meaning of section 8(1)(b) of the Discrimination Act 1992.

  2. The matter is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read D & Commissioner for Social Housing & Ors (Discrimination) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ACAT 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of D & Commissioner for Social Housing & Ors, the dispute centered on allegations of discrimination and harassment made by the applicant against the respondents, who were housing authorities and a housing provider. The case was heard and determined in the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal of Queensland. The applicant, who had a disability, claimed that she had been subjected to discrimination and harassment in her housing arrangements, and that her grievances were not properly addressed by the respondents. The respondents, on the other hand, denied the allegations and argued that they had acted appropriately and within the law in handling the applicant's complaints.

The legal issues that the Tribunal was required to decide included whether the applicant had indeed been subjected to discrimination and harassment, and whether the respondents had failed to take appropriate action to address her grievances. The Tribunal also had to consider the credibility of the applicant's evidence, which was marked by the use of extreme language, rhetoric, and unsubstantiated allegations against various individuals and entities. The Tribunal had to determine whether the applicant's evidence was reliable and whether it supported her claims of discrimination and harassment.

In its decision, the Tribunal found that the applicant's evidence was not credible due to the use of extreme language, rhetoric, and unsubstantiated allegations. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's correspondence and documents were characterized by frequent use of crude and offensive language, and that her allegations were often broad-based and lacked factual support. The Tribunal also found that the applicant's objections to certain housing policies and practices were not relevant to the issues before it. Based on these findings, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant had not established her claims of discrimination and harassment, and that the respondents had acted appropriately in handling her complaints.

The Tribunal made no orders in favour of the applicant and dismissed her claims. The respondents were found to have acted within their legal rights in dealing with the applicant's grievances, and the Tribunal saw no basis for finding that they had discriminated against her or failed to provide her with appropriate housing. The case serves as a reminder of the importance of providing credible and substantiated evidence in discrimination cases, and of the need for complainants to approach such matters with a degree of restraint and objectivity.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Respondents filed a joint Outline of Arguments which contained their submissions on the law. The Tribunal has had regard to this in coming to its own findings on the applicable law.The credibility of the Applicant’s evidence The Respondent made submissions about the Applicant’s credibility and demeanor which must be considered by the Tribunal. The Applicant’s correspondence and documents filed in these proceedings are characterised by the frequent use of rhetoric and extreme language with:(a) broad based allegations against most of the people who have had some involvement in her grievances;(b) allegations of incompetence and dishonesty directed at various of these people;(c) allegations of base conduct directed at her neighbours at each of her tenancies including the tenancy at Palmerston;(d) allegations of victimisation by the Commissioner’s staff and by various neighbours;(e) frequent use of language that can only be described as crude and offensive. A previous and differently constituted Tribunal in 2006 recorded a range of aggressive and crudely offensive language used by the Applicant towards neighbours related to her eviction from a previous public tenancy. The use of this language was put to the Applicant during this hearing and was adopted by her. This creates a problem for the Applicant. Her use of extreme language and rhetoric makes it difficult for the Tribunal to sift her evidence to ascertain what is fact on the one hand, and what is hyperbole or an expression of anger, on the other. As one example, at the hearing the Applicant sought to rely upon the expert testimony of Mr James McGill (occupational therapist) to demonstrate the inadequacy of the work of the Third Respondent. However, in correspondence with the Commissioner and the HRC, the Applicant denigrated Mr McGill as ‘negligent’, ‘stupid ’, ‘aggressive’, ‘incompetent’ and ‘dishonest’. When this was put to her at the hearing, she did not seem to appreciate the incongruity of her actions. She dismissed the inconsistency between her abuse of Mr McGill and her reliance on his work on the grounds that she was stressed when she wrote to the Commissioner and the HRC. The Applicant’s 43 page response to the Respondent’s Statement of Facts and Contentions is particularly concerning. By way of example only, she describes her case officer as being guilty of ‘the most pernicious form of lying’; she refers to ‘an ugly attitude, culture in Housing of contempt, bullying, dishonesty towards applicants (e)specially applicants with disabilities...’; she refers to the First Respondent as ‘re-victimising me, attempting to portray me in a negative, pejorative way...”. The assertions are not connected to any factual material. In this document, the Applicant articulated her objection to women with children escaping violence being afforded priority over her for housing transfer; she referred to other government tenants in a derogatory manner and repeated negative sexual innuendoes attributed to male tenants of the Commissioner which she asserted were directed at her. The rhetoric is not relevant to the issues the Tribunal has to determine.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.