| [2020] FWC 3598 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Colin McKerlie
v
RateIt Australia Pty Ltd T/A RateIt
(U2020/1211)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT BOYCE | SYDNEY, 15 JULY 2020 |
Application for recusal or disqualification of decision-maker on the basis of actual or apprehended bias — whether actual bias in decision to grant permission to Respondent to be legally represented — whether actual or apprehended bias based upon errors identified in appeal proceedings concerning other first instance decisions — the importance of ‘context’ when determining the ‘logical connection’ between the alleged source of bias and its supposed effect — submissions and evidentiary material relied upon to support claim of apprehended bias derived from Google searches — evidentiary material relied upon to support claim of apprehended bias protected by Parliamentary privilege (and therefore unable to be received into evidence) — claims of actual or apprehended bias rejected on the basis of no evidentiary or legal foundation — recusal application dismissed — proceedings part heard — matter listed for directions to program the matter to complete hearing.
Overview
[1] On 5 February 2020, the Applicant, Mr Colin Robert McKerlie, lodged an application for an unfair dismissal remedy (Unfair Dismissal Application).
[2] Mr McKerlie alleges that he was “dismissed” on 21 January 2020, by RateIt Australia Pty Ltd (Respondent), and that such dismissal was unfair and contrary to Part 3-2 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act).
[3] On 8 May 2020, I conducted a hearing in relation to two jurisdictional objections to the Unfair Dismissal Application (as raised by the Respondent). In brief, that hearing went to whether Mr McKerlie was an independent contractor or an “employee”, and, if an employee of the Respondent, whether his dismissal was a case of “genuine redundancy” within the meaning of s.389 of the Act. 1
[4] My decision in McKerlie v RateIt Australia Pty Ltd T/A RateIt (3 July 2020) (Representation Decision) sets out the reasons for my decision to grant the Respondent permission to be legally represented in these proceedings. 2 It also outlines the procedural background to this matter.3 I rely upon, but do not repeat, that procedural background in this decision.
Recusal Application
[5] On 15 May 2020, Mr McKerlie made an application that I recuse or otherwise disqualify myself from further involvement in these proceedings (Recusal Application). As I understand the Recusal Application, Mr McKerlie contends that:
(a) I have exhibited ‘actual bias’ in granting the Respondent permission to be legally represented in these proceedings; and/or
(b) on the basis of Google searches undertaken by Mr McKerlie, a hypothetical fair-minded and informed lay observer would conclude that my conduct has created an ‘apprehension of bias’, such that I am unable to bring an impartial mind to the determination of relevant contested issues in these proceedings.
[6] It is well established that a decision-maker, in respect of whom bias is alleged, is to rule (themselves) upon any recusal or disqualification application. The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Colin McKerlie v RateIt Australia Pty Ltd T/A RateIt and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FWC 3598
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether there was actual or apprehended bias in the decision to grant permission to the respondent to be legally represented. This involved examining the context and logical connection between the alleged source of bias and its supposed effect. McKerlie's arguments were based on errors identified in appeal proceedings concerning other first instance decisions, as well as submissions and evidentiary material derived from Google searches. However, the court found that these materials lacked evidentiary or legal foundation and could not support a claim of bias. Additionally, some evidentiary material relied upon by McKerlie was protected by Parliamentary privilege and therefore could not be received into evidence.
The court dismissed the application for recusal or disqualification, finding no actual or apprehended bias in the decision to allow the respondent's legal representation. The court emphasised the importance of context in determining the logical connection between the alleged source of bias and its supposed effect. The proceedings were part heard, and the matter was listed for directions to program the complete hearing.