Supreme Court
New South Wales
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read D'Amore v Independent Commission Against Corruption and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 473
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the states of satisfaction referred to in sections 13(3A) and 9(5) of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 1988 are jurisdictional facts. The court also considered whether the Commission's findings of "corrupt conduct" were affected by jurisdictional error, and whether the Commission had purported to make findings of jurisdictional fact for which there was no evidence, or no rationally probative evidence.
The court found that the states of satisfaction are indeed jurisdictional facts. However, it held that the Commission had not fallen into jurisdictional error. The Commission's findings of "corrupt conduct" were not affected by jurisdictional error, as the Commission had reasonably satisfied itself of the plaintiff's guilty knowledge. The court found that the Commission's reasoning was not illogical or irrational, and that the evidence supported the Commission's findings.
The court dismissed the summons, affirming the Commission's decision. The court held that the Commission was entitled to reject the plaintiff's denial that she had read the claim forms, and to consider the conflicting accounts of Ms Harbilas and the plaintiff. The court also found that it was not irrational for the Commission to take into account the evidence relating to whether the plaintiff had read Ms Schofield's email.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The defendant also drew the Court's attention to the claim forms themselves, which were said to have provided further reasons for the defendant to infer that the plaintiff was aware of the conditions of the sitting day relief entitlement when she signed the forms. Relevantly, in the bottom-left corner where the plaintiff was required to name, sign and date the form, the form reads: Member's Declaration: The electorate officer nominated above worked at Parliament House and temporary staff worked at my electorate office on the sitting days the relief staff entitlement has been claimed. In addition, the Commission considered that the box headed "Name of electorate officer working at Parliament House", being more or less in the centre of the form, and bearing Mr Nicoletti's name at multiple points in large block letters, would have been difficult not to notice (Report at 22). Counsel for the defendant submitted that the inferences arising from the forms were "so powerful in themselves" that the defendant was entitled to reject the plaintiff's denial that she had read them, without that rejection amounting to a reversal of the onus of proof. The defendant also submitted that it was not illogical for the defendant to have dwelled on the conflicting accounts of Ms Harbilas and the plaintiff, even though the ultimate fact in issue was the plaintiff's knowledge. The defendant said that the resolution of the conflict between the evidence of the two women was relevant to the allegations made against the plaintiff, one of which was that the plaintiff "instructed or authorised Ms Harbilas and Ms La Manna to falsely represent on the claim forms that Mr Nicoletti was at Parliament House". The plaintiff's position all along was that the conversation with Ms Harbilas, in which the plaintiff instructed her to fill out the forms a certain way, never took place. Ms Harbilas' position was that the plaintiff had instructed her to nominate Mr Nicoletti as the electoral officer present at Parliament House. Only by resolving the conflict could the defendant decide whether the plaintiff had so instructed Ms Harbilas - a question squarely within the defendant's remit. Further, the defendant submitted that it was not irrational for the defendant to be satisfied of the plaintiff's guilty knowledge in circumstances where there was evidence to suggest that the plaintiff thought the form was asking for the identity of the EO2, rather than the electoral officer at Parliament House. Counsel for the defendant submitted that it was open to the defendant to reject this "innocent explanation" because it could not be reconciled with the forms themselves, with the plaintiff's own insistence that the conversation with Ms Harbilas never took place, or with the other evidence tending to suggest that the plaintiff was aware of the conditions of the sitting day relief entitlement. Finally, the defendant submitted that it was not illogical or irrational for the defendant to take into account the evidence relating to whether the plaintiff had read Ms Schofield's email dated 19 September 2007. The defendant said that although the email was sent well after the plaintiff signed the claim forms, the plaintiff's implausible denial that she had read the brief email reflected poorly on her credit.