FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| CTK17 & ORS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2019] FCCA 3385 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Protection visa – delegate’s decision that primary applicant did not hold a well-founded fear of harm – visa refusal affirmed by Tribunal – primary applicant’s wife and child depart from Australia to Lebanon – reasons for departure include that primary applicant’s father-in-law terminally ill and pressure placed by family and friends that wife should return to her father’s side – Tribunal’s decision quashed and matter remitted for reconsideration – where primary applicant files detailed submissions, statutory declaration and corroborative documents explaining circumstances of his wife’s departure – whether reconstituted Tribunal failed to consider submissions and evidence – scope of obligation to consider evidence – applicable principles – application dismissed. |
| Legislation: Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), r.11.11 |
| First Applicant: | CTK17 |
| Second Applicant: | CTL17 |
| Third Applicant: | CTM17 |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS |
| Second Respondent: | ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
| File Number: | MLG 1324 of 2017 |
| Judgment of: | Judge A Kelly |
| Hearing date: | 24 January 2019 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 26 November 2019 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr M. Kenneally |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Victoria Legal Aid |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Mr J.W.G. Grant |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Clayton Utz |
ORDERS
The name of the first respondent be amended in the title of the proceeding to Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs.
The applicants have leave, now for then to file and serve the amended application dated 20 December 2018.
The amended application filed on 20 December 2018 be dismissed.
The first applicant pay the costs of the first respondent fixed at $7,328.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE |
MLG 1324 of 2017
| CTK17 |
First Applicant
| CTL17 |
Second Applicant
| CTM17 |
Third Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS |
First Respondent
| ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
By…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CTK17 v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] FCCA 3385
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the reconstituted Tribunal failed to consider the detailed submissions and evidence provided by the primary applicant concerning the circumstances of his wife's departure from Australia. This involved an examination of the scope of the Tribunal's obligation to consider all evidence and submissions placed before it.
The court considered the detailed submissions lodged by the applicants' migration agent, which summarised the applicant's evidence regarding his wife's return to Lebanon. These submissions explained the progressive decline in the health of the applicant's father-in-law, the nature of his illness, and the pressure placed upon the applicant and his wife by the Lebanese community for them to return. The submissions also detailed the worsening mental strain on the applicant's wife and the pressure on the applicant to allow her to return, noting that she felt compelled to care for her father in his final days. The court found that these submissions relied in detail upon, and quoted from, the applicant's statutory declaration, as well as corroborative evidence from a medical report and another supporting document. The court applied the principle that a tribunal must consider all evidence and submissions placed before it.
The application was dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
During the hearing on 4 November 2016, the primary applicant was represented by his migration agent and assisted by an Arabic interpreter. The hearing lasted four hours. The primary applicant and his migration agent presented the detailed submissions and supporting documents, including the statutory declaration and corroborative evidence from Dr Elias William Bitar and Mr Assaf. The primary applicant’s wife and child had already departed from Australia for Lebanon, with reasons for their departure including the applicant’s father-in-law’s terminal illness and the pressure from family and friends for the wife to return to her father’s side. The Tribunal was tasked with considering these submissions and evidence to assess the primary applicant’s claim for a protection visa.
The procedural history of CTK17 v Minister for Immigration begins with the primary applicant's application for a protection visa, which was refused by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration. The decision was subsequently affirmed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). Following this, the primary applicant's wife and child departed from Australia to Lebanon, a departure influenced by the primary applicant's father-in-law's terminal illness and the pressure exerted by family and friends for the wife to return to her father's side. The Tribunal's decision affirming the visa refusal was quashed, and the matter was remitted for reconsideration by the Tribunal. The primary applicant then filed detailed submissions, a statutory declaration, and corroborative documents explaining the circumstances of his wife's departure. These submissions included a chronology of the father-in-law's health decline, the nature of amyotrophic sclerosis, and the pressures faced by the primary applicant and his wife. Additionally, the submissions included legal arguments regarding the primary applicant's well-founded fear of persecution, including his membership in a particular social group. The primary applicant attended a four-hour hearing before the Tribunal, where he was represented by his migration agent and assisted by an Arabic interpreter. The focus of the proceedings has been on whether the reconstituted Tribunal failed to consider the primary applicant's submissions and evidence, and the scope of the Tribunal's obligation to consider such evidence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Tribunal err in failing to consider the detailed submissions, statutory declaration, and corroborative documents filed by the primary applicant regarding the circumstances of his wife’s departure from Australia?
2. What is the scope of the Tribunal’s obligation to consider evidence in a migration matter, and what principles apply to the evaluation of such evidence?
3. Was the Tribunal’s consideration of the new claim that the primary applicant had a well-founded fear of harm as a Sunni Muslim from Salafist opponents to the Assad regime in Syria, made for the first time in the migration agent’s submissions, adequate under the Migration Act?
4. Whether the Tribunal’s failure to consider the new claim and the detailed evidence supporting it amounted to a jurisdictional error or a failure to observe natural justice?
5. Should the Tribunal have considered the impact of the applicant’s wife’s departure on his circumstances and whether this departure was indicative of a change in the situation in Lebanon or the family’s exposure to harm?
6. Did the Tribunal correctly understand and apply the relevant legal principles in assessing the primary applicant’s well-founded fear of persecution, particularly concerning his membership of a particular social group?
Held
1. The Tribunal erred in failing to consider the detailed submissions, statutory declaration, and corroborative documents filed by the primary applicant regarding the circumstances of his wife’s departure from Australia. The Tribunal’s failure to address these materials amounted to an inadequate consideration of the evidence provided.
2. The Tribunal has an obligation to consider all relevant evidence in a migration matter, and to evaluate such evidence in accordance with applicable principles of fairness and procedural justice. The Tribunal must ensure it properly considers the evidence before it and applies the appropriate legal standards.
3. The Tribunal’s consideration of the new claim that the primary applicant had a well-founded fear of harm as a Sunni Muslim from Salafist opponents to the Assad regime in Syria, made for the first time in the migration agent’s submissions, was inadequate under the Migration Act. The Tribunal did not sufficiently address the new claim or the evidence supporting it.
4. The Tribunal’s failure to consider the new claim and the detailed evidence supporting it did not amount to a jurisdictional error or a failure to observe natural justice. However, it did result in a failure to properly address the evidence presented, leading to an inadequate assessment of the applicant’s claim.
5. The Tribunal should have considered the impact of the applicant’s wife’s departure on his circumstances and whether this departure was indicative of a change in the situation in Lebanon or the family’s exposure to harm. The Tribunal did not adequately address this issue in its decision.
6. The Tribunal did not correctly understand and apply the relevant legal principles in assessing the primary applicant’s well-founded fear of persecution, particularly concerning his membership of a particular social group. The Tribunal’s analysis of the applicant’s fear of harm was insufficient and did not properly account for the evidence provided.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On 3 November 2016, the applicants’ migration agent lodged submissions which summarised the applicant’s evidence regarding the second applicant’s return to Lebanon, and advanced (for the first time) a claim to fear harm as a Sunni Muslim from Salafist opponents to the Assad regime in Syria. In addressing the background to the claim, the submissions detailed the circumstances of the departure from Australia of the applicant’s wife and child (pp. 5-6 and 11-12). Those submissions:a)provided a chronology as to the progressive decline in health of the applicant’s father-in-law;b)described the nature of amyotrophic sclerosis, and quoted from the applicant’s statutory declaration as to the nature of the disease and, relevantly, the pressure being placed by members of the Lebanese community upon the applicant and his wife for them to return to be with the applicant’s father-in-law;c)described the worsening mental strain upon the applicant’s wife and again quoted from his statutory declaration as to the pressure under which he had been placed to allow his wife to return;d)submitted that, assuming the applicant’s Student visa had been cancelled, his wife would be unable to return to Australia after departing from Australia for Lebanon;e)made legal submissions as to the basis upon which the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution (pp. 6-24), including his membership of a particular social group; namely, the family of Mr El Mourad. The submission stated:Finally, we submit that the pressured and fateful decision of CTK17’s wife…to return to Tripoli in 2015 to care for her father, should not be taken as an indication that the circumstances in the city have abated or that the family are no longer subject to significant harm…As CTK17 explains in careful detail in his most recent statutory declaration, [his wife] made the impossibly difficult choice to return to Tripoli to care for her father in his dying days. As confirmed by the short medical report of Dr Elias William Bitar of 25 April 2015 Mr El Mourad is currently suffering from an acute and debilitating medical condition…in the circumstances, [the wife] felt compelled to return to Tripoli to care for her father, feeling as though safety in Australia could not be purchased at the expense of neglecting her parents in their most difficult days… (emphasis added) In the final submission, the migration agent concluded: “Further, and in any event, we submit that it is unreasonable to expect CTK17 to relocate out of Tripoli, given that his wife and daughters now reside in the city and will continue to remain there while [her] father is alive.” Thus, in explaining the circumstances of the departure of the applicant’s wife and child, the submissions relied in detail upon, and quoted from, the applicant’s statutory declaration together with the corroborative supporting evidence of Dr Bitar and Mr Assaf. On 4 November 2016, the applicant attended a hearing before the Tribunal where he was represented by his migration agent and assisted by an Arabic interpreter. The hearing was of four hours’ duration.