Construction Industry Training Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Construction Industry Training Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 2219 (29 July 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/2380

Re:Construction Industry Training Australia Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Skills Quality Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:29 July 2019

Place:Perth

The Tribunal makes no order.

......................[sgd]..................................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay of decision under s 41(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – relevant considerations – is prospects of success a relevant consideration? – consequences of not granting a stay – parties affected – is hearing rendered nugatory? – public interest – conditions attaching to stay – stay order to remain in place

LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – ss 37, 41(2), 42C(1)
National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act2011 (Cth) – ss 2A, 3, 21, 22(1), 36(2), 36(2)(f), 36(3), 39, 39(1), 179(2), 180(2), 185(1), 199, 200(2), 201, 203(2),
Standards for Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) (2015) – cls 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.8, 2.3, 2.4, 3.1, 4.1, 5.2
Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations Act 2005 (WA) – ss 9, 12

CASES
Australian International College Pty Ltd v Australian Skills Quality Authority [2001] FCA 2097
Institute of Training Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 4127
Madafferi v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 250; (2001) 106 FCR 76; 184 ALRD 473; 63 ALD 373
Menzies Institute of Technology and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 343
Re Commonwealth and Quirke [1986] AATA 57; (1986) 9 ALD 92
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No.2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re Gurkhas Institute of Technology Pty Ltd trading as Royal Gurkhas Institute of Technology and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2017] AATA 1018
Re Oaklands and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2011] AATA 199
Rust-Oleum Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Pesticides & Veterinary Medicines Authority [2017] AATA 298
Samir Pty Ltd and Aged Care Standards and Accreditation Agency [2012] AATA 333
Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798
Stirling Skills Training (Inc) and Australian Skills Authority [2019] AATA 1721
Sunrise Institute of Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 3935
Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 3047
Windshuttle v Commissioner of Taxation [1993] FCA 553; (1993) 46 FCR 235; 93 ATC 4992; [1993] FCA 553; 27 ATR 88

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

29 July 2019

THE APPLICATION

  1. This is an application for an order staying the operation of the Respondent’s decision to cancel that Applicant’s registration under s 39 of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) (the NVR Act) (the Decision).

  2. Pursuant to s 42C(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act),
    on 14 May 2019 orders were made by consent that pursuant to s 41(2) of the AAT Act the operation of the Decision be stayed pending further…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction Industry Training Australia Pty Ltd and Austral... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 2219
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a stay of a decision made by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) to cancel the registration of Construction Industry Training Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant). The application was heard by Deputy President Boyle of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant a stay of ASQA's decision pending the determination of the Applicant's substantive appeal. This required the Tribunal to consider various factors, including the Applicant's prospects of success in the appeal, the consequences of not granting a stay (specifically, whether the hearing would be rendered nugatory), the parties affected by the decision, and the public interest. The Tribunal also considered the conditions that might attach to any stay order.

The Tribunal reasoned that while there were conflicting accounts regarding the Applicant's compliance with regulatory standards, particularly concerning the evidence provided by ASQA's representatives and the Applicant's CEO, the Applicant had raised arguable points. The Tribunal noted that many of the identified non-compliances appeared to be matters of degree and opinion, and that the Applicant had presented evidence of significant rectification efforts undertaken with the assistance of a consultant. Furthermore, the Tribunal acknowledged that a failure to grant a stay could render the substantive hearing academic if the Applicant ceased to operate financially, a point conceded by ASQA.

Balancing these considerations, the Tribunal concluded that, on balance, the existing consent order of 14 May 2019, which stayed the implementation of ASQA's decision and prohibited the Applicant from enrolling students or issuing qualifications, should remain in place. Consequently, no further orders were made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant contends (A1, para. 15) that it can succeed in three ways:(a)demonstrating that the cancellation of registration was too severe;(b)demonstrating that the compliance issues identified in the audit report were not well-founded or have been rectified before the hearing; and(c)demonstrating at the hearing that it is fully compliant.The evidenceApplicant Two documents were filed by the Applicant which were headed ‘Affidavit’. Neither document however, was in the form required of an affidavit. Neither document stated that the deponent was swearing or affirming the contents of the statement (see s 9 of Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations Act (2005) (WA) (the Oaths Act)). Both documents appeared to be “certified” by a public officer at the Malaga Licensed Post Office. Although both documents refer to a “deponent”, neither was in the form of a statutory declaration (see s 12 of the Oaths Act). Both documents were signed by Mr Charles Posselt, the CEO of the Applicant, and I will take these documents as being signed witness statements of Mr Posselt. The second statement, dated 5 July 2019, went only to providing the information sought by me in the hearing as to the number of employees the Applicant has, the number of students that would be affected by the cancellation of the Applicant’s registration and the alternative RTO (if any), offering the same or similar courses. In paragraph 16 of its submissions the Applicant says that it has “commenced a significant rectification process” and refers to “remedial material produced by RTO Advance” with a footnote which says “see Rectification material”. Unfortunately that material is not defined or otherwise identified. I assume that the relevant material is that attached to, or referred to in, the statement of Mr Charles Posselt dated 17 June 2019. That statement, however, does not define “Rectification material” nor does it identify material attached to the statement as being produced by the consultant retained by the Applicant, Ms Bowler or her company RTO Advance. At paragraph 8 of his statement Mr Posselt says that the Applicant had engaged Ms Bowler of RTO Advance “to both review the audit report and assist [the Applicant] to rectify all areas of non-compliance”. At paragraph 10 of his statement Mr Posselt says (A2, para. 10):Having received this expert assistance and guidance, I am confident that [the Applicant] with respect to both the courses offered and the scope of its courses, is now fully compliant. No affidavit, statement or other evidence from Ms Bowler was provided as to the Applicant’s compliance or the steps being taken to address the claimed non-compliances identified in the audit. Paragraphs 12 and 13 of Mr Posselt’s statement is as follows:12. I have commissioned a series of documents to be filed with the Tribunal. These documents have been served on ASQA electronically and I rely on the Rectification Response Table provided as a snapshot of our current compliance.ATTACHED AND MARKED ‘CP-1’ IS A COPY OF THE RECTIFICATION RESPONSE TABLE.13. As I have noted above, in support of the Stay Application, I have commissioned Ms Judith Bowler to assist with the completion of all rectifications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Obviously if the Applicant did not survive financially any final hearing would become academic. In other words, it would be rendered nugatory. By its submissions at paragraphs 75 and 76 of its submissions, the Respondent, in effect, agrees that that would be the case. CONCLUSION Applying the considerations identified by President Downes J in Scott, the approach that has generally been taken by tribunal members since the time of that decision, I find that, on balance, the order made by consent on 14 May 2019 that the implementation of the decision under review be stayed and that the Applicant must not enrol students or issue VET statements of attainment or VET qualifications until further order of the Tribunal should remain in place. Given the terms of that order I therefore make no further order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Based on the above identified factors Ms Lennox says that she does not believe “that the Applicant is capable of “quickly and efficiently rectifying the current identified non-compliances” (R3, para. 26).Consideration of prospects of success Mr Posselt’s statement and the evidence of Ms Arthur and Ms Lennox are considerably at odds. While the affidavits of Ms Arthur and Ms Lennox address the material that the Applicant provided in January 2019, in the case of Ms Arthur, and material provided some time in or before May 2019 in the case of Ms Lennox, neither of those affidavits addressed the matters raised by Mr Posselt in his statement of 17 June 2019. The Applicant’s counsel at the hearing submitted that the majority of the non-compliances identified by the Respondent and referred to in the affidavits of Ms Arthur and Ms Lennox were “matters of degree, and subjective degree at that” (Transcript at 21). In relation to one of the non-compliances identified in the Evidence Analysis document Exhibit AL-1 to the affidavit of Ms Lennox, on page 19/27 (as numbered in Ms Lennox’s affidavit) of that document, there is reference to a non-compliance with Standard 1.8 under the heading “Validity and Sufficiency” in relation to the “Performance Criteria”. The statement is made that while “the organisation has provided a mapping document …there was limited information…” (R3, AL-1, 19/27). Other similar examples from that document were identified by the Applicant’s counsel.For instance on page 21/27 of Ms Lennox’s evidence analysis document the assessment of non-compliance is based on Ms Lennox being of the view that “The assessment tool provided for this unit of competency does not contain enough context or observable behaviours of the assessor to reliably and sufficiently assess a candidate…” (R3, AL-1, 21/27). It does seem to be the case that while both Ms Lennox and Ms Arthur are apparently qualified and experienced, whether documentation or practices comply or not is, in a lot of cases, a question of degree and opinion. It may well be that the opinions and views formed by Ms Arthurs and Ms Lennox are correct and will be found to be so on a substantial hearing, however, given the matters that Mr Posselt has raised, his claims that the documentation does comply and his claims that substantial steps have been taken, with the help of an apparently qualified consultant, Ms Bowler, it would be difficult to find that the Applicant’s case had no prospect of success. I am also mindful of the fact that neither of the affidavits, undoubtedly due to time constraints, addressed the matters raised by Mr Posselt in his statement of 17 June 2019. That is in no way meant as a criticism of Respondent. That is simply the fact. The Respondent has also raised a new allegation, new in the sense that it was not part of the audit, being that Mr Posselt is not a fit and proper person to be the CEO of an RTO. The submissions in this regard seem to rely significantly on two answers provided by Mr Posselt in his statutory declaration of 4 April 2017 and on complaints that have been made against other companies controlled by Mr Posselt (see [59]-[61] above). In relation to the complaints, it emerged at the hearing that one of the “plethora of complaints” to which the Respondent apparently refers (see [62] above) was in fact dismissed by the Respondent following its own investigation (Transcript at 12). The document relating to that complaint apparently appears at pages 185-187 of the T documents. That part of the T document that (according to the Applicant’s counsel) showed the result of the complaint, namely the Respondent dismissing it, was redacted. Counsel for the Respondent was not in a position to confirm or deny that that was the case.