Commissioner for Act Revenue v Butt & Carey (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE v BUTT & CAREY (Appeal) [2016] ACAT 109

AA 1/2016; (AT 51/2015; AT 52/2015)

Catchwords:             APPEAL – land tax – remittal of penalty tax – statutory interpretation – meanings of ‘failure to take reasonable care’, ‘reasonable excuse for the failure’ and ‘exceptional circumstances’ in statutory context

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 79, 82

Taxation Administration Act 1999 ss 31, 37
Land Tax Act 2004
Rates and Land Tax Act 1926 s 22EC (repealed)

Cases cited:A Plus Plumbing and Building Services Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2012] ACAT 76

B & T Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd v Construction Occupations Registrar and Anor [2013] ACTSC 219
Carey & Butt v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2015] ACAT 85
Chakravarty & Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 11
Hay v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 23
Lukatela v Birch [2008] ACTSC 99
In an Application for Bail by Massey [2008] ACTSC 145
ISPT Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Appeal) [2013] ACAT 43
Jokhan and Jokhan v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2012] ACAT 15
RVO Enterprises Pty Ltd as trustee for the RM O’Mara Family Trust v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] NSWADT 64
Scott and Anor v Commissioner of ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 73
Steele v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2010] ACAT 15
Stott v The Queen [2016] ACTCA 36
Theron v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 73
Wade & Tan v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2014] ACAT 79

Texts and papers       Macquarie Dictionary, 5th edition

Tribunal:                  Presidential Member G C McCarthy

Date of Orders:  23 September 2016

Date of Reasons for Decision:         23 September 2016

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY           )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                 )          AA 1/2016

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Appellant

AND:

ERIC BUTT

First Respondent

JAN CAREY

Second Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:  Presidential Member G C McCarthy

DATE:23 September 2016

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision of the original tribunal is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed

………………………………..

Presidential Member G. C McCarthy

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The appellant, the Commissioner for ACT Revenue, appeals from a decision of the tribunal given on 9 December 2015 to remit 40% of the penalty tax imposed on the respondents, Mr Butt and Ms Carey, arising from their failure to pay land tax.[1]

  2. In these reasons, the word ‘tribunal’ is used when referring to the tribunal that conducted the original hearing. The words ‘appeal tribunal’ are used when referring to this appeal tribunal. The word ‘Tribunal’ is used when referring to the Tribunal in other cases.

  3. The issue under appeal arose in the following way.

  4. The respondents are the joint owners of a residential property in the ACT. They had rented the property since 2004, but had not declared to the Commissioner that it was rented and had not paid land tax for which they were liable consequent upon…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner for Act Revenue v Butt & Carey (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACAT 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commissioner for Act Revenue v Butt & Carey (Appeal) involved an appeal concerning land tax and the remittal of penalty tax. The Commissioner for ACT Revenue challenged the decision of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) to remit part of the penalty tax imposed on the respondents, Butt and Carey. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, which conducted a rehearing of the case.

The central legal issues in the case were the interpretation of the statutory provisions relating to 'failure to take reasonable care','reasonable excuse for the failure', 'exceptional circumstances', and 'fair and reasonable'. The court had to determine whether the ACAT was correct in remitting part of the penalty tax, and if the Commissioner had demonstrated an error on the part of the tribunal. The appeal hinged on whether the ACAT had applied the correct legal standards in its assessment of the respondents' tax obligations.

The court began by considering the meanings of the statutory terms in question, drawing on previous decisions such as those in RVO Enterprises Pty Ltd. It was established that whether a taxpayer had taken reasonable care in attending to their tax obligations was a question of fact. Factors indicating reasonable care included reasonable attempts to comply with tax laws and reliance on professional advice, while factors indicating a failure to take reasonable care included oversight, lack of adequate records, and errors in complying with the law. The court found that the respondents had failed to take reasonable care, as evidenced by their inadvertent errors and lack of professional advice. The ACAT had correctly applied the statutory provisions in remitting part of the penalty tax, and thus the appeal was dismissed.

The Supreme Court confirmed the decision of the original tribunal, dismissing the appeal by the Commissioner. The court held that the ACAT had not erred in its assessment, and that it was open to the tribunal to remit part of the penalty tax based on the statutory criteria. The appeal tribunal accepted the respondents' submission that it was for the Commissioner to demonstrate error on the part of the tribunal, which had not been successfully established.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision of the original tribunal is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Regarding an appeal by way of a rehearing, in Lukatela v Birch [2008] ACTSC 99[11], Rares J said:21.And, although the appeal is by way of rehearing, the appellate [sic] does not have a free hand. Only if, after making proper allowance for the advantages of the trial judge, it concludes that an error has been shown, then, the appellate court is authorised and obliged to exercise its appellate duties in accordance with the statute: Fox 214 CLR at 127-128 [27] per Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Kirby JJ. 22.Ordinarily, if there has been no further evidence admitted and no relevant change in the law, a court entertaining an appeal by way of rehearing can exercise its appellate powers only if satisfied that there was error on part of the court below: Coal and Allied Operations Pty Limited v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2000] HCA 47; (2000) 203 CLR 194 at 203 [14] per Gleeson CJ[2000] HCA 47; 203 CLR 194 at 203 [14] per Gleeson CJ, Gaudron and Hayne JJ. [12][10] ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, section 82[11] at [21] – [22][12] In B & T Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd v Construction Occupations Registrar and Anor [2013] ACTSC 219 Burns J set out relevant principles concerning the nature of appeal to the appeal tribunal is dealt with by way of review Applying these principles, in my view the appeal succeeds or fails according to whether it was open to the tribunal to remit part of the penalty tax. The appeal tribunal accepts the respondents’ submission that it is for the Commissioner to establish that the tribunal was in error when remitting part of the penalty tax. I have approached the matter by first considering the meanings of ‘failure to take reasonable care’ and ‘reasonable excuse for the failure’, per sections 31(2) and (3) on the one hand, and ‘exceptional circumstances’ and ‘fair and reasonable’, per sections 37(a)(ii) and (b) on the other. Whether a taxpayer has taken (or failed to take) reasonable care in attending to their tax obligations is a question of fact.[13] In RVO Enterprises Pty Ltd[14] the NSW Administrative Decisions Tribunal, per Judicial Member Verick said:Factors that would indicate that a taxpayer took reasonable care include reasonable attempts to comply with the tax law, reasonable professional and other inquiries to ensure compliance, reliance on professional advice or on official published views of the tax law. Factors which indicate the taxpayer failed to take reasonable care include oversight or forgetfulness to meet with obligations, failure to maintain adequate records and procedures to prevent errors from occurring, not seeking professional advice and errors in complying with the law. [13] RVO Enterprises Pty Ltd as trustee for the RM O’Mara Family Trust Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] NSWADT 64 at [23][14] RVO Enterprises Pty Ltd as trustee for the RM O’Mara Family Trust Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] NSWADT 64 at [23] Referring to the facts in RVO Enterprises, at [25] Judicial Member Verick continued:Non-compliance [with] the pay-roll tax obligations in this matter was due to “inadvertent error”, complexity of the PRT wage provisions, fluctuation of wages at the end of financial years for presumably income tax purposes, introduction of GST and lack of advice from professionals employed by the applicant. These are not factors that indicate that the applicant took reasonable care to attend to its pay-roll tax obligations. On the contrary, they are factors, which indicate that the applicant failed to take reasonable care.