Commonwealth of Australia v Wright Solution Qld Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commonwealth of Australia v Wright Solution Qld Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1575

File number: NSD 2121 of 2017
Judge: ROBERTSON  J
Date of judgment: 18 October 2018
Catchwords: EDUCATION – penalties – where multiple contraventions of ss 117(1) and 121 of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) (NVR Act) by first respondent and where second respondent involved in those contraventions – where first respondent contravened ss 117 and 121 of the NVR Act by providing, or offering to provide, Vocational Education and Training (VET) courses or parts of VET courses, and purporting to issue VET statements of attainment, at a time when it had ceased to be a registered training organisation as a result of its non-compliance with relevant standards and requirements – where respondents admitted contraventions – where joint statement of agreed facts – where agreed submission on appropriate range of penalties – where co-operation on the part of the respondents
Legislation: National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) ss 2A, 117, 121, 137, 138, 141
Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2018] HCA 3; 351 ALR 190

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation [2018] FCAFC 73; 357 ALR 55

Australian Softwood Forests Pty Ltd v Attorney-General (NSW); Ex rel Corporate Affairs Commission [1981] HCA 49; 148 CLR 121

Commonwealth v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2015] HCA 46; 258 CLR 482

Rural Press Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2003] HCA 75; 216 CLR 53

Date of hearing: 18 October 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 69
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr TM Begbie
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr SL Kissick
Solicitor for the Respondents: Gaffney Lyons & McMahon
Table of Corrections
22 October 2018 Paragraph 15 has been replaced in its entirety.  Paragraph 15 previously read as follows:  “Prior to all of the conduct, which I set out below, there had been the events and warnings set out at [47]-[59] of the statement of agreed facts. A renewal of registration audit in early August 2013, that audit finding there had been “critical non-comliacne with the …RTO standards by Wright Solution”; a final audit report on … on 18 September 2018; the decision on 18 December 2013, rejection Wright Solution’s renewal application; notification on… 2014 of the decision not to renew the registration; the …; the reviewof the further evidence in March 2014; the analysis of that information in early March 2014; and on 19 March 2014, the chief commissioner deciding to affirm the decision under s 17 rejecyting Wright Solution’s application for renewal as a RTO, notifed on …. to Wright Solution; and the … letter setting out the effect of that refusal….. The effect of all of this was that…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth of Australia v Wright Solution Qld Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1575
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Commonwealth of Australia v Wright Solution Qld Pty Ltd, the Commonwealth, acting under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) (NVR Act), sought penalties against Wright Solution Qld Pty Ltd and its director, Mr Wright, for multiple contraventions of sections 117(1) and 121 of the NVR Act. The contraventions involved the provision and offer of Vocational Education and Training (VET) courses, as well as the purported issuance of VET statements of attainment, by Wright Solution while it was not a registered training organisation (RTO). The court was tasked with determining the appropriate range of penalties for these breaches, taking into account the respondents' cooperation and admissions of guilt.

The legal issues before the court included the appropriate penalties for multiple contraventions by the respondents, the relevance of the respondents' cooperation, and the maximum penalties under sections 117(1) and 121 of the NVR Act. The court considered the submissions by both parties on the appropriate range of penalties and the agreed submissions on penalty. It also considered the principle of penalty discount for cooperation as established in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation.

The court found that Wright Solution had contravened sections 117(1) and 121 of the NVR Act on multiple occasions, resulting in 43 contraventions. The court determined the penalties for these contraventions, taking into account the respondents' cooperation and admissions. The court found that Wright Solution should be subject to a total penalty of $180,000, with Mr Wright personally liable for a penalty of $69,750. The court also ordered that the respondents pay the applicant's costs in the agreed lump sum of $75,000.

The court's reasoning was based on the statutory provisions of the NVR Act, the terms of the respondents' cooperation, and the principles of penalty discount for cooperation. The court found that the penalties proposed by the applicant were appropriate, but adjusted the discount for cooperation from 30% to 25%. This resulted in the final orders being made against Wright Solution and Mr Wright for the specified penalties and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Wright Solution pay to the Commonwealth pecuniary penalties pursuant to s 137 of the NVR Act for each of the contraventions of ss 117(1) and 121 of the NVR Act described in declarations 1 to 4 above in a total amount of $180,000.

2. Mr Wright pay to the Commonwealth pecuniary penalties pursuant to s 137 of the NVR Act for each of the contraventions of s 138 of the NVR Act described in declaration 5 above in a total amount of $69,750.

3. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs in the agreed lump sum of $75,000.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 September 2018, the applicant filed its written submissions as to the appropriate range of penalties. On 11 October 2018, the respondent filed its written submissions, adopting the applicant’s submissions on the appropriate range of penalties. I also note that the applicant handed up an updated table of submissions on penalty.The facts Based on the statement of agreed facts and adopting much of its language, I find as follows. The first respondent admitted 43 contraventions of the NVR Act arising from its continuing to operate as a training organisation, despite losing its registration to do so. It offered to provide training services in relation to VET courses or parts of VET courses, and provided such training, contrary to s 117(1). It also purported to issue VET statements of attainment contrary to s 121. Mr Wright, the director of Wright Solution, was involved in each of its contraventions and is thereby separately liable to penalties for them under s 138(2) of the NVR Act. Prior to all of the conduct, there had been the events and warnings set out at [47]-[59] of the statement of agreed facts. These included a renewal of registration audit in early August 2013, that audit finding there had been “critical non-compliance with the NVR RTO standards by Wright Solution”; a finalised audit report on 14 December 2013, after having regard to the rectification evidence provided by Wright Solution on 18 September 2013; the decision on 18 December 2013, rejecting Wright Solution’s renewal application; notification on 16 January 2014 of the decision not to renew the registration; the application on 14 February 2014 by Mr Wright for reconsideration of the reviewable decision; the review of the further evidence in March 2014; the analysis of that evidence in early March 2014; on 19 March 2014, the chief commissioner deciding to affirm the decision under s 17, rejecting Wright Solution’s application for renewal of registration as a RTO; notification on 26 March 2014 by letter to Wright Solution; and, significantly, the terms of that letter of 26 March 2014 setting out the effect of the expiry of the organisation’s registration, a number of important legal obligations requiring immediate attention and that the organisation would no longer be a RTO it being then necessary to remove all references from the organisation’s advertising and marketing material. The effect of all of that was that from and after 20 April 2014, Wright Solution was not a RTO. The first three groups of contraventions by Wright Solution involved its conduct in relation the Toowoomba Regional Council (Council). The first group of contraventions occurred when Wright Solution offered to provide VET courses, and parts of VET courses, to the Council when it was not a RTO by entering into a contract with the Council to be a preferred supplier for training services (the Preferred Supplier Contract) in May 2014. Wright Solution thereby offered to provide 19 separate courses (the Offered Courses) to the Council in Queensland during the period 5 May 2014 to 5 May 2015. Each of the Offered Courses were VET courses, or parts of VET courses. In May 2014, Wright Solution was not a RTO and was not authorised to provide, or offer to provide, VET courses or parts of VET courses. Wright Solution had previously been advised by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA) on 26 March 2014 that it would cease to be a RTO on 28 April 2014 and that penalties applied to organisations that falsely held themselves out as being RTOs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This leaves the question of costs. The applicant submitted that, consistent with the usual practice, Wright Solution and Mr Wright ought to be ordered to pay the applicant’s costs of these proceedings. In the respondents’ written submissions they submitted that it was anticipated that there would be an agreement on costs. The parties have informed me that such an agreement has eventuated this morning.Conclusion and orders I make the declarations as sought and I order each of the respondents to pay the pecuniary penalties as stated above. I order that the respondents pay the applicant’s costs in the agreed lump sum of $75,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In consequence of these submissions on behalf of the respondents, the applicant amended its table on penalty in light of what it accepted demonstrated a further willingness on the part of the respondents to co-operate in the proceeding in an effort to reduce the time and costs involved in the hearing. The applicant’s submissions on penalty filed on 20 September 2018 suggested that the respondents should receive a discount on penalty in the order of 20% to reflect their level of co-operation. Having regard to this additional co-operation, the applicant submitted that a discount on penalty in the order of 30% would be appropriate. The applicant submitted an updated table setting out the revised proposed penalty ranges the applicant intended to seek from each of the respondents. Consideration In light of the submissions of the parties, the terms of s 137(3) of the NVR Act and the recent consideration of principle in Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation [2018] FCAFC 73; 357 ALR 55 at [226]-[237], I turn first to the contraventions by Wright Solution. In relation to the provision of 19 VET courses or parts of VET courses to the Council by entering into the Preferred Supplier Contract on 15 May 2014, there were 19 contraventions of s 117(1) with the maximum penalty for each contravention being $102,000. I regard this as one course of conduct and I consider that the penalty range put forward is appropriate. I determine the penalty for the 19 contraventions is $110,000. In relation to the provision of part of a VET course to 12 employees of the Council, there were in the period May to July 2014 12 contraventions of s 117(1) with the maximum penalty for each contravention being $102,000. I regard this as one course of conduct and I consider that the penalty range put forward is appropriate. I determine the penalty for the 12 contraventions is $20,000. I next consider the contraventions of s 121 constituted by Wright Solution purporting to issue 11 VET statements of attainment to 11 employees of the Council on 10 July 2014. The maximum penalty for each contravention is $102,000. I regard this as one course of conduct. I consider the penalty range put forward is appropriate. I determine the penalty for the 11 contraventions is $85,000. Fourth and last in relation to Wright Solution, I consider the single contravention of s 117(1) constituted by the company, in July to August 2014, providing part of a VET course to Ms Skinner. The maximum penalty is $102,000. I consider the penalty range is appropriate. I determine the penalty for the contravention is $25,000. The total penalty in respect of Wright Solution is therefore $240,000. I do not accept as appropriate the co-operation discount of 30% put forward by the applicant and consider that the appropriate discount is 25%. This gives a total penalty in respect of Wright Solution of $180,000. I next turn to the contraventions by Mr Wright. I note that Mr Wright personally signed the Preferred Supplier Contract in which Wright Solution offered to provide 19 VET courses or parts of VET courses to the Council in May 2014. There are 19 contraventions. The penalty for each contravention is $102,000. I accept that this was a single course of conduct. I regard the penalty range put forward as appropriate. I determine the penalty for the contraventions is $50,000.