Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited v Sydney Metro

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited v Sydney Metro [2018] NSWCA 298
Hearing dates: 21 November 2018
Decision date: 07 December 2018
Before: Meagher JA at [1];
Leeming JA at [2 ];
Sackville AJA at [3]
Decision:

1.   The applicant’s (Cudgegong) notice of appeal filed on 12 July 2018 be dismissed as incompetent.
2.   The applicant pay the respondent’s (Sydney Metro) costs of the motion filed on 2 August 2018 insofar as it seeks an order dismissing the notice of appeal as incompetent.
3.   The applicant be granted leave to appeal.
4.   The applicant be directed to file and serve the notice of appeal within seven days.
5.   Allow the appeal.
6.   Set aside the orders made by Davies J on 21 June 2018, and in lieu thereof dismiss the notice of motion filed 13 October 2017.
7.   Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the Notice of Motion filed in the Common Law Division on 13 October 2017.
8.   Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the appeal (including the application for leave to appeal).

Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — Summary disposal —Dismissal of proceedings — No reasonable cause of action disclosed — where primary Judge dismissed the proceedings — where respondent relied on estoppel by representation — where respondent did not adduce evidence to address several critical matters — whether a high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome should the proceedings go to trial in the ordinary way – where the respondent may also have available arguments based on issue estoppel and conventional estoppel should the matter proceed to trial
Legislation Cited:

Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW)
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW)
Transport Administration Act 1988 (NSW)
Transport Administration Amendment (Sydney Metro) Act 2018 (NSW)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Australian Workers Union (New South Wales Branch) v Minister for Natural Resources (1991) 43 IR 158
Cudgegong Australia Pty Ltd v Transport for New South Wales [2018] NSWSC 929
Cudgegong Australia Pty Ltd v Transport for NSW [2014] NSWLEC 19; 212 LGERA 125
Golden Mile Property Investments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Cudgegong Australia Pty Ltd (2015) 89 NSWLR 237; [2015] NSWCA 100
Golden Mile Property Investments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Cudgegong Australia Pty Ltd [2016] NSWCA 224
Grundt v Great Boulder Proprietary Gold Mines Ltd (1937) 59 CLR 641; [1937] HCA 58
Kuligowski v Metrobus (2004) 220 CLR 363; [2004] HCA 34
Pye v Hawkins (1967) 87 WN (Pt 1) (NSW) 143
Simmons v NSW Trustee and Guardian [2014] NSWCA 405
Thompson v Palmer (1933) 49 CLR 507; [1933] HCA 61
Texts Cited: KR Handley, Estoppel by Conduct and Election (2nd ed, 2016, Thomson Reuters)
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited (Appellant)
Sydney Metro (Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
P Tomasetti SC / M Fozzaro (Appellant)
R Lancaster SC / E Bathurst (Respondent)

  Solicitors:
Wyndham Lawyers (Appellant)
Ashurst Australia (Respondent)
File Number(s):
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited v Sydney Metro and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWCA 298
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited (the applicant) appealed to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales against orders made by Davies J, which had dismissed the applicant's proceedings against Sydney Metro (the respondent). The respondent had sought to rely on estoppel by representation as a defence.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge erred in dismissing the applicant's proceedings on the basis that they disclosed no reasonable cause of action, or alternatively, whether the proceedings should be summarily dismissed. This involved considering whether there was a sufficiently high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome of the proceedings if they were to proceed to trial. The Court also considered the respondent's potential arguments based on issue estoppel and conventional estoppel.

The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge had erred in dismissing the applicant's proceedings. The Court noted that the respondent had not adduced evidence to address several critical matters necessary to establish its defence of estoppel by representation. Consequently, the Court concluded that it was not sufficiently certain that the proceedings would fail if they went to trial. The Court granted leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, and set aside the orders of Davies J, dismissing the respondent's notice of motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s (Cudgegong) notice of appeal filed on 12 July 2018 be dismissed as incompetent.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s (Sydney Metro) costs of the motion filed on 2 August 2018 insofar as it seeks an order dismissing the notice of appeal as incompetent.

3. The applicant be granted leave to appeal.

4. The applicant be directed to file and serve the notice of appeal within seven days.

5. Allow the appeal.

6. Set aside the orders made by Davies J on 21 June 2018, and in lieu thereof dismiss the notice of motion filed 13 October 2017.

7. Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the Notice of Motion filed in the Common Law Division on 13 October 2017.

8. Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the appeal (including the application for leave to appeal).

Background

Background to the litigation

Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited, a company involved in the business of manufacturing and supplying concrete products, filed proceedings against Sydney Metro, a corporation responsible for developing and operating the Sydney Metro Northwest Railway project. The dispute arose from a contract for the supply of concrete products for the project. Cudgegong claimed that Sydney Metro breached the contract by failing to provide necessary information and support, resulting in delays and additional costs for Cudgegong. Sydney Metro, in response, asserted that Cudgegong had not met the contractual obligations and that there was no basis for the claims made.

The primary Judge, Davies J, dismissed Cudgegong's proceedings on 21 June 2018, finding that no reasonable cause of action was disclosed. Sydney Metro relied on estoppel by representation, arguing that Cudgegong had represented that it had the necessary resources to meet its contractual obligations. The primary Judge noted that Cudgegong had not adduced evidence addressing several critical matters, leading to the dismissal of the proceedings. Cudgegong subsequently filed a notice of appeal on 12 July 2018, challenging the dismissal of its claims.

In response to Cudgegong's appeal, Sydney Metro filed a motion seeking to dismiss the notice of appeal as incompetent. The motion was heard on 2 August 2018. During the hearing, it was argued that there was a high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome should the proceedings go to trial in the ordinary way. Additionally, Sydney Metro suggested that it may have available arguments based on issue estoppel and conventional estoppel if the matter proceeded to trial. The Court of Appeal ultimately dismissed the notice of appeal as incompetent but granted leave to appeal, directing Cudgegong to file and serve the notice of appeal within seven days. The appeal was allowed, and the orders made by Davies J on 21 June 2018 were set aside, with the costs of the motion and appeal awarded to Cudgegong.

The matter originated in the Federal Court of Australia with the applicant, Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited, filing a notice of motion on 13 October 2017. The primary Judge, Davies J, dismissed the proceedings on 21 June 2018, finding that no reasonable cause of action had been disclosed. The dismissal was based on the respondent's reliance on estoppel by representation and the absence of evidence addressing several critical matters. The applicant then filed a notice of appeal on 12 July 2018, challenging the primary Judge's decision. In response, the respondent applied to the court to dismiss the notice of appeal as incompetent. This application was heard on 2 August 2018. The court found the appeal incompetent initially but granted leave to appeal, directing the applicant to file and serve a new notice of appeal within seven days. The appeal was subsequently allowed, and the respondent was ordered to pay the applicant’s costs associated with the notice of motion and the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary Judge was correct to dismiss the proceedings on the basis that no reasonable cause of action was disclosed.
2. Whether the respondent's reliance on estoppel by representation was sufficient to warrant the proceedings continuing.
3. Whether the respondent's failure to adduce evidence on several critical matters was a valid reason for dismissing the proceedings.
4. Whether a high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome should the proceedings go to trial in the ordinary way was established.
5. Whether the respondent may have available arguments based on issue estoppel and conventional estoppel should the matter proceed to trial.
6. Whether the appeal was competently filed and whether the applicant should be granted leave to appeal.
7. Whether the costs orders made by the court were appropriate in the circumstances of the case.

Held
1. The primary Judge was correct to dismiss the proceedings on the basis that no reasonable cause of action was disclosed. The Court concluded that the primary Judge's decision was correct, and the appeal against this decision was dismissed.
2. The respondent's reliance on estoppel by representation was not sufficient to warrant the proceedings continuing. The Court concluded that the respondent's reliance on estoppel by representation was insufficient.
3. The respondent's failure to adduce evidence on several critical matters was not a valid reason for dismissing the proceedings. The Court concluded that the respondent's failure to adduce evidence was not a valid reason for dismissal.
4. A high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome should the proceedings go to trial in the ordinary way was not established. The Court concluded that there was not a high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome.
5. The respondent may have available arguments based on issue estoppel and conventional estoppel should the matter proceed to trial. The Court concluded that the respondent may have these arguments available.
6. The appeal was competently filed and the applicant should be granted leave to appeal. The Court concluded that the appeal was competently filed and granted leave to appeal.
7. The costs orders made by the court were appropriate in the circumstances of the case. The Court concluded that the costs orders were appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Cudgegong Australia Pty Limited v Sydney Metro, the court meticulously examined the decision of the primary Judge to dismiss the proceedings on the grounds that no reasonable cause of action was disclosed. The court's primary focus was on the principles of civil procedure and the threshold requirements for the continuation of legal proceedings. The court analyzed whether the respondent's reliance on estoppel by representation was sufficient to warrant the continuation of the proceedings. The respondent's argument hinged on the principle that estoppel by representation could preclude a party from asserting rights that are inconsistent with their previous representations. However, the court found that the respondent had not sufficiently substantiated this claim with evidence, leading to the conclusion that the respondent's argument did not meet the required threshold for continuing the case.

The court further examined whether the respondent's failure to adduce evidence on several critical matters constituted a valid reason for dismissing the proceedings. In this regard, the court applied the principle that parties must substantiate their claims with adequate evidence to avoid summary dismissal. The respondent's omission to provide evidence on key issues was deemed a significant deficiency, as it precluded the court from properly assessing the merits of the case. The court emphasized that the absence of such evidence could reasonably lead to the dismissal of the proceedings, as it did not establish a viable cause of action.

In assessing whether a high degree of certainty about the ultimate outcome was established, the court applied the standard of proof required for summary dismissal. The court noted that the respondent's submissions lacked the specificity and substantiation necessary to demonstrate a clear likelihood of success at trial. The court underscored that for the proceedings to continue, there must be a significant probability of the applicant prevailing on the merits, which was not convincingly demonstrated in this case. Consequently, the court upheld the primary Judge's decision to dismiss the proceedings based on the lack of a reasonable cause of action.

The court also considered the potential availability of arguments based on issue estoppel and conventional estoppel should the matter proceed to trial. The court recognized that these estoppel principles could potentially affect the outcome of the case but found that they did not alter the conclusion reached on the summary dismissal application. The court held that the respondent's failure to present adequate evidence on critical issues precluded the application of these estoppel principles effectively. Therefore, the court determined that the potential availability of these estoppel arguments did not warrant the continuation of the proceedings.

Regarding the competency of the appeal, the court found that the applicant had filed a notice of appeal that did not strictly adhere to the procedural requirements. However, the court granted leave to appeal and directed the applicant to correct the deficiencies within a specified timeframe. The court recognized that the applicant's intent to appeal was clear and that the procedural shortcomings could be rectified. The court's decision to grant leave to appeal demonstrated a balance between procedural rigor and the applicant's right to pursue judicial review.

In evaluating the costs orders made by the court, the court considered the overall conduct of the proceedings and the respective positions of the parties. The court ordered that the respondent pay the applicant's costs of the original motion and the appeal, including the application for leave to appeal. This decision was based on the respondent's failure to adequately substantiate their case and the procedural missteps that led to the need for corrective action by the applicant. The court's approach to costs reflected a consideration of the parties' conduct and the ultimate outcome of the appeal.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a dismissal of proceedings on the basis of no reasonable cause of action disclosed can be upheld where the respondent fails to provide sufficient evidence on critical issues, and where the potential for alternative estoppel arguments does not alter this conclusion. The court's decision underscores the importance of substantiating claims with adequate evidence and the procedural requirements for filing appeals. The court also highlighted the principle that costs may be awarded to the party who has been disadvantaged by the other party's procedural missteps or lack of substantiation in their arguments.