Australian Centre for Advanced Studies Inc. and Australian Skills Quality Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

Australian Centre for Advanced Studies Inc. and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2021] AATA 1400 (20 May 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2019/5304

Re:Australian Centre for Advanced Studies Inc.

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Skills Quality Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Date:20 May 2021  

Place:Perth

  1. The Reviewable Decision of the Chief Commissioner of ASQA dated 15 August 2019 is set aside.

  2. The matter is remitted to ASQA with a direction that the renewal of the Applicant’s registration should be granted because the Applicant complies with s 17(2) of the NVR Act.

    .........................[Sgd]...............................................

    Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

    CATCHWORDS

    VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING – registered training organisations – rejection of renewal of registration – whether non-compliance with Standards for Registered Training Organisations – whether failure to exercise meaningful control – most courses delivered through third party providers – whether Applicant had adequate oversight over the delivery of courses – Applicant found to be compliant with Standards – recommendations made to improve ASQA’s audit processes – decision under review set aside and remitted to ASQA

    LEGISLATION

    Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – s 2A

    National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) – ss 2A, 2A(e), 3, 16(1), 17, 17(1), 17(2), 17(2)(a), 17(2)(b), 17(3), 31(1), 31(3B)(a), 116(1), 155, 185(1), 199, 200(1), 203(1)

    Standards for Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) 2015 (Cth) – standards 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.7, 1.8, 1.10, 1.13, 1.14, 1.15, 1.16, 2.1, 2.4, 3.1, 5.1

    Vocational Education and Training Act 1996 (WA) – s 27(1)

    CASES

    Access Training Institute Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority; Kirana Training Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2020] AATA 2470

    Construction Industry Training Australia Pty Ltd and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2019] AATA 2219

    Ielati and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2018] AATA 4276

    Re Austwide Institute of Training Pty Ltd and Secretary, Department of Education and Training [2016] AATA 266

    REASONS FOR DECISION

    Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

    20 May 2021

    BACKGROUND

  3. By an application to this Tribunal dated 5 September 2019 (T1), the Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Chief Commissioner of the Respondent, the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA), made on 15 August 2019 (T27) (the Reviewable Decision).

  4. The Reviewable Decision rejected an application made by the Applicant on 20 June 2018 (T7) under s 17 of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act2011 (Cth) (NVR Act) for renewal of its registration as a registered training organisation (RTO).

  5. The renewal application was rejected because ASQA decided that the Applicant had abrogated its responsibility to properly oversee the delivery of the vocational education and training (VET) courses it was registered to provide. ASQA also decided that the Applicant failed to properly ensure these VET courses complied with the requirements of the NVR Act and the Standards for Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) 2015 (Cth) (the Standards). This was because the Applicant primarily delivered its courses through third-party providers (known as “

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Centre for Advanced Studies Inc. and Australian S... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1400
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Administrative Tribunal reviewed a decision by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) concerning the renewal of registration for the Australian Centre for Advanced Studies Inc. (the Applicant). The Applicant, a not-for-profit faith-based organisation, sought to renew its registration as a Registered Training Organisation (RTO) to deliver various certificate, diploma, and graduate diploma level courses, many of which were delivered through third-party auspicees. ASQA had rejected the renewal of the Applicant's registration, citing non-compliance with the Standards for Registered Training Organisations, particularly concerning the Applicant's alleged failure to exercise meaningful control and adequate oversight over the delivery of courses by its third-party providers.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Applicant had complied with the relevant Standards for Registered Training Organisations, specifically in relation to its oversight of third-party course delivery. The central legal issue revolved around ASQA's interpretation of the Standards and whether the Applicant's arrangements with its auspicees met the required level of control and quality assurance mandated by the regulatory framework.

The Tribunal found that ASQA's interpretation of the Standards, while seemingly informed by best educational practices, at times exceeded the explicit requirements of the Standards themselves. Applying the relevant provisions of the Vocational Education and Training Act 1996 (WA) and the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (NVR Act), the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant was compliant with numerous specified Standards, including those relating to enrolment processes and student information. The Tribunal noted concerns regarding the protracted timeline of ASQA's audit process, which it considered to be at odds with the object of protecting students.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside ASQA's decision and remitted the matter back to ASQA to determine the period of registration. The Tribunal also made recommendations to ASQA regarding improvements to its audit processes, including investigating the reasons for delays in conducting audits and communicating outcomes to applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant’s concerns about the way the audit was conducted is not an issue for determination before this Tribunal. However, as will become evident from these reasons, some concerns do arise on the facts regarding ASQA’s interpretation of the Standards and audit processes. The Tribunal is permitted to make recommendations to enhance good government, to facilitate better decision-making and to improve government accountability and transparency (see discussion in Ielati and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2018] AATA 4276 at [40]–[42]). Therefore, the Tribunal has concluded these reasons with some observations about how ASQA could better improve its audit processes. Additionally, throughout these reasons the Tribunal has made observations with respect to ASQA’s interpretation of relevant Standards. As will be explained in the reasons below, ASQA’s interpretation of the Standards, which commendably appears to be informed by best educational practices, sometimes exceeds the requirements of the Standards themselves. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICANT AND ITS REGISTRATION The Applicant is a “not for profit faith-based organisation”, with a seven-member management board, based in Coolbellup in Western Australia (T24/130–1). The Applicant was first registered as a training organisation under s 27(1) of the Vocational Education and Training Act 1996 (WA) on 19 August 1999 and became registered under the NVR Act on 1 July 2011 (T26/179). At the time the Reviewable Decision was made, the Applicant was registered to provide 16 courses (but actually provided 15) at certificate, diploma and graduate diploma level, and five accredited courses (courses developed by private entities that are registered with ASQA as satisfying the national accreditation requirements). These 21 courses were in the areas of theology, leadership and management, client assessment and case management, community services, hospitality, music and dance (T24/131; A1 [12]). Also, at the time of the Reviewable Decision the staff in the Applicant’s central office consisted of one full-time principal and four part-time officers attending to student administration, administration, finance and the web page (T24/131; A1 [11]). Most of the Applicant’s courses were delivered by auspicees, with whom the Applicant had agreements, although some teaching and assessment in the Graduate Diploma of Management (Learning), courses in Christian Ministry and Theology and a Certificate IV in community services was undertaken by a past principal and the acting principal of the Applicant (T24/131; A1 [13]). As at February 2019, the Applicant had agreements with approximately 19 of these auspicees, although “two of [the organisations] had been suspended at the time and some had no students”. Most of the auspicees operated in Western Australia, however four of the 19 auspicees delivered courses in other Australian states. The majority of these auspicees were secondary schools or faith-based organisations (T24/131-132; A1 [14]).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 26 August 2019 the Applicant sought review of the decision in this Tribunal (T1). THE HEARING AND THE EVIDENCE This application was heard on Tuesday 28 July 2020, Thursday 15 October 2020, Friday 16 October 2020 and Thursday 5 November 2020. Acting principal Dr Woods appeared on behalf of the Applicant. Mr S Rebikoff of counsel appeared on behalf of ASQA, instructed by Ms P Singh from ASQA. Both Dr Woods and Mr Rebikoff appeared via videoconference for each day of the hearing. By agreement of the parties, ASQA presented its case first, followed by the Applicant. ASQA called Ms Trestrail, manager of regulatory operations, regulatory operations division of Perth ASQA, to give evidence on the first day of hearing, and Ms Lennox, principal regulatory officer, regulatory operations division of Perth ASQA, to give evidence on the second day of hearing. The Applicant called Ms Kylie De Meo, a teacher at Canning Vale College, to give evidence on the second day of hearing. Dr Woods on behalf of the Applicant gave oral evidence and was cross examined on the second, third and fourth days of the hearing. All witnesses gave evidence via videoconference. The Tribunal admitted the following documents into evidence at the hearing:(a)Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SFIC), revised 31 March 2020 (Exhibit A1);(b)statutory declaration of Ms Kylie De Meo, dated 18 May 2020 with two attachments:(i)a completed and signed “Assessment Tasks and Instructions” form for the unit “Provide responsible service of alcohol”, dated 21 August 2018; and (ii)a blank, undated version of the same form for the same unit (Exhibit A2);(c)statutory declaration of Dr Bethwyn Roberton, dated 15 May 2020 with attachment reproduced at A73 (Exhibit A3);(d)Applicant's Materials, A1–A134, comprising 1489 pages (Exhibit A4);(e)amended SFIC of ASQA, dated 15 March 2020 and filed with the Tribunal on 15 May 2020 (Exhibit R1);(f)Section 37 (Tribunal Documents), T1–T29, comprising 203 pages (Exhibit R2);(g)Supplementary Tribunal documents, ST1-ST151, pages 204–2,021 (Exhibit R3);(h)affidavit of Ms Amy Lennox, dated 14 May 2020, with attachments AL-1 to AL-2 (Exhibit R4);(i)affidavit of Ms Stephanie Trestrail, dated 6 December 2019, with annexures ST1 and ST2 (Exhibit R5); and (j)annotated unsigned version of affidavit of Ms Amy Lennox at Exhibit R4 (Exhibit R6).LEGISLATION AND STANDARDSEstablishment and Objects Section 155 of the NVR Act establishes a National Vocational Education and Training Regulator, being ASQA. The Act also provides for a framework for the national regulation of vocational education and training. Section 2A of the NVR Act sets out the objects of the NVR Act, which refers to this regulatory framework: The objects of this Act are:(a)to provide for national consistency in the regulation of vocational education and training (VET); and(b)to regulate VET using:(i) a standards-based quality framework; and(ii) risk assessments, where appropriate; and(c)to protect and enhance:(i) quality, flexibility and innovation in VET; and(ii) Australia's reputation for VET nationally and internationally; and(d)to provide a regulatory framework that encourages and promotes a VET system that is appropriate to meet Australia's social and economic needs for a highly educated and skilled population; and(e)to protect students undertaking, or proposing to undertake, Australian VET by ensuring the provision of quality VET; and(f)to facilitate access to accurate information relating to the quality of VET.Note 1:The standards-based quality framework mentioned in paragraph (b) consists of instruments made by the Ministerial Council, the Minister or the National VET Regulator.Note 2:These objects are subject to the constitutional basis for this Act (see Division 3).(Original emphasis.)Registration

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on the Applicant’s enrolment processes, and the information discussed with and provided to the student as part of the enrolment process, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant is compliant with Standard 5.1. CONCLUSION For the reasons set out above, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant is compliant with Standards 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.7, 1.8, 1.13, 1.14, 1.15, 1.16, 2.1, 2.4, 3.1 and 5.1. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant’s application for renewal of its registration as an RTO should be granted and that it is appropriate to remit the matter back to the Respondent to determine the period for which the Applicant is to be registered as a result of the renewal (s 31(3B)(a) of the NVR Act). RECOMMENDATIONS The conduct of the Audit undertaken by ASQA is not before the Tribunal to review. However, as mentioned at paragraph [7] above, the Tribunal has a role in promoting good government decision-making (Ielati and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2018] AATA 4276 at [40]–[42]). The Tribunal can therefore make recommendations or observations that may be used to improve future administration. The Applicant has responded in a timely fashion to requests from ASQA. However, the same cannot be said for ASQA. The Applicant submitted its renewal application on 20 June 2018, approximately four months before its registration was due to expire. ASQA then decided to conduct the Audit and advised of its intention to do so on 17 December 2018, being approximately two months after the expiration of the Applicant’s RTO registration. After a process of requesting information from the Applicant, the Audit did not take place until 11 and 12 March 2019 and yet there were more delays. The audit report was not finalised until 8 April 2019 and was not actioned until 25 June 2019. Once the audit report was received, the Applicant responded within one month, but the audit report was not updated until 12 August 2019. It was not until 21 August 2019, that the Reviewable Decision was sent to the Applicant, some 15 months after the Applicant made its application for renewal of RTO registration. This protracted process is at odds with the object of protecting students (s 2A(e) of the NVR Act) who undertake or propose to undertake vocational education and training. Such a delay could cause detriment to students who may have expended time and money enrolled in a course that is later found not to comply with the Standards and that they should never have been able to enrol in in the first place if timely action had been undertaken by ASQA. In short, the timing of the Audit and the length of time it took ASQA to conduct the Audit is concerning to the Tribunal. Recommendation 1 ASQA should investigate why it was not until after the Applicant’s registration expired that the Audit was undertaken. It should also investigate why the Audit process was so protracted and why there were significant time delays between producing the audit report and advising the Applicant of the outcome.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 2A of the NVR Act sets out the objects of the NVR Act, which refers to this regulatory framework: The objects of this Act are:(a)to provide for national consistency in the regulation of vocational education and training (VET); and(b)to regulate VET using:(i) a standards-based quality framework; and(ii) risk assessments, where appropriate; and(c)to protect and enhance:(i) quality, flexibility and innovation in VET; and(ii) Australia's reputation for VET nationally and internationally; and(d)to provide a regulatory framework that encourages and promotes a VET system that is appropriate to meet Australia's social and economic needs for a highly educated and skilled population; and(e)to protect students undertaking, or proposing to undertake, Australian VET by ensuring the provision of quality VET; and(f)to facilitate access to accurate information relating to the quality of VET.Note 1:The standards-based quality framework mentioned in paragraph (b) consists of instruments made by the Ministerial Council, the Minister or the National VET Regulator.Note 2:These objects are subject to the constitutional basis for this Act (see Division 3).(Original emphasis.)Registration As noted above, this application concerns a renewal application made to ASQA by the Applicant to renew its registration as an RTO. Section 16(1) of the NVR Act provides that: A person may apply to the National VET Regulator for registration, including renewal of registration, as an NVR registered training organisation. Section 3 of the NVR Act further provides that: NVR registered training organisation means a training organisation that is registered by the National VET Regulator as a registered training organisation under this Act. It is an offence for a person to provide a VET course without being registered as an RTO. More specifically, s 116(1) of the NVR Act provides that:(1)A person commits an offence if:(a)the person provides, or offers to provide, all or part of a VET course in a referring State or a Territory; and(b)the person is not an NVR registered training organisation.Penalty: 300 penalty units.(Note omitted.) The Reviewable Decision was made pursuant to s 17(1) of the NVR Act which provides that “The National VET Regulator may grant an application for registration”. Sections 17(2) and 17(3) of the NVR Act further provide: (2)In deciding whether to grant an application, the National VET Regulator must consider whether the applicant complies with:(a)the VET Quality Framework; and(b)the applicable conditions of registration set out in Subdivision B of this Division.(3)When considering the application, the National VET Regulator may conduct an audit of any matter relating to the application. Section 31(1) of the NVR Act generally provides that ASQA may renew the registration of an RTO if the RTO makes an application for renewal at least 90 days before its registration expires. Section 31(3) of the NVR Act provides that if the RTO’s registration would expire before its application is decided, its registration will continue until the application is decided. VET Quality Framework