Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 3047 (23 August 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/2656, 2018/2657, 2018/2658, 2018/2659

Re:Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Skills Quality Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member R Cameron

Date:23 August 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal revokes the stay order granted on 6 June 2018.

........................[sgd]................................................

Senior Member R Cameron

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – stay application – interim stay order revoked - Applicant’s registration cancelled under National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 - renewal of registration as an RTO refused – consideration of factors as to whether stay should be granted – public interest – financial circumstances of Applicant – whether application rendered nugatory if stay not granted

Legislation

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 25A
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 1305 and 1306
Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 69
National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth)

Cases
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
O’Donnell v Reichard [1975] VR 916
Re Australian College of Vocational Studies Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 1088
Re Bundy and Anor and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2013] AATA 59
Re Commonwealth of Australia and Quirke (1986) 2 ALD 92 at [95]
Re Gurkhas Institute of Technology Pty Ltd trading as Royal Gurkhas Institute of Technology and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2017] AATA 1018
Re Kirby and Collector of Customs (1989) 20 ALD 369
Re Kumar and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 107 ALD 178
Re Oaklands and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2011] AATA 199
Re Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798
Re Sher-E-Punjab Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 46
Re Trades College Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2018] AATA 1360
Ward v Apprice (1704) 6 Mod Rep 264

Secondary Materials
J.D. Heydon, “Cross on Evidence”, 9th edition, LexisNexis Butterworths, 2013
National Code of Practice for Providers of Education and Training to Overseas Students 2017 (National Code 2017)
National Standards for ELICOS Providers and Courses 2011 (ELICOS Standards)

Standards for Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) 2015

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member R Cameron

23 August 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd (“TEA”) is the Applicant in four proceedings before the Tribunal.[1]  TEA seeks to stay the operation and/or implementation of the Respondent’s[2] decisions made on 4 May 2018.

    [1] Those applications are numbered 2018/2656, 2018/2657, 2018/2658 and 2018/2659. A separate application has been made for each of the reviewable decisions identified in these reasons.

    [2] Throughout these reasons the Respondent will be referred to as "ASQA."

  2. The First decision of the Respondent made on 4 May 2018 under section 33 of the NationalVocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (“NVR Act”) (“the First decision”) rejected an application by the Applicant to change the scope of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3047
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Technical Education Australia Pty Ltd (the Applicant) for a stay of decisions made by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA or the Respondent). The reviewable decisions included the cancellation of the Applicant's registration as a Registered Training Organisation (RTO) and the refusal to renew its registration under the *National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011* and the *Education Services for Overseas Students Act 2000*. The Applicant sought an interim stay order to prevent these decisions from taking effect pending the final determination of its application for review.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant a stay of the Respondent's decisions. This required the Tribunal to consider various factors, including the public interest, the financial circumstances of the Applicant, and whether the application for review would be rendered nugatory if a stay were not granted. The Tribunal also had to assess the strength of the Applicant's case in light of significant findings of non-compliance identified during an audit conducted by ASQA.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the Applicant's failure to provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate that it had adequately addressed the extensive non-compliance issues identified in ASQA's audit reports. Despite warnings and opportunities, the Applicant's submissions and evidence were found to be cursory and insufficient to counter the Respondent's findings of systemic problems, poor judgment, and an unwillingness to comply with the law. The Tribunal rejected the Applicant's contention that non-compliance is inevitable in a regulated environment, emphasising the obligation of all RTOs to adhere to legislative requirements. The Tribunal also noted that it lacked sufficient evidence to assess the Applicant's compliance history over its entire operational period.

Ultimately, the Tribunal determined that the Applicant had not presented a compelling case for a stay. The Applicant had a strong case to answer regarding significant non-compliance, and the evidence provided did not adequately address these issues. Consequently, the Tribunal revoked the interim stay order that had previously been granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Also filed by the Respondent was a Statement of Reasons Pursuant to section 37(1)(a). This Statement of Reasons prepared by the Respondent’s solicitor contains extensive written submissions. THE VARIOUS APPLICATIONS MADE TO ASQA, THE AUDIT AND OTHER FACTS LEADING TO THE REVIEWABLE DECISIONS On 21 March 2016 the Applicant applied to the Respondent to amend its CRICOS registration to add three further courses.[6][6] The application is to be found that document T 67 of the T documents; it was accompanied by supporting documentary evidence which is found at document T 60 of the T documents. The Applicant sought on 11 May 2016 to amend its VET registration to add an additional course.[7] [7] The application and supporting material is to be found at document T 16 of the T documents. By an application made on 22 March 2017 the Applicant sought to renew its registration as an RTO.[8] [8] The application to renew the RTO registration is found document T 20 of the T documents. Such application was supported by evidence attached to an email from the Applicant to the Respondent which is document T 21 of the T documents. The supporting documentary evidence relied upon by the Applicant for the renewal of the registration is extensive and comprises many hundreds of pages. On 12 May 2017 two events occurred. Firstly, the Applicant requested an extension of time in which to finalise the application to renew its CRICOS registration.[9] Secondly, it made an application to renew its CRICOS registration supported by sundry documentary evidence.[10] [9] The letter seeking an extension of time to make the CRICOS renewal application is to be found in document T 28 of the T documents.[10] The application to renew the CRICOS registration and supporting evidence is found in documents T 29, T 30 and T 31 of the T documents. There was correspondence between the parties after each of the applications was lodged, which resulted in some further evidence being furnished by the Applicant to the Respondent in support of several of those applications. It is not necessary to examine this material in detail, other than to acknowledge that this series of steps concerning provision of information occurred.[11] [11] Appropriate details of the exchange and reference to the documentary evidence establishing such exchange can be found in the Respondent's Statement of Reasons between paragraphs 30 to 33, inclusive. The reviewable decisions subsequently evolved as a result of an extensive audit process undertaken by the Respondent, as the statutory regulator of RTOs such as the Applicant. In the context of this application, it is useful to provide some background to the decision of the Respondent to undertake the audit process.[12] The Applicant was registered with the Victorian Registration and Qualifications Authority on 27 April 2006 and such registration was transferred to the Respondent on 1 July 2011. The Applicant is also what is known as a “CRICOS provider”. The Respondent contended that the Applicant “has had a poor compliance history since being under” its jurisdiction. Apparently, since approximately December 2016 three decisions of the Respondent’s Commissioners have been made, the effect of which was to change the Applicant’s scope of registration.[12] This account is derived from the Final Audit Report of 14 February 2018 being T 59 of the T documents at page 2652.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant was well-warned in the course of the hearing on 6 June 2018, when the interim stay order was made, of the necessity to provide evidence to a requisite standard at any subsequent hearing. In addition to the observations of the Tribunal at that hearing, Mr Cox on behalf of the Respondent made strenuous representations to the Tribunal and alerted the Applicant that it had a strong case to answer in the light of the audit conducted and significant findings of non-compliance on the part of the Applicant. It is regrettable that these warnings and representations as to the standard of evidence required of the Applicant at the resumed hearing of the stay application have not been heeded.THE EVIDENCE AND MATERIAL BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The following evidence was before the Tribunal, filed on behalf of the Applicant:a)A bundle of documents attached to what appears to be some form of submission headed “Stay Order Concerns by ASQA” was filed with the Tribunal on 5 June 2018. Included in that bundle of documents were documents described as “Contract Agreement”; a copy of a Lease of Real Estate between the Applicant and Maliku Holdings Pty Ltd, the landlord of the premises situated at Suite 40 Metro West Shopping Centre, in Albert Street, Footscray; a lease between the Applicant and Allied Educational Services Pty Ltd, the landlord of premises situated at Level 1, 382-384 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne; a bundle of employee payslips; a bundle of letters of employment; sundry employment documentation and a copy of what appears to be a printed bank statement downloaded from the Applicant’s online banking account;b)A “Statement of Evidence” of Ifzal Syed dated 5 July 2018, with six annexures which include a copy of the Applicant’s Certificate of Incorporation; its monthly Profit and Loss Statements from December 2017 to May 2018; a bundle of bank statements; a document described as the Applicant’s “Organisational Chart” and a series of spreadsheets apparently identifying current students enrolled for various courses with the Applicant;c)A “Second Statement of Evidence” of Ifzay Syed made on 11 July 2018 with an “Appendix A”. Appendix A is divided into four columns identifying the applicable Standards or provisions of the National Code; the Respondent’s “reasons for non-compliance”; the Respondent’s “complaints for non-compliance” and the Applicant’s purported “Rectification” of the non-compliance issues identified by ASQA. Additionally, the Applicant’s counsel filed with the Tribunal written submissions in support of the application for the continuation of the interim stay order. The Respondent filed three folders of documents which included, amongst other things, copies of each of the reviewable decisions and two iterations of the relevant compliance audit conducted by its officers and relied upon by it in making each of the reviewable decisions.[5][5] The First Audit Report (VET) (CRICOS) (to provider) is dated 9 October 2017 and document T 52 of the T documents. The second audit report (VET) (CRICOS) (Final) is dated 14 February 2018 and document T 59 of the T documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Fourth decision of the Respondent made on 4 May 2018 was to not renew, under section 10E of the ESOS Act (“the Fourth decision”) the Applicant’s registration to provide the following courses to overseas students at Suite 40 Metro West Plaza, 27 Albert Street, Footscray:a)AUR30616 Certificate III in Light Vehicle Mechanical Technology;b)AUR40216 Certificate IV in Automotive Mechanical Diagnosis;c)AUR50116 Diploma of Automotive Management;d)B5B50215 Diploma of Business;e)BSB60215 Advanced Diploma of Business;f)CHC30113 Certificate III in Early Childhood Education and Care;g)CHC50113 Diploma of Early Childhood Education and Care;h)SIT50416 Diploma of Hospitality Management;i)SIT60316 Advanced Diploma of Hospitality Management;j)22251VIC Certificate II in EAL (Access);k)22255VIC Certificate III in EAL (Further Study); andl)22258VIC Certificate IV in EAL (Further Study). The First, Second, Third and Fourth decisions will be collectively referred to throughout these reasons as the “reviewable decisions”.[3][3] The four decisions concerned are contained in letters dated 4 May 2018 signed by Benn Gramola - Manager Regulatory Operations, Adelaide on behalf of the Respondent. They are documents T 61, 62, 63 and 64 of the T documents. They are also attached to each of the separate Applications for Review filed with the Tribunal and are documents numbered T 1, 2, 3, and 4.THE INTERIM STAY ORDER GRANTED BY THE TRIBUNAL The Tribunal granted an interim stay order on 6 June 2018. Such interim order is effective until the determination of the stay application. Additionally, the Tribunal imposed five conditions on the Applicant which included a prohibition on the enrolment or commencement of any new students for VET courses. There were additional conditions imposed by the stay order which cast upon the Applicant various reporting and record-keeping obligations.[4] [4] The terms of the Stay Order of 6 June 2018 are referred to for their full force and effect. The interim stay order was also accompanied by directions from the Tribunal adjourning the further hearing of the stay application to a date to be fixed by the Registry and requiring that the Applicant file and serve any further evidence upon which it intended to rely by way of affidavit, not less than seven days prior to the date of the resumed hearing of the stay application. The Applicant was well-warned in the course of the hearing on 6 June 2018, when the interim stay order was made, of the necessity to provide evidence to a requisite standard at any subsequent hearing. In addition to the observations of the Tribunal at that hearing, Mr Cox on behalf of the Respondent made strenuous representations to the Tribunal and alerted the Applicant that it had a strong case to answer in the light of the audit conducted and significant findings of non-compliance on the part of the Applicant. It is regrettable that these warnings and representations as to the standard of evidence required of the Applicant at the resumed hearing of the stay application have not been heeded.THE EVIDENCE AND MATERIAL BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Overall, given the limited evidence, the Tribunal cannot place much weight on this factor.OTHER CONSIDERATIONS The Applicant by the submissions filed through its counsel has identified two other relevant matters for consideration by the Tribunal. They are as follows:a)The nature of the non-compliance; andb)The Respondent’s view of the history of the applicant’s non-compliance. Concerning the nature of the non-compliance, the Applicant contended that it is almost inevitable that in every compliance audit conducted by the Respondent, there will be some areas of non-compliance revealed. The Applicant submitted that the Respondent’s contention that the Applicant’s history of non-compliance shows “evidence of systemic problems, poor judgement and an unwillingness to comply with the law” is misplaced.[63] The Applicant argued that the more critical consideration is the Applicant’s attitude to rectification and continued improvement, given the nature and effect of the identified problems. The Applicant submitted that the audit does not identify the Applicant as a dysfunctional or rogue operation, designed to flout the regulations or deny students education. Further, it is contended that any non-compliance history must be understood in the context of a small company with less than 200 students and 12 staff operating in a highly regulated environment without the support of a large compliance/human resources team.[63] This contention is made in paragraph 74 of the Respondent's submissions filed with the Tribunal. Whilst to some extent this contention cannot be fully addressed without a final hearing of the matters in dispute, the Tribunal again refers to its analysis of significant evidence of non-compliance and a history of non-compliance. As noted above, there has been insufficient evidence provided by the Applicant to demonstrate that all instances of non-compliance identified in the Final Audit Report have been addressed. The Applicant has a very strong case to answer and has not done so, other than in a most cursory fashion. The contents of the Final Audit Report, which identify the failure on the part of the Applicant to comply with the applicable Standards and National Code, are extensive and have not been remotely adequately addressed. Whether the Applicant is a small company or not, it has an obligation to adhere to the requirements of those Standards and the National Code. This obligation is mandated by each of the NVR Act and the ESOS Act. Compliance with the law is not too difficult an obligation to impose upon a RTO. Therefore, the Tribunal cannot accept this contention on the part of the Applicant. As for the second limb of the Applicant’s contention, the Tribunal does not reach a conclusion one way or another concerning the Respondent’s view of the history of non-compliance on the part of the Applicant. It does so for several reasons. The Tribunal does not have the evidence which would enable it to reach a conclusion about the Applicant’s history of compliance or otherwise over the entire 12 years that it has conducted business. As is apparent from the content of the T documents, the Tribunal only has evidence concerning the audit most recently conducted by the Respondent on 3 to 6 October 2017. This audit has been the subject of two reports. Those audit reports identify significant failures by the Applicant to comply with the applicable Standards and the National Code. Those failures have not been adequately addressed by the evidence before the Tribunal in this application. It is this evidence upon which the Tribunal will make a decision concerning this application.