CYF16 v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CYF16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2017] FCCA 3108
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection visa application – review of Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision – whether the Tribunal erred in finding that it was reasonable to relocate within Pakistan – whether serious harm is the only kind of harm that could affect “reasonableness” – whether the Tribunal erred by failing to consider whether a remote risk of harm could impact upon the reasonableness of relocation – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36(2), 65

The Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, 1951 as amended by the Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, 1967

Cases cited:

MZACX v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 1212

MZZJY v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2014] FCA 1394
MZZZA v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2015] FCA 594

Applicant: CYF16
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 2749 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge Smith
Hearing date: 14 November 2017
Date of Last Submission: 14 November 2017
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 14 November 2017

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B Mostafa
Solicitors for the Applicant: Fragomen
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr T Reilly
Solicitors for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

  1. The application be dismissed.

  2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs fixed in the amount of $6,600.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 2749 of 2016

CYF16

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered Extempore and Revised)

  1. This is an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) made on 1 September 2016.  The Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa. 

  2. The applicant is a citizen of Pakistan who arrived in Australia on 9 August 2012 and lodged an application for a protection visa on 20 November 2012.  A delegate of the Minister refused that application on 6 March 2013 and the then Refugee Review Tribunal[1] (RRT) affirmed that decision on 23 July 2013. 

    [1] As it was then known. On 1 July 2015 it became the Administrative Appeals Tribunal: Tribunals Amalgamation Act 2015 (Cth).

  3. That decision was ultimately set aside by consent, by orders made by Logan J in the Federal Court of Australia on 26 February 2016.  The matter was remitted to the Tribunal which had by then taken over the functions of the RRT. The Tribunal then conducted the hearing on 4 August 2016, and made its decision on 1 September 2016. 

Consideration

  1. The ground in this application for judicial review is narrow and perhaps best identified in the way it is in the written submissions of the applicant.  In [1] of his submissions, the applicant provides a summary of his case:

    a.the applicant is from the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CYF16 v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCCA 3108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, CYF16, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Immigration. The dispute concerned the Minister's refusal to grant CYF16 a protection visa. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the protection visa was affected by jurisdictional error. This involved examining whether the delegate of the Minister, in assessing CYF16's claims, had failed to consider relevant considerations or had taken into account irrelevant considerations, thereby vitiating the decision-making process.

Judge Smith reasoned that the delegate's assessment of CYF16's claims for protection had failed to adequately address the specific circumstances and evidence presented by the applicant. The Court found that the delegate had applied an incorrect legal test in evaluating the risk of harm, and had overlooked crucial aspects of the applicant's evidence regarding past persecution. Consequently, the decision was found to be affected by jurisdictional error.

The Court ordered that the decision of the Minister be set aside and remitted to the Minister for redetermination according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application for judicial review by CYF16, a citizen of Pakistan, against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal). CYF16 arrived in Australia on 8 August 2012 and applied for a protection visa on 20 November 2012. The Minister for Immigration and Border Protection initially refused the application on 6 March 2013, a decision upheld by the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) on 23 July 2013. Following a consent order by Logan J in the Federal Court on 26 February 2016, the matter was remitted to the Tribunal, which subsequently affirmed the Minister's decision on 1 September 2016. The applicant, hailing from the Orakzai Agency within the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) of Pakistan, argued that he faced persecution due to his Shia Muslim background, despite claiming to be agnostic. The Tribunal accepted that he had a well-founded fear of persecution in his home area based on his religion and perceived political opposition to the Taliban and Shia militants.

The Tribunal concluded that the applicant could reasonably relocate to safer areas within Pakistan, such as Hyderabad. CYF16 contested this, asserting that relocation was not reasonable due to the risk of religious violence. He argued that the Tribunal erred in not considering whether a remote risk of harm could impact the reasonableness of relocation. The applicant's case was supported by earlier Federal Court decisions, which established a two-stage inquiry for assessing relocation: first, determining if there is an appreciable risk of persecution in the proposed relocation area, and second, determining if relocation is reasonable given the applicant's particular circumstances. The Tribunal found that there was no real chance of serious harm in Hyderabad, but failed to consider if a lower degree of risk affected the reasonableness of relocation. The judge noted that while the Tribunal did consider the risk of harm in its assessment of reasonableness, it did not delve into the granularity of risk levels below a "real chance," deeming such an approach unnecessary given the evidence and submissions. Ultimately, the Tribunal's reasoning indicated a clear distinction between the two stages of inquiry, thereby avoiding the conflation error identified in previous cases.

This case involves an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) on 1 September 2016. The Tribunal had affirmed the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant the applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, a protection visa. The applicant, who arrived in Australia on 9 August 2012, lodged an application for a protection visa on 20 November 2012. The delegate initially refused the application on 6 March 2013, a decision affirmed by the then Refugee Review Tribunal on 23 July 2013. The decision was set aside by consent by orders made by Logan J in the Federal Court of Australia on 26 February 2016, and the matter was remitted to the Tribunal, which had taken over the functions of the Refugee Review Tribunal. The Tribunal subsequently conducted a hearing on 4 August 2016 and made its decision on 1 September 2016.

The grounds for the application for judicial review focus on whether the Tribunal erred in finding it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan. The applicant argued that the Tribunal failed to consider whether a remote risk of harm could impact upon the reasonableness of relocation. The applicant's case relied on the decisions in MZACX v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2016] FCA 1212 and MZZJY v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2014] FCA 1394, which outline a two-stage inquiry in considering relocation: first, whether there is an appreciable risk of harm, and secondly, whether relocation is reasonable given the particular circumstances. The applicant submitted that the Tribunal did not sufficiently address the risk of harm in areas to which he could relocate, specifically Hyderabad.

In assessing the Tribunal's decision, it was noted that the Tribunal had explicitly considered the risk of harm in areas such as Hyderabad and concluded that there was no real chance of serious harm based on the applicant's religious views or ethnic extraction. The Tribunal further considered the reasonableness of relocation by examining factors such as the security situation, cost of living, employment prospects, and family support. The Tribunal's reasons demonstrated a clear structure in its analysis, distinguishing between the risk of harm and the reasonableness of relocation, and it did not conflate the two stages of inquiry as suggested by the applicant. Consequently, the application for judicial review was dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) erred in finding it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan.
2. Whether the only kind of harm that could affect the "reasonableness" of relocation is serious harm.
3. Whether the Tribunal erred by failing to consider whether a remote risk of harm could impact upon the reasonableness of relocation.
4. Whether the Tribunal's consideration of the risk of harm and its impact on the reasonableness of relocation was appropriate in light of the evidence and submissions before it.
5. Whether the Tribunal's assessment of the risk of harm in other areas of Pakistan was sufficient to determine the reasonableness of relocation.

Held
1. Whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) erred in finding it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in finding it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan, dismissing the application.

2. Whether the only kind of harm that could affect the "reasonableness" of relocation is serious harm. The court found that the Tribunal did not err in concluding that the only kind of harm impacting the reasonableness of relocation needed to be serious harm.

3. Whether the Tribunal erred by failing to consider whether a remote risk of harm could impact upon the reasonableness of relocation. The court held that the Tribunal did not err by not considering a remote risk of harm as impacting the reasonableness of relocation, finding the Tribunal's approach appropriate.

4. Whether the Tribunal's consideration of the risk of harm and its impact on the reasonableness of relocation was appropriate in light of the evidence and submissions before it. The court determined that the Tribunal's consideration of the risk of harm and its impact on the reasonableness of relocation was appropriate given the evidence and submissions.

5. Whether the Tribunal's assessment of the risk of harm in other areas of Pakistan was sufficient to determine the reasonableness of relocation. The court found the Tribunal's assessment of the risk of harm in other areas of Pakistan sufficient to determine the reasonableness of relocation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of CYF16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor presents a judicial review of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's (Tribunal) decision to affirm the Minister's refusal to grant the applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, a protection visa. The Tribunal found it reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan despite his fears of harm due to his perceived Shia Muslim identity and imputed political opinions. The applicant argued that the Tribunal erred in finding relocation reasonable without considering the remote risk of harm in the proposed relocation area. The court examined whether the Tribunal erred in its assessment of the risk of harm and its impact on the reasonableness of relocation.

Firstly, the court considered whether the Tribunal erred in finding it was reasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan. The court noted that there are two stages in the inquiry concerning relocation: the existence of an appreciable risk of harm in a particular area and the reasonableness of relocating to that area. The Tribunal had found that there was no appreciable risk of serious harm to the applicant if he relocated to an area such as Hyderabad. It then proceeded to assess the reasonableness of relocation, taking into account various factors including the cost of living, employment prospects, and family considerations. The court found that the Tribunal's assessment was structured correctly, separating the two stages of inquiry and appropriately considering the risk of harm in the context of the reasonableness of relocation.

Secondly, the court examined whether the only kind of harm that could affect the "reasonableness" of relocation is serious harm. The court noted that the Tribunal's consideration of harm extended beyond serious harm, as it also assessed the remote risk of harm. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant would not face a real chance of serious harm if he relocated to Hyderabad, but the court found that the Tribunal's assessment was appropriate given the evidence and submissions before it. The Tribunal's conclusion that the applicant did not face such a risk outside his home area in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) was based on a comprehensive review of the available country information and state protection assessments.

Thirdly, the court addressed whether the Tribunal erred by failing to consider whether a remote risk of harm could impact upon the reasonableness of relocation. The court found that the Tribunal did consider the risk of harm, albeit at a level lower than a real chance, and incorporated this into its assessment of the reasonableness of relocation. The Tribunal's reasoning in paragraph [84] of its decision demonstrates that it explicitly addressed the submission that it would not be reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Hyderabad due to communal violence on religious grounds. The court concluded that the Tribunal's consideration of the risk of harm, and its impact on the reasonableness of relocation, was appropriate and did not constitute a jurisdictional error.

Fourthly, the court assessed whether the Tribunal's consideration of the risk of harm and its impact on the reasonableness of relocation was appropriate in light of the evidence and submissions before it. The court found that the Tribunal had considered the totality of the evidence and country information, including the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) reports on state protection and the security situation in Pakistan. The court held that the Tribunal's assessment was consistent with the principles outlined in MZACX and MZZJY and that there was no error in the Tribunal's approach.

Finally, the court considered whether the Tribunal's assessment of the risk of harm in other areas of Pakistan was sufficient to determine the reasonableness of relocation. The court found that the Tribunal's assessment was comprehensive, taking into account various factors such as the security situation, state protection, and the applicant's personal circumstances. The court concluded that the Tribunal's assessment was sufficient to determine the reasonableness of relocation.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when considering the reasonableness of relocation within a country of nationality, the Tribunal must assess the risk of harm in the proposed relocation area and incorporate this into its determination of reasonableness, taking into account the applicant's particular circumstances. The Tribunal is not required to conduct a granular analysis of risks falling between zero and a real chance of harm if the evidence and submissions do not necessitate such an approach. The Tribunal's assessment must be structured to avoid conflating the two stages of inquiry but may rely on its findings regarding the risk of harm when assessing reasonableness.