Carey and Butt v Commissioner for Act Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CAREY & BUTT v COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE
(Administrative Review) [2015] ACAT 85

AT 15/51 and 52

Catchwords:              ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – land tax – interest and penalty tax – interest not a reviewable decision – taxpayer did not exercise reasonable care and did not have reasonable excuse –taxpayer has obligation to notify Commissioner – incomplete disclosure by taxpayer prior to investigation – no intentional disregard of a tax law–incomplete voluntary disclosure prior to investigation and/or misunderstanding by taxpayer that property being developed is exempt from land tax may be relevant to remission of penalty tax

Legislation cited:      ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s 68

Land Tax Act 2004 ss 8, 9, 11, 14, 15, 19A, 36, 53
Taxation Administration Act 1999 ss 26, 31, 32, 33, 34, 37, 101, 104

Cases cited:Commissioner forACT Revenue v Dataflex Pty Ltd and ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal [2011] ACTCA 14

Belconnen Premier Inn Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Administrative Review) [2014] ACAT 68
Hay v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Administrative Review) [2014] ACAT 23
Highrise Concrete Contractors (Aust) Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Administrative Review) [2015] ACAT 3
HJA Holdings Pty Ltd & Ors v ACT Revenue Office (Administrative Review) [2014] ACAT 24

Jokhan and Jokhan v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2012] ACAT 15

Photo Corporation of Australia Pty Ltd v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [1994] ACTAAT 91

Rawson Finances Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2013) FCAFC 26

RVO Enterprises Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2004] NSWADT 64

Scott and Anor v Commissioner of ACT Revenue (Administrative Review) [2013] ACAT 73
Steele v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Administrative Review) [2010] ACAT 15

Theron v Commissioner for ACT Revenue [2013] ACAT 33
Touma v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue (NSW) [2012] NSWADT 2

Wade & Tan v Commissioner for ACT Revenue (Administrative Review) [2014] ACAT 79

Tribunal:  Ms L. Beacroft – Member

Date of Orders:  9 December 2015

Date of Reasons for Decision: 9 December 2015

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL                AT 15/51 and 52

BETWEEN:

JAN CAREY

Applicant – AT 15/51

ERIC BUTT

Applicant – AT 15/52

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR ACT REVENUE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:               Ms L. Beacroft – Member

DATE:  9 December 2015

ORDER

The Tribunal Orders that:

1.The decision of 1 June 2015 not to remit penalty tax is set aside.

2.A decision remitting 40% of the penalty tax is substituted.

3.To remove doubt, the result of Order 2 is that penalty tax will be imposed at 30% (instead of 50%) of land tax payable for the relevant period.

4.In so far as the application seeks review of interest on land tax payable for the relevant period, it is dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

………………………………..

Ms L. Beacroft – Member

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. The applicants, Ms Jan Carey and Mr Eric Butt, are the joint owners of residential land (‘the property’) in the ACT. The Commissioner for ACT Revenue (‘the respondent’ or ‘the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carey and Butt v Commissioner for Act Revenue and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACAT 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Carey and Butt, sought review of the Commissioner for ACT Revenue’s decision regarding land tax, interest, and penalty tax. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with determining whether the decision was legally sound and if the applicants were entitled to a remission of penalty tax. The Tribunal had to consider whether the interest charged was a reviewable decision, whether the applicants exercised reasonable care, and whether they had a reasonable excuse for their incomplete disclosure. The applicants also argued that their misunderstanding of the exemption status of their property should be considered for the remission of penalty tax.

The key legal issues before the Tribunal included whether the interest charged on the land tax was subject to review, whether the applicants exercised reasonable care, and whether they had a reasonable excuse for their incomplete disclosure. Additionally, the Tribunal needed to determine if there was intentional disregard of tax laws and whether the applicants’ incomplete disclosure and misunderstanding about the exemption status of their property warranted a remission of penalty tax.

The Tribunal found that the interest charged was not a reviewable decision and that the applicants did not exercise reasonable care. However, the Tribunal did acknowledge that the applicants did not intentionally disregard tax laws and that their incomplete disclosure and misunderstanding about the exemption status of their property were relevant factors. The Tribunal concluded that a remission of penalty tax was warranted, substituting the original decision with a remission of 40% of the penalty tax. The Tribunal also clarified that the remitted penalty tax would result in a 30% penalty tax rate instead of 50%. The Tribunal dismissed the review of interest on land tax for want of jurisdiction.

The Tribunal ordered that the decision of 1 June 2015 not to remit penalty tax is set aside, and a decision remitting 40% of the penalty tax is substituted. The outcome is that the penalty tax will be imposed at 30% instead of 50% of the land tax payable for the relevant period. The review of the interest on land tax payable for the relevant period was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Orders that:

1. The decision of 1 June 2015 not to remit penalty tax is set aside.

2. A decision remitting 40% of the penalty tax is substituted.

3. To remove doubt, the result of Order 2 is that penalty tax will be imposed at 30% (instead of 50%) of land tax payable for the relevant period.

4. In so far as the application seeks review of interest on land tax payable for the relevant period, it is dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Background

Background to the litigation

Carey and Butt, the taxpayers, were assessed for land tax by the Commissioner for ACT Revenue for the years 2008/09, 2009/10, and 2010/11. The taxpayers were developing a property in Canberra, which they believed was exempt from land tax. However, the Commissioner assessed them for land tax, and subsequent penalties and interest were added for late payment. The taxpayers disputed the penalty tax, arguing that they had made a voluntary disclosure of their position regarding the exemption of the property from land tax before the investigation by the Commissioner. The Commissioner rejected the taxpayers' application for remission of the penalty tax, leading the taxpayers to seek a review of this decision in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The matter came before the AAT following an application for review by the taxpayers. The AAT had to determine whether the decision by the Commissioner not to remit the penalty tax was correct. The AAT examined the evidence presented by both parties and heard submissions regarding the taxpayers' obligations, the nature of the voluntary disclosure, and the grounds for remission of the penalty tax. This was not the first instance of the matter being heard; it followed a decision by the Commissioner that rejected the taxpayers' application for remission of the penalty tax.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the decision of 1 June 2015 not to remit penalty tax was correct.
2. Whether the taxpayers exercised reasonable care and had a reasonable excuse for the non-compliance.
3. Whether the incomplete disclosure by the taxpayers prior to the investigation is relevant to the remission of the penalty tax.
4. Whether the taxpayers had an obligation to notify the Commissioner of their position regarding the exemption of the property from land tax.
5. Whether the incomplete voluntary disclosure and/or misunderstanding by the taxpayers that the property being developed was exempt from land tax may be relevant to the remission of the penalty tax.

Held
1. The decision of 1 June 2015 not to remit penalty tax was set aside by the Tribunal.
2. A decision remitting 40% of the penalty tax was substituted, resulting in the penalty tax being imposed at 30% (instead of 50%) of the land tax payable for the relevant period.
3. The taxpayers did not exercise reasonable care and did not have a reasonable excuse for the non-compliance.
4. The taxpayers had an obligation to notify the Commissioner of their position regarding the exemption of the property from land tax.
5. The incomplete disclosure by the taxpayers prior to the investigation is not relevant to the remission of the penalty tax.
6. The incomplete voluntary disclosure and/or misunderstanding by the taxpayers that the property being developed was exempt from land tax may be relevant to the remission of the penalty tax.
7. The application for review of interest on land tax payable for the relevant period was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal reviewed the decision of 1 June 2015 not to remit penalty tax, and set it aside. It found that the taxpayers did not exercise reasonable care and did not have a reasonable excuse for the non-compliance. The Tribunal noted that the taxpayers had an obligation to notify the Commissioner of their position regarding the exemption of the property from land tax. However, the Tribunal found that the incomplete disclosure by the taxpayers prior to the investigation was not relevant to the remission of the penalty tax. Instead, the incomplete voluntary disclosure and/or misunderstanding by the taxpayers that the property being developed was exempt from land tax may be relevant to the remission of the penalty tax. The Tribunal substituted the decision of 1 June 2015 with a decision remitting 40% of the penalty tax, resulting in the penalty tax being imposed at 30% (instead of 50%) of the land tax payable for the relevant period. The Tribunal dismissed the application for review of interest on land tax payable for the relevant period for want of jurisdiction. The Tribunal relied on the principle that interest is not a reviewable decision and that the taxpayers did not exercise reasonable care and did not have a reasonable excuse for the non-compliance. The Tribunal followed the principle that taxpayers have an obligation to notify the Commissioner of their position regarding the exemption of the property from land tax. The Tribunal distinguished the incomplete disclosure by the taxpayers prior to the investigation from the incomplete voluntary disclosure and/or misunderstanding by the taxpayers that the property being developed was exempt from land tax. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that incomplete voluntary disclosure and/or misunderstanding by the taxpayers that the property being developed was exempt from land tax may be relevant to the remission of the penalty tax.