Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Ltd v Dib Group Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Ltd v Dib Group Pty Limited [2010] FCA 805

Citation: Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Ltd v Dib Group Pty Limited [2010] FCA 805
Parties: COOLABAH TREE AUST-WIDE PTY LTD (ACN 115 559 101) and ANDREW DONALD GRANT v DIB GROUP PTY LIMITED (ACN 002 889 474); DIB GROUP PTY LIMITED (ACN 002 889 474) v COOLABAH TREE AUST-WIDE PTY LTD (ACN 115 559 101) and ANDREW DONALD GRANT; DIB GROUP PTY LIMITED (ACN 002 889 474) v KEVMARK INDUSTRIES PTY LIMITED (ACN 097 354 679); KEVMARK INDUSTRIES PTY LIMITED (ACN 097 354 679) v DIB GROUP PTY LIMITED (ACN 002 889 474)
File number: NSD 1020 of 2008
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 30 July 2010
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – whether prospective corporate lessee and fuel reseller misled by allegedly false representations as to the likely future revenues to be achieved at a redeveloped service station outlet with the consequence that the sublease and fuel reseller agreement entered into by that corporation should be set aside or varied – alleged misrepresentations not made – no reliance upon statements actually made – application dismissed

LANDLORD AND TENANT – commercial premises let to fuel wholesaler and then sublet to franchisee – business unsuccessful – sublessee abandoned premises – lessee also abandoned premises – whether abandonment in each case constituted repudiation of the lease and sublease respectively – whether other conduct on the part of the lessee constituted repudiation in any event – lease repudiated by lessee and sublease repudiated by sublessee – property owner (lessor) and sublessor entitled to damages – damages assessed as the value of the lost bargain – other damages awarded for breach of the lease

Legislation: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), s 133A(1)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 51A, 52, 87
Cases cited: Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority (NSW) (1982) 149 CLR 337 applied
Hanson v Newman [1934] 1 Ch 298 applied
James v Hutton and J Cook & Sons Ltd [1950] 1 KB 9; [1949] 2 All ER 243 applied
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 applied
O’Brien v Robinson [1973] AC 912; [1973] 1 All ER 583; [1973] 2 WLR 393 applied
Dates of hearing: 2, 6, 7, 8 and 9 October 2009
Date of last submissions: 16 October 2009
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 197
Counsel for the Applicants/ Cross-Respondents in the First Cross-Claim: Dr AJ Greinke
Solicitor for the Applicants/Cross-Respondents in the First Cross-Claim: Freestone Law Pty Ltd
Counsel for the Respondent/Cross-Claimant in the First and Second Cross-Claims/Cross-Respondent in the Third Cross-Claim: Mr DL Cook
Solicitor for the Respondent/Cross-Claimant in the First and Second Cross-Claims/Cross-Respondent in the Third Cross-Claim: Macree Law
Counsel for the Cross-Respondent in the Second Cross-Claim/Cross-Claimant in the Third Cross-Claim: Mr S Flanigan
Solicitor for the Cross-Respondent in the Second Cross-Claim/Cross-Claimant in the Third Cross-Claim: Wilshire Webb Staunton Beattie

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Ltd v Dib Group Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 805
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Coolabah Tree Aust-Wide Pty Ltd v Dib Group Pty Limited, the dispute arose between the prospective corporate lessee and fuel reseller, Coolabah, and the property owner, Dib Group, concerning a sublease and fuel reseller agreement. The issues at the core of this case involved whether Coolabah was misled by false representations about the likely future revenues of a service station outlet, leading to the claim that the sublease and fuel reseller agreement should be set aside or varied. Additionally, the case addressed whether the abandonment of the premises by both the sublessee and the lessee constituted repudiation of the lease and sublease, respectively.

The court assessed whether Dib Group had indeed made the alleged misrepresentations and whether Coolabah relied upon them when entering into the agreements. The court found that Dib Group did not make all the representations alleged by Coolabah, and even if some were made, Coolabah did not rely on them. Consequently, the claim for damages or compensation based on misleading and deceptive conduct was dismissed. The court also ruled that the abandonment of the premises by both the sublessee and the lessee constituted a repudiation of their respective agreements. As such, Dib Group was entitled to damages for the lost bargain, and Kevmark was entitled to damages for breach of the lease.

Coolabah's claim for damages was limited to a specific scenario outlined in an expert's report, which Dib Group did not challenge. The court noted that Coolabah had failed to prove the market value of certain items, which was a gap in their evidence. Dib Group's claims against Coolabah for unpaid rent and damages for repudiation of the sublease were upheld, with judgment awarded accordingly. The court further dismissed Dib Group's claims against Kevmark and awarded Kevmark damages for breach of the lease.

The court's final orders included dismissing Coolabah and Andrew Donald Grant's application against Dib Group, awarding Dib Group damages against Coolabah, dismissing Dib Group's claims against Mr Grant and Kevmark, and awarding Kevmark damages against Dib Group. Each party was also ordered to pay the respective costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application brought by the applicants (Coolabah and Andrew Donald Grant) against the respondent (Dib Group) be wholly dismissed.

2. Coolabah and Mr Grant pay Dib Group’s costs of and incidental to that Application.

3. There be judgment in favour of Dib Group against Coolabah on the First Cross-Claim (being Dib Group’s Cross-Claim against Coolabah and Mr Grant) in the amount of $370,580.35.

4. The First Cross-Claim as against Mr Grant be wholly dismissed.

5. Coolabah pay Dib Group’s costs of and incidental to that Cross-Claim.

6. There be no order as to the costs of that Cross-Claim as between Dib Group and Mr Grant.

7. The Cross-Claim brought by Dib Group against the cross-respondent in the Second Cross-Claim (Kevmark) be wholly dismissed.

8. Dib Group pay Kevmark’s costs of and incidental to that Cross-Claim.

9. There be judgment in favour of Kevmark against Dib Group on the Third Cross-Claim (being Kevmark’s Cross-Claim against Dib Group) in the amount of $251,113.68.

10. Dib Group pay Kevmark’s costs of and incidental to that Cross-Claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For all of the above reasons, I am not persuaded that Coolabah relied upon any of the statements which were made to its representatives at the 4 May meeting or in George Dib’s email of 8 May 2007. Conclusions on Liability (Coolabah’s Case) I have found that Dib Group did not make all of the representations which Coolabah alleges Dib Group made to it. As far as the representations as to signs and LPG AutoGas are concerned, I have found that those representations were made but that Coolabah did not rely upon either of them when entering into the sublease and fuel agreement. As far as the alleged financial representations are concerned, I have found that certain statements were made but that they were not in the terms alleged or as clear and firm in their content as Coolabah contended. I have also found that Coolabah did not rely upon those remarks in this category. For these reasons, Coolabah’s case against Dib Group for damages or compensation founded upon misleading and deceptive conduct fails. Its claim must therefore be dismissed with costs. The same result flows in respect of Mr Grant’s claims for relief. No case was sought to be made by Coolabah at the hearing in support of its claim that cl 53 of the sublease should be declared void or set aside. No particular grounds or arguments for such relief were put. That claim must also be rejected. Damages As I have mentioned at [22] above, Coolabah’s claim for damages was confined to its claim pursuant to Scenario 1 in Mr Thynne’s report. The amount of that claim was $1,010,401.00. The method adopted by Mr Thynne to arrive at that figure was not challenged or criticised by Dib Group. In addition, only one substantive challenge was mounted to the detail of Mr Thynne’s calculations. This challenge concerned the way in which Mr Thynne had brought to account the value of the equipment, fixtures and fittings which Coolabah was admittedly able to remove from the premises when it abandoned them on 1 July 2008. Mr Thynne used the depreciated value of those items for tax purposes as the amount which he should take into account in assessing Coolabah’s loss. This was an arbitrary approach designed to overcome the fact that no attempt had been made by Coolabah to prove the market value of those items. This was a gap in Coolabah’s evidence. Were I to assess damages in favour of Coolabah (a task which I am not required to do given the findings which I have made), I would need to consider what adjustment (if any) I should make to Mr Thynne’s assessment of damages on account of this difficulty. It is fair to say that Mr Thynne’s other work was appropriately supported by sufficient primary records of Coolabah to satisfy me that his assessment was a reasonable one, having regard to the assumptions which he made and the records and evidence tendered to prove the truth and reasonableness of those assumptions. DIB GROUP’S CLAIMS AGAINST COOLABAH AND MR GRANT These claims are for unpaid rent and damages for repudiation of the sublease. Allegations were made in Dib Group’s Cross-Claim that Coolabah was also liable in damages for breach of the fuel agreement. However, such a case was not pressed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 34 of the head lease provided:34. REMOVAL OF ALTERATIONS AND FIXTURES 34(1) The Lessee shall(a) remove(i) any alterations, additions, fixtures, partitions and fittings made or installed by the Lessee in the Leased Premises during this Lease;(ii) all signs and notices erected or affixed by the Lessee to the Leased Premises and to the Building;(iii) all nails and screws inserted by the Lessee into any part of the Leased Premises;(b) reinstate(i) the Leased Premises to their condition before any alterations, additions, installations and partitions were made or installed by the Lessee; and(ii) make good, in a proper and workmanlike manner, any damage caused to the Leased Premises by the installations and their removal.Period of removal34(2) The Lessee shall comply with the obligations under clause 34(1) (a) before the expiry or termination of this Lease;(b) if this Lease is terminated suddenly or unexpectedly, by forfeiture, destruction or other event, within fourteen (14) days after the termination of this Lease.Removal of fixtures34(3) (a) The Lessee is entitled to remove from the Leased Premises all fixtures installed by the Lessee during the lease term (except fixtures which the parties agreed in writing to become the Lessor’s property and not removable by the Lessee).(b) The Lessee may remove fixtures during the term of this Lease, during any extension of the term of this Lease, during holding over after the expiration of this Lease, and during the term of a new lease granted to the Lessee, notwithstanding the surrender of this Lease, subject to this clause.(c) The Lessee (or the Lessees successors or assigns) must remove fixtures within the number of days in Item 23 in the Reference Schedule after having ceased to occupy the Leased Premises,(d) The Lessee covenants to repair any damage caused to the Leased Premises by the removal of fixtures, or becoming apparent on their removal, in a workmanlike manner, so as to restore the Leased Premises to its condition before the installation of those fixtures which are removed.(e) Those fixtures which the Lessee does not remove within the period specified in paragraph (c) may at the Lessor’s option remain permanently affixed to the Leased Premises and be and remain the property of the Lessor.Consequences of failure to remove and reinstate34(4) If the Lessee fails to comply with the obligations under clause 34(1) or (3) within the periods in clause 34(2) or (3)(c)(a)the Lessor may cause the removal, reinstatement and repairs to be carried out, and the Lessee is responsible for and shall reimburse the Lessor for the Lessor’s reasonable costs and expenses;(c)if the Lessor incurs further loss in reletting the Leased Premises by reason of the Lessee’s failure, the Lessor may recover from the Lessee the loss of rent and operating expenses which would have been received from a prospective Lessee. Kevmark put this claim in the following way:(a)In a letter dated 23 July 2008 to Kevmark’s solicitor, Mr Wortes, of Kevmark, identified in precise terms the various items which he asserted were required to be remedied as at 23 July 2008 in order to restore the premises to the condition they were in when handed over to Dib Group (and Coolabah) in September 2007. Substantially the same details were provided in a letter dated 20 April 2009 from Kevmark to Riverford Design Services Pty Ltd. The items listed in this second letter were identified in photographs provided with the letter. (b)Those letters and photographs prove the work which had to be done; and(c)Steven Batger, a Quantity Surveyor employed by Mitchell Brandtman (NSW) Pty Ltd, quantified the cost of carrying out the works identified in Mr Wortes’ correspondence at $288,261.00 exclusive of GST. That figure included an amount for the supply and installation of an LPG AutoGas tank estimated to cost $121,818.00. Since that item is the subject of a separate claim, the amount of $121,818.00 should be deducted from the amount of $288,261.00 in order to arrive at the quantum of the present claim. Thus, the present claim is quantified at $166,443.00 exclusive of GST.