Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Groves

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA v GROVES

[2012] SASC 110

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

3 July 2012

TRADE AND COMMERCE - COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT OR FALSE REPRESENTATIONS - FALSE REPRESENTATIONS GENERALLY

TRADE AND COMMERCE - COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT OR FALSE REPRESENTATIONS - CHARACTER OR ATTRIBUTES OF CONDUCT OR REPRESENTATION - RELIANCE, INDUCEMENT AND CAUSATION

TRADE AND COMMERCE - COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION - ENFORCEMENT AND REMEDIES - ACTIONS FOR DAMAGES - CAUSATION

TRADE AND COMMERCE - COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION - ENFORCEMENT AND REMEDIES - ACTIONS FOR DAMAGES - ASSESSMENT OR AVAILABILITY OF DAMAGES - WHAT LOSS OR DAMAGE RECOVERABLE  - LOST COMMERCIAL OPPORTUNITY

TRADE AND COMMERCE - COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION - ENFORCEMENT AND REMEDIES - OTHER ORDERS OR RELIEF  - COMPENSATORY ORDERS

The plaintiff claims $7.9 million principal and interest payable by the defendant.  The defendant counterclaims for damages of $7.5 million and other relief for misleading conduct.

In September 2006, the plaintiff lent to the defendant $4 million (later $5 million) on an unsecured basis to fund the purchase of the Adelaide Dome.  In February 2008, the defendant lost his major asset (shares in ABC Learning Centres which he had jointly founded).  The plaintiff asked the defendant for security.  The defendant told the plaintiff that he intended to sell the Dome and asked the plaintiff to prepare a mortgage over the Dome.  In May 2008, the defendant granted a mortgage over the Dome to the plaintiff.

The defendant alleges that two representations induced him to enter into subsequent facility agreements with the plaintiff, grant the mortgage and not to refinance the loan under a secure long term facility with an alternative financier which he would otherwise have done.

The first alleged representation was that in March 2008 the defendant told the plaintiff’s executive manager that he would need a 3 to 5 year facility if he could not sell the Dome and the manager responded that it would not be a problem subject to security and valuation of the Dome.

The second alleged representation was that in May 2008 the defendant told the executive manager that he would need a longer term facility if he did not sell the Dome and the manager responded that the plaintiff’s credit officers saw no problem with this and there was no danger that he would not be granted a longer term facility in the future if he needed it.

In September 2008, the defendant lost his employment.  In early 2009 his prospect of selling the Dome fell through and he ceased paying interest to the plaintiff.

The defendant claims damages of $7.5 million, comprising:

(a) $1.5 million in additional interest incurred to the plaintiff compared to an alternative facility;

(b) loss of the opportunity to earn $1.5 million in additional…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Groves and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Groves, the Federal Court of Australia was presented with a case concerning allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (the Bank) alleged that Mr Groves, the owner of the Adelaide Dome, had entered into a mortgage agreement with misleading representations, and subsequently failed to disclose the possession of a duplicate certificate of title, thereby breaching the terms of the mortgage agreement. The Bank sought damages for losses incurred due to the alleged misleading conduct, as well as an order for Mr Groves to produce the duplicate certificate of title.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether Mr Groves had indeed made misleading representations to the Bank and if so, whether these representations caused Mr Groves to incur any loss by staying with the Bank instead of seeking alternative financing. The court also needed to determine the extent of any loss suffered by Mr Groves as a result of the alleged misleading conduct and the appropriate remedy, including potential damages and an order for the production of the duplicate certificate of title.

The court found that Mr Groves had not proven on the balance of probabilities that he made the alleged misleading representations to the Bank. Even if the representations had been made, the court held that they would have constituted misleading conduct within the meaning of section 18 of the ACL. However, the court further determined that Mr Groves had not established that these representations, if they occurred, caused him to incur any loss by staying with the Bank. The court held that even if the representations had been misleading and caused a loss, the Bank was entitled to damages for the interest differential and loss of opportunity to earn revenue. The court also ordered Mr Groves to produce the duplicate certificate of title to enable the Bank to register its mortgage.

In summary, the court dismissed the Bank's claims for misleading conduct and awarded the Bank damages of $7,951,024.65 plus interest from a specified date to the date of judgment, along with an order for Mr Groves to produce the duplicate certificate of title.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On 13 October 2008, Mr Flude sent an internal email to Mr Cook and others within the Bank saying that he preferred to have the security documents (doubled sided mortgage) back from Mr Groves before intimating to him that the Bank would not further extend his facility. I do not consider that this reflects adversely on Mr Flude’s honesty any more than Mr Groves’ conduct in not disclosing to the Bank in late 2008/early 2009 that he had decided not to produce the duplicate certificate of title to the Bank once it was in his possession. 3. Background facts to December 2007Commonwealth Bank personnel The Institutional Banking division was at the material times the division within the Commonwealth Bank responsible for listed companies and large private companies. Personnel dealing with clients were divided into three areas. 1.The Relationship or Sales area was responsible for the relationship with clients. Sales personnel determined the terms (including fees and interest rates) and recommended the grant, extension or renewal of facilities to clients.2.The Risk area was responsible for assessing credit risk and making the ultimate decision on the grant, extension or renewal of facilities to clients.3.The Credit Management area was responsible for troublesome and impaired loans referred by the Sales/Risk areas. In the normal course of business, personnel in the Sales and Risk areas worked together in relation to a given client. If a client’s facilities were transferred to the Credit Management area, that area took over the entire responsibility for that client within the Bank. Within the Relationship area:1.Mr Klein was a Relationship Executive based in the Sales area of Institutional Banking in Queensland (until December 2007). 2.Mr Klein (and two other Relationship Executives) reported to Mr Flude, who was an Executive Manager in the Sales area of Institutional Banking in Queensland (until December 2008). Mr Flude was initially the Executive Manager and later was one of two Executive Managers in Queensland.3.Mr Flude reported to Mr Allen, who was Head of Institutional Banking Queensland (from May 2007 onwards). Approximately five Relationship Executives reported directly to the Head of Institutional Banking Queensland until the appointment of the second Executive Manager.4.Mr Allen reported to Mr Green, who was General Manager Institutional Banking (Australia-wide and based in Sydney). Within the Risk area:1.Mr Hallinan and (from 2007 onwards) Mr Davies were Risk Executives in the Risk area of Institutional Banking in Queensland. 2.Mr Hallinan and Mr Davies reported to Mr Cook, who was Executive Manager Risk Queensland. Mr Cook was responsible generally for Risk in Queensland. 3.Mr Cook reported (from February 2007) to Mr Williams, who was General Manager Risk Management (Australia-wide and based in Sydney). Within the Credit Management area:1.Mr Olsen was a Senior Manager based in Queensland and Mr Gugerly was a Senior Manager based in New South Wales.2.Mr Olsen reported to Mr Watts, who was Executive Manager, Credit Management Queensland and was generally responsible for credit management in Queensland.Mr Groves

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLUE J
The Bank also seeks an order that Mr Groves produce the duplicate certificate of title to enable the Bank to register its mortgage. If Mr Groves were to be unsuccessful in his counterclaim, he did not resist an order that he produce the duplicate certificate of title for that purpose. Clause A18.1 of the standard terms incorporated into the mortgage executed by Mr Groves contains a covenant that the mortgagor will deposit with the Bank any documents of title relating to the property. Subject only to Mr Groves’ counterclaim, it is appropriate to make an order that Mr Groves produce the duplicate certificate of title to enable the Bank to register its mortgage. 15. Conclusion I find that Mr Groves has not proved on the balance of probabilities that Mr Flude made the alleged representations. If (contrary to my conclusion) the representations were made, they would have been misleading and made in trade or commerce within the meaning of section 52 of the Trade Practices Act. If (contrary to my conclusion) the representations were made, Mr Groves had not proved on the balance of probabilities that they caused him loss and in particular caused him to stay with the Bank and not seek an alternative long term facility or that he would otherwise have obtained such a facility before 30 September 2008. If (contrary to my conclusion) the representations were made and caused Mr Groves to stay with the Bank and not seek an alternative long term facility which he would otherwise have obtained, Mr Groves has suffered a loss of:1.$1,286,139 by way of interest differential; and2.$271,670 loss of opportunity to earn revenue plus $27,720 loss of use of monies;but has not proved he suffered any loss of opportunity in respect of the capital value of the Dome. If (contrary to my conclusion) the representations were made and caused Mr Groves not to seek an alternative long term facility which he would otherwise have obtained and Mr Groves has suffered a loss of opportunity in respect of the capital value of the Dome, the value of the loss of opportunity is $850,000. The Bank is entitled to judgment for $7,951,024.65 plus interest calculated from 29 February 2012 to the date of judgment. The Bank is entitled to an order that Mr Groves produce the duplicate certificate of title to enable the Bank to register its mortgage. I will hear the parties in relation to final orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLUE J

In September 2006, settlement took place on the purchase. Mr Groves retained the Dome and immediately transferred the Adelaide 36ers to Dr Hemmerling for no consideration. Operation of Adelaide DomeDr Hemmerling/ADPL September 2006 to October 2009 From settlement of the purchase by Mr Groves in September 2006, ADPL operated the stadium. ADPL received all revenue generated by the stadium, including rent and usage fees paid by the tenants, users and sponsors. ADPL met all expenses incurred in operating the stadium. Mr Groves personally received no revenue as a result of his ownership of the Dome, and met the costs of interest on the CBA facility together with building insurance (and sometimes rates and taxes). While Mr Groves was initially the director and shareholder of ADPL, in practice he left the management of ADPL and therefore of Adelaide Dome to Dr Hemmerling. In May 2007, Mr Groves transferred the shares in ADPL to Dr Hemmerling and Dr Hemmerling replaced him as the director. Mr Groves gave evidence, which I accept, that the informal arrangement between Dr Hemmerling and himself was that any profit or loss of ADPL in operating the Dome would be to the account of Mr Groves (rather than Dr Hemmerling). This was reflected in Mr Groves’ writing off a “loan” of $200,000 to ADPL in the 2008 year.Mr Bell/ADPL November 2009 to January 2010 In November 2009, Mr Bell acquired ADPL from Dr Hemmerling. He took over the effective management of the Dome. On 1 November 2009, Mr Groves and Mr Bell signed a memorandum of understanding. It provided for Mr Groves to grant a lease to ADPL and to procure the current tenants to enter into subleases with ADPL. In the first year of the lease, Mr Groves was to pay a cash rental incentive of $100,000 to ADPL. It was agreed that Mr Bell would become the sole shareholder and director of ADPL and that ADPL would pay him a salary of $60,000 per annum plus bonuses (and implicitly that any profit generated by ADPL would be to the account of Mr Groves rather than Mr Bell). Mr Groves gave evidence, which I accept, that the informal arrangement between Mr Bell and himself was that any profit or loss of ADPL in operating the Dome would be to the account of Mr Groves (rather than Mr Bell), subject to the arrangements for remuneration to Mr Bell reflected in the memorandum of understanding. This explains what otherwise appear to be very confused provisions of the memorandum of understanding.CBA January to March 2010 On 8 January 2010, CBA went into possession of the Dome as mortgagee. It appointed Messrs Kidman and Hart of Ferrier Hodgson as agents for the mortgagee. The agents for the mortgagee negotiated short term periodic agreements with the tenants and users of the Dome. On 25 March 2010, CBA relinquished possession of the Dome back to Mr Groves. Mr Bell/ADPL & Mr Groves March to September 2010 After CBA relinquished possession, Mr Bell and Mr Groves in conjunction assumed management of operations at Adelaide Dome. This was accounted for, in part, in the name of ADPL and, in part, in the name of Mr Groves (although no financial statements were prepared in any form for revenue received or expenses paid by Mr Groves).