Corbett v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

Corbett v Northern Territory of Australia [2015] NTSC 45

PARTIES:CORBETT, Jennifer

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING TERRITORY JURISDICTION

FILE NO:LA 5 of 2014 (21223534)

DELIVERED:  11 August 2015

HEARING DATES:  5 and 29 December 2014

JUDGMENT OF:  BARR J

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – Workers’ compensation – appeal from Work Health Court – worker unsuccessfully claimed compensation for mental injury – magistrate found that injury was result of reasonable administrative action taken in connection with the worker’s employment and hence not compensable as an “injury” as defined – Work Health Court failed to apply the correct legal test in deciding the issues raised by the employer’s defence of reasonable administrative action – employer had to prove that administrative action relied on was the cause of worker’s injury to the exclusion of any other work related causes – error of law – appeal allowed – decision in favour of worker not inevitable – matter remitted to the Work Health Court for retrial.

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act; Return to Work Act, s 3, s 53, s 116.

Rivard v Northern Territory (1999) 150 FLR 33, applied.
Hart v Comcare (2005) 145 FCR 29; Swanson v Northern Territory (2006) 204 FLR 392, not followed.

State Transit Authority of New South Wales v Fritzi Chemler [2007] NSWCA 249; Attorney General’s Department v K [2010] NSWWCCPD 76; Wiegand v Comcare Australia [2002] FCA 1464; Athval Management Pty Ltd v Doherty [2002] NSWCA 277, followed.

Wilson v Lowery (1993) 4 NTLR 79; Ceva Logistics (Australia) Pty Ltd v Redbro Investments Pty Ltd [2013] NSWCA 46, referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:D McConnel

Respondent:  K Sibley

Solicitors:

Appellant:Ward Keller

Respondent:  Collier Lawyers

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Bar1511

Number of pages:  32

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Corbett v Northern Territory of Australia [2015] NTSC 45

No. LA 5 of 2014 (21223534)

BETWEEN:

JENNIFER CORBETT

Appellant

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

CORAM:     BARR J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 11 August 2015)

  1. The appellant worker (“the worker”) commenced proceedings in the Work Health Court in Alice Springs claiming that she had suffered injury (a depressive illness) arising out of or in the course of her employment with the respondent employer. The worker’s claim was disputed on a number of grounds by the employer. One of the grounds was that the worker’s injury was a result of reasonable administrative action taken in connection with the worker’s employment.[1]

  2. The reference to ‘reasonable administrative action’ comes from the definition of “injury” in s 3 Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act[2] (“the Act”):

    injury, in relation to a worker, means a physical or mental injury arising before or after the commencement of the relevant provision of this Act out of or in the course of his or her employment and includes:

    (a)     a disease; and

    (b)the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Corbett v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NTSC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal of Corbett v Northern Territory of Australia, the appellant, Corbett, sought compensation for a mental injury she claimed was sustained as a result of her employment. The Northern Territory of Australia, the respondent, argued that the injury was not compensable as it was the result of reasonable administrative action taken in connection with Corbett's employment. The appeal was brought from the Work Health Court, which had previously dismissed Corbett's claim. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Work Health Court had correctly applied the legal test in deciding the employer's defence of reasonable administrative action. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the Work Health Court had correctly assessed whether Corbett's injury was caused by reasonable administrative action taken by the employer, to the exclusion of any other work-related causes.

The court found that the Work Health Court had failed to properly apply the relevant legal test. The magistrate did not sufficiently analyse the evidence, including the medical evidence, to determine if Corbett's injury was caused by the reasonable administrative action or if it was contributed to by other work-related causes, such as her relationship with Mr Alexander. The court concluded that the magistrate had conflated the issue of whether Corbett had reasonable reactions or perceptions with whether those reactions or perceptions were justified by the behaviour of others. This misapplication of the legal test constituted an error of law. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the decision was remitted to the Work Health Court for a retrial to properly apply the legal test and make a determination on the defence of reasonable administrative action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It may be noted that the psychiatrists did not place equal importance on the causative significance of events and circumstances preceding the worker’s breakdown on 10 January 2012. Dr Frost appears to have adopted the worker’s history that her relationship with Mr Alexander was a contributing cause of her injury, in that it “undermined her well-being”. Professor McLeod states that the worker “may have been very mildly relapsing”, prior to her ultimate breakdown following her competency being questioned. Dr Rodney said the worker believed that “her anxiety level began building up in late 2011 with the allegation of harassment and victimisation”.[37] Conclusions On my reading and analysis of the Reasons, I am satisfied that the learned magistrate failed to apply the relevant legal test in deciding the issues raised by the employer’s pleading of reasonable administrative action. His Honour’s findings and conclusions, on the significant issue identified in the case below and on appeal, did not analyse the worker’s contentions in the manner required by law. He did not refer to the principles explained in [20] above. He failed to make findings as to whether the worker did react emotionally or psychologically to actual events, situations or relationships in the workplace. Rather, he conflated the issue of whether the worker had reactions or perceptions with whether those reactions or perceptions were reasonable and/or justified by the behaviour of Mr Alexander and others. The magistrate did not subject all the evidence, including the documentary evidence extracted in [26], to proper analysis directed to the legal issues raised by the pleadings and the arguments of counsel. As a result, the magistrate did not decide the issue as to whether the worker’s alleged feelings of anger, resentment and bitterness towards Mr Alexander caused or contributed to her mental injury. Although his Honour considered the medical evidence, he did not analyse the medical evidence, parts of which I have extracted above, with specific reference to the identified issue. In not making a finding as to whether or not the worker’s relationship with Mr Alexander caused her mental injury, the magistrate did not properly decide whether the defence of reasonable administrative action could apply in the circumstances. The errors referred to in [37] and [38] are properly characterised as errors of law for the purposes of s 116 of the Act. Mr McConnel submits that, given the learned magistrate’s errors, I should allow the appeal, set aside the decision of the Work Health Court, make a finding that the worker’s injury was contributed to by the worker’s problems with Mr Alexander and, in consequence, uphold the worker’s claim.[38] In the alternative, if I cannot be satisfied that the worker’s injury was contributed to by the worker’s problems with Mr Alexander, I should still allow the appeal “on the basis of the totality of errors by his Honour in his approach to deciding the issues in the case and the failure to provide adequate reasons”.[39] Mr McConnel contends that the matter should then be remitted to the Work Health Court for rehearing by another magistrate to determine the defence of reasonable administrative action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established