Colonial Sugar Refining Co Ltd v Attorney-General for the Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read
15 CLR 182

THE COLONIAL SUGAR REFINING CO.

LTD. AND OTHERS

THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE

COMMONWEALTH AND OTHERS. Constitutional law-Powers of Commonwealth-Compulsory inquiry-Incidental

power-Inquiry as to matters outside powers of Commonwealth Parliament- MELBOURNE,

Royal Commission, powers of-Judicial power of Commonwealth-Granting of Sept. 24, 25,

immunity in State Court-Royal Commissions Act 1902-1912 (No, 12 of 1902 26, 27, 30, Oct. 4, 22.

-No. 4 of 1912), 88. 6B, 6DD-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), secs. 51 (xxxix.)-128.

Practice - Action against Crown - Declaratory judgment-Injunetion - Threatened illegal act.

15 CLR 183

Practice-High Court-Appeal to Privy Council-Certificate of High Court H. C. -The Constitution (63 &64 Vict, c. 12), sec. 74.

A power to enact a law compelling persons to give evidence on matters as to which the Executive Government of the Commonwealth thinks it desir- able to collect information to be made use of in exercising any existing power of the Commonwealth Parliament is "incidental" to the execution of that power within sec. 51 (xxxix.) of the Constitution.

But, held, by Griffith C.J. and Barton J. (Isaacs and Higgins JJ. dis- senting), that such an incidental power does not extend to enacting a law compelling persons to give evidence on matters information as to which is relevant only to a possible amendment of the Constitution under sec. 128

Held, therefore, that the Royal Commissions Act 1902-1912 is within the power of the Commonwealth Parliament to enact, but (by Griffith C.J. and Barton J., Isaacs and Higgins JJ. dissenting) that it should be construed as intended to apply to compelling evidence on such limited matters only.

Sec. 6DD of the Royal Commissions Act 1902-1912, which purports to give a qualified protection in State Courts from the criminative effect of admis- sions made by a witness on examination before a Royal Commission, is within the power of the Commonwealth Parliament to enact.

Sec. 6B, even if invalid as an attempt to confer part of the judicial power of the Commonwealth upon a Royal Commission, is severable from the rest of

Pursuant to the Royal Commissions Act a Royal Commission was appointed to inquire into the sugar industry, and a summons was issued to the manager of the plaintiff company to attend and give evidence and produce documents before the Commission, notice being given to him of the intention of the Commission to ask certain specified questions and to produce certain specified documents. Before the summons was returned the plaintiff company and its officers brought an action against the Attorney-General and the members of the Commission claiming a declaration that the Act was invalid and a consequent injunction to restrain the members of the Commis- sion from proceeding upon the summons, and, alternatively, if the Court held that the whole Act was not invalid, a declaration that the manager was not bound to answer questions or produce documents relating to matters as which the Federal Parliament had no present legislative power or which were not relevant to the subject matter of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colonial Sugar Refining Co Ltd v Attorney-General for the Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1912] HCA 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Colonial Sugar Refining Co Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth and the members of a Royal Commission. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the Royal Commissions Act 1902-1912 was invalid, or alternatively, that certain provisions of the Act were beyond the powers of the Commonwealth Parliament. The plaintiff also sought an injunction to restrain the Commission from proceeding with a summons issued to its general manager to give evidence and produce documents. The dispute centred on the scope of the Commonwealth's legislative power, particularly its incidental powers, and the extent to which a Royal Commission could compel evidence on matters outside the Parliament's current legislative authority.

The High Court was required to determine whether the Royal Commissions Act 1902-1912, and specifically sections 6B and 6DD, were within the constitutional powers of the Commonwealth Parliament. A key issue was whether the incidental power under section 51(xxxix) of the Constitution extended to compelling evidence for matters that could only become subject to Commonwealth legislative power through a constitutional amendment under section 128. The Court also had to consider whether the Act, or parts of it, were severable if found to be invalid, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to a declaratory judgment and an injunction to restrain the Commission's proceedings.

Griffith CJ and Barton J held that the power to enact laws compelling evidence for matters within the Commonwealth's existing legislative powers was incidental to the execution of those powers. However, they found that this incidental power did not extend to compelling evidence for matters relevant only to a potential amendment of the Constitution. They concluded that the Royal Commissions Act was valid but should be construed as applying only to such limited matters. They also found section 6DD to be within Parliament's power. Isaacs and Higgins JJ dissented on the interpretation of the incidental power.

The Court was equally divided in its opinion on the validity of the Act and the extent of the Commission's powers. Consequently, a certificate pursuant to section 74 of the Constitution was granted, indicating that the matter would proceed to appeal to the Privy Council.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.