Credit Suisse AG v Gu (Strike Out and Amendment)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Credit Suisse AG v Gu (Strike Out and Amendment) [2023] FCA 407 

File number: NSD 211 of 2022
Judgment of: CHEESEMAN J
Date of judgment: 5 May 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where cross-claimants seek to strike out certain paragraphs of the defence of a cross-respondent – where in response the cross-respondent seeks leave to amend its defence to the cross-claim – whether proposed amendments which raise defences of illegality under foreign law and priority of competing equitable interests are futile such that leave should be refused –– Held: leave to amend refused.    
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.21(1)(e), 16.53
Cases cited:

Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & NZ Banking Group Ltd [1994] FCA 636; 217 ALR 226

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; 239 CLR 175

Australia Capital Financial Management Pty Ltd v Linfield Developments Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCA 99; 18 BPR 36,683

Black Uhlans Inc v New South Wales Crime Commission [2002] NSWSC 1060; 12 BPR 22421

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao [2015] FCAFC 94; 236 FCR 322

Deutsch v Deutsch [2012] VSC 227; 6 ASTLR 386

Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners [1949] HCA 1; 78 CLR 62

Dye v Commonwealth Securities Limited (No 2) [2010] FCAFC 118

FAI Insurances Ltd v Pioneer Concrete Services Ltd (1987) 15 NSWLR 552

Favell v Queensland Newspapers Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 52; 221 ALR 186

Fullerton Nominees Pty Ltd v Darmago [2000] WASCA 4

Galafassi v Kelly [2014] NSWCA 190; 87 NSWLR 119

Matheson Engineers Pty Ltd v El Raghy [1992] FCA 619; 37 FCR 6

Moffet v Dillon [1999] 2 VR 480

Osborn v McDermott [1998] 3 VR 1

Polar Aviation Pty Ltd v Civil Aviation Safety Authority and Ors [2012] FCAFC 97; 203 FCR 325

Tamaya Resources Ltd (in liq) v Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu [2015] FCA 1098

Trade Practices Commission v Pioneer Concrete (Qld) Pty Limited [1994] FCA 628; 52 FCR 164

Xinfeng Australia Internal Investment Pty Ltd v GR Capital Group Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 614

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 54
Date of hearing: 9 December 2022
Counsel for the Cross-applicants/Third to Sixth Respondents: Mr S Docker with Mr D Meyerowitz-Katz
Solicitors for the Cross-applicants/Third to Sixth Respondents: MJF Law Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Cross- respondent/ Eighth Respondent: Mr G Gee
Solicitors for the Cross-respondent/Eighth Respondent: Norton Rose Fulbright

 

ORDERS

NSD 211 of 2022
BETWEEN:

CREDIT SUISSE AG ABN 17 061 700 712

Applicant

AND:

MENGHONG (MICHAEL) GU

First Respondent

GREAT LANDS INVESTMENT PTY LTD

Second Respondent

MR ZHI HUANG (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

CHEESEMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 MAY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application by i-Prosperity Pty Ltd ACN 142 091 585 (in liquidation) (IPPL) for leave to amend its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Credit Suisse AG v Gu (Strike Out and Amendment) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Credit Suisse AG v Gu (Strike Out and Amendment), the Federal Court of Australia was called upon to determine the admissibility of proposed amendments to the defence by i-Prosperity Pty Ltd (IPPL) in response to cross-claims brought by the Hu Parties. The Hu Parties had sought to strike out certain paragraphs of IPPL's defence. IPPL, in turn, sought leave to amend its defence to include new defences relating to illegality under foreign law and priority of competing equitable interests. The central issue before the Court was whether the proposed amendments were futile such that leave should be refused. The Court considered the principle that leave to amend will not be granted if the amendment would be futile, a proposition supported by several precedents.

The Court found that the proposed amendments were not fairly arguable. Specifically, IPPL's proposed amendments regarding illegality under foreign law did not adequately connect the alleged illegal conduct to the obligations the Hu Parties sought to enforce. The Court noted that for an illegality defence based on international comity to succeed, there must be an act or contemplated act on foreign soil that is necessary for the performance of the contract being enforced. IPPL failed to establish such a connection, rendering their proposed illegality defence speculative and unconnected to the substantive obligations at issue. Similarly, the proposed amendments concerning the priority of competing equitable interests did not sufficiently link to the substantive claims advanced by the Hu Parties.

As a result, the Court refused leave to amend IPPL's defence. The Court dismissed IPPL's application for leave to amend its defence, except for those parts of the amendments which were not opposed by the Hu Parties. The Court ordered IPPL to file an amended defence by a specified date, subject to the terms outlined in the orders. Additionally, IPPL was directed to pay the costs of the Hu Parties for the interlocutory applications, with an opportunity for other parties to be heard on an alternative costs order if desired.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application by i-Prosperity Pty Ltd ACN 142 091 585 (in liquidation) (IPPL) for leave to amend its defence to the Second Further Amended Statement of Cross-Claim dated 13 May 2022 filed on behalf of the Hu Parties in the form attached to the Interlocutory Application dated 13 September 2022 be dismissed save only for those parts of the amendments which were not opposed by the cross-claimants (being the Hu Parties).

2. By 4pm on 10 May 2023, IPPL is to file and serve an Amended Defence in a form consistent with order 1.

3. Subject to order 4, IPPL pay the costs of the Hu Parties of the related interlocutory applications the subject of these reasons.

4. By 4pm on 10 May 2023, any party wishing to be heard on an application for a costs order different to that in order 3 is to notify the Associate to Cheeseman J and any other relevant party.

5. Any application notified under order 4 will be heard at the case management hearing on 12 May 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Leave to amend will not be granted where the amendment would be futile: see Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao at [21]; Plaintiff P1/2003 v Ruddock [2007] FCA 65; 157 FCR 18 at [12]-[14]. Each case turns on its own facts. BACKGROUNDSubstantive proceedings It is useful to briefly address the procedural context. At the heart of the proceeding is a priority dispute in respect of competing asserted equitable interests in surplus funds of about $5.2 million remaining after the mortgagee sale of a property at 10 Superba Parade, Mosman, New South Wales. The property was previously owned by Mr Menghong (Michael) Gu. Mr Gu was declared bankrupt in August 2021. His trustee in bankruptcy assigned to the Hu Parties the whole of Mr Gu’s rights, title, and interest in the surplus funds and the various associated rights to sue which are relevant to the present proceedings, pursuant to a deed of assignment and sale dated 17 January 2022 (the Gu Assignment). Despite being the first respondent in the proceeding, neither Mr Gu or his trustee in bankruptcy, Mr David John Kerr, have appeared or filed a notice of address for service. The whereabouts of Mr Gu are not known, although, media reports suggest Mr Gu fled Australia in July 2020 and has not returned. Credit Suisse AG was the relevant mortgagee and original applicant in the proceeding. Credit Suisse is no longer an active party. The surplus funds are presently held in an interest bearing account opened by the solicitors for the Hu Parties and pursuant to order of the Court are to be so held pending the resolution of the proceedings. These proceedings originally comprised two proceedings, one of which was transferred from the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The proceedings, being inter-related, were consolidated following the transfer being effected. The rationale for the transfer was to ensure that the two proceedings could be heard together free from doubt as to jurisdiction in respect of certain aspects of the claims under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth): Credit Suisse AG v Gu (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 198 at [32]. The pleadings in that proceeding, being NSD 211 of 2022, stand as the pleadings in the consolidated proceedings. As assignees under the Gu Assignment, the Hu Parties seek to set aside certain transfers of property by Mr Gu to Great Lands Investment Pty Ltd and Mr Chunshan Jing, pursuant to ss 120 and/or 121 of the Bankruptcy Act and press a claim in respect of the surplus funds. The Hu Parties’ cross-claim which is relevant to the present interlocutory applications is one of four cross-claims in the proceedings — the respective cross-claimants seeking payment of part or all of the surplus funds are:(1)the Hu Parties (the relevant cross-claim);(2)IPPL;(3)Great Lands; and(4)Jing Spring Hill Pty Ltd (JSH) as assignee from Mr Jing.See: Credit Suisse AG v Gu (No 2) at [5]. Before the proceedings were transferred to this Court, the Supreme Court made orders for discovery and evidence, and the proceedings were fixed for hearing commencing on 4 April 2022 with an estimate of five days. Since the proceedings were transferred there have been a number of developments, including the provision of discovery, security for costs, and amendments to pleadings, which have increased the estimate of the likely hearing time.THE RELEVANT PLEADINGSThe Hu Parties’ cross-claim

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

IPPL does not allege any material facts in its proposed amended defence which allege the requisite connection between the conduct they seek to impugn as illegal under Chinese law and the interest they seek to assert or their conduct in respect of that interest. Taking the proposed amended defence at its highest, I am satisfied that the Priority Amendment is not fairly arguable — it does not rise above an allegation of general naughtiness on the part of the Hu Parties. Accordingly, leave to amend must be refused. Again, I have reached this conclusion conscious of the caution attendant on the exercise of discretion in the present circumstances.CONCLUSION For the reasons I have given I will make orders dismissing the amendment application, save to the extent that the proposed amendments were not opposed by the Hu Parties. In the result, I see no reason why costs should not follow the event. I will make an order accordingly, but will condition it on any party who wishes to be heard on an alternative costs order having an opportunity to be heard, provided notice is given within the period specified in the orders I will make.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further or in the alternative, the Hu Parties allege that the payment to the Hu Parties of the surplus funds in repayment of the debt owing in respect of the subscription for the convertible debentures issued by Blue Whale (in respect of the China subscription amount) pursuant to the Hu Deed, would involve foreign exchange trading or another transaction involving foreign exchange, by or with the assistance of the same parties, none of whom have at any time been authorised by the People’s Bank of China to conduct foreign exchange trading or another transaction involving foreign exchange: [30A(p)-(r)] of the proposed amended defence.CONSIDERATION The Hu Parties oppose the Illegality Amendment on the basis that it is both not arguable and futile. For the reasons which follow, I am satisfied that leave to amend to include the Illegality Amendment should be refused. The illegality defence on which IPPL seeks to rely is informed by the public policy of international comity. Australian courts will not will not enforce a contract that provides for the commission of a criminal offence in a foreign country with which Australia is not at war, regardless of whether the contact is implemented and the criminal offence is committed. In order for IPPL to avail itself of a defence based on the principle it must first establish that there is an act, or a contemplated act, on Chinese soil which is necessary for the performance of the contract sued upon which is said to be illegal under Chinese law: Fullerton Nominees Pty Ltd v Darmago [2000] WASCA 4 at [28]-[32] per Ipp J (Kennedy and Wallwork JJ agreeing). A useful illustration of the principle in the present context is provided by the facts in Xinfeng Australia Internal Investment Pty Ltd v GR Capital Group Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 614. That decision arose in circumstances where an application was made to set aside a judgment obtained pursuant to consent orders. The judgment had not been enforced. The defendants moved to set it aside on the ground of illegality. The illegality relied upon concerned an alleged contravention of Chinese exchange control laws arising from a facility agreement that was relied upon as the basis for a debt claim in the proceedings which had been settled by consent. In that context, having concluded that the primary contention of illegality under Chinese law was not established, Parker J observed, in obiter, that the “agreement to settle the proceedings was a separate and distinct contract which cannot be impeached even if the underlying claim by the plaintiffs was arguably invalid”: Xinfeng at [207]. IPPL in essence contend that the precise boundaries of the defence are not defined and submit that there is no judgment which says that the defence does not apply where there is no act on foreign soil. IPPL points to the observation made by Parker J in Xinfeng at [143], to the effect that there are a number of uncertainties about how far the illegality principle extends, one of which is the connection between the violation of foreign law and the obligation being enforced (at [152]ff). That may be so. However, the fact that the metes and bounds of the defence are not defined does not alter the fact that IPPL has not identified any case in which an illegality defence has been recognised in remotely similar circumstances nor advanced any sound basis rooted in comity to support the application of the principle to the facts as alleged by it. An analysis of the pleadings presently in issue demonstrates that IPPL’s Illegality Amendment is predicated on allegations which do not form part of the claim advanced by the Hu Parties. Even taking IPPL’s allegations at their highest, the facts alleged are divorced from the obligation which the Hu Parties seek to enforce and at their highest are incidental factual allegations about events adjacent to the anterior convertible debentures agreement. There is no allegation that the China subscription amount was made or required to be made under contract that is relevant to the Hu Parties’ claim such that it would attract the policy considerations that inform the illegality defence.